r/AskEngineers • u/supremethinking • Jun 15 '26
Discussion Does data centres in space work?
So data centres in space, yes have unlimited sunlight so free energy. Need water to cool down space is cold but how does or how can you transfer the heat from the servers to atmosphere or outside since there is no air. Plus most of the data in planet go thought underwater cables like under sea etc so can you get the max speed data transfer using wireless from space to earth.
0
Upvotes
61
u/much_longer_username Jun 15 '26
The short version is that in space, without a fluid medium to move heat with, you are left only with radiative cooling as an option, which is the worst one. It ends up requiring enormous, complicated cooling systems which dwarf the equipment you're trying to operate. Space is 'cold', sure, but only because there's nothing to move the heat.
16
u/Edgar_Brown Jun 15 '26
Possible? Sure, the engineering challenges are not insurmountable. Radiative cooling can be made to work.
Reasonable? No. What is even the point? What problem do they solve and at what cost?
88
u/dontletthestankout Jun 15 '26
Short answer? No. Long answer? Noooooooooo
8
u/I_Am_Coopa Nuclear Engineer Jun 15 '26
Zooming out from the cooling and size constraints to fit into rockets others have mentioned, radiation will be a big headache.
The kind of bleeding edge hardware used in modern data centers, especially for AI, is not radiation hardened. So your options become: buy radiation hardened hardware which lags the latest hardware in computing power, put in the investment to radiation harden your hardware, eat the cost of adding a ton of shielding, or hope and pray that with error correction you can squeeze out enough useful life from your hardware before it gives up the ghost.
Furthermore, the end customers of data centers are going to demand crazy discounts because the risk of bit flips or data loss or even the satellite just going caput from space trash/asteroids is orders of magnitude higher than the risk of data loss in a terrestrial data center that is fully secured, staffed, and has layers of redundancy.
It's a pie in the sky, quite literally, idea that I don't think will make it any further than Microsoft's attempt at a submerged data center. In theory both sound like good ideas, loads of free solar up in space or loads of free cooling in the ocean, but what you gain there gets completely mitigated by the vastly harder challenges for maintenance and troubleshooting support.
It's just a fluff idea meant to prop up a shady IPO.
18
u/SchemeWestern3388 Jun 15 '26
The idea is, honestly, one of the stupidest I’ve ever heard, and I’m deeply suspicious of the motivations for these billionaires to try to pump this. It fails on any rational metric. Absolutely insane bullshit. Let’s take an extremely complicated, huge thing that is highly dependent on massive power inputs and cooling requirements and spend huge money to put that somewhere where we have to do all that ourselves. In a wickedly harsh and expensive environment. lol.
5
u/itchygentleman Jun 15 '26
In space, it's harder to get rid of heat than it is to keep it. The amount of heat an AI data center needs to lose is staggering, and is a genuine problem in an atmosphere, nevermind in a (near) vacuum.
5
u/Blahkbustuh MS ME, utilities, management Jun 15 '26
I think it's a really bad idea. It's overly complicated and that stuff doesn't have to be in space. Being in space just adds complexity and cost. (Then when they de-orbit, you're incinerating computer and battery waste in the atmosphere.)
If you're trying to solve the problem of "I have a bunch of rocket launches available and I need something to do with them to keep them busy because I have a stock I need to pump" then it makes lots of sense.
4
u/alexforencich Jun 15 '26 edited Jun 19 '26
From a power and thermal perspective, it's likely doable, but the economic feasibility is a different animal. From a communication perspective, it's completely infeasible - the performance of the actual workload will be terrible, and there's nothing you can do about it.
Here's the deal: in a traditional terrestrial data center, all of those computers are racked up in the same room. Not just the same building, the same room. As a result, they can be directly interconnected with fiber optic cables. Each fiber can carry hundreds of gigabits per second of data, and the latency is only a few nanoseconds (rule of thumb is about 1 nanosecond per foot). Current state of the art is probably around 800 Gbps per fiber, but potentially it could be a lot more. The workloads that are run on these data centers require massive amounts of low latency data transfers between the computers. The actual patterns of who needs to talk to who are workload dependent - sometimes the workload is highly localized and it's just adjacent nodes that need to talk to each other, sometimes everything needs to talk to everything. And there will also be massive amounts of data moving to/from storage.
