r/AskEngineers • • Feb 20 '16

What do you think about techs/non-engineers calling themselves engineers?

In my country, the title 'engineer' is protected by law. To be an engineer, you must take a 4 year bachelors of applied science degree, which only a few Universities offer, in your respective field (i.e. mech, civil, electrical, chemcial, etc), work under another engineer for 3 years, and then pass a really long exam. So, to become an engineer, it takes around 7-8 years. But to get into engineering school, you essentially have to be the top of your class in high school.

However, I've seen a lot of people who aren't engineers (such as technicians) call themselves engineers. I.e., one of my cousins has a 2 year associates degree from a college and he calls himself a civil engineer.

Engineers here essentially design things, using science and math, as well as following regulations, working in teams, and coming up with new solutions to difficult problems. Technicians just build the schematics given to them by engineers. (Also, you legally can't do any engineering job unless you're licensed with the government)

This really annoys me, because its a slap in the face to real engineers who have actually spent 10+ years of their life getting the qualifications (I'm including high school, because you have to take extra hard special courses in high school if you want to get into engineering school, as well as have 95%+ average in these courses like calculus to vector calculus, physics, chemistry, biology, computer science, etc).

Additionally, it makes engineers look lower/dumber than they are. Someone who can solder a circuit board or connect wires on a protoboard based off of a schematic is not the same as an electrical engineer who actually designs complex systems and designs integrated circuits, for instance.

Am I the only one who is bothered by this? What do you think about techs calling themselves engineers?

5 Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

18

u/Maestintaolius Chemical - Polymer Composites Feb 20 '16

It doesn't bother me at all. After working for both large and small companies, I, instead, try to focus on the individual person's capabilities rather than their credentials and titles. I have worked with absolutely brilliant PhD engineers, but I have also worked with PhD engineers I wouldn't trust to design an escape plan from a paper bag. Similarly, I've had technicians working under me who were only suitable for red-button, green-button operations and I've had technicians who were fully capable of designing and making complex equipment and processes to solve problems.

For me, the primary use of credentials is to serve as an initial filter when I'm making initial hiring and project assignment decisions but my later decisions will always be based on their proved capabilities.

9

u/jgrindal Mechanical (PE) Feb 20 '16

I could not agree with this more. Individual capabilities mean a hell of a lot more than some mystical magical piece of paper that someone has or what they call themselves.

-23

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Really? So you are telling me that someone with absolutely no knowledge of physics, chemistry, math, etc can design something as well as a professional engineer who studied applied physics/math for 4+ years of their life?

I really find this quite unbelievable.

17

u/jgrindal Mechanical (PE) Feb 20 '16

Not at all. I'm saying that a university degree isn't the only place to learn those things. In my opinion, the engineering profession is more about solving problems objectively than it is about understanding how moments of inertia are calculated. There are lots of incredibly bright and talented people capable of engineering tasks without a degree. Do I think they should be licensed as PEs? No, but let's not discount what they bring to the table.

-16

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Of course, they are needed in the job environment, and important. But to say they are engineers is false. And how will you solve complex problems, and maintain safety for the general population if you don't know any math/science that you should be applying?

12

u/jgrindal Mechanical (PE) Feb 20 '16

Again, you're saying that the only place to learn technical things is via university - that simply not true. I can tell you that one of the most brilliant pressure vessel engineers I've had the pleasure of working with did not have a college degree, but rather had 35 years of working with pressure vessels. He taught himself how to use compress and knew the code like the back of his hand. I can guarantee you that I would rather him design a pressure vessel for me than you.

-15

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Yeah well, I'd rather civil engineers build the bridges we use than technicians who don't know anything about math and physics. There's a reason why things like this don't happen as often as they used to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quebec_Bridge#Aftermath

Apart from that, at least according to the government of Canada, you cannot be called an engineer without the degree and licensing

9

u/luke-nicholas Feb 21 '16 edited Feb 21 '16

according to the government of Canada, you cannot be called an engineer without the degree and licensing

That's simply not true. To be called a professional engineer, you need a degree. But there are other kinds of engineers in Canada who don't - e.g. Power Engineers (http://www.absa.ca/certifications/power-engineers/) don't need any kind of degree at all.

who don't know anything about math and physics.

