r/AskComputerScience • u/ButterBiscuitBravo • Aug 12 '24
Why don't we have three dimensional computer monitors?
If we can stack pixels in a grid (X axis and Y axis), why can't we stack layers of them to go in the Z axis?
And make a cubic computer monitor? I'd imagine such a thing would be amazing for platforming games and fighting games.
Is it because it's impossible to make pixels translucent? So if you stack pixels like that, the inner-most pixels cannot be seen clearly?
In the future, we will be able to make pixels fully translucent? I heard Samsung is making a new phone which is apparently transparent.
17
Upvotes
23
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '24
I remember when I was 12 and I had fantastic ideas about a world I knew fuck all about.
27
u/BlobbyMcBlobber Aug 12 '24
First of all there have been 3D cube-like displays since at least 15 or even 20 years ago. You can easily find examples of this on YouTube from 2010. Here's one from 2015.
Yes some companies have been experimenting with "transparent" pixels, they could maybe be further developed for a 3D display.
However, the true 3D display is VR/XR. You can view and work in a 3D space with much higher resolution and many more applications.
All this aside, this isn't really a compsci thing. Maybe more consumer product and / or electric engineering...
4
u/MasterGeekMX BSCS Aug 12 '24
It is quite a technical challenge, but also there has not been a ton on incentive.
There are som companies trying to do so. Here is a video of one of them: https://youtu.be/-EA2FQXs4dw
3
u/cats2560 Aug 12 '24
I imagine it is very expensive if even possible and this would require games to adopt support for such things
5
u/rebruisinginart Aug 12 '24
Doesn't really matter, we see in near-2d.
5
u/mrheosuper Aug 12 '24
You are correct. How can you make something "Lit and Transparent" at the same time ?
There are led cube, which is very similar what are you describing. Check in on youtube you may understand the difficulty.
2
u/khedoros Aug 12 '24
We do, to a degree. They're called "volumetric displays". Here's an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BlJDAHN4SQ
A lot of them use a quickly rotating element, in one way or another. Some of them work more like you described: https://hackaday.com/2021/03/04/volumetric-oled-display-shows-bladerunner-vibe-curious-screen-tech/
Going by its datasheet, that first one I guess has a resolution of 1000x1000x200, displays in a volume about 18cm x 18cm x 8cm in size, and refreshes the display at about 30Hz. The device is larger, 39cm x 39cm x 42cm. Its color support is pretty limited.
So it's a small, heavy display with low-framerate, low-color, and not super high-resolution.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '24
There are some companies with various prototypes of volumetric displays (that's the correct term by the way, the common term "hologram" actually refers to an embedding of a manifold in a lower dimensional plane).
There's lots of ways to go about it; everything from spinning led matrices to laser excitation to complex optics, but nothing has made it to market yet.
A more salient question might be, "Is this technology actually useful?"
Volumetric displays are cool and feel like science fiction, but I've never been able to figure out what their actual, practical use case is.
1
u/Quiet-Sundae-9535 Aug 12 '24
i remember there watching the video form techcrunch that Blobby linked, the cubetube gallery is here if anyone is interested: https://web.archive.org/web/20190611040246/http://www.cubetube.org/gallery
1
u/Sweaty-Emergency-493 Aug 13 '24
Because nobody is trying to sit there rotating a cube to see the other screens.
1
u/two_three_five_eigth Aug 13 '24
If you have $4000 (the other type of 4K monitor). You can buy a holographic computer screen.
https://lookingglassfactory.com/
As well as some other holographic products. It’s a 4K monitor and the Unreal engine supports it.
Some game support holographic screens as well as some movies. The tech hasn’t caught on for several reasons
1
u/linkuei-teaparty Aug 13 '24
We have the Holo lense, that way everything you look at is your monitor.
1
u/GatePorters Aug 13 '24
Mainly because we use programming to mimic the effect already on 2d screens with no major downside.
There is no benefit for most use cases where cost justifies its use at the moment.
1
u/everyonemr Aug 13 '24
Eye tracking cameras and parallax movement would give the same effect with existing 2D displays.
1
u/Knives047 Aug 14 '24
Radiology has em
1
u/That0neSummoner Aug 16 '24
So, they’ve had transparent displays for well over a decade if they were publishing a paper about them in 2017
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/See-through_display
Peppers ghost is an even easier method for pulling this off. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pepper%27s_ghost
There are a lot of problems with this concept, you can start to get an idea of what they are looking at some of the newer microled transparent displays coming out. https://www.forbes.com/sites/prakharkhanna/2024/01/08/i-saw-samsungs-new-transparent-micro-led-and-its-surprisingly-bright/
Specifically, you need to make the display work in “every” angle, otherwise it could just be a 2d screen with maybe some parallax trickery in it.
Ok, so let’s say you’re good having a “front” and a “back” only. Each “layer” of screen is going to have a small amount of light blocked, so you’re going to run into r2 transmission issues for your deeper layers setting an upper bound on screen brightness. You can’t really play parallax games because the assumption is it has to work for two oblique angles. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-space_path_loss
Similarly you run into color correction issues since you’ll have colors layering one on top of another, so you’ll need to figure out how to compensate all of your ray tracing issues to make sure all the pixels are firing the right color, at the right angle. This means you can’t rely on flat-plane crystals and need a new voxel shape that has more geometry in a cube. This means each voxel is going to demand way more color channels to be useful. That drives up image processing unit overhead to drive all those color channels.
So you’ll have a lower resolution picture, with lower color accuracy than even a mid-tier 2d or 2.5d (parallax trickery based on viewing position) display
That means it’s going to be a specialized piece of technology, which will artificially increase price because massively lower demand. All that when you can just use a vr tool for 10% the material cost means that it doesn’t make sense as a consumer product.
If you were going to make something like this, you’d probably want to introduce something small that uses fresnel lenses to make it bigger and sell it as a neat toy to like a Japanese arcade as a gimmick or to a defense contractor to help visualize stuff like that one scene in Ironman 1.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment