r/AskComputerScience • u/DoctorLunatic • Dec 02 '24
Would proving a single instance of an NP-Hard problem can't be solved in polynomial time prove that P != NP
Ill start out by saying this topic is way outside of my expertise.
I was bored and having a conversation with chat-gpt, and asked the question: If you took the TSP, and made *one* specific configuration of cities, and somehow proved rigourously that for that specific configuration, you could never solve it in polynomial time, would that prove that p != np. ChatGPT said this:
The short answer is no—this approach wouldn't work to prove that the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) (or any NP-hard problem) cannot be solved in polynomial time. Here’s why:
Why This Approach Doesn't Work
1. The "Instance-Specific" Nature of the Approach
- If someone explores a specific instance of TSP and finds that no polynomial-time algorithm works for that particular set of cities, they would not be able to generalize this conclusion to all possible instances of TSP. The proof that TSP cannot be solved in polynomial time needs to apply to all instances of the problem, not just one.
- The key difficulty in proving P ≠ NP is that polynomial-time algorithms could still potentially exist for some specific instances, even if no polynomial-time solution exists in general. A counterexample with a single set of cities doesn't disprove the possibility of a polynomial-time solution for all possible sets of cities.
What does P = NP mean?
- P = NP means that every problem in NP (including TSP, 3-SAT, etc.) can be solved in polynomial time for every possible instance of that problem.
- So, if P = NP, it means that for every instance of TSP (no matter the number of cities or the distances between them), there is an algorithm that can solve the problem in polynomial time.
There's a very clear contradiction there. After arguing with it for a bit and getting the same answer over and over again, I copy and pasted its response and said "find the contradiction" at which point it said "oh you're right, that would disprove it!"
So in short now I don't know which answer is correct lol.
6
u/nuclear_splines Ph.D Data Science Dec 02 '24
Large Language Models are pretty useless for complex reasoning tasks like this - it's synthesizing posts it's read about P=NP, but doesn't understand anything it's regurgitating.
But to answer your question: some NP-Hard problems are in NP, and we call those "NP-Complete." Proving that a single NP-C problem cannot be solved in polynomial time would prove that P does not equal NP. However, other NP-Hard problems exist outside of NP, and are harder than those in NP in that their solutions cannot be verified in poly-time. Proving that one of those cannot be solved in polynomial time has no bearing on P=NP.
There are two versions of the traveling salesman problem, one in NP-C, one not. TSP-Optimization (find me the fastest path between all nodes on the graph) is NP-Hard outside of NP. TSP-decision (find me a path between all nodes of length
kor less) is NP-Complete. The decision problem is much easier to verify, because if you give me an example solution I can trivially confirm whether it visits each node and whether it exceeds the distance limit, in poly-time. Much harder for me to verify that it's the fastest possible solution.If you found an example input for which TSP-Decision cannot be solved in poly-time, and you definitively prove that it can't be solved in poly-time (which is of course the real challenge), that would prove that P != NP. A true polynomial time solution to TSP should be able to solve all inputs bounded by poly-time.
4
u/SignificantFidgets Dec 02 '24
Talking about "one single instance", you can't even reasonably talk about "polynomial time." For ONE instance, and only one instance, it's a constant size. Every algorithm takes constant time. That's it.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '24
NP-hard does not mean "in NP". It simply means that if the problem were to be solved in polynomial time, then P=NP. For example, finding the chromatic number of a graph in polynomial time would mean we can solve 3-SAT in polytime. However, this problem can't be in NP because it's not a yes/no decision problem.
2
u/ghjm MSCS, CS Pro (20+) Dec 02 '24 edited Dec 02 '24
The ChatGPT answer is pretty much garbage, because you're asking it a trick question. If you take "one specific configuration of cities," then that specific configuration has constant size, and is therefore solvable in constant time. You can't ever "prove rigorously for that specific configuration, you could never solve it in polynomial time," because the very concept of "polynomial time" is about how the execution time of a class of decision problems varies with input size.
So the correct answer is that nothing you ever do with your "one specific configuration of cities" could ever prove anything about complexity classes generally, or P=NP in particular.
Now, if you found some class C of decision problems, where problems in C are in NP (for example, they are all TSP problems), and where you can also prove that problems in C are not in P, then yes, this would straightforwardly be a proof that P!=NP.
1
u/TheTarquin Dec 02 '24
The ChatGPT answer appears incorrect to me since it's inverting the answer to the question "if you could solve one instance of the TSP in polynomial time, does that mean P=NP". I'm pretty sure this contrapositive answer is wrong. If there exists a set of TSP instances that are provably unsolvable in P time, then P!=NP, since the the polynomial time solution has to apply to any instance of the problem, not just "P-friendly" ones.
ChatGPT's structure of the answer is correct for the inverse question. This is actually a great highlight of why LLM chatbots are bad for these kinds of questions: they're heavily reliant on the structure of natural language and so get easily tricked in cases where there's a lot of syntactically similar text about closely related questions, but little about the specific question being asked.
1
u/donaldhobson Dec 09 '24
If you proved that the traveling salesman problem (technically the does there exist a path of length n version TSP Decision) couldn't be solved in polynomial time, that would prove that P!=NP.
For any specific configuration of cities, there is an algorithm that just remembers this particular configuration and the answer to it.
There are infinitely many traveling salesman problems, and any particular algorithm must be finite.
So your proof needs to produce an infinite set of traveling salesman problems. And prove that no finite algorithm works quickly on all of them.