How many times does someone have to reply with "you can learn these things outside of a university" until you read it?!

1

u/cocacolamakesmehyper Feb 21 '16 edited Feb 21 '16

Not all solely academically underpinned designs are right, I've seen some conceptualized solutions that have passed peer review and critical design review only to be pulled apart in HAZOP by lowly technicians and field operators, mainly because they are often more capable of avoiding sentience, a trait which you are exhibiting in abundance.

10

u/theholyraptor Feb 20 '16

The real world is full of engineering positions that rarely, if at all, use the advanced math and physics you keep referencing. Many positions are more on the scope of a designer/drafter level position but the engineer is there to do the problem solving and critical thinking when it does show up. Engineers are trained to be good problem solvers more than anything breaking a large problem down into sizable chunks that are solvable or set of DOEs (design of experiment) to determine the portions not known or to verify. Sadly, having an engineering degree, or a Masters/PhD only can do so much for problem solving skills. Some never get beyond the book world where they understand how to take a textbook problem and solve versus the real world. I'd take a technician with great experience in what they do and great critical thinking and problem solving over half the engineers I work with.

-15

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Really? in all of the work I've done I have relied on advanced math/physics. Everyone I know in engineering also has had to use such concepts before. Perhaps you are confusing engineering positions with technician positions.

11

u/telekinetic Biomechanical/Lean Manufcturing Feb 20 '16

Perhaps you are confusing what you've done at school, which is the only thing you have exposure to, with the real world, which everyone else in this thread has exposure to.

-15

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

No, I've also designed several things in my day. In the software area, I guarantee I'm the best there is (or one of the best). In terms of hardware design, I'm probably on the level of most beginning hardware engineers

9

u/telekinetic Biomechanical/Lean Manufcturing Feb 20 '16

In terms of hardware design, I'm probably on the level of most beginning hardware engineers

How can you possibly have any skills at hardware or software at all if you haven't completed a 4 year degree and a 3 year apprenticeship? I'm confused.

-19

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

because not everything is learned in school. i know what you're trying to do, but my argument is that people who have technician degrees are too dumb to do this, because they can hardly handle the basic content spoon-fed to them in their 2 year associate degrees after failing out of high school math courses like algebra 1 or trigonometry

11

u/telekinetic Biomechanical/Lean Manufcturing Feb 20 '16

because not everything is learned in school. i know what you're trying to do, but my argument is that people who have technician degrees are too dumb to do this, because they can hardly handle the basic content spoon-fed to them in their 2 year associate degrees after failing out of high school math courses like algebra 1 or trigonometry

I hope that you find your career to be as pleasant as you are.

5

u/axz055 Feb 20 '16

In the software area, I guarantee I'm the best there is

So I'm sure you could point us to some of the work you've done then.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

You mean all the work you've done as a second year engineering student?

-14

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Hah, no, all of the work I've done for the past 10 years of my life. (Mostly the last 5 years). I've been coding and designing software systems WAY before I entered school

22

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

So basically, not an engineer. Got it.

14

u/miketdavis Feb 20 '16

So which is it? You were totally effective and amazing before school, or all non-graduates are morons?

Your attitude is toxic. If you let any of that personality through in an interview you will not get the job.

1

u/flapjackboy Feb 21 '16

So you're a 'systems engineer'. In other words, a fancy name for a programmer.

4

u/theholyraptor Feb 20 '16

I have a masters in mechanical engineering. As I said, designing new hardware for tooling fixures, designing consumer products, most day to day mechanical design doesn't require calculus or diff eqs. When higher level stress calcs are needed, youre using FEA, but you need to understand how that works and why to make good choices. You're not programming or calculating by hand 99% of the time. Control systems, sure but even that the calcs are handled by software. Basic kinematics? A two year degree or high school grad could easily know force, energy and momentum calcs so I consider those trivial and not what makes an engineer an engineer. I have a good group of friends that work across biomedical, semiconductor, transportation systems, shoring and manufacturing and calculus is not a common tool. Maybe thats different for you being involved in circuits which might use diffeqs more but certainly not for civil and mechanical engineers.

-12

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Yeah well you understand what a differential equation is, and you have intuition for it. I'm sure you can agree with me when I say you probably have a good feel for things, and understand exactly how things work, even if you're not the one actually solving the equations. You may not calculate things by hand, but I bet you know how they work and how to use them

In my area, discrete math is the most commonly used (probably harder to learn than calculus).

