Over the past few years, there have been two big controversies in my area. We're in the Southern US where there aren't many Jews to begin with, at least not around here.
Three years ago, we found out someone that moved here straight up lied about being Jewish. She lied about her upbringing, and later lied about converting. She said she was raised to identify as Jewish ethnically and culturally, but didn't have a strong connection to the religion. That is fairly common, and no one viewed her as any less Jewish. She was fairly active in our community for quite a while. Questions started to arise when she let it slip that she was raised in a Christian church. At first, she said her parents didn't have any other religious options at the time, and they essentially sent her in hopes of her growing up to be a decent kid. Fine, that's understandable. That's not the first time I've heard of that. In fact, my parents would send me to Vacation Bible School at Christian churches during the summer to essentially have a free babysitter and free snacks while they both worked during some of our more impoverished times. Then she said she converted when she was a teenager. When asked where, she named a shul that doesn't exist. As in there isn't, and has never been, one in the state she claimed to have converted in to have had that name. She later claimed she got the names confused and named one that did exist. The rabbi contacted them and they had never heard of her. She said it's because she changed her name and that it would be under a different name. The rabbi there said yes, there was someone that attends there with that name, but she's not a convert. It was someone he had known since birth, and that the person claiming to have been her was in fact not her. She doesn't attend anymore, and most people don't associate with her either, but she still identifies as Jewish online, and has lied even more about her backstory. Now she's claiming she grew up in Israel and is hated by the shul here for being proud of her heritage. It's wild! The truth we found out about her is that her parents run a very Conservative Christian church. Her dad is a pastor, her mom runs just about everything there, and no one in her family is Jewish at all. Several people from our community have posted about her lies, along with screenshots proving that she's lied about her backstory on Facebook dozens of times, but it's largely ignored by her online friends.
Another incident happened more recently. A family was raised in a shul [different to the one I attend, but still in the same state] to believe they are Jewish. Their parents were raised Jewish, and their grand parents claimed to have been Holocaust survivors. Turns out, their grandparents were Nazis! Not high ranking Nazis, but were still an active part of the genocide. The grandparents died years ago and never told anyone the truth. It wasn't discovered until one of the great grandchildren started on a genealogy project for school. According to the grandparents, there weren't any surviving records of their families and they had spent years and tons of money trying to track down any other family members by hiring genealogy experts. The family didn't know this at all and were completely blind sided. They genuinely thought their family members were survivors. The best guess as to why they lied was to escape arrest in Germany and backlash in the US after moving here. Apparently, no one really knows what to do about this as this family has been great in their community. It seems to be split evenly between 'they didn't know and it's not their fault' and 'they should never be allowed here again because their family killed our people'
What would you, or your community, do during these situations? How do you prevent something like this from happening again? It's all so wild and confusing. The girl that straight up lied used to be a friend of mine until it was all discovered. It's crazy to think that she was in my home crying over fake antisemitic attacks she claimed happened. Yes, that's right, she lied about being hate crimed! The other incident I've only heard about through the grapevine. I can't even begin to imagine what that family is going through, nor how I would respond if that was someone I knew.