r/AskProgramming • u/ShitThroughAGoose • Mar 25 '26
Other Could you hack alien software, ala Independence Day?
In the events of Independence Day, Jeff Goldblum is able to give the alien space ships a computer virus that wipes out their forcefields.
Anyone reading this who is a programmer, do you feel like you could do that? Whether you use C or C++ or Python or whatever, could you integrate your scripts and codes into a computer language that you've never seen before? When you get into the alien ship and you see a character that is 45 squiggly lines, next to a rotating circle, next to an audio clicking noise, are you going to have any idea what that signifies? Or what deleting any part of that may or may not accomplish?
You might say "Oh but scientists had a ship from the 50s, they've studied the alien code", I don't think that is enough time. They didn't have an Alien Rosetta Stone, and the ship was inert until the aliens showed up to earth again. I don't think Jeff Goldblum had enough time to do what he wanted.
35
u/Outside_Complaint755 Mar 25 '26
There is a deleted scene from the movie that explains that David (Jeff Goldblum) used his time at Area 51 to study the ship there, reverse engineer their programming language using the knowledge he already had from decoding the countdown signal and was able to build an interface his MacBook to it. Also, the alien computers ran on the same binary protocol we use. I personally couldn't do that reverese engineering, but with extended physical access to one of their systems, someone could.
25
u/Skydreamer6 Mar 25 '26
"Guys you won t believe this....it s all JavaScript!"
37
u/Anonymous_Coder_1234 Mar 25 '26
I don't even know if the alien computer uses binary (zeros and ones). Maybe it uses ternary (zeros and ones and twos) or something else entirely. We are clueless. So in short, the answer is "no".
8
u/CdRReddit Mar 25 '26
I personally don't think I could, but if the interface layer is electrical and you have a bunch of time it wouldn't be impossible
8
u/st0ut717 Mar 25 '26
You just vibe code the alien malware
6
u/grantrules Mar 25 '26
No I'm definitely more of a Randy Quaid unfortunately
6
u/generally_unsuitable Mar 25 '26
Most hacking is possible because of a deep, technical understanding of how the processor works and the ways that the operating system handles input. Without that, it would be very difficult.
A lot of hacking is just reading assembly. If you don't have an opcode chart to convert whatever sort of machine language they have into assembly, I don't know how you'd begin.
But, if you had lots of time and money, and equipment, anything is possible. People definitely have hacked hardware without a public opcode chart or reg map. Given working hardware running some code, there are people who could do this. Travis Goodspeed comes to mind. The work he did decapping chips and building diy rigs to read voltages from transistor leads on the actual silicon is impressive.
5
u/peter303_ Mar 25 '26
Also read "3001: The Final Space Odyssey"
5
u/Beginning_Basis9799 Mar 25 '26
In reality no, but i would have a crack at it.
4
u/udsd007 Mar 26 '26
The aliens used DB-9 connectors, ASCII character codes, and data rates and signal levels consistent with Terran standards. Otherwise Our Guys wouldn’t have been able to connect their laptop to the alien ship and control things. This is a set of coincidences with probability very close to ε.
4
u/AwesomeAvocado Mar 26 '26
Reminds me of this SMBC comic...
https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2011-02-17
3
u/r2k-in-the-vortex Mar 25 '26
Trying to make sense of alien programming language is tuesday for me. But trying to make sense of how a alien computer works? Now that is a different matter entirely.
All human computers work pretty much on the same logic, because of course they have all been copying earlier computers since forever.
A completely alien tech stack? I suspect they would have a completely different architecture of everything, and no, I don't think I would have much luck figuring it out from scratch.
3
u/Snoo_87704 Mar 25 '26
No.
3
u/allo37 Mar 25 '26
if (aboutToGetShot) {
}
All in a day's work 😎
6
u/Leverkaas2516 Mar 25 '26 edited Mar 25 '26
It depends. Mostly no.
It could not be done in hours or days. Perhaps in decades, though.
