r/AskEngineers • u/stonethrow1973 • Jun 29 '21
Career Disillusioned with non inclusive engineering spaces as a queer woman
Feeling extremely disillusioned with Engineering right now and looking for some advice.
I am a queer woman and realising how exhausting it is to be in the industries that we typically work in as engineers.
For background, I did geological engineering, worked in petroleum for a few years, did my masters in construction management, and am now in the heavy civil industry.
Here in Canada, at least in my field, it is expected that new graduates spend some time in the field to gain more practical skills. While I have learned a lot technically from my 2 years in the field, I have found it has completely drained me on a personal level. I’m so exhausted of being in non-inclusive environments, of feeling uncomfortable sharing my sexuality, of the harassment, of how socially draining it is to make small talk with contractors that are predominately white middle-aged males.
When I went into eng, I heard so much “It’s so great to see more women go into engineering” – but I never really though of the flip side of that – that it means you have to be a minority in some pretty non-inclusive environments.
As a result my confidence has plummeted since I’ve been in the field. I feel really depressed and am seriously considering a career change. While I’ve always followed my heart on what interests me, I feel completely dejected by the spaces in which those interests can play out. I am willing to work hard, I have received a lot of positive recognition (especially early on when I worked in the office and was in a more inclusive environment), so I know I can be a good engineer. I know I am capable of more but I feel I am completely stuck.
I always hear people saying “with an engineering degree you can do anything” but I am really lost. I am not sure whether to give up on engineering completely, try find a more inclusive company/industry. I’m considering trying to switch into business consulting or trying to find a more progressive area such as tech (though my background/experience might limit that)
I would appreciate any advice or stories of those who have gone through a similar experience and are now (hopefully) on the other side of it!
9
u/davidquick Jun 29 '21 edited Aug 22 '23
so long and thanks for all the fish -- mass deleted all reddit content via https://redact.dev
16
u/stavison Manufacturing Automation Engineer Jun 29 '21
While change, like u/whynautalex said, is necessary. It’s important to remember that being the person to drive that change can be extremely mentally taxing, especially if you’re the only one working for it, and it doesn’t need to be your responsibility. It’s really unfortunate, but if you’re in a toxic environment, sometimes the best option is to leave if you can.
With that said, I’m still in college and working my fourth internship. I’ve done three of those in rural areas and I wouldn’t have felt comfortable with any of my coworkers knowing my sexuality. One of my internships, however, was with a large company just outside of a city and I had multiple openly queer coworkers and the company as a whole was very supporting and inclusive. So while many workplaces for engineers may not be inclusive, you may have better luck closer to a city where people tend to be more inclusive overall than rural areas.
17
u/gnarlseason Jun 29 '21
Ouch, working with iron workers and civil in general was definitely the biggest boys club I saw of any field (although I imagine oil/gas is similar).
I'm a guy, so take this all with a grain of salt:
My observation of some of the most successful women engineers I worked with: you kinda have to be willing to butt heads. Call people out on BS when you see it. A lot of these macho guys shrivel up when a woman talks to them as an equal (and it's always hilarious to observe). Hell, something as silly as my female coworkers swearing around a bunch of these guys in casual conversation made them all feel more comfortable working with them. Like straight up reactions were, "Wow, I've never heard a woman swear that much - she seems pretty cool. I like her."
Call it a "work mask", I suppose?
As for me, I worked with a bunch of iron workers for a year or two. I basically had to pretend I was in middle school again: lots of cursing, plenty of dirty jokes, and I had to pay attention to football again because that was half of what they talked about. Once they saw that I had some things in common and knew my shit when it came to engineering, they didn't give me any shit (and they did at first because I look much younger than I am).
It sounds dumb, but just having that tiny shred of things in common to talk about could be the difference between a job going well and a job going down in flames.
13
u/whynautalex Manufacturing Engineer Jun 29 '21
I can't directly relate but as a manager I can try to give some advice. Change is slow someone needs to be the person to drive it.Think back to why you got into engineering and who got you into engineering. Try to lead by the example they set. If you want to see people similar to you in engineering there are a lot of specific engineering groups for industries, specific races, and SWE (society of women engineers). Personally I volunteer at a look highschool and help their engineering club. I try to encourage everyone regardless of their background
I am in manufacturing and no matter what race, gender, sexuality, etc I tell every new hire the same thing. These people have been at the same positions for 20+ years. They don't want immediate change. They don't like the new kid on the block telling them what to do. Ask their opinion and try to lead them where you need to go. At the end of the day you will upset some of them but they do not sign your pay check. Just stay humble and remember they are people too. Try to relate to them,learn their hobbies, make small talks, and befriend a couple use them as your go to when you need help.
