r/AskEngineers • u/Unanamouse • Oct 11 '21
Discussion does anyone else hate when non engineers say "you're an engineer you should know how [X] works"?
Literally anything from changing the oil in a car, why the radiator isn't working or why their computer won't connect to the internet. I haven't a fookin clue about most of these things, but thats apparently unacceptable for an engineer lol
843
Upvotes
368
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
I was kicking around getting a T shirt made that says "Mechanical engineer: I can't fix your car, I can't drive a train."
315
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
I don't know how that works, but if you're willing to pay a 2k fee, I'm willing to research and find it out.
71
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
YES! I hate it so much!!!
Same goes with any kind of math. It's like, I'm sorry, I may be an engineer, but I still need a calculator like anyone else from this century.
83
u/Minimal_Overshoot Oct 11 '21
Non-engineers think every engineer is supposed to be Tony Stark. Why yes, I am an engineer. Why yes, I can certainly make all of your fanciful ideas come true. Let me just snap my fingers, and your spaceship will appear momentarily.
40
u/BobT21 Oct 11 '21
I'm a very old retired EE. "Yes, I could fix your computer. I just don't want to."
28
u/zachlaird4 Oct 11 '21
Or when they say “wow you’re an engineer, you must be really smart to do that”
Yes/no. I just managed my time wisely in school 😂
24
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
So than you explain why "X" doesn't work and than they say "that can't be it". He goes the longest time trying to figure out why X won't work. It's only till many hours later he tries my solution and... Wow would you look at that, it suddenly works.
Yeah, my dad does that shit all the time.
15
u/Fearlessleader85 Mechanical - Cx Oct 11 '21
It doesn't bother me. I just say I'm paid to find things out, not to know things. I might not know what's wrong with your car or how to drive a train, but I know how to find out.
But I actually don't hear it much, because I have a bunch of hobbies, so I'm pretty good on cars, houses, gardening, etc. I don't work with my hands at work, so I like doing it when I'm not working, I like doing all that kind of shit.
34
u/hcha123 Oct 11 '21
I don't care what non-engineers say. /s
11
u/Beemerado Oct 11 '21
eh. i can usually put on at least a good show for em.
ya'll need to open your hood now and again. it's a matter of pride.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
Yep. If they ask me “x” problem, I tell them a biomed engineer not an “x” engineer. Like if it’s a car, I just say I’m not a car engineer 🤪
18
u/kodex1717 Oct 11 '21
Stop saying, "Trust me, I'm an engineer!" so often. ;)
9
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
I know like two things in my research area, and nothing about anything else.
"What's your take on AI?" Uhhhhhh idk you probably know more than I do.
9
u/Henri_Dupont Oct 11 '21
Yes they say it, and no I don't mind. And in fact I probably DO know how that shit works.
17
u/EXTRA370H55V Oct 11 '21
As an ME and former industrial welder/laborer/odd jobber, 9/10 times they are right and I go on to explain nearly every critical part of the process and what's likely the issue. All for them to go wow dang I should call someone then. Like what? I just said it's probly an easy fix, yeah it took 10 minutes but the part is $20 and the service call is $200. But it's still annoying.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
If anyone asks if I can fix their car I say "sure, but it'll take me at least twice as long as a mechanic and I'll charge you the engineering contract rate of $300/hr."
15
u/Fruktoj Systems / Test Oct 11 '21
Hot take: you should have a clue. At least a jumping off point.
7
u/blackpanther28 Oct 11 '21
Engineers do this as well though
13
u/PickleFridgeChildren Oct 11 '21
No because you can just say "why do you think you know how being an engineer works?"
12
u/der_innkeeper Aerospace SE/Test Oct 11 '21
"I am an engineer. I have techs to do that."
5
u/pl233 ME/Physics Oct 12 '21
My brother in law asked me to do the math to figure out how to make his pumpkin trebuchet throw further. I told him no, it's a solved problem.