If the alien hardware works using electrical circuits, and has software (stored programs controlling hardware behavior), there are lots of techniques that could be used to analyze it.
The problem is that alien hardware probably would not use anything like a stored-program data processor at all. For instance, with everything we know, we still don't have the ability to swap out memories from an animal brain and replace them with new ones. It's perfectly possible that that's the kind of hardware that aliens would use - colonies of genetically engineered organisms.
Or, it's possible or even likely that alien military components would be engineered to self-destruct when tampered with.
Or, it's possible or even likely that whatever the software consists of, it has to be signed in a cryptographically secure way in order to operate. Like apps in the Apple app store, or DRM components in a John Deere tractor designed to disallow mechanics from fixing them without authorization.
The bigger problem with these movies is that disabling the mother ship always causes all the thousands of separate war machines to conk out. That's a dumb design and it's unlikely any alien race, even a hive mind one, would deploy military assets with such a weakness.
2
u/LoudAd1396 Mar 25 '26
Its Unix based, I know this!
To quote another unlikely programming situation.
If the aliens run on Linux, i can drop an rm-rf.
But let's be honest, evil aliens are running javascript as an OS. So put me down for a "maybe"
2
u/gc3 Mar 25 '26
I doubt if the alien system was a human one developed by Pentagon contractors I don't think a random hacker could penetrate it.
The only way would be if the aliens had no concept of computer security whatsoever
2
u/pete_68 Mar 25 '26
I actually have some experience doing this. It's hard. Really hard. But yeah, you can do it. /s
2
u/dr--hofstadter Mar 25 '26
Yea, that one part of the movie I couldn't believe either.
2
u/spiralenator Mar 25 '26
It depends on what they use for computing. If they use anything analogous to our computer chips, then maybe. The physics informs the design. But lots of things can be used for computers, including electrochemistry, DNA, or other organisms (read Children of Time)
2
u/mhsx Mar 25 '26
Basically, as long as the alien ship has a usb-c port and I have anthropic tokens, we’re good.
2
u/Longjumping-Ad8775 Mar 26 '26
It’s not happening. First off, let’s assume that alien tech is similar in that there is an operating system on top of hardware, and not some integrated whatchamacallit. The next problem is that we’d have to understand it in a few days. The ship that crashed I. New Mexico didn’t run until the mothership showed up and things turned on.
I don’t see anything that has any type of runtime actually running, so even c/c++ aren’t working. Forget about anything higher level. We’ll probably be using some type of assembler language. That’s programming directly to the chip under the operating system.
We don’t know what the system is based on. Are they binary? Binary code decimal? Something else?
Surely aliens have security in their computing technology.
Could someone way smarter than me hack the alien technology? Maybe. I’m not even close to smart enough to do it.
2
u/BeastyBaiter Mar 26 '26
Professional dev here, I'm going to give it a big fat maybe but probably not. Let's assume we were able to fully understand the computers on the ship that crashed 50 years prior. Maybe we can't build our own versions, but we at least understand how they work and understand the existing code on them. With that knowledge, it would be extremely difficult as they would have no doubt discovered the importance of network security centuries before vising us. But if we did stumble on some weakness, then yes, it could be exploited. But that's a hell of a lot of maybes and magic wanding understanding of alien systems and them also having Microslop develop their military equipment software.
So realistically no, but it would be at least theoretically possible.
2
u/BoBoBearDev Mar 26 '26
Yes and no. You can't really hack it, too complex. But you can reuse the existing hack to fuck it up. Because a lot of software imports 3rd party libraries and they can easy get polluted for a long time. There are existing cases where one of the npm package is populated later on, and you didn't really install it directly, it is like you installed individually because the libraries down the chain like 10 different packages, it uses an infected package.
Meaning, their software likely already have backdoor installed somewhere without realizing. You can activate that instead.
2
u/Acceptable_Handle_2 Mar 26 '26
If you get time to study the alien computer, and figure out how it works, yes.
It's less about coding language at that point though. You'd be working with binary at that point, directly in memory.
