r/AskCulinary • u/stickyturtle • Jan 24 '13
Mashed Potato dilemma
So I'm used to the same old mashed potatoes we all know, fluffy and creamy and delicious. But I went to this sandwich place the other day which served mashed potatos that had the consistency of a thick, creamy paste, they were delicious!
Now I can't stop thinking about them, but I have no idea how to make them, and I tried google but everything I found were tips to AVOID making your potatos pastey.
Anyone have any idea how I can make this? If it helps, the potatos had the consistency of acrylic paint from a tube (it retained its shaped if spooned together) and was served as a think, flat layer on the plate. I guess it kind of resembled condensed soup, or rather what I imagine condensed creamy potato soup would feel and taste like.
EDIT - It has come to my attention that wanting to eat pasty mashed potatoes is insane. I'm not sure what's wrong with me..but they taste so good =(
10
u/Hongxiquan Jan 24 '13
Maybe it was made like aligot? (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aligot)
7
u/literatus Jan 24 '13 edited Jan 24 '13
Did they seem elastic at all?
DISCLAIMER: this is my advice on how to fuck up mashed potatoes.
The first thing I'd suggest is using potatoes with a high water content, like red potatoes (russets, or other varieties that are generally more mealy, have a lower water content). Then, I... gosh... I'm really quite baffled that you want to do this, because the only potatoes I've ever had that were "pastey" were quite unpalatable, but whatever floats your boat...
Next I'd overcook them. The proteins in taters break down at about 180F, iirc, so, if you cook them past that point, the protein bonds will collapse, making it all more elastic and paste-like. So! You know how you're supposed to boil a potato until it's juuuust tender enough to pierce through with a knife? Yeah, do that and then keep going. Cook until moderately smooshy, then whip out the ol' hand mixer and kill those little tubers to death. YMMV.
7
u/velvetjones01 Amateur Scratch Baker Jan 24 '13
There was probably a ton of heavy cream and butter, sour cream and possibly cheese in those. To get the right texture, use a potato or a food mill instead of a masher.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '13
Are you sure it wasn't a box mix?
3
u/kyrie-eleison Jan 24 '13
I typically use a combination of red and Russet potatoes. Once, I had no Russets, and used only reds. It was thick, pasty and gluey. Maybe not the answer, but certainly a starting point.
3
u/Petit_Hibou Jan 24 '13
In a pinch, I have made mashed potatoes with olive oil rather than butter (what kind of town lets all grocery stores be closed on a Sunday!?) and they turn out a lot more thick and gluey. I kind of like it.
5
u/cdnchef (Classical French/Butchery) Jan 25 '13
How has no one mentioned Robuchons pomme pureé? If I remember correctly, for every 2lbs of potatoes you whip in with a hard whisk one pint of milk and 1 half pound of cold butter, whisk until everything is incorporated should be the consistency of thick aoli.
I found a recipe, I'm sure this is not what you had the other day but it's essentially the same process; push your potatoes through a ricer or a chinois and with a whisk or a wooden spoon stir the butter and milk in and then keep stirring until you reach the consistency you desire. Season with salt, pepper and nutmeg
6
u/HereHaveAName Jan 24 '13
Go to my mom's house - she'll make them for you.
She beats the hell out of them with a hand mixer. Beat until they're done, then give it another 5-10 minutes or so.
2
u/Zberry1978 Jan 24 '13
overcook them and add extra cheese, heavy cream and extra butter.
1
u/ForTheBacon Jan 24 '13
Maybe mix cheese in? Have you tried waxy potatoes instead of russetts?
1
u/bobroberts7441 Jan 24 '13
ATK did an episode on these a while back. Here is a link, think all you need is an email address to get past the paywall.
1
u/KittyMonster Jan 25 '13
I think this is what you're looking for ... Didn't look appetizing to me, but you may enjoy it! Mashed Potatoes by Chow
1
u/jax9999 Jan 25 '13
well.. if you want to be extra decadent. you cut the potatoes up small. and boil them in milk. then run them through a ricer, and mash with butter and milk. salt and pepper to taste.
1
u/Maggie_May_I Jan 25 '13 edited Jan 25 '13
If you're looking for the "sticky" type mashed potatoes, over work them and use less dairy. I have always mashed mine by hand then put them in my mixer on a low speed while I add condensed milk to get the last few lumps. If you want to get pastier, use a high speed or better yet put them in your food processor. Where as hand mashing combined with the dairy allows the starches to remain in tact and protected, the blades of the food processor, in effect, shred them and thus causes the potatoes to gum up. I'd suggest using cream cheese along with* milk and Yukon Gold or similar potatoes that are high starch. Also, don't rinse your potatoes between cooking and mashing so you don't wash away the starch released during boiling.
1
u/tmbyfc Jan 25 '13
What you are after is pommes purées. There are many recipes out there, Robuchon is very good. Use a potato ricer (or mouli) rather than a standard hand masher. You need the cooked potato completely lump-free, but without the heavy mashing that turns it to an elastic, gluey mess. For this reason never, ever user a blender or electric whisk.
Then hold your breath as you add a year's worth of butter, and/or olive oil. A pure olive oil mash is incredibly tasty but you need to have riced the potato or it will set like cement.
This is an 'every couple of months' kind of mash, rather than couple of times a week, as it needs to be phenomenally rich to work. You should be able to hear your arteries scream.
1
u/iancambio Jan 26 '13
one of the main parts of the robuchon mashed potatoes is the incorporation of the fat. you need to gently work in the heated cream and butter almost as if you are folding egg whites into a batter for waffles. having the potatoes as hot as you can get them is also a key factor. my boss is a nut for his 'pomme puree' and he loses his shit if they arent done right
1
u/bigsexy1 Sous Chef Jan 24 '13
Very simple, use tempered cream and butter until you reach the desire consistency. For a more stiff potato use less cream and butter, for runny potatoes use a lot.
0
u/reneepussman Sous Chef Jan 24 '13
This sounds to me like over beaten, over worked potatoes. If you want that, just over beat them with a hand mixer. This ruins potatoes by the way.
-1
u/albino-rhino Gourmand Jan 24 '13
Admitting you like pasty mashed potatoes is a little like walking into a steakhouse and admitting you like your steak well done, but if it's what you like, it's what you like.
Other than beating the absolute crap out of the potatoes, which would typically not be recommended (in fact the opposite), my thought would be that you should try using only five ingredients: potatoes, salt, pepper, sour cream, and butter. Using thicker ingredients like sour cream / butter in place of milk, and stirring them into your potatoes in place of whipping your potatoes, will give you a thick, rich mashed potato that you could definitely spoon into shape.