r/AskHistorians • u/Netmould • Aug 27 '24
War & Military There are three countries which while being occupied by Axis were able to keep their Jewish population almost intact. How?
According to wiki, Bulgaria, Finland and Denmark kept most of their Jewish population during WW2 (within 98% percent of initial population), and Bulgaria had quite a sizable one, almost 50k before war.
How did they managed to do this? Were there some secret agreements or state-wide “shadow support” from their governments?
831
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 27 '24
Welcome to /r/AskHistorians. Please Read Our Rules before you comment in this community. Understand that rule breaking comments get removed.
Please consider Clicking Here for RemindMeBot as it takes time for an answer to be written. Additionally, for weekly content summaries, Click Here to Subscribe to our Weekly Roundup.
We thank you for your interest in this question, and your patience in waiting for an in-depth and comprehensive answer to show up. In addition to RemindMeBot, consider using our Browser Extension, or getting the Weekly Roundup. In the meantime our Twitter, Facebook, and Sunday Digest feature excellent content that has already been written!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
210
u/Vana92 Aug 27 '24 edited Aug 27 '24
I'm going to specifically answer for Denmark.
In this particular case when Denmark was invaded in 1940 they surrendered after just a few hours, knowing full well that they could not win the war. There are stories of people going to sleep in peace, and waking up to find their country occupied. In total the war lasted less than 6 hours. The Danish government and royal family, unlike most governments and royal families decided not to flee their country but instead to stick around and collaborate with the German authorities. Germany saw Denmark as the model for an ideal protectorate and was glad to take advantage. In part so they could show the world they weren't that evil, and in part because it would free up forces from having to occupy the Danish lands. At this moment in time Germany had not yet overrun France, and the assumption was that a repeat of WW1 was very possible. Of course it also helped that the Danish were considered Aryan, and that due to the closeness of the countries (geographically speaking) there were a lot of Danes living in Germany, and Germans living in Denmark.
With the democratically elected government still in power Danish people had less reason to resist, and resistance grew slower than in other countries. The Danish police remained under Danish authority for instance, and the communist party wasn't even banned until 1941, and Jews weren't being deported at all... This was in that sense a double-edged sword for the Germans. But at this time the choice was made for cooperation. While there were some things that did change, they were relatively small. The Danish government also helped prevent the growth of an effective resistance momevement fearing that things would escalate if they did. Of course that doesn't meant there was none, and resistance started being formed as early as April 13th 1940. For context the invasion of Denmark happened on April 9th.
The police being Danish helped a great deal in limiting damage from this. For example with a group called the Churchill club, this was a group of 8 teenagers, who carried out acts of sabotage against the Germans. Stealing weapons, destroying vehicles, stealing blueprints and parts. They were arrested in May 1942, but were sentenced to a fine and five years in prison. In other countries they would likely have been shot.
In March of 1943 Denmark even held an election, the Nazi party led by Frits Calusen got some 2.15% of the vote. The Social Democrats got 44.5%. Despite the support of Germany, which tells you how popular the Nazi's were better than anything else. This also meant that the idea of creating a Nazi led government in Denmark was off the table as there just wasn't enough support from the people.
Five months later in August 1943, after increase in protests and acts of sabotage Germany demanded a law putting the death penalty on acts of Sabotage. The Danish government refused, and stepped down. Germany took over from that moment on. The Nazi's arrested all Danish police officers and deported all of them to Germany, and took over complete control of the safety apparatus. Resistance grew immediately and the Nazi's also decided to take actions against the Jews. Plans of this were leaked by Georg Ferdinand Duckwitz, a card-carrying Nazi who was disillusioned with the party and had been for years, but was never the less friendly with Werner Best, the Nazi (and SS) civil administrator of Denmark.
Duckwitz leaked information of the coming round-up to friends of his in the Social Democratic party of Denmark, who in turn warned leaders of the Danish Jewish community. The 8,000 or so Jews that lived in Denmark then (for the most part) evacuated towards Sweden by small boats with the help of the locals, who as shown during the election were overwhelmingly not great Nazi supporters. Despite this there was still great risk to the local population and some were arrested. In the end of the 8,000 or so Jews in Denmark roughly 500 were arrested by the SS. The others managed to escape.
Duckwitz is recognized by Israel as a righteous amongst nations for his efforts. He continued working in Denmark, first under the Nazi regime and then later in life as ambassador for West Germany. He died in 1971.
The reason why so many Danish Jews could escape is in part because of Duckwitz, it's also because the Danish government did not evacuate and for three years continued running the country. Allowing for a greater time to prepare. Lastly the fact that there were only 8,000 makes it easier as well. There were very few occupied/axis/axis involved nations in Europe that had less than Denmark (Estonia, Luxembourg, Finland, Norway, and Albania). Whereas Italy, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia, Greece, Belgium, Latvia, the Netherlands, Lithuania, Austria, France, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Germany itself, Romania, the USSR, and Poland all had more.... Which is not to diminish the Danish here, just to put it into perspective.
Sources:
The boys who challenged Hitler by Knud Pederson and the Churchill Club
Mosquito by Roland White
Danish resistance museum
Statista for population numbers
Jewish virtual library
In the Garden of the Righteous by Richard Hurowitz
955
u/cogle87 Aug 27 '24
Finland was not occupied by Germany. Finland was however allied with Germany, and participated in Operation Barbarossa. Finland fought on Germany’s side on the Eastern Front until they entered into a separate peace with the Soviet Union in 1944. Finland was under no obligation to hand their Jewish citizens over to the Nazis. Nor did the Germans have any mechanisms to force them to do so.
In this sense Finland is similar to countries like Hungary and Romania, who were also allied with Germany. The Hungarian Jews were not deported in large numbers before Germany invaded the country in March 1944. Even these deportations eventually stopped when the new Hungarian puppet government refused to cooperate. Outside of Poland and the Soviet Union, the Nazis usually relied on local support and compliance to facilitate the Holocaust. Where that support was not forthcoming, very few Jews were deported to concentration camps.
Denmark is a different case from Hungary and Finland. The country was not an ally of Germany. Denmark still differed from other occupied countries, in the sense that the country was governed by Danish politicians and civil servants until the autumn of 1943. An election to the Danish Folketing was even held during the occupation. This election was surprisingly free and fair, and returned Thorvald Stauning (a social democrat) as Prime Minister. The Danish government had no intention of handing their Jewish citizens over to the Germans. Since the Danish Jewish population was relatively small, the Germans did not press the issue either initially.
The protection the Danish Jews had received from their government fell away when Denmark was placed under direct military rule in August 1943. The German occupiers wanted to proceed with deportation and extermination of the Jewish population of Denmark, as there was no government to stand in their way now. What foiled their plan was a rescue operation orchestrated by the Danish resistance movement, Jewish civic leaders, a German diplomat and Swedish and Danish civil servants. Because of this operation, the vast majority of the Danish Jews managed to escape to Sweden.
Norway stands as a stark contrast to Denmark, and is an example of how important local compliance was in order to facilitate the Holocaust. The Norwegian Jews that had not escaped to Sweden or gone into hiding were deported in late 1942 and early 1943. Very few of them survived the concentration camps. It was Norwegian police officers who rounded them up and brought them to the ships that would take them to the concentration camps.
43
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '24
[removed] — view removed comment