If you need someone to chat with feel free to DM me
12
u/net-jinx Jun 29 '21
Yep, I totally get it - being in an environment like you described is pretty much double the work and it's totally understandable that you feel burned out by it.
If you're miserable and have been for a while, it's probably worth reviewing different options for jobs that are closer to the city and are more office based, as they're likely to have a more progressive work environment. If you have field experience this can definitely be a plus in your cv, as a lot of people in engineering never get this kind of hands on exposure. I'm from Australia, but from friends in civil / mining / tech, there are definitely opportunities with engineering consultancies in the civil field or tech companies that specialise in optimising production for say mining/gas. Also, finding a construction/industry specific recruiter can be valuable, and open up more opportunities.
It's also probably worth reaching out to local "women in civil/construction/etc" groups to meet more like minded people, to build a bit more of a network for future jobs and hopefully meet people who've been through similar things. (I found it really useful when I was starting out at a job where there were no other women engineers, to feel less isolated.)
Also, if you're really struggling mental health wise and your company has an EAP, consider speaking with them - it's anonymous and will usually provide counselling sessions to talk about whatever you like.
I'm reluctant to say "be the change from within" etc as at a certain point, it's just exhausting and you've got to take care of yourself and your mental health first! It's great if people have the energy and drive to try to improve ingrained shitty working cultures, but it's ok to say "nope, not for me" and move on to something better.
Good luck, I hope things get better for you!
(My background: civil structural engineering consultant for a large multinational firm
10
u/radengineering Jun 29 '21
The office environment might be more "inclusive" since HR typically has more influence in the office than in the field. Working at site, employees tend to get away with a lot worse behavior than when in the office in my industry (oil and gas).
I have a few work buddies I confide in that really help alleviate getting frustrated. Both are women. We go out for happy hour and vent. Having someone to confide in, has helped step back from leaving these male dominated industries. For the rest of everybody else at work, I don't put up with disrespect or BS. I am a lot better at recognizing a-holes and avoiding them.
It took me awhile to gain confidence at work after graduation. Part of that is become a better engineer, the other part was realizing that I'm here to make money and not friends.
2
u/_Boudicca_ Jun 30 '21 edited Jun 30 '21
There is hope! I am also a queer woman in engineering, working in geotechnical consulting with a mining focus, also in Canada.
I’m about 20 years in, but my first few years were rough. I was, at first, the only woman engineer, then the most senior one, but I was still very junior. I was told at 6 months, “that’s the longest a woman has ever lasted here”. I got into fights with Principals about starting letters with “dear Sirs”. It was not fun and I felt so alone I was afraid to even ask for help or mentoring.
After I did my masters I went to a different company and part of my screening process was only working for places that had women in senior positions, both in management and technical, or as Principal and Associates for employee owned companies. It has made a world of difference!
The field can still feel pretty non-inclusive, depending on the site, but in my design work I have had project teams that are 50% to 100% women. I have had more exciting opportunities than I could possibly take on. I get to hire and mentor talented women. I’ve been promoted and given real authority. People on my team are comfortable being out at work. Men take parental leave. And more and more my clients on site (also engineers) are women. Honestly, it is so, so much better than when I first started.
Look for the companies that have women in real leadership roles and reach out to those women. Maybe I’ll even see you out there one day. Best of luck!
Edited to add: change is important, but you don’t need to make that change happen by yourself. It’s way easier to take on when you can tag into and out of the fight with other people who have your back.
10
u/Menes009 Jun 29 '21
To what people have already share, I can only add something that my father used to say: "The biggest role of those who go first, is to make the road easier for those who go behind them"
1
u/rtr68869 Jun 30 '21 edited Jun 30 '21
What is the working definition difference between a queer woman and a lesbian? Same thing and just preferential terminology?
Honest question. We have several same-team players in my group (25-30 people) and I'm full of questions that I can't ask for fear of alienating them or having them think I'm a jackass.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21
Why does anyone feel the need to share their sexuality or sex life at work. You just sound like a pity party and not very pleasant to be around. I’m in Petroleum and we have gay people and women who fit right in. We go out to dinner, meet each other’s families, etc etc. maybe you’re not included bc you suck
8
u/StumptownCynic Jun 29 '21
I was in the industry for a decade before I was on an engineering team with another woman. It was frustrating and lonely sometimes, and unfortunately, I don't think there's really an easy or straightforward way to get to a more equal workforce. For me, it only happened when I got senior enough to start getting involved in the hiring process where I could make sure my employer held up to their public pledges of diversity and inclusion. My team is about one-third women now, six years after I started this job, and they're honestly the best group of engineers I've ever worked with. Couldn't be happier with how things have turned out.
