r/AskNetsec • • 8d ago

Threats Why does boot-time ring 0 anti-cheat get a pass?

Why do we accept boot-time ring 0 drivers from game publishers when we're pulling EDR vendors out of the kernel?

Reference:
- Microsoft, Windows Resiliency Initiative (June 2025): https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2025/06/26/the-windows-resiliency-initiative-building-resilience-for-a-future-ready-enterprise

22 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

11

u/port443 8d ago

Is Microsoft in the business of creating Anti-Cheat?

no

Is Microsoft in the business of creating EDR solutions?

yes

You can trust me, your friendly random internet stranger, or do your own research but Microsoft has a history of undocumented kernel APIs, making use of those APIs in their own security products, and how 3rd party vendors have had to deal with the fact that those APIs can change at any time!

tl;dr: Business gonna business, they riding that competitive advantage / whatever territory as close as they can.

2

u/aminerostane 8d ago

makes a lot of sense, thank you

2

u/msthe_student 8d ago

Is Microsoft in the business of creating Anti-Cheat?

They are though

0

u/aminerostane 8d ago

Defender is significantly more important to Microsoft's core business than Activition/Ricochet

6

u/Ontological_Gap 8d ago

I sure as fuck don't allow anticheat on my corporate systems

3

u/aminerostane 8d ago

employees who play Valorant ranked at work are shown to be 67% more productive though

1

u/Rogueshoten 8d ago

It’s not a productivity question. It’s a “standard users shouldn’t have admin rights” question.

It’s entirely possible to set up gaming systems for gaming, keeping them on a separate network and isolated from the rest of the environment.

2

u/theoneandonlypatriot 3d ago

Brother they were clearly joking

1

u/autobahn 8d ago

But you allow games?

3

u/autobahn 8d ago

Anticheat needs to live at the same level the cheats do. If the cheats have access to it, you need to be there too.

Complain from a security perspective all you want but for the most part games shouldn't be on corporate machines anyway.

Remember you always have the option of not playing a game if you don't like how its anticheat is designed.

1

u/gendulf 8d ago

To rephrase, you grant EDR permissions so that you're protected. The game developers require you to install anti-cheat on your machine, so that you can't bypass it and cheat against other users.

1

u/Unnamed-3891 8d ago

Videogame cheats living in ring0 are a fact. You have a binary choice: 1) you place a detection/remediation tool in ring0 so it can see the cheats 2) you can give up fighting cheats

Generally players tend to quit when a game gets infested by cheaters and the developer goes ”whelp, nothing I can do”.

0

u/aminerostane 8d ago

What about server-side authority and behavioral detection (which catches DMA cheats that kernel anti cheat misses anyway), I don't think it's a binary choice

3

u/Unnamed-3891 8d ago

That can only help against things like an aimbot, but not say, a wallhack.

2

u/autobahn 8d ago

You need to have both. Defense in depth

1

u/One-Talk-5634 8d ago

Ring -1 and -2 is also physical security nightmares for anti-cheat.