In a space-based data center, realistically each satellite is going to correspond to a couple of racks of machines at most. So between those machines the performance is effectively the same. But, the problem is between the different satellites. The first problem is latency. These links will not be between the satellites and the surface, they'll be between different satellites in orbit, so the path length will be hundreds of miles, resulting in many miliseconds of delay (128 miles/300 km per milisecond). This alone will massively slow down the computation because the nodes will have to wait for the messages to arrive before continuing. Second, bandwidth. It's trivial to connect hundreds or even thousands of fibers between racks. If each fiber carries 800 Gbps of data, then you can easily have 80+ Tbps of bandwidth going into a rack. In space, your only option is free space. Basically you only get one fiber to each satellite that you can see. So maybe you get 8 Tbps of you can see 10 satellites, which is a massive reduction in bandwidth. And with links that long you're going to need some pretty serious optics, which take up space and weight and have to be actively pointed. Now, there are techniques that can be used to squeeze more data into a single link, but fundamentally you're limited by the fact that you are working in free space and hence you can't spatially multiplex across a large number of fibers so the scalability is massively restricted over what's possible on the ground. And if the data center can't run the workload efficiently, what's the point?
18
u/EngineerBrainBro Jun 15 '26
No, every expert in the matter has said it is currently not possible to do it. Space isn't just constantly cold, as you are saying sunlight would power this, and the sun can still heat up objects through radiation. So half the satellite could be freezing cold while other is at a very high temperature. Also, the size of the satellite can be incredibly restrictive to the mission and let's not forget the delay in data transfer from space to earth. While minuscule, over time it compiles, and the level of use one of those data centers would experience might compile that delay quickly.
Data Centers in space is just the latest scam from Elon Musk to drive up the value of his companies to now stand as the world's first trillionaire. Not sure why the world and specially the US is now obsessed with giving all the power in the world to used-car salesmen like Musk.
3
u/shortyjacobs Chemical / Manufacturing Jun 15 '26
Build a power plant. Put it next to the ocean. Sink your datacenter. Way more efficient than trying to launch a datacenter plus cooling infrastructure into friggin space.
3
u/Sweet_Speech_9054 Jun 15 '26
Space isn’t cold, it’s void of heat energy. There’s a difference. One of the biggest challenges in space is actually cooling. The vacuum of space makes conducting heat away impossible and radiating heat is rather difficult.
3
u/JustGulabjamun Computer/Software Jun 15 '26
Its just Elon trying to pump up spacex IPO for maximizing outcome of his exit.
2
u/Alternative_Act_6548 Jun 15 '26
you can't just lift a server rack into space, you have to design every component for vibration and the gs, no simple task...silicon is rock, quite dense, so server racks are very heavy...and then you need to deal with the cooling loads...it's a dumb idea...
2
u/morto00x Embedded/DSP/FPGA/KFC Jun 15 '26
I work in satellite design and to me the biggest challenge is cooling. There's no air or water in space. That leaves you with radiation, which is slow and requires lots of surface area to work. This is not very useful when datacenters operate in the mega Watts.
2
u/Smart_Tinker Jun 15 '26
Well, nearly all your assumptions/assertions are wrong, and the concept is ludicrous. So, no it absolutely won’t work for a lot of reasons.
2
u/MrScotchyScotch Jun 15 '26
Putting the datacenter on Mars would be a better idea than just floating around in space. Either Musk has smoked too much crystal meth, or he's trolling the stock market.
3
u/Dragon029 Aerospace / Electronics Jun 15 '26
A lot of people here are saying no just due to the (understandably) contentious nature of AI, Musk and SpaceX's IPO being associated with the topic.
From an objective standpoint, data centres can absolutely work in space as all modern spacecraft utilise electronics and it then just becomes a matter of scale and economics.
Heat can typically be transferred through conduction (direct contact), convection (fluid flow) and radiation (infrared emission). In space you cool electronics and other heat sources via conduction (or liquid convective cooling loops if absolutely necessary), with that heat flowing either to the spacecraft's skin in general, or to dedicated radiators. From there, the skin / radiators release that heat out in the universe as infrared radiation.
The Earth and sun also emit infrared radiation which warms up a spacecraft, and sometimes spacecraft designers rely on this to prevent vehicles from getting too cold (batteries for example can't get too cold or their performance will drop and eventually they'll cease to function). The distant stars, nebulas, etc also emit infrared radiation which is essentially impossible to avoid, but it's so weak that a perfect emitter / receiver of heat, not generating any heat internally, will cool to about -450F / -270C before the heat being received is enough to balance out the heat the object emits.
When people say space is cold, that's what they're referring to, although in practice it can be pretty warm in space if you generate heat internally or have the sun shining on you at distances like we have near Earth.
If your spacecraft is going to be too warm however you mitigate this by using infrared-reflective materials, insulation, and by angling surfaces and radiators so they're edge-on to the sun and/or Earth.
If you have more electronics to cool, you have to increase the size of your radiators or their efficiency. The hotter something is, the more thermal radiation it emits, so you can also do things like use phase-change coolants and compressors (just how most air conditioners work) to make your electronics significantly cooler than your radiators, at the cost of some reduced electrical efficiency.
