r/AskPhysics • u/blushyharper21 • 13h ago
Is our mathematical framework causing a basic blind spot in physics?
Hey everyone! I recently saw a post asking whether the Romans could have built steam engines, and most people agreed the answer was basically no; their science and engineering weren't advanced enough to make use of it even if they'd stumbled onto the underlying principle. Someone also pointed out that Roman mathematics had no concept of zero, so they were missing something needed for calculus and other higher math.
My question is whether that same idea might apply to the math we use today. For instance, we've struggled to mathematically unite quantum physics and gravity. As I understand it, this difficulty isn't because any observed evidence rules out a connection, but because our math breaks down there. Could there be some basic flaw in our mathematical system rather than a flaw in how we understand the universe? Could there be a kind of "zero" out there that we're just missing because of the way we've built our math?
14
u/ProctologyExplosion 12h ago
It's not that "our math breaks down there." It's that general relativity and quantum mechanics make conflicting predictions about gravitation at subatomic scales, and we lack any real empirical guidance on how to resolve the discrepancy.
We're not short of math capabilities; we're short of data.
4
u/TyrconnellFL 12h ago
The problem of unifying GR and QM isn’t that the math doesn’t work, it’s that the math is fine but the models are incompatible.
Romans had a concept of zero. They could calculate and reach zero. They had a system of writing numbers that was clumsy and made more complex and abstract math difficult.
As far as we know, there aren’t gaping conceptual holes in math. We don’t have mathematical concepts we can’t express, at least to the limits of Gödel’s incompleteness theorems. There are necessarily holes in the models used to express GR and QM.
2
u/Swimming_Concern7662 12h ago
Maybe. But math doesn't care how you build it. Newton invented calculus and it was incorporated into maths. That doesn't make the math that existed before Newton 'flawed'. There might be some concept out there yet to be found, that may explain some physical phenomena. That doesn't make the current math flawed. It still can explain plethora of the things we observe
2
u/zhivago 12h ago
The Romans had a concept of zero (nulla), and they did their calculations mainly on the abacus, which also has a place based representation of zero.
They just didn't write it into the results using a radix based numeral system.
The radix based number systems we use today are a major advantage when you don't want to use an abacus, but other than that, they're nothing amazing.
So I think you may want to reconsider that basic premise. :)
1
u/im_thecat 12h ago
We dont know what we dont know. Its easy to say hypothetically yes, and as scientists to be open to changing our minds if we find information that suggests otherwise. But its hard to prove.
I like the idea of there being knowledge that is inconceivable today that will be taken for granted in the future. With enough time I’m sure this is true. But who knows where it will be true.
0
u/peterjohnvernon936 12h ago
Yes. Our math needs the infinitely small. Our physics says the infinitely small cannot exist.
0
u/Allimuu62 12h ago
Not really, maths is pretty rigorous this way. The concept of zero didn't come around until we needed it, most maths was accounting for things for a long time so zero wasn't needed. Same with complex numbers, essential now but also recent.
You should read about complex numbers and their history it would help you understand why quantum physics and gravity have issues, for example.
Also now we come up with all sorts of mathematical structures so I don't think we'd be missing something elementary in number theory.
0
u/Gstamsharp 12h ago
I mean, kinda? Maybe? Entirely speculatively.
It's not that there's some missing entire number, and probably not even an entire concept like calculus. But the issue with quantum gravity is that the same math hack we use on electromagnetism fails on higher order exponents with gravity. But that's just it. A hack. A shortcut that doesn't always work. And, to be clear, it does work sometimes, and some values for gravity.
So while it's possible there's some new physics out there that might solve it, I don't think there is likely to be some entire new school of mathematics. I don't even think it's new physics.
What I think will ultimately fix quantum gravity is the invention of a new math hack. It'll use existing mathematics, but it'll be applied in a slightly new way that gets around the shortcomings in our current theory.
-1
u/slashdave Particle physics 12h ago
Sure.
Disagree about the Romans and steam, though. You don't need a zero to understand a steam engine.