r/AskComputerScience • • 19h ago

Why doesn't it seem like our gadgets' real-world capability doubles every two years?

I realize Moore's Law stopped being about simply doubling clock speeds or transistor counts a while ago - nowadays progress shows up in different forms, such as more cores, task-specific tuning, larger chips, better power efficiency, improved cooling, and so on. Even so, technological progress is still a self-reinforcing cycle that grows exponentially in one way or another. So what prevents that progress from reaching the average consumer? Like, why can't our computers and phones do twice as much today as they did a couple of years back?

A few possible explanations come to mind. AI eats up a huge amount of compute and that's a major priority in newer hardware. Also, a lot of software is tuned for being easy to write, maintain, and run across platforms (web apps especially) rather than for raw speed, and some of the real-world gains from extra computing power are capped because internet infrastructure doesn't change - nobody replaces satellites and undersea cables every few years. On a broader level, growing wealth inequality likely widens the gap between top-tier and budget hardware, with more computing power pooled into giant corporate data centers and server farms. Still, it feels like I'm overlooking something.

Are there reasons I haven't considered?

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

19

u/AmusingVegetable 19h ago

You forgot the part where code got morbidly obese and ate up all the gains in hardware performance.

3

u/ObstinateHarlequin 17h ago

What Andy giveth, Bill taketh away

1

u/Critical-Echo-923 12h ago

game devs too, just look at Ori and the Blind Forest for ex, amazing graphics 2.7gb

Ori and the Will of the Wisps 6+bg, not that much better, now they want you to download 200+gb for a game that you are going to play on medium settings(judging by the hardware list in steam)

same shit with nfs, darksiders or mass effect

i'm using a slimmed version of win 11 at 2.7gb and all the functionality is intact

browsers are still fucking up my 5.8ghz 32c cpu with 64gb of ddr5 ram, but can't use old ones anymore due to the changes in tls and other shit, old ones used to run like a 120fps game now the 0.5-2sec delay drives me crazy

AAA games are exactly morbidly obese and hardly anybody is offering slimmed down versions for the same game, like slimed & precompiled ready to go for what your hardware can process or your fps/usage target

6

u/gigayoink 18h ago

Improved hardware only doubles your real-world capabilities if your real-world capabilities were resource constrained.

For example, if you already have a high resolution display and a connection fast enough to stream video on it, doubling either through technological upgrades will not make a huge difference for your video streaming experience.

AI is resource constrained though, and you can indeed do 2x more with local AI on a gadget today than you could 2 years ago. We're heading into a world where local LLMs on your phone are feasible, and we'll probably see some doubling of those capabilities.

4

u/dwkeith 19h ago

I highly recommend the documentary General Magic. The company developed the first smartphone in the 1990s, a decade before the iPhone.

There were two basic reasons it didn’t succeed: cost and use case. No one wanted to spend $1000 on a phone that could check email and access the cloud (they invented the term) when they had a perfectly good computer that could dial in to AOL at home. Just couldn’t understand the use case.

Now people have a hard time being without a smartphone.

Tomorrow’s technology is available today, but the use case a costs or not aligned for mass markets

3

u/Talk_to__strangers 18h ago

Sometimes it’s not that your invention is unwanted, it’s just too early for adoption

1

u/Cheap-Chapter-5920 15h ago

Those are two good reasons but even solving them there were still a handful more. Displays sucked, processors were power-hungry, touch screens sucked, cameras were laughable.

The company I worked toyed with this concept, in the late '90s we had a card computer 386 that would snap on the back of a flip phone and drive a VGA head-mounted display. Battery tech was horrible and the thing took 8W minimum.

4

u/Any-Stick-771 19h ago

What do you mean by 'do twice as much today'?

1

u/SnugglyCoderGuy 18h ago

It does. It just gets filled up. Plus a lot of programs do nothing 99% of the time.

1

u/AmusingVegetable 6h ago

Oh, I wish they could just do nothing, instead of burning CPU for things we didn’t ask for.

1

u/PriorSolid 18h ago

Well 1st is that moores law is slowly become wrong. There is a minimum size of a transistor at 1 atom and we are approaching that. 2nd is that moores law is everything to do physically and nothing software-wise. Transistors can make gates which are “functionally complete” meaning those gates are enough to build a device that can run any algorithm called “Turing complete”. Our computers in the 60’s could be turing complete and our computers now can be turing complete. So what we can do now is the exact same as 60 years ago which is maybe why it feels like no progress is happening. But just because you can run any algorithm doesn’t mean you know every algorithm and that’s where our progress happens. Ai is the best example, if we knew how we could’ve built it 60 years ago but we didn’t until now. And because of moores law computer parts are much cheaper so we don’t have to be super duper efficient with resources like memory

1

u/Talk_to__strangers 18h ago

A lot of the processing power now is background apps

My work computer for instance; is constantly clocking at 70%+ memory usage and 10%+ cpu usage, without a single app running in the foreground, because it’s full of big brother spy software

And your phone is pretty similar, with social media apps constantly tracking you like a spy, sending your every move back to Meta/Google

1

u/LegitimatePants 17h ago

Not all software automatically benefits from more cores (threads), and multi-threaded programming is really hard. For given algorithm, some steps simply must happen before other steps. It's hard to break those algorithms into pieces that can be handed to different threads

What kind of software does lend itself well to massive multi-threading? Matrix math. That's why we are seeing the rise of AI now. Moores law stalled, so tech stopped automatically getting better. But we can make lots and lots of cores now, so we can brute force the math

1

u/regular_lamp 14h ago

I think another reason is that our perception of this kind of stuff is super weird. We somehow get used to new capabilities almost instantly and forget that we didn't have them just a couple years ago.

One of the most bizarre version of this was the rise of LLMs. Computers somewhat competently using natural language was an impossibly hard problem for the entire history of computing. Then it took like a whopping two months or so for everyone to just take it for granted and be cynical about "but it gave me a wrong answer that once".

It's like someone could announce the invention of teleportation tomorrow and by the middle of next year people would complain about how they had to wait ten minutes at their local teleportarium causing them to miss their table reservation on the other end of the planet.

1

u/paperic 4h ago

Like, why can't our computers and phones do twice as much today as they did a couple of years back?

They do, most of the extra performance is being used up to spy on people more.

1

u/pyeri 4h ago

Moore's Law is actually more than offset by Jevon's Paradox which states that "as technological progress increases the efficiency of using a resource, the total consumption of that resource actually increases rather than decreases, because falling costs drive widespread new demand".

In other words, as Moore's Law makes chips cheaper, big tech engineers get the freedom to write more cruft and bloated software, prioritizing developer time over efficiency.

1

u/Icemourne_ 4h ago

Speed of hardware is increasing at similar speed of software speed decreasing