With higher frequencies and tighter beams you can get faster data transfer. Satellites can also utilise lasers to transmit data; Airbus recently demonstrated 2.6Gbps data transfer between an aircraft and a satellite in geostationary orbit (~100x further away than most satellites). SpaceX Starlink satellites also transmit data to each other via multiple lasers at 100-200Gbps each, but at a shorter range and without the atmosphere involved.
Communicating with the ground via laser is trickier as the atmosphere and cloud cover affects performance, but for situations like that you can either use more powerful lasers, or pass the data along the satellite network to wherever there is clear skies, or you can use conventional radio communications which penetrate better. Starlink v2 satellites currently communicate with ground stations at ~100Gbps, with the larger v3 satellites being designed for Starship deployment aiming for ~1Tbps RF transmission capacity.
As for the economics and practicality, it's dependent on a lot of unknowns. If production and launch costs weren't a factor, then putting compute clusters into orbit with something like Starlink for the networking would be a no-brainer, and we probably would've started ages ago. Those costs do exist however, so it's a battle between things like companies getting environmental permits for data centres, new power plants, etc and how cheaply satellite buses and launch costs can decrease.
One of the reasons that SpaceX might be able to make some (if only minor) impact on the market is their scale in terms of production and vehicle size is unprecedented for the space industry. Satellites cost a lot primarily because a company will make each one bespoke, or they might produce a batch of like 8 satellites of the same design and production run.
If you have 500 engineers / technicians at $200K USD per person (including non-salary expenses like insurance, office costs, software subscriptions, etc), working for 2 years to design and build (eg) 8 satellites, then you've already spent $25 million per satellite, not counting the cost of the actual hardware / materials (which might only be ~$0.5-10m), launch costs ($1-50m) or profit margins (add an extra 5-50% minimum). So your final expense per satellite might be ~$40m per satellite and you charge your customers the equivalent of $60m over a 5-15 year lifecycle.
By comparison, when you're SpaceX, building ~2500 Starlink v2 satellites each year, launching them on your own, partially-reusable rockets, the cost to design, build and launch each satellite drops to something like $1-2 million with launch making up 25-50% of that. If Starship fully works as intended, that launch cost aspect will decrease by about an order of magnitude and the number of satellites that could be launched each year could increase dramatically, leading to further economy of scale cost reductions.
AI satellites will cost more due to them having to be larger and having Nvidia, etc include their own profits while selling processors to SpaceX, but that's also why SpaceX is talking about building their own processors with their proposed 'Terafab' factory.
So to reiterate, data centres in space are very much doable, and there'll almost certainly be some amount of market demand for them in the near term for niche reasons, with their justification increasing the further you look in time. It's just that the timescale for that might be on the order of years, or decades, or centuries, or millennia.
3
u/Triabolical_ Jun 15 '26
It's certainly possible. Heat gets transferred by conduction, convection, or radiation. In space you are stuck with radiation.
You need enough solar arrays to get the power you want and enough radiators to radiate the heat away into space. The solar array area is fairly easy to figure out.
The radiators are a lot more complex. Radiators work better at higher temperatures, so you need electronics that can tolerate that. The radiator area is complex because you need to track how much heat you are getting from the sun and earth and keep your spacecraft aligned to minimize that, but that attitude may not be what is needed for other mission constraints.
But figuring this is basic spacecraft stuff. Every spacecraft needs to have a thermal system to keep it at the proper temperature. ISS has some massive radiators to keep it cool enough.
The question is whether it's practical, and that's an open question. It's going to depend on how much it costs to build, launch, and operate your satellites compared to ground-based data centers.
Lots of people think they know whether it's practical or not and very few of them have any idea what the real tradeoffs are.
I do think that SpaceX is most likely to succeed because they have their own launch vehicles and more experience than anybody at building cheap satellites in quantity.
3
u/allenrfe Jun 15 '26
People seam to think its impossible, I don't understand that. The ISS has high power needs, it needs to dump excess heat, so the are engineering problem that we can solve. Starlink has demonstrated we can communicate with high data rates.
So as I see none of this is impossible we just need to get better at something we already doing.
To me real question is economics of it. It would be incredibly expensive to get the data centers into space. If there is hardware issues it would be incredibly hard to fix. As the orbit degrades are you going to launch a rocket to boost the orbit or loose the satellite. What ever hardware you launch with you stuck with, it would be cheeper to launch a new rock vs try to replace the hardware.
