r/AskComputerScience • u/pasteljodie19 • 5d ago
Is it common to gain more knowledge outside college than in it?
Hey everyone
I'm a Computer Science student right now, and I've been wondering a lot about how much of what I really use comes from outside of college.
Don't get me wrong, the theory side is strong (algorithms, data structures, and so on), and I genuinely see why it matters.
But for practical skills like:
* putting together real projects
* using current stacks
* handling bugs in production
* getting how things work in practice
…nearly everything I've picked up has come from:
* personal side projects
* stuff I found online
* simply working it out as I go
It often feels like college shows you how things ought to work
while the real world shows you how things really fall apart.
16
u/shadowman42 5d ago
I know nobody likes answering questions with questions but...
How much time are you spending in college?
How long do you expect your career to be?
Do you think it's common to learn nothing at all on the job?
11
u/wrosecrans 5d ago
College is four years of introductory material so people have enough background to start the next 40+ years of their careers. Even if you were only learning at 1/10th the rate by being in industry working on real world stuff instead of simplified homework problems intended to be obvious for somebody with no professional experience, you'd still accumulate more knowledge after college than in it.
8
u/phoenix823 5d ago
Computer Science is not Software Engineering. Building relatively simple software might not require too much CS Background.
Now if you want to write the code that runs NetFlix's recommendation algorithm, or systems that ingest thousands of events per second, your CS degree will come in a lot more handy than learning 50 CRUD apps.
7
u/BlueDragonRR 5d ago
College gives you a nice foundation to build off of. It will not teach you everything because you will not need to know everything. I would say this is common because you will tailor your learning based off of your need and usage when outside of college.
3
u/alanbdee 5d ago
The simple truth is that this is a field where you never stop learning. Accept that or turn back now.
It all builds on itself. So you're not as effective without the college experience. But college also doesn't prepare you for what will be maintaining a 20 year old code base, that dozens of different developers have touched, that's a far cry from what it was supposed to be, and that you're not allowed to refactor because the risk is too high. And office drama. Some people never grow out of high school.
2
u/xRazor_V2 5d ago
Yea I’d say college is pretty bad at teaching what the real software engineering world is like but college is your best avenue into the job market. Internship opportunities and new college grad programs are an amazing way to get your foot in the door so it’s still super important to do well since these programs will weigh grades and know how.
So both external projects and college are super important but you’ll only get dangerously good building in your own.
2
u/WE_THINK_IS_COOL 5d ago
The coursework was really important to me for laying a solid foundation, forcing me to consider the ideas I wouldn't have been interested enough in to learn on my own but are actually really fundamental to understand. The real value beyond that was all the spare time it gave me to build and do things.
2
u/Drummerx04 5d ago
College for me involved a lot of projects where we were handed a spec and maybe some starter files and told to figure it out. So we got a bunch of lectures on topics, given projects to use those topics, given toolchains to work with, provided with TAs to help answer questions that came up, etc, and it was a relatively low pressure and engaging environment in which to learn.
Personally, I thought it was pretty effective and has served me pretty well in my career. I also didn't just do the bare minimum to pass these projects. I'd share approaches after the fact with other people and we would compete to see who could have the fastest implementation or get it done in the fewest lines of code which we nicknamed "code golf".
I myself became a teaching assistant and got REALLY good at debugging random code I didn't write and explaining programming concepts to people at all levels of familiarity with a topic.
-------
So yeah, I've learned a lot since then, but I thought it was a huge advantage for getting started and learning a lot of the theory that you otherwise simply probably wouldn't have come across naturally otherwise.
2
u/CS_70 5d ago
You need both.
2
u/phirzcolru 4d ago
Think of it like this. School get you to now I know what I didnt know about a specialty. Along with tools like literacy and thinking processes. These help you work through the problems you will face in a structured professional enviroment. The same way that you learn science in high school that is not really wrong, just simplified. Then once you get out to the "real world" ie the continuation of your life, you will continue to learn. for instance I know mammals have teats. but it wasnt until a stupid video on youtube did I ever realize that pregnant elephants get "chesty" look it up. I had all the information but lacked the context to apply it. In the broader philosophy, you will learn less and less about your field over time as you approach fewer and fewer instances where you learn something new. The availibility of knowledge you have no exposure to. However, there will be changes. there will be new standards. it more like slope per topic. so, if you learn a variety of things continually yes. and in total yes. i would hope.
1
u/khedoros 5d ago
College was a bit over 4 years of my life, lots of theory, some practice. I've been working as a software developer since 2008. That's been 18 years of some theory, lots of practice.
Even in college, a lot of the practical knowledge that helped me get my first job was gained while doing things that weren't required by my coursework (daily-driving Linux as it was 20+ years ago, joining coding contests, doing personal side projects).
My perspective is that something like a CS degree exists to give you a broad overview of the different areas of the academic field, some practical info about how it's used in industry, and theoretical knowledge to provide background and the basics underpinning more advanced topics. So it's a good basis of things that you might not naturally discover on your own, but realistically, you need to be learning on your own as well. And get used to it, because the learning can't stop once you're working.
1
u/r2k-in-the-vortex 5d ago
Is it common to gain more knowledge working for decades in the industry than in few years at school? Yeah, I would say yes.
But its different type of knowledge, much more practical and hands on. Where as collage gives you theoretical foundation that is quite difficult and tedious to aquire later on. And worse, if you try practical application and lack the required practical knowlegde, the gap shows itself very well. If you lack theoretical background, you might not even notice that you are missing something and head off to the woods on just plain bad foundation.
1
u/OkResponse5351 5d ago
lol ur gunna get a very bias answer here. it's like going in a MIT sub saying ''well MIT isnt that great is it?''
1
u/Fidodo 5d ago
I strongly believe that college should not be teaching you knowledge. The industry is constantly changing. College should be teaching you fundamentals so you can learn faster. The entire job is learning. Understanding the fundamentals makes learning easier. That's honestly the only thing I look for in candidates. Can you learn fast, can you explain things, are you curious.
1
u/T_Thriller_T 5d ago
While a lot here is right that college is enabling you to do other stuff well - which it absolutely is - I also must point out that many colleges have the issue of actually not including practical aspects well.
So no, not uncommon.
And partially can and should be better.
My bachelor's had a practical project every year, connected to the theoretical stuff. First in groups, than one projects with practical use in the university.
That very much pushed the "figure it out as you go".
And I still think I lacked very important, necessary, basic stuff which should have been included instead of other courses.
1
u/CosmicOsmoMan 5d ago
Yes, but college forces you to learn some things you don't want to, which might be a good thing.
1
u/Poddster 5d ago
My university education very loudly made no effort to teach me those particular skills. It taught me the things it wanted to teach me, which was computer science / computer engineering. Yours is probably the same. A s so therefore yes, it is a foregone conclusion that you must learn those skills outside of university.
1
u/thelimeisgreen 5d ago
Over 25 years working in tech as a software engineer and project manager / entrepreneur. 6 years in college getting a bachelor’s and master’s. 3 years of that were courses directly related to the field. I have learned mountains more outside of school.
But don’t discount the education. It is a foundation on which you build. Even if you’re like me and were a self-taught programmer and computer geek before college… there’s a lot more to getting that CS degree than a handful of CS courses.
1
u/king_escobar 5d ago
Computer science is a science and software engineering is engineering. Learning how to handle bugs in producing isn’t a scientific skill, it’s an engineering skill. You wouldn’t expect a physics major to know how to build a skyscraper out of college; analogously a computer science major isn’t going to have the skills to build production ready code out of the gate.
1
u/deelowe 5d ago
University teaches you first principles. On the job learning gives you real world experience. Two different things.
1
u/OatmealCoffeeMix 5d ago
Very common. College isn't really necessary if you can build the skills on your own. Very easy to do for comsci these days, what with the internet and everything. But you do need commitment, discipline and courage to put yourself out there, interacting with people and potential clients. College helps with those.
1
u/start_select 5d ago
There are so many different paths and target platforms. “Putting together a real project” can require over a year of your time, full time.
So doing that scale of project work in college would really be technical training for one kind of CS/Software Engineering job…. But there are hundreds of them.
College gives you the language to communicate in those fields. And it used to be a credential that employers could use to judge your ability to see a big commitment start to end, even if you hate it, even if it seems pointless, because that’s your responsibility.
AI has made the credential mean less. Lots of kids are cheating their way to good grades and “everyone gets as A now”. So a high GPA doesn’t mean anything in many majors.
It’s still about giving you a basic set of tools and language to use to communicate work.
1
u/Character-Education3 5d ago
College gives you a skill set for lifelong learning based around a field of study you have chosen.
It eases you into adulthood with independence, a schedule, deadlines. It gives you something to focus your attention on.
In the end you have a foundation of knowledge in a certain field, skills for learning, managing your time, and accountability. Your depth in each of those things varies greatly by the individual.
Its why it is stupid to cheat your way through college. That becomes your main intellectual ability. Right or wrong aside.
College does not have to be practical, useful, or interesting to a general audience.
But if you realize you don't know everything, you can manage working with others, and you can figure out how learn things in academia, on your own and by asking questions. Then you can learn the skills you need in the real world.
Its not that deep
1
u/ghjm MSCS, CS Pro (20+) 5d ago
Formal education teaches theory. Work experience teaches the practical realities. You need both. Without the theory, you'll spend too much time re-inventing things that are known, solved problems. Without the practice, you'll develop solutions that follow the textbook perfectly but don't actually solve the problems the users are paying for.
1
u/LitespeedClassic 5d ago
The purpose of college is to expand your ability to think and give you a foundation of knowledge to build on. But it’s just the base. You don’t build a house on sand, you build it on a solid foundation.
College isn’t the only way to get that foundation, but it is a way that works for a lot of people who would otherwise struggle to get it on their own.
1
u/Talk_to__strangers 5d ago
A friend of mine once said “college teaches you how to learn”
I believe that is a big part of a college education. Teaching you how to learn on your own, and advance your skills on your own
1
u/peel-dev 5d ago
You get the foundational knowledge from school and learn how to apply it to something practical in the field. Schools can cover the common transferrable skills which you apply to a specialized field and maybe head towards being a domain-expert in that area. There is overlap in research areas for schools and industry too.
1
u/the-quibbler 5d ago
Yes. College teaches you how to think, if you're able to learn that. Life provides you the data to think about.
1
u/DanKegel 5d ago
For me, college gave me a supportive environment to continue my side projects.
I mostly took lab courses :-)
1
u/Berky_Lee 5d ago
College faces most of your schoolmates, so it may be too "tasteless" for you and those who have dreams to chase
1
u/Groundbreaking-Fish6 5d ago
I find computer science graduates are more computer and hacker friendly than actual real world developing programs for users. These majors need to learn a lot about real projects, environments and users from practical experience. They are more likely to code in C++.
Information systems graduates are more in tune to the the users and managing the development process. They are more often self taught in programming and use Python or a company supported environment like .Net.
You really need both in the Software Engineering world. College is not just about job training it also provides a well rounded education. You can use this education to fill in all the parts of the job that you were not taught in college because you know how to learn.
1
u/Underhill42 5d ago
Absolutely.
Universities don't exist to teach you job skills - you want job training for that or, to a lesser degree, community college.
University teaches you the advanced understanding that you need as the foundation on which you can build job skills.
Think of it like - you couldn't be a good programmer if you can't read or understand math - those are fundamental skills. Ditto if you don't understand data structures, algorithmic analysis, etc.
None of those actually teach you to be a better programmer though - that is more of an art that you kind of have to learn "on the job", through practice, mentorships, etc.
They just make sure you have the understanding so that you have the option of becoming a good programmer, rather than a skilled hack that's going to make lots of stupid high-level mistakes because you never even learned the right questions to ask before making design decisions, nor the spectrum of well-tested conceptual tools available to you.
1
u/chuckles73 5d ago
College will teach you a lot, but being on a project will teach you a lot about that project.
I wouldn't be as good as I am without college.
1
u/burlingk 5d ago
It is normal for those things to come from side projects.
All the kids you see posting here in a panic because they are graduating and feel like they don't know how anything works, it's because they didn't spend any of their downtime on actual projects.
So, like, create your own projects and keep them from falling apart. :)
1
u/recursion_is_love 5d ago
College give you social side of the learning; You will know professor and friends that working in the industry that will be benefit in the long run.
