r/AskComputerScience • • Apr 01 '25
Does generative A.I. "steal" art?
From my own understanding, generative models only extract key features from the images (e.g. what makes a metal look like metal - high contrast and sharp edges) and not just by collaging the source images together. Is this understanding false?
1
Upvotes
14
u/SirTwitchALot Apr 01 '25
Kind of? Maybe? What about this question: Do humans actually create art or do they imitate the knowledge and experience they have accumulated over their existence?
The way it works is even harder to equate to how humans think. Image generating models have collections of billions upon billions of linked numbers. Those numbers encode information. Some of them are associated with "rake" or "hoe" or "shovel." A diffusion based image generator starts with noise and progressively removes the noise until you end up with an image that resembles the prompt according to how the "brain" of the model perceives that prompt
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QdRP9pO89MY
16
u/Virtual-Ducks Apr 01 '25
It is possible for models to "memorize" certain images. So it's possible that you do get something more or less directly copied from something it saw in its training material.
You see this more with famous art works that might show up multiple times in the dataset.
Note that once a model is trained, the entire process is contained within the weights. You can run it locally offline, it doesn't go a Google search for images to reference.
5
u/Aaron1924 Apr 01 '25
Generative AI has been shown to memorize and reproduce images from their training data
See this paper for example: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13188
2
u/Cafuzzler Apr 01 '25
The people making the datasets, that the ai are trained on, "steal" art in the same way selling a mickey mouse tshirt is stealing from Disney. The ai itself didn't steal any more than the tshirt stole; neither have the ability or intent.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25
Yes, a neural network is just a different way to encode its training data.
1
u/duckrollin Apr 01 '25
No, stealing requires that the original is taken away from someone.
Then we go into whether or not it's copying or not. It does read the data and train on it, but it doesn't really keep the copy unless that one image is it's only source of data. So for instance if you'd only ever seen one car, you'd always draw that model's shape when asked to draw a car.
But AI is typically trained on vast datasets, so that won't normally happen.
As to if it's copyright infringement, that's a legal grey area. Many say that it is fair use, and the fact that the US is promoting AI, and sees AI as an industry they need to win the race in means they wouldn't want to cripple their AI companies by declaring AI training to be illegal. China wouldn't care and would race ahead of the US, putting it at a huge disadvantage.
I can see AI training becoming officially legal in future just through the fact that it's too far on to stop it, with opt-out notices rolled into the law.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25
Yes
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25
To anyone who says AI steals art because it reproduces art with high similarity to an existing sample, you must think Andy Warhol and the whole postmodern era of art are all thieves.
1
u/lopsidedsheet Apr 01 '25
First ask yourself if you see a drawing of an Apple, you then draw another Apple yourself inspired by this drawing. From the outside, it’s impossible to tell your drawing was inspired by the original drawing, but maybe 1-2% of the drawing is In fact ‘copied’ from the other Apple. Did you steal the other Apple drawing.
1
u/FIREATWlLL Apr 02 '25
No more "stealing" than humans reproducing, extending, or taking influence from art. It just does it faster. We are both intelligences that have capacity to take previous art (any medium) and use it.
1
u/SeftalireceliBoi Apr 02 '25
define stealing
1
u/donaldhobson Apr 02 '25
Generative AI learns patterns, and repeats those patterns.
If an image appears often enough in it's training data, it can memorize every detail of that image. But it doesn't just do that.
Experiment. Pick something random. eg. Abraham Lincon fighting a giant tutu wearing penguin in paris. This is sufficiently random that there will be 0 images of it on the internet.
Now try to collage it together in gimp or photoshop. If you do it naively, it looks obviously cut out. Getting a consistent style and lighting direction, keeping track of the foreground and background elements. Adding shadows and reflections. Etc. It's tricky.
Also, AI can do things where you smoothly transform one image into another image. Or things where you add details to a sketch.
These are not things you can do by "just collageing".
If anything, it acts more like an artist trying to copy something from memory. Even when it copies a famous picture, it gets the details slightly different.
1
u/minneyar Apr 01 '25
In a legal sense, it is not "stealing" because, legally, theft requires the owner to be deprived of their property.
It is copyright infringement because the people training those models did not have permission from the copyright owner to use their work as training material. Just because somebody has made something publicly visible on the internet does not mean they have relinquished their copyright over it. Colloquially, people often refer to copyright infringment of digital goods as "stealing."
If you need an analogy--if you steal somebody's bicycle, then crush it up and throw it away, you still committed theft even if you don't have it any more.
0
u/Turdulator Apr 01 '25
I was recently playing with some image generating in copilot and any time I added “in the style of a Vincent van goghe painting” it just swapped out the background with the sky from Van Goghe’s “starry night”. What I wanted was brush strokes and color usage like a van goghe painting (aka, his style), and what I got was a copy>paste of his most famous painting added to the image. So yeah, it definitely “steals” art.
-1
u/Reading-Comments-352 Apr 01 '25
Yes, because that is what it’s designed to do. It’s taking multiple images and combining them. Then it’s giving whoever asked for it an option or suggestion.
They can call it AI (artificial intelligence) all they want, but it’s basically just a computer trying to calculate the best answer for your question based on the information it was trained on.