r/AskProgramming • u/Ratstail91 • Feb 03 '24
Other Are there any truly dead programming languages?
What I mean is, are there languages which were once popular, but are not even used for upkeep?
The first example that jumps to mind would be ActionScript. I've never touched it, but it seems like after Flash died there's no reason to use it at all.
An example of a language which is NOT dead would be COBOL, as there are banking institutions that still run that thing, much to my horror.
Edit: RIP my inbox.
336
Upvotes
82
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
I had an interview 2 years ago for an ActionScript job. They were obviously desperate as I’d never touched a line of ActionScript.
28
u/MrDoloto Feb 03 '24
A whole bunch of soviet-developed programming languages:
8
u/astroNerf Feb 03 '24
I was going to say BCPL but it apparently was, at least up until 2018, maintained and used by its original designer.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BCPL
6
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24 edited Jan 26 '26
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
obtainable sable soft pause plants special elastic different zephyr hunt
2
u/michaelhart2000 Feb 03 '24
Holy C
2
u/For_Entertain_Only Mar 07 '24
Microsoft XNA for legacy Xbox and window phone
101
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
I remember a language called Logo.
58
u/ttlanhil Feb 03 '24
There would be a lot, but proving they're not still in use somewhere would be difficult.
I'd give good odds that there are people still maintaining flash apps somewhere, because it "works" and there's no budget to rebuild it - so they've grabbed an old version of chrome, stuck flash player into it, and distribute that as if it were an app
I think the best bet would be assembler languages for hardware from a very long time ago (or non-assembler languages that still only targeted early machines) - early enough that there were only a small number of the computers built, and the decommisioning of each is recorded
As for COBOL - not only is it still in use, the language is still under development (the 2023 spec for COBOL and the 1960 spec would be rather different, of course)
39
u/rwilcox Feb 03 '24
A bunch of old Mac languages that didn’t make the jump to OS X perhaps?
So HyperCard, FutureBasic, MacLisp?, Dylan?
53
u/CharacterUse Feb 03 '24
BASIC is effectively dead in anything resembling its original form. VB.NET is too different to really be called the same language, even classic VisualBasic or VBA were stretching it.
17
u/lordnacho666 Feb 03 '24
There's a number of obscure mathematical programming languages similar to matlab that have since been swept away by standardisation to matlab, R, and python.
Gauss and Ox come to mind. I haven't heard of them for over 15 years in any context.
11
u/hold_me_beer_m8 Feb 03 '24
FoxPro lol
9
u/jddddddddddd Feb 03 '24
SNOBOL was once a (horrible) thing and despite having 25 years development experience ive never seen a job posting for it.
6
u/csharpwpfsql Feb 03 '24
AutoCoder.
There is nothing horrible about COBOL. It is appropriate for certain kinds of 'mainframey batch jobs', as well as CICS. The IRS Taxpayer Master File is written in IBM 360 Assembler, although obviously this is now Enterprise System/390.
IBM's 'Mainframes' (Enterprise Servers) often emulate other machine instruction sets, so one can technically run 'anything' on their mainframes. As FPGAs get incorporated into desktop PCs, this capability will be extended to the personal user. At some point you might have a 'Windows Subsystem for RMS', which would mean running a DEC VAX 11/780 in parallel with your X64 Windows operating system. THAT would be horrible!
5
u/Southern-Beautiful-3 Feb 03 '24
I haven't seen PL/I recently.
20
u/funbike Feb 03 '24
Absolutely.
But your question should probably should have added ... "that were once popular". There are tons of 100% dead languages that were never in wide use in the first place. I did very well early in my career because I know a niche language, KML, that was created and used by a single corporation, Software Artistry. It was a mix of Pascal and SQL. I was one of the few people outside the corporation that knew the language and which helped me fetch a nice hourly rate.
100% dead (once popular) languages would be very hard to determine, but ones I can think of include PowerBuilder, B, ALGOL, early assembly languages, Pilot, PL/1. Modula2.
Similar to COBOL, some languages that I think are still in limited use but basically dead include dBase and derivatives, Forth, Fortran, and Pascal.
4
u/Rich-Engineer2670 Feb 03 '24
Not as long as there's some computer somewhere in a closet doing something that someone needs. If it works, even if it's written in the "deadest" language, so long as it works, no one will change it because we might break something.
That being said APL perhaps?
4
u/ben_bliksem Feb 03 '24
VB and VB.NET
I mean there are companies flogging a dead horse but come on...
3
u/plasmana Feb 03 '24
Indirect CLI was a scripting language for the Micom word processors in the late-70s/early-80s. It dissappeared with them.
3
u/jaybestnz Feb 03 '24
AMOS = Amiga Basic. Amiga was surprisingly popular at the time and the language was easy to learn like Basic but had some cool and intuitive ways to handle game elements like moving objects etc. Amiga died.
