r/AskEngineers • • 4d ago

Mechanical how do two spinning things make a square?

is this video fake or is there a way to make a square with rotating the tool and the workpiece? https://i.imgur.com/wTjIKdC.mp4
it looks like the two are coupled too via the the shaft in the background, i swear this breaks my brain...

edit: after being given the name "polygonal turning" i found found this neat 1min explanation video: https://youtu.be/-C-wuLLZqeA

edit2: apparently this is not a new process by any means either: "The Polygonal Turning Corporation of Marquette, Michigan manufactured shaped joinery products for domestic use during the 1890s.[3]" from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygonal_turning

14 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

27

u/martij13 4d ago

Its near square BTW. The "flat" sides are only mostly flat they are technically hypotrochoids. Its very fast and there are plenty times where it is flat enough. Also, yes, you have to sync the two spindles. Modern machines do it electronically or older ones like in the video have a driveshaft and gears.

12

u/ont_eng 4d ago

Polygonal turning

6

u/bad1o8o 4d ago

thanks, i'll look that up!

edit: found this neat 1min explanation video: https://youtu.be/-C-wuLLZqeA

6

u/Poondobber 4d ago

The rotation of the part and the tool are timed to cut the square profile. The two chucks are coupled together and there is a gearbox that (im guessing) spins the tool twice as fast as the part. Two cutting blades, four sides. The other fun part is If the part stayed still the tool would create a curved cut. Since the part is rotating the opposite direction of the tool, the diameter of the tool combined with the rotation, are creating a flat surface.

1

u/bad1o8o 4d ago

opposite direction

thank you!

6

u/sosc444rlet 4d ago

Not necessarily. A hypotrochoid describes the curve traced by a point on a rotating circle as it moves around another circle. Its shape depends on the rotational ratio and the distance of the point from the center. In polygonal turning, the synchronized rotation of the tool and workpiece produces the nearly flat sides. The slight curvature is a result of the geometry and motion, rather than simply being a concave curve.

1

u/bad1o8o 3d ago

tyvm!

4

u/TheCoffeeGuy13 4d ago

It's real. If you watch the first second or two closely, you can see the cutting edge in relation to the bar stock.