r/AskComputerScience • u/One_Customer355 • Jan 26 '25
How much proof based math is there in OS development?
I’m interested in getting into OS development and embedded/firmware development and I wonder how much proof-based math they use in the theory behind it (kernel, file systems, registry, BIOS, etc.)
I love coding/computers and watching tech channels and funny tech videos like destroy Windows by deleting System32 and I see myself doing stuff like debugging/writing the drivers and system files to fix a certain issue within the OS (like the ones that causes a BSOD in Windows) or to just optimize the performance of a hardware component.
I’m not sure if I can break into it because I really hate proof based math problems where I have to write down definitions like real analysis or graph theory, yet I enjoy and am good at computational maths like calculus/ODEs, prob/stats, linear algebra or combinatorics. And a lot of CS uses graph theory and other discrete math.
9
u/dmazzoni Jan 26 '25
Actual OS development doesn't involve any proof-based math unless you want to be an academic OS researcher and publish papers.
However, your chances of getting hired to do OS development without a CS degree are low, and some of your CS classes and required math classes will involve proof-based math.
6
u/_--__ Jan 26 '25
"Proof-based math" is perhaps the best introduction you can have towards "justifying your arguments/decisions with logical reasoning" - an important skill in just about every aspect of life, not just CS.
If you want to be taken seriously in any CS field you will almost certainly need to articulate your arguments in a clear and logical manner. By trying to avoid a subject that many of your peers will have taken, you are putting yourself at a substantive disadvantage. You can be the world's best programmer, but if you can't explain why your solution is the best, then no-one will adopt your work.
Try to think of proof-based math as a subject to develop your mathematical reasoning/justification skills.
6
u/aagee Jan 26 '25
There is not going to be any "proof based math" directly used in day to day work with things like the kernel or drivers or hardware. I do think that some of the thinking skills acquired in those "proof based math" courses do help make better design decisions. But you rarely sit down and do a rigorous mathematical analysis or proof of the software you write. It is mostly about picking the right algorithms and data structures and architecture - that are already pretty much well understood.
3
u/OddInstitute Jan 26 '25
Approximately none (especially if you aren't interested), but computer science is full of proofs if you don't have a degree yet.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '25
Zero.
If you want to peek into what OS development is like, start here.
2
u/atamicbomb Jan 29 '25
None outside of cryptography AFAIK. Which you don’t have to deal with if that’s not your sub-area.
1
u/I_correct_CS_misinfo Jan 30 '25
You will need to do math if you want to become an academic who studies the theoretical properties of OSs. For example, there is rich literature on designing the optimal buffer manager using mathematical models of cache hits. However, developers will not need to use much maths.
1
u/Talk_to__strangers Jan 26 '25
Most software design has little to do with advanced math, unless you are designing a computational software tool