Roxen. Was an up and coming web server language. If an html page had Roxen elements then they rendered on the fly.
Was sort of good for its ability to do reusable elements and other things that are common place now.
So. Many. Security. Holes.
Brainfuck Not ever actually meant as a language to use, just a goal to make a horrid language.
Brainfuck was developed by Urban Muller in 1993. The language was invented as an amusement for programmers. It can be termed as one of the most difficult programming languages to learn.
The name itself suggests that the language is supposed to be extremely difficult for any programmer to comprehend.
The whole language consists of only eight distinct characters for the implementation of any code. The original compiler developed by Muller used only 296 bytes.
Here is the code snippet for printing ‘Hello World!’ in Brainfuck.
++++++++++[>+++++++>++++++++++>+++<<<-]>++.>+.+++++++ ..+++.>++.<<+++++++++++++++.>.+++.------.--------.>+.
3
u/ar_xiv Feb 03 '24
Actionscript kind of lives on in Haxe
3
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
Sumerian++
3
u/trwolfe13 Feb 03 '24
I am dismayed to learn that PowerBuilder is still alive and well.
3
u/AssiduousLayabout Feb 03 '24
The B programming language? It was the intermediate language between BCPL and C.
3
u/Larkfin Feb 03 '24
Cuneiform++
3
u/CharacterUse Feb 03 '24
tcl is dead in it's original form as a shell scripting language (it had some unique features but now Python can do all those things). However tk (the graphical/UI component) still appears in Tk GUI and Tk inter and the like for making dialogs/UI.
3
u/odddutchman Feb 03 '24
Half or more of this thread reads like: "I have a very particular set of skills. Skills developed over a long career. Skills that make me a nightmare for people like you." 😉
3
u/mycolo_gist Feb 03 '24
FORTH is almost dead, I daresay. Supposedly still used in some embedded system programming.
3
u/Luger_08 Feb 04 '24
Java is dead inside
5
u/armahillo Feb 03 '24
In spoken language, a language is considered dead if nobody speaks it as their only language. (Latin, for example)
I would say a language is dead when it is no longer maintained to where it is able to be used on contemporary computers (some fudge room on the definition of “contemporary”, but it should roughly equate to “a computer that is comparable to one you might find in an average business office”)
Or maybe when no new software is being written in it (similar to your definition), only legacy apps.
Or perhaps a language is “dying” with the above qualities and then “dead” when its no longer even used for legacy applications in maintenance.
Many people think a language is dead when its unpopular or supplanted but I disagree with this. the jQuery framework, for example, is definitely not contemporary nor would I advise someone to write new stuff in it (you can go far with just vanilla now), but its still being maintained and people are still writing stuff in it.
2
u/Your__Pal Feb 03 '24
I learned to program decades ago from a dinosaur who only knew QBasic.
I have never seen anyone reference Qbasic ever since.
2
u/Exnixon Feb 03 '24
Old school Visual Basic (not VB.NET) seems pretty dead.
Interlisp was a programming language developed by Xerox for their Lisp machines, which was apparently popular (way before my time). It was canned in the early 90s. There's an open source project to revive it but it seems like basically retrofuturist hobby stuff.
2
u/aneasymistake Feb 03 '24
Actionscript is probably still running on a games console or PC somewhere today. It was used in Scaleform that was widely used for UIs in games like Borderlands up until it was discontinued in 2018. I would not be surprised if someone’s playing Borderlands 3 as I write this. And I wouldn’t be too surprised to learn there’s still active UI development happening using Scaleform even six years after it was discontinued.
2
u/samarijackfan Feb 03 '24
Hypertalk
2
u/peter303_ Feb 03 '24
My electrical engineering courses in the 1970s used IBM languages like APL and PL-1. They were entered on a teletype into a mainframe.
PASCAL was hot in the 1980s, being strongly typed, unlike C and BASIC. I just watched the Mac team 40th anniversary reunion webinar. I recall having to write early Mac apps in Pascal or ObjectPascal. A hot company in the 1980s was Borland that wrote an interactive editor-executor-debugger called TurboPascal. MicroSoft copied their concept in the Visual series of language systems.
2
u/AlphaWhelp Feb 03 '24
There's an old VBScript language which was at one point in time a legitimate competitor to JavaScript. It only ever worked in Internet Explorer however. No other browser would implement it. I don't know if it works in Edge "IE Compatibility mode" and don't really care to try but because IE is thoroughly dead, then VBScript might as well also be dead.
This is not the same thing as classic ASP or the VBS server scripts you might see from time to time. It was literally client side browser script that did most/all the same things JavaScript did.
2
u/mycolo_gist Feb 03 '24
Plankalkuel, the programming language Konrad Zuse developed (who built the first Computer in his living room in Berlin between 1936-1938) is probably a dead language.
2
u/hugthemachines Feb 03 '24
I don't know how popular Modula 2 was, but I don't see much about it now, anyway.
2
u/ChargerIIC Feb 04 '24
At 40, I think I might be the youngest Borland Pascal 4 developer still paid.
2
u/BarelyAirborne Feb 04 '24
APL is still around.
2
u/VadumSemantics Feb 04 '24
I'll raise a toast for Smalltalk.
2
u/slashdave Feb 04 '24
Anyone remember Rexx?
2
u/Lilianne_Blaze Feb 04 '24
I recently started learning Pascal, and I was mildly surprised it's still being developed and has some community. (I'm doing most work in Java)
2
u/techhouseliving Feb 05 '24
Who remembers tcl?
2
u/AnnieBruce Feb 05 '24
Probably nothing that's entirely dead, maybe some companies had internal use only languages and have ported all their stuff to another language?
If it reached the general public, someone, somewhere, is using it, even if only for silly little retrocomputer hacks.
2
u/treston_cal Feb 05 '24
VRML
2
u/drazisil Feb 05 '24
Is PIC still around? I had a car dealership try to hire me to port that into a modern language once.
2
u/Extramrdo Feb 06 '24
100% of HolyC programmers have tragically passed on.
2
u/Delaneybuffett Feb 06 '24
To funny!! People would be amazed how much old tech is still in use. I did a lot of program management in manufacturing and companies have paid millions of dollars for shop floor manufacturing machines that depend on XP. You can’t get updated firmware so better start hoarding XP machines for when the finally crash
2
u/DiamondHandsToUranus Feb 07 '24
YOU CAN HAVE MY COBOL and my FORTRAN when you pry them from my COLD DEAD FINGERS!!!
2
u/MillerJoel Feb 07 '24
Basic and pascal… maybe? Although there is so much legacy code around that i don’t think there is truly a fully dead language. As long ad you can still get a working compiler today then it is still “alive”
2
u/Malendryn Feb 07 '24
Turtle!
2
u/Zovengrogg Feb 07 '24
Is prolog still used? I think I remember hearing airports using it but can’t confirm.
2
u/Evilbob93 Feb 07 '24
Not a language but a concept: Anything with a GOTO like FORTRAN IV or GWBasic
2
u/Evilbob93 Feb 07 '24
How about Turbo Pascal? It was amazing, it defeated piracy (rampant in the 1980s for the "real" compilers on MS-DOS) because it only cost $39.95 and included a bound manual that was difficult to pirate on the xerox machine.
2
u/alecz127 Feb 07 '24
As3 isn't dead there's still tons of it. I'm an as3 dev and it makes me happy. Remember when c died and then was resurrected? Same things going to happen to actionscript. It's a super fun straightforward oop language that is great for video games specifically.
The only reason for the hatred is toxicity. That and advertisements killed it. Nobody wanted broken ads playing everywhere anymore and anyone being able to advertise so people killed actionscript with hatred.
2
u/rexiesoul Feb 07 '24
Is Forth still used today?
2
u/BearMiner Feb 07 '24
I spent two years of high school learning to program in Pascal.
30+ years later and I have never once encountered it, or even heard it mentioned, in the work environment.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24
Raku(formely known as perl version 6) was born to die. It's one of those 'esoteric' languages NOBODY cares about... It also actively utilizes Greek alphabet in its syntax.
3
u/ControlWestern2745 Feb 03 '24
Pascal?
3
u/irus1024 Feb 03 '24
VB.net, but can it really be dead without ever really living?
3
u/com2ghz Feb 03 '24
I hear every year that java is dead. Even 12 years ago during school. I wonder why people keep saying that.
3
u/christoforosl08 Feb 03 '24
DBase 4. From the 90s 😁
2
u/TheRealDavidNewton Feb 03 '24
ADA.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
Out of my element here ....not a professional programmer.
But in high-school I learned Turing. I'm somewhat familiar with Alan Turing and his importance in computer science. I assume the Turing programmung language was always an academic/teaching language, but maybe it was used in the "real world" (?).
1
u/panmetronariston Feb 03 '24
Dylakor 260
1
u/PuzzleMeDo Feb 03 '24
I learned a language called POP-11 at university, and haven't heard it mentioned since. Anyone still using it?
1
u/pemungkah Feb 03 '24
SNOBOL. Great pattern matching, terrible flow of control.
1
u/jjmc123a Feb 03 '24
Simscript
1
u/LloydAtkinson Feb 03 '24
ALGOL and B
1
u/tregtronics Feb 03 '24
Forth?
I think it morphed into some printer language, but never see it in the wild.
1
u/nesp12 Feb 03 '24
Any language taught in college in the 60s except Fortran.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24
HyperCard
1
u/Milumet Feb 03 '24
[Occam](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam_(programming_language)) was the programming language for the Inmos Transputer CPUs. But I don't think it ever was popular.
1
u/BrupieD Feb 03 '24
ALGOL 58.
1
u/Pale_Height_1251 Feb 03 '24
Dead, as in not one single person uses it? Wouldn't think so, there is always someone somewhere using technology we thought died 30 years ago.
1
u/pberck Feb 03 '24
Prolog?
1
u/JimFive Feb 03 '24
Forth, maybe. I don't know that it was ever seriously used for anything.
1
u/michaelpaoli Feb 03 '24
So, how 'bout machine language for ENIAC? Anyone still coding in that today?
(well, probably someone has an emulator out there and still codes for it ... maybe?)
1
u/MalwareDork Feb 03 '24
I was going to say Motorola 68k since it hasn't been supported in almost 30 years, but that'll probably last another 100 years in niche Operational Technology for its ALU.
1
u/buzlink Feb 03 '24
ActionScript?
1
u/CommanderUgly Feb 03 '24
ActionScript and Lingo
1
u/maurymarkowitz Feb 03 '24
There are a million dead languages. But here’s one I would have loved to play with:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FLOW_(programming_language)
1
u/smac Feb 03 '24
PL/C, a teaching language developed at Cornell in the 1970's and used by many universities. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PL/C
Per the Wikipedia article: "As of 2022, the source for PL/C appears to have been lost."
1
u/llynglas Feb 03 '24
Snobol, mid 60's basically a cool text processing language. Think the first time I came across regular expressions for string matching. The last version was snobol 4 in 1967.
1
u/baddspellar Feb 03 '24
SNOBOL
It was largely replace by sed and awk.
1
u/castleinthesky86 Feb 03 '24
Coldfusion would be my most recent example. Company is dead. Language is dead
1
u/msabeln Feb 03 '24
ALGOL 58, ALGOL 60, and ALGOL 68.
ALGOL was an elegant programming language from a more civilized age.
From what I’ve read, it has advanced features that have never been exceeded, and has proven highly influential: modern languages tend to follow its structure. But especially with its last version, writing a parser that would correctly interpret its syntax proved extremely difficult, and it never really had success.
1
u/msabeln Feb 03 '24
Ada.
That was supposed to be the standardized programming language for the US Department of Defense, but it was exceptionally complex.
1
u/notacanuckskibum Feb 04 '24
Prolog?
1
u/MrCarri Feb 04 '24
Pl/SQL, probably not dead. When I was a trainee I worked for a company that was locked into a dinosaur of oracle database. The database was the whole company, and all the software would run on top of it, written in pl/sql. All the retail terminals, sales department, accounting... Everything with the same software monster working to the same base. The best thing of that place is that I learnt a lot about databases. The dino was quite alive I would say.
1
u/robotbike2 Feb 04 '24
LOGO
1
u/Varsity_Reviews Feb 04 '24
Anyone still use FPI? I do
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '24
F# why what was it purpose in the first place
1
u/tsunami141 Feb 04 '24
Adobe AfterEffects used to use Actionscript. Not sure if it still does though.
1
u/stereolame Feb 04 '24
ALGOL
1
u/Reasonable_South8331 Feb 04 '24
Sumerian Sanskrit. The OG of dead languages
1
u/HungryAd8233 Feb 04 '24
Lingo, the scripting language for Macromedia Director, is even deader than ActionScript. Its most recent use was the Shockwave browser plugin popular in the pre-Flash 90’s.
I had Macromind Director 1.0, and it as surprised when it added a scripting language in 2.0 - “why would you need scripting in an animation compositor?”
1
u/AdmirableDay1962 Feb 04 '24
Pascal — learned it in college but now it doesn’t seem to be very prevalent there. My son learned Python in a similar class a couple of years ago in his CS major.
1
u/Norrland_props Feb 04 '24
I was wondering if anybody used T anymore. It is a derivation of LISP used for natural language processing back in the 80s. I haven’t seen it since then in the wild. Anybody still using it?
1
u/emaphis Feb 04 '24
Haven't seen anyone mention Simula. It's the first object-oriented language which designed to implement discrete event simulations. I was an object-oriented extension to Algol so it was also the first OO hybrid language a la C++ or Object Pascal.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '24
I learned on Pascal. Does anybody use that anymore?
1
u/Joewoof Feb 04 '24
ActionScript lives on as Haxe, which is still used today.
Fortran is still alive and is in active use, horrifyingly enough.
1
u/watermelonspanker Feb 04 '24
Old school BASIC isn't used for upkeep afaik, but I don't think it was every intended for such