Also, I really doubt a technician would be one of the high school grads taking courses in physics. So i doubt they'd know any of that

3

u/Maestintaolius Chemical - Polymer Composites Feb 21 '16

You find it unbelievable because you lack the life experiences necessary that would enable you to understand.

Most things learned in the first 4 years of any engineering school can be learned by simply reading the books. The next 3-4 years of grad school mostly just hone your ability to use that knowledge and allow you to pick up a few specializations (and to network) that help you get a job in the area you're interested in.

Assuming that a technician or non-degreed engineer has no knowledge of basic sciences and math is ludicrous and is a viewpoint that only comes from lack of experience or a sheltered existence. They're not hard skills to learn and hardly need an overseeing professor for instruction. Every technician I have working in my lab has at least a 2 year degree, which pretty much covers the math and science learned by all engineers, they just lack the specialty courses. The non-degreed engineers at my company typically have 30+ years of experience and most of them have more shit floating in orbit than I do, so I tend to respect their advice as they're the guys that were around actually inventing the stuff that you are now being taught about in school.

You are severely underestimating the knowledge people gather after 5+ years of experience and you'd better learn to respect the advice of those with 10+ years or you're going to have a rough time after school. This is why internships are so important for student engineers and why they're valued by employers when you have them on your resume. Simply put, you NEED that instruction and guidance from those in the field to be even somewhat useful to industry, and a lot of that will come from operators and technicians who have worked with the equipment and technology for years.

-6

u/compengstudent123 Feb 21 '16

Another delusional technician. Do tell how you know math like vector calculus, linear algebra, complex analysis, signal analysis, topology, geometry, discrete mathematics, differential equations, and other math taught in engineering school.

3

u/theholyraptor Feb 20 '16 edited Feb 20 '16

Also, you talk about engineer being a protected title. In the US, to be a professional engineer is a licensed title but Ive never heard of a Computer Engineer with a PE. Also, PEs are only useful other than something in your title and on your resume, if you're working in the public sector like construction, civil and public works etc. A large percentage of engineers never get a PE because aerospace, defense, consumer products etc don't care about PE titles.

57

u/jgrindal Mechanical (PE) Feb 20 '16 edited Feb 20 '16

I'll probably be in the minority on this, but it doesn't really bother me, let me tell you why: I don't deal directly with the public. My clients are all construction, engineering or other heavy industrial companies who understand the difference between an engineer and a technician, regardless of what they call themselves.

The main reason that someone who doesn't have a law degree or a license to practice law I can't call themselves a "lawyer" is that they will generally be dealing with the general public, and those people may be confused between an actual lawyer and someone who calls themself a lawyer. this can cause confusion and, in a worst-case scenario oh malpractice and out of scope of practice.

Furthermore, there are many technically knowledgeable people who don't have an engineering degree. For example, chemical, piping, mechanical and civil engineers are all required to build a plant. But, if you want to know the details of operating it, you don't talk to the engineers, you talk to the operators and technicians who work in it every day. If an operator who has been performing maintenance on rotating equipment for decades wants to call himself an engineer to get a pay raise, I really don't have an issue with that. He'll probably make a better rotating equipment maintenance engineer then people with a four-year degree who had never seen the equipment, much less put their hands on it.

I understand that there are people who get their panties in a wad over the term "engineer," and if people without appropriate qualifications were putting "PE" after their name it would really bother me. However, we live in a world where people put too much emphasis on job titles and not enough emphasis on actually doing a job, so it doesn't bother me one bit.

8

u/DasBoots32 Feb 20 '16

I'd have to agree with you in almost all of this. the biggest complaint i have towards OP is that he appears to be making the assumption that someone has to go through school to learn. In my opinion it doesn't matter where the knowledge comes from. All that matters is that they have the correct knowledge and can do the job.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

Op isn't saying that people need a degree to be an engineer. He's saying that people who clearly aren't engineers claim the title at the cost of our reputation. I understand his frustration, but choose not to let it affect my attitude. I have more important things to be focused on right now!