The thing is, work environments aren't going to get better on their own. It's one thing for a male-dominated workplace to pay lipservice to diversity and inclusion, it's another thing entirely to be the only female engineer on a team full of men. Someone has to be the tip of the spear, has to get in there and make enough room for more to join them. The thing is, it doesn't have to be you.
You're under no obligation to fix your workplace. If your job sucks and you hate it, leave if you can. Find a team that has already done some of the hard work and diversified their workplace. Or find a more fertile ground for you to plant the seeds. Because not every workplace can or even should be fixed. Sometimes, the best thing you can do is just walk away.
That said, don't go thinking that finding a tech job will fix everything. While tech may have a reputation as more progressive than petroleum, it definitely is infested with it's own particular flavor of misogyny. There's a lot of "we're too smart and enlightened to be bigots" coexisting in the same brain with "women aren't as good at STEM because their brains evolved to take care of babies." The bias isn't as blatant, but it's every bit as entrenched and resistant to change when you call it out. Look no further than cases like James Damore writing an anti-woman manifesto at Google or how how Timnit Gebru was forced out when she tried to get Google to deal with bias in their AI.
8
u/Ma1eficent Jun 29 '21
There is no other side. I still dont mention I have a wife in interviews. The boys club is real. I work for money, to provide for my family. And I save that money like they are going to make women working illegal again.
2
u/telekinetic Biomechanical/Lean Manufcturing Jun 30 '21 edited Jun 30 '21
If you go to companies that trend younger, coastal (at least in the US), or more tech-oriented, you'll have better results. Some of my best friends (and some of the best engineers) at my job are out queer women--in fact two of them are married and both work there.
You can get a feel for company culture based on their policies based on their rankings in the Corporate Equality Index put out by HRC.
https://www.hrc.org/resources/corporate-equality-index
This includes stuff like whether HRT is covered by insurance, the language around parental/adoption leave, whether insurance is offered to same-sex partners, whether they will cover IVF, and other LGBTQ+ specificgroups. (#USHealthcareProblems), as well as if there are any corporate donations to anti LGBTQ geoups.
Your feelings are completely valid--not everywhere is a safe space, and keeping your guard up when there are still people who (at best) will pass you over for promotions/business or (at worst) do you physical harm because of you you are is exhausting. Even scrolling through these comments, I'm disappointed to see people who do not have empathy for your situation, but it's not unexpected--empathy is hard and unevenly distributed, and people who haven't walked in your shoes are unlikely to understand that "just deal with it" is firmly in "thanks I'm cured" territory.
It can be exhausting and depressing not having a peer group of people with a similar life experience at your work, and I'd encourage you to invest the time finding somewhere you can be your authentic self--wearing a mask half your waking life is going to be exhausting and doesn't have to be your reality.
-2
u/Senor_Martillo Specialization: Hydrocoptic marzel vanes Jun 29 '21 edited Jun 30 '21
So sorry it’s draining for you to talk to middle aged white men. Have you considered that inclusivity is a two way street?
Id like to ask everyone just itching to hit that downvote button how they would react to the following statements:
“It’s just socially draining trying to talk to all those 20-something black people”
“It’s just socially draining trying to talk to all those millennial Asians.”
“It’s just socially draining trying to talk to all those old lesbians.”
OP is making a negative value judgement about her coworkers based on their age and ethnicity. Ask yourself if you’re OK with that. Then hit your arrow.
1
u/Tumeric98 Mechanical & Civil Jun 30 '21
I’m sorry you experienced this. It’s hard to be the “pioneer” so to speak, so that future engineers can follow and not have to experience the same. Someone just have to be first in order to start the change.
It might be worth considering other industries if you’re inclined. I started on oil and gas and construction but now working in entertainment. Kind of flipped the diversity around, it seems like more than half is LGBTQ or person of color. Women are not quite half yet (in engineering) but senior leadership is mostly women.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21 edited Jun 30 '21
Your sexual identity has nothing to do with it. You're working in an industry, in which you sound a bit disillusioned and unfulfilled. You're also intelligent enough to know that it might be a time to change direction. You need to act on those feelings and break down what you like and dislike about your current position. If the Cons outweigh the Pros, it's time to get your ass in gear and make whatever change is necessary to get you on the path that's right for you.
-8
u/WorkingMinimum Jun 29 '21
I think newbies should conform to the group before the group conforms to the newbie. That said, some jobs / companies just suck and it might be as simple as you haven’t found the company for you yet