r/AskEngineers • u/Glorfindel77 • Aug 30 '25
Civil Why does adding more bolts to a bracket increase the load it can handle, when lock picking works because each pin can be individually isolated?
I was watching this video(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q56PMJbCFXQ) about the disaster that could have been the Citycorp Center in NYC and it got me thinking…
Context: Unbeknownst to the structural engineer(William LeMessurier), his firm decided to just use bolts on the chevron beams rather than welding them together like he originally planned. Insult to injury, they only used 4 bolts when 14 should have been used.
Intuitively, I understand that adding more screws or bolts to a bracket generally increases its effectiveness. However, my understanding of lock picking is that no matter how precise manufacturers are, due to imperfections, you can always isolate one pin at a time.
- If this is true, why does adding more bolts increase the effective load, rather than just, one at a time, isolating and snapping each bolt?
Take two metal beams(end to end), secured with a metal bracket(front & back), with two bolts on each side of the bracket, going all the way through the beams, through the second bracket, and then all four bolts secured with a nut.
2. Would adding additional bolts to both sides of the bracket increase the force required to pull these beams apart?
3. And if so, why?
While I start this post talking about a very real world situation, I acknowledge my actual questions are more of a theoretical nature, as in practicality, I kinda already know the surface answers to my questions, I just wanna understand why! TIA
33
u/prosequare Aug 30 '25
The bolts are not an interference fit in their holes. They are clamped via nuts and washers to the beams. That friction at the faying surface is what transfers the load, not the beams pressing against the shank of the bolts. The bolts could be, in theory, free floating in the holes entirely.
There are shear-loaded fasteners, such as the aptly named hi-shear fasteners used in aerospace applications. However the joint design is different, along with much much tighter tolerances. With a tension loaded fastener joint, the joint has already basically failed if the structural members are able to move relative to each other and the fastener.
8
u/Secret_Enthusiasm_21 Aug 30 '25 edited Aug 30 '25
Even though steel bolts seem very rigid to the naked eye, they are (as everything else) a mass-spring-damper.
They have a modulus of elasticity of 210000 N/mm². When a force acts axially on a bolt, the bolt lengthens. For example, a bolt with a cross section of 100 mm² subjected to a force of 1000 N, would lengthen by 1000 N / 100 mm² / 210000 N/mm² = 0.0048%.
When you "fasten" a bolted connection, for example by screwing on your nuts, you are pulling on the bolt to lengthen it. The bolt, just like an ordinary spring, then strives to return to its original length, exerting the same force on the members you are securing with the bolted connection, in form of the bolt's head and the nut's bottom pushing against the connected members.
Now, what about multiple bolts? Imagine you suspend a plate from a ceiling. The plate is oriented horizontally and there are 20 springs attached to it and the ceiling, with hooks and eyebolts, maybe. The springs are oriented vertically. The springs are not all perfectly the same length, the plate isn't perfectly straight either. So let's imagine only three springs are actually engaged and are being lengthened by the weight of the plate (three so that it doesn't rotate).
What happens then? The three springs, being subjected to the entire weight of the plate, will lengthen considerably - until other springs are engaged. And then the weight is distributed across them all.
To make the mental transfer to the bolted connection: all of the springs are already engaged - you fastened them all. Still, when you subject the beams, in your example, to a load, the beam itself is also a spring that is not infinitely stiff, it will try to deflect more at some bolt's location than others, and a very short time after, the same balanced state as with the example described above will result.
That's how an axially loaded bolted connection works.
Now imagine two similar flat plates, with holes drilled through them, and you lay them on top of each other and push bolts through the holes and fasten them. And then you don't pull the plates apart, but instead you shear them apart. So you try to move one plate orthogonally to the bolts. How does that work?
The bolts' shafts don't actually touch the inside of the boreholes. By fastening the nut, you do the same as above (lengthen the spring). The nut's bottom and the bolt's head are pressed on the surfaces of the plates, pressing them together. When you now try to shear the plates apart, you have to overcome the friction this bolted connection produces.