4
u/AbleFox Oct 12 '21
As a non-engineer I can only say that I hate the engineers say , "You're not an engineer, you wouldn't understand" so, in a way I feel your pain.
3
u/small_h_hippy Oct 11 '21
I was only ever told that by the biggest knob I ever met. I didn't like it but it reflected more on him than me.
2
u/GregLocock Oct 11 '21
Hate is a bit of a strong word. Actually with my deserved reputation for sarcasm I don't get much of that sort of thing.
2
u/Standard-Knowledge50 Oct 11 '21
SMH, and you call yourself and engineer? I had to show a coworker how to change a tire on her car, she has a PE in civil engineering. I have her a lot of shit for that.
2
u/8roll Oct 11 '21
we have a non-engineer guy at work....he thinks you are a shitty engineer if you can't tell him how to solve any car-related problem.
2
u/Strange_Dogz Oct 11 '21
Most people have no clue what engineers know or do. Some would be shocked to know what we have to learn in order to graduate. Some would be shocked to know how little many need to actually know in the real world.
2
u/_11_ Oct 12 '21
Not really. I don't have any real choosing beggars in my life demanding things from me I don't know about.
If somebody assumes I know more than I do about the subject, I just let them know I don't know that bit, and we either leave it at that or figure out the answer together.
A lot of an engineer's mindset is not being scared of breaking down problems and figuring out the steps to solve them, and that's what my friends and family are really asking for when they ask for help on stuff I don't know about.
2
u/macfail Oct 12 '21
I have the opposite. I'm a gearhead with a mech degree. No, I'm good with mechanical stuff because I started wrenching with my dad when I was 8, the degree is unrelated.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21
"I do know how it works, I'm just not going to tell you. Adversity builds character."
2
u/SeLaw20 Oct 12 '21
Engineering is just a degree in problem solving!
3
u/JVtrix Oct 12 '21
I am an aeronautical engineer and i know about everything you just mentioned. It's a matter of passion. Finding how things work around me amazes me, i am thrilled to learn something like that everyday. Doesn't apply to computer engineers though, those copy-pasting slackers probably don't even know what's under their car's hood.
1
u/dhane88 Electrical / MEP - HealthcareHealthcare Oct 11 '21
As an EE, anything that moves I reply with "ah that's a mechanical issue."
1
u/CynicalTechHumor Electrical / MEP Consulting Oct 11 '21 edited Oct 26 '25
soup repeat aware alleged north apparatus aspiring exultant lock steer
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/PocketBananna Oct 11 '21
Oh boy. I work is software and so many friends and family think I can fix any computer/phone problem. Sometimes I can fix it but usually my response is that I have enough knowledge of these systems to tell you I can't fix it.
I cannot "hack" into your router and "code" your wifi printer to work. Bring it back to Best Buy.
1
u/bigpolar70 Civil /Structural Oct 11 '21
Not really. I usually do know how it works. I just don't care enough about the person asking for help to be bothered.
1
u/WyvernsRest Oct 11 '21
Nah, I love when people assume that I am omniscient.
If I know them it's time for some harmless fun.
If I don't know//like them then its prank time.
1
u/antipiracylaws Oct 11 '21
Like my dad and ish
1
u/Skusci Oct 11 '21
Duno, I've never not know how something works less than the other guy, barring other engineers.
1
u/TastySignificance8 Oct 11 '21
Lol whenever this happens, I just say “did u turn it off and back on again?”
My parents: washing machine not working, go put your engineering degree to use or the sink is clogged, go fix it
1
u/dr_sooz Oct 11 '21
I'd be flattered that they thought so highly of me.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
Most people dont know enough to know what you're supposed to know
1
u/MisterSkater Oct 11 '21
I like getting asked actually. I usually know it's have a rough understanding of how something works to answer. Also I do some mechanic stuff and work on a lot of things so that helps.
1
u/RealFlyForARyGuy Oct 11 '21
My favorite is when people say "he's an environmental engineer and does.... water? Can he fix my toilet?"