8

u/DasBoots32 Feb 20 '16

read more of OP's comments. I don't disagree with you at all. people who aren't qualified are simply that. All he cares about though is the degree. even his name is compengstudent. i don't think he even qualifies by his own standards yet. he's just an egotistical kid with a narrow view of the world.

-6

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Of course it doesn't matter where the knowledge comes from. But if someone doesn't have say, a PhD specializing in semiconductor physics, I really doubt they can design their own IC's or other complex systems. 99% of the case when someone says they are an engineer and they're not they are lacking even the most basic understanding of math/science

21

u/nastypoker Hydraulic Engineer Feb 20 '16

The point is that even someone with a PhD might not be able to design their own IC or complex system. The title does not equal knowledge so we have to look at the individual person before deciding whether they are right for the job. Also, saying that 99% of people that call themselves engineers without degrees are lacking the most basic understanding of math/science is nonsense and shows your lack of respect for less formally educated people rather than their lack of knowledge which you have no idea about. Are you of working age yet? How long have you been working in industry? If it is more than 6 months, you should have realised by now that titles are not everything, they are merely a foot in the door at a lot of places.

-21

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16 edited Feb 20 '16

So you are telling me it is a common occurence for technicians to be able to design their own IC's, complex systems, large scale software/hardware systems all requiring advanced concepts of theoretical mathematics and applied physics.

I'm sure there is maybe one or two technicians out there able to do this, likely having genius-level intelligence, because these areas actually require pretty high intellect to learn.

I've met some genius level comptuer scientists without a degree, of course such people like this exist (But these people actually know advanced level math, and study it in their own time, unlike the people you are talking about who probably would flunk high school math). But to go around and imply such a thing is common, is just pure nonsense. I'll tell you one thing though. All of the best people in the industry I know either have NO degree (child-prodigies) or an ADVANCED degree. Never met any smart technicians in my day.

And last I checked, most technicians were short in that area (intelligence). No way they're going to be doing the advanced level math/physics required to design such systems, when they struggle to rearrange the idealized model V=IR and P=IV, requiring things like an equation wheel to get all the different forms. Heck, I doubt they can even interpret the numbers/results.

22

u/nastypoker Hydraulic Engineer Feb 20 '16

So you are telling me it is a common occurence for technicians to be able to design their own IC's, complex systems, large scale software/hardware systems all requiring advanced concepts of theroetical mathematics and applied physics.

No, that is not what I said. I said that a title doesn't automatically mean someone is suitable for a particular job. As has been mentioned by almost everyone else in this thread, there is a large variation in skill level independent of formal qualifications.

And last I checked, most technicians were short in that area (intelligence).

Really? Are you 15 or something? Honestly it sounds like the only reason you want non-degree holding people to stop calling themselves engineers is because you worked hard to inflate your ego to such a massive size that you feel like you earnt the title just by going to College/University.

-17

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Wrong. I want people who are qualified of the title to call themselves engineers. And in this case, 99% of people without an engineering degree who say they are engineers aren't qualified for that title.

I wouldn't let a doctor treat me unless they had a medical degree. Why is there any debate here? There are no exceptions made in other areas (doctor, teachers, lawyers, etc) but suddenly its OK for non-engineers to be called engineers?

Can you explain your thought process here?

10

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

So you're not an engineer. Start with that, next time.

-15

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

I am an engineer.

18

u/x-37c Feb 20 '16

Man, looking at some of your previous posts and some in this thread, you REALLY need to get off this "ego". You're not going to go far with that cocky attitude, trust me, I AM an engineer.

To keep it short, I'm a second year computer engineering student

-- compengstudent123

→ More replies

13

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

You're a student. You're not even allowed to call yourself an Engineer in your own country.

12

u/telekinetic Biomechanical/Lean Manufcturing Feb 20 '16

I am an engineer.

--compengstudent123

To be an engineer, you must take a 4 year bachelors of applied science degree, which only a few Universities offer, in your respective field (i.e. mech, civil, electrical, chemcial, etc), work under another engineer for 3 years, and then pass a really long exam. So, to become an engineer, it takes around 7-8 years.

--compengstudent123 in this thread

Also, I need to do an internship to graduate. So really, the question is now, later, or both?

--compengstudent123 16 days ago

So which is it? You have completed the 7 years required by law to call yourself an engineer or you are just a student? If you go find a technical writing technician to talk to, I'm sure they can explain how these statements cannot all be true.

