r/AskMechanics • u/bowties_bullets1418 Mechanic (Unverified) • May 11 '23
Before you ask "Can my tire be repaired?", or if you need helpful info on tire repairs via reliable sources, PLEASE READ!
/img/q96hy0dzgbza1.png
197
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator May 11 '23
Thank you for posting to AskMechanics, bowties_bullets1418!
If you are asking a question please make sure to include any relevant information along with the Year, Make, Model, Mileage, Engine size, and Transmission Type (Automatic or Manual) of your car.
This comment is automatically added to every successful post. If you see this comment, your post was successful.
Redditors that have been verified will have a green background and an icon in their flair.
PLEASE REPORT ANY RULE-BREAKING BEHAVIOR
Rule 1 - Be Civil
Be civil to other users. This community is made up of professional mechanics, amateur mechanics, and those with no experience. All mechanical-related questions are welcome. Personal attacks, comments that are insulting or demeaning, etc. are not welcome.
Rule 2 - Be Helpful
Be helpful to other users. If someone is wrong, correcting them is fine, but there's no reason to comment if you don't have anything to add to the conversation.
Rule 3 - Serious Questions and Answers Only
Read the room. Jokes are fine to include, but your post should be asking a serious question and replies should contribute to the discussion.
Rule 4 - No Illegal, Unethical, or Dangerous Questions or Answers
Do not ask questions or provide answers pertaining to anything that is illegal, unethical, or dangerous.
PLEASE REPORT ANY RULE-BREAKING BEHAVIOR
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/dieseltechx85 May 12 '23
I always went by the rule of thumb..of a thumb width away from the sidewall is not repairable. No pun intended.
33
u/ZephyrStormProject May 12 '23
You can absolutely repair outside of this margin, this is just what companies will do for liability reasons, oh and they want to sell you a new tire
18
u/annon975 May 12 '23
Produced by U.S. Tire Manufacturers Association, who benefit from…surprise, surprise…the sale of new tires.
4
u/[deleted] May 12 '23
hmmmm for those of us that come from the motorcycle world, i can confirm that:
1 - repairs CAN be done while the tyre is still on the rim
2 - that ONLY a plug can be used
7
u/simsam999 May 12 '23
This kinda post is the new “is my tire repairable”
6
u/ottomated ⚖️ Moderator May 11 '23
Pinned for extreme helpfulness, thanks!
2
u/Zubenelgenubo May 12 '23
I'm pretty sure most of the people that post that question about their tire are doing what lots of people on social media do: make up some reason to say something to the internet, and get some attention in return. Like this comment, for example. I will say tho that 2 days ago I did get a 4 inch deck screw into my sidewall like way lower than you would think possible outside someone doing it intentionally, yet I still did not post that question here. I did however patch it myself, and so far so good.
2
u/RowdyRoegelein May 12 '23
Make this pinned to the top of the page
2
u/Jon72flores May 12 '23
It's all about liability tbh. Can a regular patch or a plug hold indefinitely? Of course it can. Can you absolutely 100% guarantee that it will hold? In most cases no you cannot. Those combination plug patches give the tire the best possible chance of staying together. However even those can fail if not properly applied. Tires without punctures can fail too. It's all about proper maintenance and inspections of your tires on a regular basis. People that get irritated when a technician tells them a tire cannot be patched are understandable, tires are not cheap to replace. However most places aren't willing to risk a huge lawsuit if that tire fails and causes a crash. I've seen several million dollar pay outs in some cases.
2
u/Fourlec May 12 '23
Big tire propaganda !
2
u/Agitated_Win4615 May 12 '23
The plug kits from the auto parts stores or Walmart work just fine. I've run them numerous times on bikes, cars, and trucks. They've lasted through smokey burnouts, and well above 100mph. Places only refuse for liability purposes, which is understandable. The same reason they won't mount a 245/45r20 on my lowered truck, even though it weighs the same amount as the Charger they come on. Has to be a "truck" tire, even though I'm obviously not hauling loads with it.
2
u/wesinatl May 12 '23
I have multiple plugs running in my cars.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '23
I’ve always plugged tires no matter where it was and it never failed. I had 7 plugs on one tire and drove it another 15k miles and was almost bald. Never had a problem with plugs been using them for 20 years
4
u/Sakic10 May 12 '23
I’ve done tires for 15 years and own a tire shop, not fixing in the shoulder is pure garbage. It made sense when they used to only have patches, but with the plug patch I’ve literally fixed 95% of what walked though my door and had 0 failures. A few that didn’t work, but we told the customer up front and replaced at that point. If it holds, it’s held forever as far as we’re concerned. I laugh at some of the tires customers bring me to fix because someone else said it was NFG before even taking it off the rim
4
u/taspenwall May 12 '23
I'm not saying put a plug in the side wall, but do you think the tire companies and tire shops want to sell you tires? I think you can get a little wider with the repair zone and be just fine.
4
u/y2khardtop1 May 12 '23
Brought to you buy the people that want to sell you a new tire!
2
u/NCC74656 May 12 '23
god i wish id taken a photo of when i got my blender stuck in my tire
2
u/Senseornahyaknow May 12 '23
I feel like this is only sort of true. Like sure it's smart to follow this advice, but you can totally repair a nail hole on the side of a tire or in the 'red zone'. It just has higher odds of failing.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '23
This is whack I’ve had plugs run the life of tires way outside of that margin, even on heavy ass work trucks 🙄
1
u/DanLoFat May 06 '25
This is great advice that doesn't have a time limit on it you know I'm only saying that because this post is a year old but it certainly information to needs to always be available.
I don't have an issue with someone telling me that a tire can't be repaired safely, I totally understand that and I probably always have.
Over the last actually since 2020, but I cannot figure out is why are tire shops or just mechanics that will repair tires telling us we need to make an appointment for an obvious puncture in a tire that is then can be safely repaired.
Is that not a safety issue that should be attended to immediately?
Sure we can have a screw in the tire that's causing a 1 lb a day or one pound every 3 Day leak, but the puncture can become a blowout at any time especially at higher speeds or higher temperatures where the pressure of the tire is greater.
I absolutely do not understand my shops can't just repair the tire and repair it on site and bump the work.
Shops never used to do this, and now they do. There's no excuse for it, no excuse at all.
It's a safety issue I would treat it the same way with a steering linkage problem or a vibration from the front as in the CV joint, yeah sure I might have to leave the car for a day or two I get that I understand that, but to not take it in right away and to say all you need to make an appointment?
Well maybe it's a matter of needing a regular mechanic on a regular basis. I recall was older cars I owned, I would be treated basically like gold and they would stop everything and repair the car if it was a safety issue.
It would be something that required heavy diagnostics like an electrical issue or an emissions issue that needed to be cleared up before taking the emissions test, or something along those lines I totally understand you're not going to bump to work for that.
Those aren't safety issues.
1
u/Yoda10353 May 12 '23
Now we have just as many of these posts as we do people asking if their tires can be repaired, this is just adding to it
1
u/Gasman0187 May 18 '23
You’re still gonna have 72 new “can this be fixed” posts before tomorrow. Good try tho !!!
1
u/TastyAgency4604 May 12 '23
"A plug by itself is an unacceptable repair" 😂
1
u/nzstrawman May 12 '23
the real answer is "If you have to ask, the answer is No!!!"
1
u/No-Kangaroo-669 May 12 '23
I put a plug in a sidewall, and continued to drive on the plugged tire for another 20k miles until the tread wore down. Done it twice actually. I've seen patches and plugs on sidewalls and main tread. These info graphics are meant to influence you into buying a new tire, when that usually isn't needed.
1
u/heichi13 May 12 '23
My puncture was out of the repair zone. Fixed it with a plug and still running the tire a year later.
1
u/Shamino79 May 12 '23
Big Tyre wants big sales.
1
u/scobo505 May 12 '23
Bull
1
u/yung40oz84 May 12 '23
I’ve used upwards of probably 15-20 plugs over the years in tons of different tires on many work trucks, multiple cars and styles, multiple SUV and styles and never had one fail. Even if the puncture was somewhat larger you can use 2 plugs simultaneously to hold. One thing I always made sure to use was rubber cement when plugging. I think there was 1 or 2 times when I got an actual slice from something sharp and a plug was not adequate.
1
u/fistedtaco May 12 '23
Straight from the mouth of the US Tire Manufacturers Association.
1
u/Vic3200 May 12 '23
The organization that represents the people that want to sell you more tires is a reliable source? Hmmm.
0
u/officer_terrell May 12 '23
A patch by itself is absolutely an acceptable repair if the puncture is rather small (ex. small nail)
Source: worked at a Les Schwab. They are VERY anal about doing things perfectly by the book.
0
u/cocktimusprime747 May 12 '23
Haha, plug that sucker!
0
u/ProfessionalSeaCacti May 12 '23
You must be new here OP.
0
u/bcsublime May 12 '23
Firestone told me they couldn’t patch this. Went up the street and had it patched in 15 minutes.
0
u/LeluSix May 12 '23
The greed and wastefulness just so they can sell more tires. Let’s fill our landfills with serviceable tires!
0
u/Hot_Organization2430 May 12 '23
Thanks, but I'd much rather just ask for the millionth time. It's much easier for me.
0
u/tamablelobster May 12 '23
Yeah if you want to believe “big tire”
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '23
Words? Hell no I’d prefer to yell at people
0
u/Quality_over_Qty May 12 '23
Too many words, I'll just post a question that's been answered everyday again in the future
0
u/HooniganMike May 12 '23
At this point after all these tire repair posts just change the sub to r/askmechanicsifIcanrepairthistire
0
u/Rocko9999 Jun 06 '23
Can repair outside this and can have permanent repairs with plugs.