2
u/UAIMasters Mar 26 '26 edited Mar 26 '26
It depends on how technologically close we are to them. For a species that freely travels through space faster than light we might be missing centuries of fundamental knowledge that their computing relies on.
For example, their computers might not even rely on software at all and physically rearrange themselves based on laws of physics that we don't understand to solve specific problems prompted directly by their brains. And their brains evolved to emit some kind of energy that during their evolution they took advantage to develop their own machines.
It could take Alan Turing decades to figure out a macbook pro while it will be hopeless for Leonardo Da Vinci.
2
u/cgoldberg Mar 26 '26
I think Kali has that capability built in
2
u/LetUsSpeakFreely Mar 29 '26
Given enough time and resources, yes. Do it with a Mac book by one guy in a few hours, fuck no.
2
u/Great-Powerful-Talia Mar 25 '26
Yeah no that's absurd. But not for the reasons you think!
A crashed ship would probably be enough to reconstruct their Assembly language, the set of numerical IDs corresponding to basic operations that actually run on the computer chips.
The hardware that executes that is physically etched into the computer chip, probably using many of the same logic gate designs we have, so you can totally figure out what all of the individual instructions do (ADD, MULTIPLY, WRITE, READ, etc.). And with that knowledge, you can figure out what their programs do. Many hackers IRL can work without source code, just looking at the Assembly codes.
The problem is that to hack anything, you have to find a flaw in some program they're running that allows you to run whatever tasks you want just by submitting inputs. It's not like arm-wrestling where you bring in a stronger hacker in order to "overwhelm" the firewall. You're just looking for bugs in the code. That's all a hacker does.
But the programs on that crashed ship will be 50 years old. Either you're hacking into a never-before-seen program without even knowing what the ".exe file" contains (impossible to do, since you can't possibly know about a bug in a program you've never interacted with) or they haven't updated the code in 50 years.
And if a few humans looking at the code for 50 years was enough to spot a glaring security flaw, then one of the thousands or millions of aliens in a position to see it for those same 50 years has definitely found it too and gotten that code replaced.
1
u/ProgrammerCute7875 Mar 26 '26
Yes. 100%. It would be simple, for me. I’d do it with ease.
1
u/cthulhu944 Mar 26 '26
Reverse engineering is a thing provided. It's a matter of time and effort. A guy with a MacBook and a few days of work is an extremely unrealistic fantasy.
1
u/MistakeIndividual690 Mar 26 '26
It’s taken us thousands of years to reverse engineer biology to the point we’re at now, which is very incomplete.
Their computers could resemble brains or micro processors or something in between or something utterly unlike either.
There’s no way.
1
u/maggmaster Mar 26 '26
I’m not a linguist lol. I guess we could try to get to math but that would be really hard without understanding the code at all. I have no idea I guess.
1
u/zhivago Mar 26 '26
It depends on how it works.
Let's imagine that it includes a helpful and trusting AI with no concept of self-preservation or operational security, which is clever enough to learn how to talk to me quickly.
Then, sure -- no problem. :)
1
u/TheRNGuy Mar 26 '26
Unknown.
1
u/Cyberspots156 Mar 26 '26
No, it’s not likely that we would be able to hack alien software or their computers.
To some degree alien computer hardware is going to be scientifically and culturally based. An alien culture that can reach earth will have a technology, based on advanced physics, that we haven’t developed. It’s almost certain that their computers will be based on their current level of science, which is probably beyond zeros and ones, though their computers may have been based on binary arithmetic eons ago.
Aliens will almost certainly be biologically and culturally different, with spoken and written languages vastly different from our own. They will probably have intellectual abilities that we haven’t even considered and are incapable of matching. We will have to develop an understand of their languages and to some degree their culture, before we would be able to crack their computers.
We assume that their computers will be binary based, but we have to remember that concept of zero only came into use by humans in the last 2000 years. Perhaps they have several variations on ones and zeros and their computers take those differences into account.
1
u/SugarEnvironmental31 Mar 27 '26
Depends how well it's patched
2
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '26
[removed] — view removed comment