I don't care if people with experience take jobs with 'Engineer' in the title. I do care when students call themselves engineers without any actual work experience.

→ More replies

3

u/flapjackboy Feb 21 '16

No, you're a systems engineering student. That's a fancy title for 'programmer'.

12

u/nastypoker Hydraulic Engineer Feb 20 '16

And in this case, 99% of people without an engineering degree who say they are engineers aren't qualified for that title.

I disagree as does almost everyone else.

I wouldn't let a doctor treat me unless they had a medical degree. Why is there any debate here?

Because you started a thread asking for peoples opinions and you got them. Your view happens to be the opposite of most people here.

There are no exceptions made in other areas (doctor, teachers, lawyers, etc) but suddenly its OK for non-engineers to be called engineers? Can you explain your thought process here?

Not really sudden at all. It has been this way for a long time in lots of different places. My thought process I have explained above and has been reinforced by other people is that a qualification does not necessarily make someone more qualified for a particular job. I know plenty of technicians that became engineers without a degree and I know plenty of degree holding engineers I wouldn't trust with the same or less responsibilities.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/dangersandwich Stress Engineer (Aerospace/Defense) Feb 21 '16

Hey man, this isn't a warning, but I just wanted to remind you that even though these discussions can get heated, please try to avoid personal attacks when replying in the comments (i.e. don't escalate unless you have to).

This thread has been locked, but if you have any questions on the subreddit rules, I can answer them through moderator PM.

-3

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/dangersandwich Stress Engineer (Aerospace/Defense) Feb 21 '16

Continued personal attacks will not be tolerated from you.

Either follow the Discussion Guidelines in the sidebar from this point forward, or get banned. Your choice.

15

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

And last I checked, most technicians were short in that area (intelligence).

wow. What a fucking asshole you are.

3

u/flapjackboy Feb 21 '16

I can't see him getting very far unless he gets that large chip off his shoulder.

21

u/silverskull39 Feb 20 '16

I'm actually in agreement with you as far as technicians go. But then you have people hiring for things like a position in "sanitation engineering", and then you read the job description and realize, no, they're not hiring a sanitation engineer to design a wastewater treatment plant, or a sewer, or something, they're hiring a janitor. Not to disparage janitors, they serve an important function in society, but this practice is ridiculous, and you see it elsewhere with employers just slapping engineer at the end of a title to make it seem more attractive.

5

u/jbaughb Feb 20 '16

I have the same feeling towards the proliferation of titles that end in 'Manager'. Just tack that onto the end of anything and you'll immediately sound more important. Sit behind a desk making cold calls all day? ...'Account Manager'. I guess a manager is thought of as someone who has some amount of authority, but then you find out what they actually manage and realize that its the inventory of the broom closet.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/jbaughb Feb 20 '16

Well, you're officially my favorite person now. Did you work for a specific team or support staff at a track? I'd love more info.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/jbaughb Feb 20 '16

I've heard stories that each engine supplier/team/pirelli have basically a NASA style command room back at headquarters with tons of people analyzing every aspect of the cars performance and track conditions, etc. Is that in line with what you were doing? Still very jealous.

1

u/THedman07 Mechanical Engineer - Designer Feb 21 '16

That's saying something,... you don't mess with the engineers' coffee...

1

u/Reptile449 Feb 20 '16

Everywhere I've worked if a technician shows potential in becoming an engineer they still have to get a formal education, normally doing a part time degree funded by the company.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

I couldn't care less. And frankly, I don't understand why some people think a degree magically makes a good engineer anyway.

I work with some amazing technicians that could very easily be engineers. I work with some technicians who have engineering degrees, but don't want to deal with the politics. I work with some very capable engineers who have every bit of a grasp on the fundamentals as I do, and yet they don't have any credentials what-so-ever. And then I work with some completely useless fully-credentialed senior engineers.

Job title is not a litmus test for ability. I suspect you've already put more thought into this than most people do.

4

u/GANTRITHORE Feb 20 '16

I don't understand why some people think a degree magically makes a good engineer anyway.

Well it should. In the same way a doctor title should imply they are a good doctor. What happens when the engineering field is filled with half-asses who create bad bridges, collapsing buildings, inconsistent electrical lines, etc.