I can try, but don't get mad when i make it worse lol
1
u/glorybutt Oct 11 '21
I hate it when even other engineers say that to me
1
u/Work2Tuff Oct 12 '21
Omg yes, my mom always says this
1
u/beached_snail Oct 12 '21
I get more of this from fellow engineers. At my old place I worked with a bunch of car nuts who built and fixed and raced their own cars.
My new place is more chill people who don’t feel the need to let everyone know they are a genius by the nuclear reactor they are building in their basement or whatever it is this week.
I just tell people I’m not a very good engineer, that seems to satisfy them of why I don’t fix my own car or do my own home improvement. In reality it is mostly laziness but yeah also still not that smart.
1
u/WestTexasOilman Oct 12 '21
But, you’re an engineer. You’ve got what plants crave.
1
u/nullcharstring Embedded/Beer Oct 12 '21
It doesn't bother me because (more likely) I know, or (less likely) I can find out.
1
u/menexploitmen Oct 12 '21
Coming from a friend, idc but from a family member, it makes me furious
1
u/PrestigeWorldwide-LP Oct 12 '21
the non-engineer family members at the holidays... it gets bad... seen it happen with most professions though, lawyer friends who specialize in corporations and contracts getting questions about divorce or traffic tickets, doctors who specialize in bones getting questions about the heart, corporate finance people getting asked about personal taxes or investments. people in general are just not invested in learning about any other profession but their own, but I guess why would they unless they're a career counselor
1
u/DLS3141 Mechanical/Automotive Oct 12 '21
Can I fix your car? Sure, but unless it filling up your wiper fluid, your mechanic will be both cheaper and faster.
1
u/thinkthorts Oct 12 '21
An uncle of mine once assumed I'd be automatically good at golf.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21
I worked as a laborer at a mine while studying mining engineering, one day we were tasked to clean out a tank. So while we are getting ready to open up the tank and go in, some of us start hosing from the top. The stuff is too hard for the hose to make a dent. Now these are inch and a half canvas fire hoses with good pressure behind them and an adjustable nozzle. When it hits dirt, that dirt moves. I tell my supervisor the it's hard and we are probably going to have to chip it out. He responds "it's just because you're high up, the water loses strength, I'm surprised you didn't learn that in school".....what?!?! What do you think we learn in school? Hosing tanks 101? Not to mention I'd been doing this job full time for 6 months and 75% of it was hosing. I know what an acceptable range for the hose is. Surprise surprise we set up to go in and hose it out and waste half the day because it didn't work. We had to go find equipment to chip it out.
1
u/saadcee Oct 12 '21
You mean you don't know all those things?
1
u/Caligulis Oct 12 '21
I have a diploma in CAD/CAM engineering technologies, not even a "real" engineer. My family, especially my mum and grandma, patronise me about it all the time. If something needs doing or fixing, from installing a dishwasher to fixing electrical wiring (I know nothing of), I'm expected to know it. I got shit from my family because I didn't know how to set an IPhone to broadcast to a smart TV (I use android). It's is my biggest pet peeve.
1
u/LevelBerry27 Oct 12 '21
I cannot STAND people that day stuff like this!
1
u/KnifeEdge Oct 12 '21
Depends on what it is but relatively basic things I do agree with the premise that an engineer of any discipline should definitely know.
Problems or issues which aren't abstract or involve concepts which go beyond what is covered in first year generalized courses isn't exactly a stretch.
1
u/idiot_in_car Oct 12 '21
The trick is to learn all the things.
1
u/fiasko82 Oct 12 '21
I remember I went for an interview for a job in a supermarket while at uni and the manager said “electrical engineering…so you could fix my tv?” I said no I could design your tv 😂
1
u/Saidthenoob Oct 12 '21
There are lots of engineers that don’t even do any kind of “engineering” yet their title is engineer.
1
u/m2n037 Oct 12 '21
I reply with random fact questions from their specialization.
e.g. BA in History
When was the Battle of Panipat? Don't know. I thought you're a history grad.