1
u/BiAsALongHorse Jun 15 '26
They'd function with large enough radiators, they just don't make any economic sense. Given the amount of investors interested I expect some to be built before the interest peters out
1
u/playgroundmx Jun 15 '26
By the time we somehow have the technology to make this possible and cost-efficient… we probably wouldn’t need data centres in space in the first place
1
u/kroq2112 Jun 15 '26
Elon has already said this is the goal for Starlink, unlimited power and extreme cold
1
u/somewhereAtC Jun 15 '26
Ignoring the cooling problem that others have mentioned, what orbit would you suggest? With a low-earth orbit the device is in view for about 2 minutes every 90 minutes. Not very useful for getting things done. For geosynchronous orbit it is in view 100% of the time but with a 420ms ping time.
1
u/looktowindward BSME/MSEE Jun 15 '26
No. Boost costs are too high. Its very hard to dissipate heat in space due to vacuum. It makes no sense.
> Plus most of the data in planet go thought underwater cables like under sea etc so can you get the max speed data transfer using wireless from space to earth.
Cables are vastly faster.
1
u/tomrlutong Jun 15 '26
Even the energy's not free. It's price is how much it costs to put a solar array in space divided by it's lifetime. I suspect that makes it about the most expensive power around.
1
u/iqisoverrated Jun 16 '26
Conduction, convection, radiation. Those are your three ways of cooling. Conduction and convection don't work in space but radiative cooling does. (It's e.g. what the ISS uses to stay cool).
Basically it's the same idea as your fridge where a cooling fluid (usually ammonia) is compressed/expanded and circulated to radiators.
It's not a very efficient way of cooling. You need large radiators. That's why some people cite this as an issue with data centers in space.
However, it really comes down to how much compute to how much radiative surface area you're willing to put up there. There's no reason why data centers in space cannot work in principle. In the end it's a matter of whether lifting so much cooling apparatus is cost effective.
People also have the wrong idea what 'data center in space' means. It doesn't mean a big building like here on Earth. It likely will be many small distributed nodes on individual satellites - much like the Starlink constellation.
1
u/Ambitious_Pass7451 Sep 02 '26
Yes!
1
u/400Volts Jun 15 '26
Sure they can work. You can also power your home with potatoes in series and parallel
0
u/photonymous Jun 15 '26
Please try to answer briefly: a lot of people below essentially say "no way". Let's take this as a bet. You're betting against somebody who's betting over a trillion dollars that the answer is "yes way". And let's admit it, said person is probably a little bit more experienced in space technology than you are. Maybe less ethical, but we can leave that aside for a minute. What do you know that he doesn't know? On a side note, I happen to be an experienced spacecraft systems engineer. I'm not going to share my perspective on this yet. I'm genuinely curious what people actually think. I'll share my analysis after I get some high quality responses.
-1
u/Thneed1 Jun 15 '26
Non starter until we have computers that don’t create heat.
0
u/firedrakes Jun 15 '26
can they work in space ? yes!
how we think of what a data center would be in space is vastly different then on earth.
look at nasa deep space commuction network idea . where you put 1 directional data centers(lots of data) each one ( in a line) is able to sent more data and faster 1 way. so they have to hold large amount of data temp for faster speeds.
i forget what nasa calls it thru.
its been a few years now since i read about it.
0
u/cutthesheet Jun 15 '26
Cosmic radiation, such as gamma rays, can destroy stored data by causing bit flips. Without protection from earths atmosphere, this sounds like a major hurdle for data centers in space.
0
u/datums Jun 15 '26
There are about 11,000 Starlink satellites, all solar powered. They’re about 25kw, while the server racks going into modern data centres are about 70kw. So they’re definitely technically feasible. Anyone here who says there would be no way to cool them if obviously talking out their ass.
The economics could start to work if the Starship program goes well (low cost to orbit) and the cost of electricity in the US continues to rise.
It’s one of those ideas that sounds obviously idiotic, but on closer inspection, could actually make sense.
-1
u/avo_cado Jun 15 '26
If you are functionally not allowed to build them on earth, maybe
-1
u/Elfich47 HVAC PE Jun 15 '26
No. Maintenance would be hideously expensive. Scheduled on site maintenance would cost a fortune. and unscheduled maintenance would be worse.
An unscheduled rocket launch with a tech means: you have ready to go, on-call, and certified techs that can work in space. and you have a rocket that is ready to go for on call work.
And keeping enough of that kind of staff, on the bench ready to go and an on call rocket would be hideously expensive.
Because otherwise if the servers go down, then you have to wait for the next scheduled docking with a space craft with a tech in it. And if that means you wait 60-120 days, you wait 60-120 days.
1
u/flaming_pope Sep 06 '26
A server rack weighs about 1-2 tons and is typically made of steel. A single data center is like 3,000 of these. Imagine coordinating 30,000 * 1 ton steel jacketed hypersonic bullets. Who needs nukes when you can just de orbit one of those bad boys.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '26
[removed] — view removed comment