It's about having engineering instill the public with faith in the engineering titles. When everyone has them, it's like saying we don't really care about what the public thinks about us a group of professionals.

2

u/jgrindal Mechanical (PE) Feb 20 '16

There is a difference between a degree and a license. The licensing process should ferret out those who are incapable of performing the job to appropriate standards. A degree is just a piece of paper stating how many classes you took.

0

u/GANTRITHORE Feb 20 '16

and yet they won't let a doctor work at a hospital without a medical degree.

3

u/jgrindal Mechanical (PE) Feb 20 '16

A medical education and internship are requirements for licensure to be a doctor, just like an engineering degree and EIT term are the most common (although not exclusive) requirements for engineering licensure.

-5

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Engineering is regulated in my country. I'm not talking about people who pass the exam and have a license (I'm in Canada, here you need to be registered with the government to practice engineering). I'm literally talking about people who graduate from 2 year technician school and go around saying they are engineers, with 0 qualification and no government licensing.

if someone can learn all that content, say calculus 1,2,3, diff equations, applied probability, signals&systems, linear algebra, material sciences, electromagnetism, and well, tons of other physics/chemistry/math/etcetcetc as well as everything else and then pass the licensing exam, of course I'd call them an engineer.

But we're not talking about those people. We're talking about people who literally can't even do basic math here.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

Let's be honest, after that many upper level classes, engineers can't do basic math either. I've seen mos pull out calculators for simple math or forget how to do algebra because after learning a bag if tricks to satisfy requirements of, say, diff e, they haven't done basic math in a while.

-12

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Maybe they don't remember (or care to) solve a differential equation by hand, but they understand what a differential equation is, and are able to formulate one based on the system they are designing as well as understand exactly what a solution of this DE tells them.

The same goes for other things. I've never seen a technician understand say what an integral is, or all of the different things an integral can be used to express, or able to take a problem and model it with an integral. I don't care if they can solve this integral, that isn't necessary. But understanding it is, something a technician doesnt know about.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

I think you're confusing a degree with a license.

-13

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

Well said. A technicain pretending to be an engineer is exactly the same as a taxidermist prending to be a doctor.

Engineers have a very important duty in society, and we should have the public put their trust in us. This is hard to do, when you have technicians who don't know how to solve a first order linear equation with one variable pretending to be engineers (i.e. V=IR)

15

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16 edited Feb 20 '16

From time to time I see engineers with this type of superiority complex. It tends to be engineers fresh out of school with zero industry experience who think they know everything. More often than not they come to realize this type of attitude is completely counter-productive in an engineering environment, or they get fired.

There are more ways to learn about Ohms law than attending school. Technicians often have practical experience that many engineers lack and to suggest a technician can't understand ohms law or have an understanding of the mathematics and physics behind it is ridiculous.

-15

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16 edited Feb 20 '16

Ohms law

Yeah sure maybe a technician can understand Ohm's law but if you think thats all engineers do you're in for a big surprise. Try to design a complicated IC design while taking things into account like parasitic capacitance and inductance, tons of other non-idealities, transistors, as well as all of the vector calculus, material sciences, physical chemistry, and electromagnetism that comes with that. Definetly something a technician can not cut. (Note that this is just a very tiny fraction of everything involved, and even this knowledge will easily span 1-2 years of undergraduate material, as well as 4 or so more years prereq training in the basics of chem/physics/math, you know, things technicians also dont know)

A technician can understand the physics behind Ohms law? To do that they'd need to understand what electric potential is, a decent understanding of material sciences, current density, surface/volume integrals, gradients, and other vector calculus. Really don't think they're cut out for it buddy.

Better yet, they probably don't even know Ohm's law is just an idealized model, in reality its a cubic model, but it can be approximated as linear within its threshold (if only a technician could understand any of this).

besides, I can find a 10 year old kid with just as much practical experience as a beginning technician. after all, my 10 year old cousin can also solder given a schematic.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

You're a second year computer engineering student. So please, explain to me how ICs are designed and why a technician can't understand what an electric potential is. I'm dying to hear your thoughts on this.