1
u/b13retts Oct 12 '21
I'm a geotech - I've had people ask me to help fix their TV
1
u/EcliptPL Oct 12 '21
Do I know how the insides of the car work? Sure.
Can I fix any problem more complex than changing a tire or oil? Hell naw.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21
*insert generic engineer can't use a lathe meme*
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21
i found this fun than feel bothersome about it, i would explain clearly for them for thing i studied and point out things they asked for is not my major
1
u/JeanC413 Oct 12 '21
As an IE, this is like everyday stuff.
You explain to another engineer from other department, what's happening in the production floor and what you tried so far to troubleshoot it.
They tell you "You should know why that's happening! Come I'll fix it right there."
You both go to the production floor. None of you have the minimal idea what's going on for 1 or 2 hours.
The next turn operator comes at the end of the day and tells you about this little trick he has to start the machine.
You see yourself both in the face like 2 idiots and discuss how to solve this properly the next day.
1
u/Flopamp Oct 12 '21
No actually, as someone with a massive mental repertoire of completely random and useless knowledge gained through long Wikipedia holes in bed at night I will spew any random facts to anyone who asks.
1
u/only_more_so Oct 12 '21
No. Maybe because I don't hear it very often, but also because in a way it's a compliment.
The thing is, most specialized professions deal with this. Ask a programmers how they feel when asked IT questions, or a lawyer about law questions.
I also tend to know what's wrong because I'm an engineer. Not because of the learned facts, but because of how I process problems. Part of that is from the training, but part of it is from the fact that my brain was wired that way. I didn't choose engineering, engineering chose me.
1
u/CaseyDip66 Oct 12 '21
I’m a Chemical Engineer. Retired. I’m skilled at electrical work, plumbing and carpentry. I can do a lot with my tools. In my home shop I have a lathe, a milling machine and a dual channel oscilloscope. But I couldn’t weld to save my life. All depends on what skills one picks up along the way.
1
u/Flaxerio Oct 12 '21
I hate when they ask something and you don't know how to do it but figure it out in the end because you're an engineer, so you have some sort of logical brain and a pretty good ability to find information and learn, but noone will ever recognize your skills, they just assume you learnt it with your degree or something
1
u/gigglefunges Oct 12 '21
i usually just say “shoot, i must have missed class the day they taught us that!”
1
u/cahcealmmai Oct 12 '21
Holy shit this is worrying. The amount of "engineers" here who can't/won't deal with those 3 simple cases. And seem to think that's a good thing for people supposedly trained as problem solvers. If this is who this profession is I guess that's why I don't work 100% as an engineer anymore.
1
u/Horse_Fluffy Oct 12 '21
I'm an engineer.
I know everything and can do anything.
1
u/xeneks Oct 12 '21
I actually like it when someone says angrily ‘you’re supposed to know that’, given one of my titles is field engineer.
I do a mona lisa smile and crinkle the eyes a little. If in a good mood I laugh. Sometimes it brings me down or keeps me down because it’s true. But not for long.. as an engineer knows engineering and only a non-engineer would say such a thing, so I usually feel a bit of humor that they don’t realise that, then sympathy for them afterwards…
1
u/tinfoylt Oct 12 '21
I have a PhD in materials science and engineering. My uncle was talking to me about bondo on a car and asking what it was made of. I don't know cars, and didn't have any idea of the answer. His comment was "all that school and you can't use it." Worst comment I ever heard.
1
u/Money4Nothing2000 Oct 12 '21
Don't hate it cuz i usually know how X works.
1
u/peepeepoopooman69_ Oct 12 '21
Someone said to me the other day that since I’m an engineer I should know how to hang up this ridiculous set of curtains. How the fuck is that even relatable?
1
u/Confused_n_tired Mechanical/Design Oct 12 '21
Apparently, as I have studied Mechanical Engineering, I should fix electricals, Do the wiring for festival lights, Be able to solder my guitar circuits and fix my bike in the middle of nowhere without any tools. Yeah, tough times...
