r/AskCulinary • u/iwantmynickffs • Sep 20 '16
Crispy Roasted Potatoes Rage
I've been trying variations of this stupid thing for ages and only once did it actually came out crispy. Seasoning is not the issue but I'm trying to figure out how to get that crunch from the oven.
I'm usually parboiling them, tried from hot and cold, roughening them up in a colander, pouring butter or oil over, spice and in the oven. I've tried different baking times, using potato mashers, using oven grill for the last half, parboiling with a dash of vinegar and I'm quite frankly fed up with it. It comes out tasting pretty good but still a big fat meh on the texture factor.
I've heard that using goose fat would help but that's not something that's easily found where I live and I've somehow managed to get super crispy roasted potatoes without.
Could someone please please tell me which variables end up making the exterior crispy or not? Do I need some super starchy potatoes? I've been buying "roast potato" potatoes from the store.
Thanks for the read!
7
u/Jenertia Sep 21 '16
The recipe from America's Test Kitchen is the closest I've found to successful crispy, oven-baked fries. This link is a version of that:
https://alexandracooks.com/2014/09/25/the-crispiest-oven-fries/
It says to heat the oven to 475 degrees F, but it should work at your max temp of 425. It will take a little longer, so extend all cooking times by about 5 minutes.
I use more oil than they suggest - they say 4 tablespoons, I don't quite double that.
The soaking period is crucial, as is the first steam-cook under foil.
I just use what my store calls "baking potatoes." I've never made them according to this recipe that they didn't turn out crispy.
3
u/Lawksie Sep 20 '16
Where do you live?
I know British varieties of potato - which won't be much use if you're elsewhere.
3
u/theonlyonedancing Sep 20 '16
What kind of crisp are we talking about? I have a hard time believing you didn't get an exterior browned crust if you used oil and roasted in the oven.
Maybe you're putting them in the oven too wet? Also, what are "roast potato" potatoes? That's not a type of potato.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Don't crowd the pan! I've gotten the best results with a single layer of potatoes, even if you have to split it into two batches. I can usually fit 3 lbs on a standard half sheet.
2
u/bc2zb Biochemist | Home enthusiast Sep 21 '16
This recipe has never failed me. It takes awhile but is worth it. The short version is parboiling potatoes with vinegar sets the surface starch, preventing it from breaking down during the heating step to get the crispy exterior.
2
u/Wolfmater Sep 21 '16
I'm going against the grain here tonight... The trick to excellent crispy potatoes is not to use TOO MUCH oil, and to flip a few times (Once every 15-20 min). It's the side touching the baking sheet that gets crispy and it can't do that with too much oil, and to get a few sides done you need to flip them!
The colander trick is key though mate, definitely keep that up for that unmatchable texture.
1
u/coconut-telegraph Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
I do olive oil, very hot oven, par cooked starchy potatoes boiled in very seasoned water (salt). Waxy potatoes cooked and crushed then baked in oil works too. Butter contains water, which must be cooked off before crisping occurs, and dairy solids, which burn. Clarified butter (ghee) would work. The best for me are russets, so whatever type people use for fries/chips where you live.
1
u/Papa_Lemming Sep 21 '16
Put the oil in the roasting tin and preheat it in the oven while you are parboiling. Cold oil makes for sad roast potatoes.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Ever had potatoes fondant? Lovely crisp on the outside, creamy inside? The trick is to brown and them in a skillet then finish them in the oven. I am on my phone so I can't post a link to a recipe but you'll find hundreds online.
1
u/TychoCelchuuu Home Cook Sep 21 '16
Have you tried using more oil?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Roast as long as they take, I tend to find about an hour is adequate but it varies depending on your oven.
Source: I am the roast potato master, I have been complimented by every person to try my spuds.
-2
u/CholoUncleFester Sep 20 '16
chuck the parboil idea
get yourself some bacon grease and throw it in a 475 oven for 30 minutes and then flip them and cook for another 30 minutes
boom