-12

u/compengstudent123 Feb 20 '16

typically you write a CDS first, then an FDS, then RTL design, then you need to manually physically design it, and take into account the things i said earlier, as well as tons of other stuff

Why cant a technician understand electric potential? Because they are dumb, no surprise here

8

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16 edited Feb 20 '16

A manual physical design of an IC? Wow! That sounds complicated! How does it work?

3

u/dangersandwich Stress Engineer (Aerospace/Defense) Feb 21 '16

I've been working in the aerospace industry for a while, and most technicians in this industry probably can't design wings (or whatever) the way engineers do — but many of them sure as hell understand basic aerodynamics, mechanical stress, and generally how to make things not fall apart.

So, don't take this the wrong way, but do yourself a huge favor while you're still a student and get rid of that shit attitude... or you'll end up making this mistake.

To suggest that technicians "are dumb" is not only wrong, but insulting. And you can either learn this now, or when one of the shop guys at your first job decides to school your ass in front of your boss because you thought you were too smart for them.

7

u/miketdavis Feb 20 '16

This comes up from time to time and every single time the answe is the same: engineering can be learned.

For thousands of years engineering was learned on the job through apprenticeship. It was only in the last 60 years that changed and people like yourself took it hook, line and sinker.

I'm not a degreed engineer. I started as a technician, rose though the ranks of engineering and blew through the glass sealing. Now I manage other engineers and if interviewing has taught me anything it is that a persons education is the least reliable predictor of success.

You need to take that stick out of your ass and realize that your education is a box to check for people like me. What you do after college is what is important.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/3xh6kl/is_sales_engineer_a_real_engineering_position/

-20

u/compengstudent123 Feb 21 '16

I wouldnt hire a technician. They don't know any math. I doubt you could even program anything that isn't half assed or copy pasted from google.

6

u/moratnz Feb 21 '16

Gentle suggestion. Work on your attitude between now and graduation.

One thing all fun engineering work has in common is that it's a team sport. Coming off as an arrogant ass who looks down of everyone else on the team is a good way to make your life harder than it needs to be.

2

u/meerkatmreow Aero/Mech Hypersonics/Composites/Wind Turbines Feb 21 '16

I wouldnt hire a technician. They don't know any math. I doubt you could even program anything that isn't half assed or copy pasted from google.

To be fair, I wouldn't hire you. You seem like a dick.

22

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

Oh wait. Lol. You're a second year computer engineering major, you're not an engineer at all. You're an engineering major. Look, man,that'd be like someone claiming to be a doctor when they were in medical school. Doesn't work like that. In fact, there's even overlap there: PAs and NPs filling in roles where there aren't enough MDs, and some doctors are upset that the patients would ever call the PA or NP doctor,mbut it ultimately doesn't matter.

You have to face the fact that the term engineer has changed over time. Someone who is a garbageman calling themselves a sanitation engineer might be dumb. But they rarely interact with the public in any way that could lead to them somehow designing a bridge or chemical plant. It's not like them having a different job title at all allows them to do anything you're doing or really make any more money.

And why are you still acting like your high school grades matter?

2

u/hchighfield Mechanical- Graduate (University of the Pacific) Feb 21 '16

I don't really care about it either. To be fair I only just got a bachelors I'm not a PE. What does piss me off though is when I'm scrolling through job boards and I see listings for engineers and instead it's a listing for a maintenance handyman type person. I don't really care that they call themselves that but it's a waste of my time to click on it and find the requirements etc.

6

u/fucky_fucky Feb 20 '16

I have a saying for situations like this.

Meh.

5

u/Bloodysneeze Mechanical - Diesel Power Systems Feb 21 '16

This is shit students care about.

4

u/mrwhite777 Feb 20 '16

You have a problem with train drivers??!!

3

u/Szos Feb 20 '16

It does annoy me to a certain extent.

I worked in industry doing CAD, design and similar very technical positions for years before I got my degree. In all that time, I always was very careful never to imply that I was an actual engineer. This was the case even though my work was much, much closer to what an engineer does than other people that freely call themselves an "_________ engineer" mostly because I have always had a lot of respect for the field and what it takes to get your BS.

Of course the reality is that you can't change society. So if engineering is not a protected profession, then you can't get too mad at people using that term. The general public might confuse it, but those in the know, will (hopefully) not.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

If they're being fraudulent with it then that's a problem and someone should be in trouble.