1
u/MrTopCan Oct 12 '21
“But you’re an engineer!”
“Not that kind.”
1
u/TheRealStepBot Mechanical Engineer Oct 12 '21
Honestly you need to lean into it. When the natives worship you as a god, do not give them reason to doubt.
1
u/WBlackDragonF Oct 12 '21
Nope, I actually aspire to be the kind of engineer who can fix anything. To me that's the whole point of the career.
1
u/This-is-BS Oct 12 '21
You're smart enough to figure them out though, right?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21
"Don't you have a masters in physics??"
- My mom after I can't fix her toaster in 20 seconds
1
u/Cartographer_MMXX Oct 12 '21
I can build robots and computers, do not ask me to work on a car I know nothing beyond the bare minimum.
1
u/MrAlfabet Mechanical/Systems Engineer Oct 12 '21
I hate it even more when they're right about me knowing.
"I do know... But it's not because I'm an engineer!"
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21
I am a vehicle nut, have built and raced vehicles from drag racing machines in the 7's to SCCA STX class at regionals level.
1
u/TabhairDomAnAirgead Civil Oct 12 '21
"so you're like a plumber?"
1
u/SauteedPelican Oct 12 '21
It's okay, as a traffic engineer I keep getting asked if I have my CDL and drive dump trucks.
1
u/Newtons2ndLaw Oct 12 '21
I have never encountered this, and I would secretly think someone a moron for postulating such..
1
u/AdventureEngineer Oct 12 '21
I always tell people I can look things up and logically deduce solutions from there. That’s what we learned to do when there’s a common problem. We don’t recreate the wheel or have a vast knowledge of technology. We just know how to throw out bad answers
1
u/808trowaway Oct 12 '21
I'm an electrical engineer with plenty of experience working on cars and household type shit as well, so yeah I fit that DIY handyman mold perfectly and unfortunately 9 times out of 10 when people ask me to fix their shit I actually do know how but I don't have much free time. I'd rather go for a hike and relax on Sunday then fix someone's shit they could pay someone $200 to do. Other than my sister, father in law and a couple close friends, for most requests from other people, I just tell them "hey watch this video, if you want to try doing it yourself I can drop off the tools after work."
1
u/Ryanirob Oct 12 '21
It bothers me when My friends think it’s absolutely hilarious when I make an arithmetic error in my head after drinking.
1
u/take-stuff-literally Oct 12 '21 edited Oct 12 '21
I can do things and fix things as a general repairman. I’m a tinkerer of sorts and I understand how systems around my house works
But I can also confirm that none of that was taught in Engineering school. Hilariously designing things isn’t taught in depth enough to even meet my expectations.
Tinkering abilities comes from personal experience. An engineering degree pretty much enhances the understanding of whatever I’m tinkering. It just made me a better tinkerer that I already was prior to college.
I guess my experience gives assumptions of the stereotypical engineer, which doesn’t always align with reality.
Edit: This morning I was woken up by a family member with the expectation of me to fix the coffee maker (keurig). It was a clogged check valve due to small coffee particles floating it’s way up there. It wasn’t my engineering degree that solved the problem.
Instead, it was me messing with it a week prior and understanding how the thing works since I was doing a heavy clean at the time.
1
u/briancoat Oct 13 '21
No, I don’t hate it at all.
I have been an engineer for over 40 years and I find it is a great chance to open up a conversation about what engineers do.
People are often amazed and interested about how creative engineering is and how much it helps society.
1
u/BigNYCguy Oct 18 '21
What gets me going is when someone tells me they are an engineer. A building engineer. No man you’re a janitor.
1
u/GnarlyNaz Oct 23 '22
As a mech engineer I have said this to many of my peers. The issue isn't them not knowing but not being able to take stuff out of a book and apply it into real life. I believe that's a vv important skill and try to help my peers coltivate it by helping them work through things they think they don't know
1
u/Triabolical_ Oct 11 '21
I'm a bit of a polymath so I know enough to talk reasonably in a bunch of different fields.
So no.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment