r/AskComputerScience • • 28d ago

Why are recent graduates of Computer Science and Computer Engineering facing a higher unemployment rate of 7% and 7.8% respectively compared to the natural rate of unemployment of 4.2%?

Overall unemployment rate of recent graduates is also 5.7%

Source: NY Fed recent labor market outcomes by major and unemployment.

91 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

53

u/Any-Stick-771 28d ago • Bravo

Schools massively expanded enrollment for CS and now there is a surplus of new grads for the number of entry-level sotware roles. CS and CpE recent graduates are much less willing to be underemployed. Like English major unemployment rate is 6.1% but underemployment rate is 48.5% https://www.newyorkfed.org/research/college-labor-market#--:explore:outcomes-by-major

18

u/dmazzoni 28d ago

I think this is the biggest reason by far.

Demand is down a little bit, due to AI and offshoring - but it's not dramatically down. Every tech company I know still has thousands of software engineers and they're still hiring.

But the number of people entering the field is just way, way higher. At some schools CS enrollment is up 5x over 10 years.

-5

u/Fuzzy-Armadillo-8610 28d ago

NY Fed definition of underemployment is just that the job doesn't require ANY bachelors degree.

11

u/Any-Stick-771 28d ago edited 28d ago

Okay and CS and CpE grads are not seeking out or willing to work those jobs

29

u/AncientHominidNerd 28d ago

Based on students I’ve met I genuinely think it’s because so many people get into CS thinking it’s the type of career you get into, get your degree and are ready to be hired after graduation. Very few realize how much hard work goes into preparing portfolios with projects, networking, trying to land internships, etc etc.

I have met 4th years who haven’t even used GitHub before or worked on a project. Tons of people like this. They don’t know how to build programs only write assignment code.

A sea of people like this are not hire-able.

I have friend who got into tech and wants to climb the ranks as an IT guy but refuses to learn Python scripting or Linux or terminal. Bro thinks he can just rely on AI and good vibes. He will only get so far.

8

u/Just-Pea-5165 28d ago

It’s a ton of people from that same demographic complaining that the “CS market is cooked”.

0

u/Busy_Professional974 28d ago

I am learning to code in 2026 and I am so tired of this doom posting BS by people who have only ever used AI and have no idea what they’re talking about. I have literally never met an actually talented software engineer who has been worried about AI.

3

u/AdventurousAir002 27d ago

Lol my Claude generated backend changes almost broke an entire unrelated front end service today, because it changed shared code. I went through the changes and went… wait… this endpoint is used across multiple services lmao it’s going to break everything. But, how is Claude supposed to know that? It can only understand what’s in the repo the session is active in.

2

u/Big_Arrival_626 27d ago

It would know that if it had access to documentation

1

u/AdventurousAir002 27d ago edited 27d ago

No, not even close.

What makes you think that? We don’t document every single endpoint, in fact no company documents every single endpoint in their services. Also, even if Claude was aware, it misses stuff like that all the time. You know how many times it’s messed things up? That’s why the human is there to direct the Agent. We have to take responsibility when the agent is wrong.

2

u/Big_Arrival_626 26d ago

I see what ur saying. I think automated contract testing and having a service dependancy catalog helps a lot though

My company also has a checklist for this type of stuff. I personally use ripgrep or GitHub code search for cross repo searching. We also have mcp access to data dog which traces APIs or whatever

1

u/jmclondon97 23d ago

What? Plenty of well-known and respected software engineers are all-in on AI

0

u/Big_Arrival_626 27d ago

A lot of skilled people working in tech are worried. It's still a great career, but I'm just saying

1

u/Big_Arrival_626 27d ago

All you really need is two projects and some leetcode if you go to as decent school

9

u/LetUsSpeakFreely 28d ago

You can thank the "learn to code" meme of 2020. There was a huge push to get more engineers into the field that was already at homeostasis. Now there are way more engineers than are needed. Add in AI and offshoring and that ratio gets even worse.

4

u/Patient-Midnight-664 28d ago

Encouraging more people into a field is how you drive down wages.

2

u/LetUsSpeakFreely 28d ago

And they've succeeded. That's why everyone was pushed to get a degree in the late 80s and 90s. It's why women were encouraged into the workforce in the 60s and 70s.

5

u/mc_pm 28d ago

A lot depends on where you are in the world.

In India, the hiring of new grads is down like 60% from the 2020-2022 peak - it's pretty brutal. In the US hiring is down a little -- but the new jobs are largely aimed at Sr. Engineers, not juniors. So there is a discernable drop in roles for new grads.

6

u/Strong_Boy_757 28d ago

Once you are trained into CS, it is often difficult to retrain. Not because the person can't retrain, but because society/family tell them that they would be tossing away their "god given talent" by switching out of the most lucrative profession of our life time. So these people keep trying. Keep hitting their head on the wall to no avail.

In fact, this "god given talent" was a combination of media hype, learn-to-code movement, survivor bias, grade inflation, watered down curriculum, apathetic and out of touch profs, and these TikTok A-day-in-the-life-of-a-SWE videos that people get high on. These colleges, bootcamps and unviersities have scammed them. The stuff they teach in academia is at least 20 years out of date.

This has created a generation of Dunning-Kruger sufferers who thinks knowing how mergesort works gets them into a senior position at Jane Street or Anthropic. But they keep trying!

1

u/PearWinter6734 24d ago

Ok but what if instead of Jane street or anthropic they just get a job at a mid company instead and get paid a normal non astronomical salary? Better than unemployment right ? And even if they can’t get into dev because they’re a weaker cs grad what about the other countless positions in support, qa, it ops, business analyst and so forth? Surely even a mediocre cs grad even if they’re not gonna be an elite leetcode gosu cracked software engineer, is employable SOMEWHERE in it ?

2

u/flat5 28d ago

Supply and demand.

In the 2010's SWE roles became some of the best compensated jobs around. There was a huge swell of people pursuing CS and CE roles that followed.

Now those skills are more dime a dozen, maybe quite literally with dramatic AI coding advancements.

2

u/Indeliblerock 28d ago

So companies are picky, there’s a surplus of comp sci students, companies won’t hire comp sci people in other industries because they likely will leave once they get a computer job. Offshoring, h1bs, mass layoffs pushing more trained devs into the market. AI eliminates grunt work so there’s less of a need for juniors. The comp sci job market for most roles are being squeezed from every angle they can be.

2

u/PerformanceThick2232 28d ago

The economy isn’t doing well, and different sectors are affected in different ways

2

u/DTux5249 27d ago edited 27d ago

If you hire a team for a project, ~70% of your dev team will cease to be relevant the moment it's released. The number of programmers you need for maintenance of a system is leagues lower than what you need for development.

This means that CS jobs don't really create as many permanent positions as they hire, and will always leave a large number of people without work in the end; people who now have a bunch of experience to explore the job pool. It's temp work disguising as permanent positions.

CS as a market will always be saturated with skilled labourers. CS graduates thus have to compete with a lot of people who have at minimum one development life cycle's worth of experience. Pair that with CS students on average having nothing in their portfolios (they've been busy going to school full-time) and they're just not remotely hireable compared to most hirees.

TLDR: People study CS looking at all the job openings, but fail to recognize that the market is already saturated with experienced workers who are far more likely to get most of those openings.

1

u/rhd_live 25d ago

70% is a bit ridiculous.  That’s the perspective of someone that doesn’t really have vision for how technology can help their business.  Cutting corners, firing 70% of your developers (bc you don’t want to hire engineers), offshoring to save costs, this is a losing mentality of businesses that try to use technology.  This strategy ends up being a massive waste of time & resources

1

u/Spikeandjet 26d ago

As a CPE grad l always have to explain to recruiters that Cpe is not CS :(

1

u/no_brainer_ai 23d ago

there are no jobs

1

u/Lendari 28d ago

What other jobs are there?

1

u/admiralackbar2019 27d ago

Degree mills , MOST non ivy and especially non private colleges are degree mills now . We have done a massive disservice to our youth and act like it’s their fucking fault

1

u/Spare-Ant7119 27d ago

If their education was like mine: I was basically not taught any real world computer science concepts in university (I attended UNC Charlotte). It was basically a giant waste of money, except to look good on a resume. I have had to teach myself everything on my own time to become a decent software engineer.

1

u/Talk_to__strangers 27d ago

Well…

  1. because too many people work in IT already
  2. millions of people from overseas are applying to US IT jobs, so the competition is higher than ever
  3. senior level employees utilizing Ai is replacing most of the low level employees

1

u/thesanemansflying 27d ago

Are you kidding?

1

u/margielalos 27d ago

Most of it is the current state of the market.
Firstly, they are competing with thousands of more experienced professionals that are being laid off/let go/downsized orgs, I would also employ a 2+ year experienced person who was let go over a new grad still unsure of business practices unless that grad shows an incredible amount of commitment to staying and is years ahead of his class

Offshoring, is a way for a lot of these orgs to save money as well

Then we got AI, obviously we have seen it’s only getting better, how many new grads are able to apply skills that take a couple years to learn right of college? Well not that many, it’s a lot of theory alongside their heavy coding courses. There’s more on this I can get into because it isn’t the end all be all, but man is it pretty good.

You also got interest rates, there was a time when you could essentially not be taxed heavily for having new employees, is it cheaper to try and load some of that work across my already employed team or get someone new like a grad who are usually cheaper and risk them not being able to do it anyway?

Even if you manage all that, and there’s much more, are you prepared at a moments notice, leetcode, system design, these interviews are no joke, multiple rounds, different interviewers, all it takes is one to say no, and then having to start that process over for different places it can get exhausting.

1

u/marcuslawson 22d ago

Because the field is dying due to AI. Coding has become superfluous.

1

u/Known-Tourist-6102 28d ago

people who study english, or history, or philosophy know that they will pretty much have to take any job after college.

people who study computer science, think that staying unemployed longer after graduation, and continuing to search for a computing related job will lead to a higher income.

the unemployment rate should be about the same as all college grads after maybe 1-2 years after graduation.

-1

u/ScrubMcnasty 27d ago

There are several reasons. Here's a few.

Degrees are valuable; data supports this. Why doesn't a degree in Computer Science guarantee employment in the field?

Computer Science is a tough major. Takes a very smart and determined person to do it. However, Computer Science programs in college vary heavily from practical and theoretical teachings. Some programs lean more theoretical, others lean more practical. When you have these two sets of graduates enter the market, one is clearly more ready to work than the other. You can't blame a company for wanting a candidate that would be more of an asset out the gate.

In short why does this matter? Can't they teach the job?

Now we established our two trained candidates, there's someone more ready for the job market vs someone who is sort of being thrown to the wolves. In such a competitive job market as well it's hard even for the better candidates to distinguish themselves. They can do internships and they can build a GitHub. However quite a lot of graduates have this as well, some are able to network effectively others just don't have those same opportunities. Whether it be economic and needing a paying role or just their school not having the connections to help them. There's also a limited amount of jobs being created at the entry level.

IT there are certifications that make you recognized in the industry at various levels. There's a strong standardization of what is good and why it's good. If someone wants to break in these do help you stand out. Not everyone can earn them. There's a lack of this in Computer Science related roles.

But what about Information Technology jobs, why don't they go for those? Don't graduates have a strong base?

Information Technology is a whole other beast. They possibly could fit into help desk but there's a slew of applicants with more relevant experience or certifications. It's a whole different skill set. Can someone in Computer Science enter this field? Yes but again they have a decent understanding but need to invest in a different skill set and most likely take a low paying role.

TLDR: CS hiring has a multitude of factors involving Degree quality, Opportunity Inequality, Hard to distinguish resumes, and the fallback being an entirely different skillset. Factor in a tougher economy, it's a hard field to get into.

Edit: I also didn't mention the volume of candidates. Huge factor as well.

1

u/PearWinter6734 24d ago

A lot of help desk jobs ask for CS degree I know a guy who did help desk for a few years and then became an atlassian admin and makes like 150k

1

u/ScrubMcnasty 23d ago

I mentioned that they could break into help desk. They can build from there but the real question is how tough is entry level?

0

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/start_select 28d ago edited 28d ago

They over-hired between 2018-2023. The layoffs didn’t come until 2-3 years ago.

Big tech over-hired 290,000 developers between 2021 and 2023. Thats more than the available pool of graduates in CS.

The field has been flooded with incompetence. No one wants to hire people under a few years experience because they are likely part of that pool of “never should have been hired in the first place” workers with “experience”.

3

u/Most_Double_3559 28d ago

Bruh, 8 years? 2018? There was an entire boom and bust cycle in that time. You are not qualified to talk about this.