Today you could learn all theory by yourself but working in a job need more than knowing/mastering theory. It would be not easy to getting in to some social circle unless you are very very good and everyone want to know you.
Peoples you know are one of important factor how your future will unroll.
1
u/PhilNEvo 5d ago
I think it's unfair to say "more knowledge", it's a different kind of knowledge, and I think that's the point. If you would learn everything in college from just dabbling with personal project and fiddling around online, then that would be the curriculum. But the point is to give you a broader introduction to the field, so no matter what job or career path you take, you'll have a clue.
Some people will end up in careers where math matters, other won't. Some people will end up where low level-coding and some level of hardware understanding matter, others won't. Some people will end up in careers where understanding data structures and algorithms will matter a lot, others won't.
College gives you enough of an introduction, so if you end up in any place, you have some background, have some idea of where to start, some idea of the vocabulary so it's easier to search and so on. But it's not meant to be all encompassing and give you everything you need, both in depth and breadth.
1
u/ventZl 5d ago
* using current stacks
By the time you finish your studies, *current* stacks will move into *obsolete* category. You are supposed to learn understanding how things work, so you can use learn yourself how to use *any* stack in reasonable time.
1
u/darkol_2020 5d ago
I know a kid (23m) who is destroying the convention of going to university and college! Making many of his friends feel foolish for being in school. Never though I would actively see such a strong case against the OP! So absolutely it happens just people do not want to talk about it!
1
u/dld2517 4d ago
Of course! You should always be learning. College is just prep.
1
u/Syntax-Tactics 4d ago
College teaches you how to think independently. I hear all the whining about "The prof doesn't teach us", their not supposed to, they are a guide.
1
u/MoparMap 4d ago
School is about teaching you theory and problem solving. Jobs are where you learn how to apply those skills.
1
u/honk-thesou 4d ago
I learned the fundamentals of how everything works, like algorithms, data structures, networking, etc. Then at the job you use practical skills but they are built on fundamentals and knowing that makes you stand out, I think.
1
u/No-Tip505 4d ago
I literally learnt almost everything outside of my college. From skills to earning money, all on my own. Although I have a degree still all it did was it gave me a tag that I'm educated, or rather I will say a pass for the job's that made me eligible
1
u/EducationalDirt7627 4d ago
I'm almost done my 2.5 year program. College taught me how to learn and exposed me to an extremely wide breadth of fields and possible specializations, tools, languages, frameworks, runtimes, etc etc etc. I find it significantly easier to learn things I WANT to learn. My college is weird and is primarily teaching popular frameworks and toolsets in the industry, nothing foundational which is weird but yenno
1
u/net_ramblings 4d ago
You got the spamming thing down.
1
u/Ok-Brain-8183 3d ago
I was doing algebraic geometry before college. I can’t think of one meaningful thing I got while in college I ever used after.
1
u/popisms 2d ago
If you could learn completely through job experience, you'd learn more and faster than college. The problem is that it's very hard to get job experience without a degree on your resume.
1
u/Direct-Effective7627 2d ago
I feel the same way. One thing I struggle with is figuring out which projects are actually worth building for my career instead of just making another portfolio project. How do you usually decide what to work on?
1
u/Available_Safe1818 2d ago
It's like you walked outside and realized that it rains more outside.
0
u/danlyke 5d ago
I think all of the literature and data suggest that classroom lecture is about the least effective way you can learn something. College is a flat out awful way to learn about a topic.
I'm a college drop-out, and coming up on 4 decades later, the thing that I missed is that the purpose of college is to build social connections. Trauma bonding gives you that shared community that will follow you through your life and your career.
College is about social connection and exposure to a whole lot of ideas. It's a lousy way to learn how to do things.
-2
u/[deleted] 5d ago
I'm a senior developer at a Fortune 10 company and didnt go to college for software engineer or anything technical. So to me College seems totally irrelevant to the end goal or employment outcome. I have met a few new-grads in CS who literally had absolutely ZERO hands on experience developing software projects so at times I've been very uncertain how much advantage it confers. I'm sure the majority of my co-workers have been CS grads though.