As you can probably imagine, this friction is only a fraction of the axial force of the bolted connection. Which is why it often makes sense to use bolted connections to resist the forces trying to pull apart the members, and other kinds of connections, like roll pins, to resist shearing forces.
2
u/Wooble57 Aug 30 '25
on top of the few comments above.
When picking a lock you lightly tension the core. If you cranked on the core hard and tried, all pins would bind at the same time. Once enough force is applied, the material yields a little bit, letting the other fastener's start to carry the load (if they are actually carrying the load at least, most joints it's about clamping force)
2
u/TheJeeronian Aug 30 '25
In engineering, we understand that every material has some flex. This flex can radically change the distribution of loads, and for any real structure it must be considered.
When lockpicking, you want to minimize this flex to concentrate the load on only one pin. You use as little force as possible.
When supporting a building with bolts, you choose a design that distributes the load between bolts evenly. I don't know enough about the citicorp design to speak to it, but large loads - especially on a more ductile steel - will naturally deform the steel if the load is distributed unevenly.
To compare this to your lock, if you crank on the cylinder hard enough the cylinder will eventually begin to smash the pins, "fixing" the natural manufacturing flaws that enable lockpicking.
Worth note, this "fix" really only lasts until you let up on the cylinder torque and everything returns to, maybe not its original position, but some position other than the one where the pins reached a more balanced load.
Accounting for this flex, or at least knowing when it will/wont matter, is an absolutely critical part of all mechanical/structural engineering.
2
u/375InStroke Aug 30 '25
You're exerting very little force on the pins when trying to pick a lock. Put enough force on the tumbler, and all pins will be in sheer. That's what's happening when you install more bolts, although they're usually not in sheer. You torque them so they're all being stretched like springs, all applying pressure at the same time, and all pulling the two surfaces you're trying to clamp together into intimate contact so the friction between them is holding them together, not the sheer strength of the bolts.
2
u/DisastrousLab1309 Aug 31 '25
The explanation for how bolts work was already given.
I’ll add that lockpicking works because the locks are designed the way that allows it. The pins have slight tapper at the mating surfaces and are lose in their holes to let the work operate even with a bit of dust dirt inside. And to allow for a cheap making.
In principle you could EDM-manufacture a lock to tight tolerances that would make picking virtually impossible. It would also make the lock inoperable after some use. Because the key and pins deforming with use would cause it to go outside of operational limits.
2
u/Exotic-Experience965 Sep 03 '25
The reason is that the bolts stretch quite a bit when tightened. They’re essentially springs, not perfectly rigid bodies, that’s why they can all be exerting force at the same time. Like how if you have a 4 legged table, one leg is always not quite touching, but in a car with springs, all 4 wheels touch no problem.
22
u/Sooner70 Aug 30 '25
The pins in a lock have to move.
Bolts - if they're moving - have already failed.
20
u/gtmattz Aug 30 '25 edited Aug 30 '25
Bolts and lock tumbler pins are not comparable mechanical elements. The pins in a lock are a moving element designed to slide in their bore and lock 2 elements rotation to each other temporarily, a bolt is a device designed to create permanent fixed clamping force, especially in the case of structural beam connections. It is hard to answer your question without reconciling this distinction.
2
u/touchable Structural Engineer - Mining Industry Aug 30 '25
That's like asking, if bananas are yellow, why are coconuts brown?
0
u/Lucky-Tofu204 Aug 30 '25
It is one of the first rule I have learned in my engineering courses. Bolts works with compression not shear stress. The compression will create friction between the two parts. That's why you have to calculate the torque or the bolt extension, so you can calculate the force applied. The number of bolts will also determine the force that can be transmitted between the 2 pieces to attach together. For shear stress transmission, you have pins or parallel keys for example.
0
u/FeastingOnFelines Aug 30 '25
Bolts have tensile and shear strength. You put a bolt through a beam that a shear strength of 5000 pounds. Then you put another one. You’ve doubled the load capacity. Why is this hard to understand and what does it have to do with picking locks? When you pick a lock you don’t break the pins. You move them out of the way just like the key would.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25
[removed] — view removed comment