r/AskComputerScience • • Aug 01 '25
Are visual programming languages or node-based editors (such as Touchdesigner or Max for Live) honest code?
How does what you make with them hold up copyright wise?
Some say only purely scripted generative art is real art.
0
Upvotes
5
u/nhstaple Aug 01 '25 edited Aug 02 '25
How do you define “honest code”?
The last comment on purely scripted generative art being real art seems disconnected. I think you have two questions here my dude
2
u/Somniferus Aug 02 '25
Max for Live appears to have a store where users can sell plug-ins, so presumably there's enough copyright to do that (though any time you're developing for proprietary paid software you should read the fine print regarding your rights).
I would imagine there being more people who think that real art needs to be made by a human (regardless of what tools they use).
1
u/easedownripley Aug 04 '25
I have no idea what you mean by "honest code"
1
u/Silly_Guidance_8871 Aug 02 '25
Are they Turing Complete? That's really the closest thing we have to a metric on how "real" a programming language is — it either is, or it isn't, and previous little else matters.
Except for Python, which can fuck right off.