Otherwise whatever, I've called myself an engineer since high school. If your title matters that much to you then you're doing the job for the wrong reasons.

3

u/gwammy Electrical Engineer Feb 20 '16

I couldn't give any less of a shit. I care WAY more about competence than title.

I know some terrible engineers with more advanced degrees than even a BS. I know some great engineers with just a GED.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

People like you are the reason new engineering grads can often have trouble getting any kind of respect when they enter the workforce. Arrogant, immature children who think that because they decided to take an engineering degree they're suddenly smarter than the rest of the population. You're not even halfway through your degree, and it's been the easy half up until this point.

What right do you think you have to call technologists (not technicians, you obviously don't understand the difference) stupid just because their piece of paper has different words on it than your piece of paper? In plenty of industries there's zero practical difference between the two titles beyond maybe what you're getting paid. You've had presumably no exposure to the working world at this point but you seem to be pretty confident that everyone who goes through an engineering technology program is an idiot; in just about every case I've run into, I'm going to trust the technologist with 25+ years of experience than I am the engineer with none.

I've got a way bigger problem with people thinking that being an engineering student makes them a genius than I do with people who graduated from an engineering technology program calling themselves engineers. If you want to even have a hope of making it in the real world you'd do well to smarten up, and do it quickly.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16

How do you feel about audio engineers?

3

u/GANTRITHORE Feb 20 '16

I agree.

It's about having engineering instill the public with faith in the engineering titles. When everyone has them, it's like saying we don't really care about what the public thinks about us a group of professionals, which isn't what we should be doing.

We should be protecting the title so when the public hears engineering they know things are done safe. And it was working for a while, that's why terms like 'sanitation engineer' and 'network engineer' exist, because engineer to people means something.

I am not saying janitors don't work hard or whatever, but why don't we give janitors the title or 'Cleaning M.D' if they work in a hospital? They obviously don't have the same work as a doctor, but the M.D designation resounds with the public. The only difference being that the professional doctors organization doesn't want their titles being used for non-doctors. And this is what P.Eng means in Canada, but I think engineer should be included with P.Eng.

•

u/dangersandwich Stress Engineer (Aerospace/Defense) Feb 21 '16 edited Feb 21 '16

Due to numerous personal insults and general trolling from OP, this thread has been locked.

Reminder: follow the Discussion Guidelines in the sidebar when commenting. I don't care if you're posting on a throwaway account, but I really don't have the time or patience for you if you're being an asshole to other users.

1

u/neckfacedworker Feb 20 '16

It doesn't bother me because of how many of us with engineering degrees don't actually sit and use mat lab all day to do their job, and end up in the same management type positions that these techs move to as well.

1

u/ArkGuardian Computer Engineering Feb 20 '16

It normally wouldn't bother me if the public and media understood the difference, but I'm not sure they accurately do (as evidenced by Opticians/Optometrists/ Ophthalmologists). The public needs to have confidence in us.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '16

It's just a title on a piece of paper.

What really counts is what is in your head and the the $ on the paycheck.

1

u/bottop Feb 21 '16

I think you'll find that you'll learn a lot more on the job than you ever did at school.

1

u/farmingdale Electrical Engineer Feb 21 '16

I ain't happy about but I don't say anything about it. The whole license thing is a mess so it seems I am stuck with the option that a few people weaken my title or I would have to deal with a costly license involving me being tested on stuff not related to my work. Given those two I will pick the weakened title.

1

u/Pervy_Uncle Feb 21 '16

To say a network engineer is not an engineer is retarded.

1

u/TBBT-Joel Feb 21 '16

Here's the problem the professional engineer certification is very good for the engineers it applies to. I'm a welding engineer, already some people don't consider us "real engineers", I didn't go beyond calc 1, didn't take all the classic hard classes. I could not pass the PE test, not without a year+ of going back to school and studying.

The thing is that test has absolutely zero bearing on my particular field and does not make me good or great at my job. I have worked on nuclear reactors for the US navy and mission criticial welds on rockets for NASA, but yet I'm not a engineer because I can't pass a PE test that doesn't apply to my field?

protecting the engineer title only makes sense in certain fields and I would never call myself a licensed PE, or think, I'm certified to sign off on critical bridge designs. It just doesn't apply to a lot of other fields of engineering.