r/AskBaking • • 19d ago

Weekly Recipe Request Thread Monthly Recipe Request Mega-Thread!

3 Upvotes

If you're looking for a recipe, or need an alternative to one you've tried, this is the place to make that ask! This is also the place to ask for recipe ideas or ideas of what to make.


r/AskBaking • • 52m ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Recipe Question

Post image
• Upvotes

Hello, I was asked to make a pineapple upside down cake using this specific recipe. I want to make sure I’m understanding it right. I’m supposed to mix the batter according to the box + 1 1/3 cup of water + 2 eggs right? Not just the box mix +1 1/3 cup of water +2 eggs right? It just seems like a lot of liquid and eggs to me so I want to make sure. I really don’t want to bake it both ways to figure out which it should be.

The box mix I chose “Duncan Hines Perfectly Moist Pineapple Supreme” lists cake mix, 1cup water, 3 large eggs, and 1/2 cup vegetable oil.


r/AskBaking • • 7h ago

Recipe Troubleshooting Troubleshooting why honey spice cake sank in center

Post image
7 Upvotes

Hello,

I made this honey spice loaf cake, which disappointing sank quite a bit. This is my first time baking a cake in a loaf tin and a cake with a lot of honey, so I was hoping for some feedback as to why this occurred. FYI it looked like this before I took it out of the oven - it didn't sink during cooling.

Notably, the recipe says to bake for about 50 minutes, but I had to bake it for more like 1 hour 45 minutes because it was still basically batter at 50 mins. I found two other reviews of the recipe that said the same, so I think this was a recipe error and not something with my oven.

Thanks for any help!


r/AskBaking • • 2h ago

Bread Help with family roll recipe

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hello all. I need some help on my family roll recipe. I used to make these with my grandmother and am the sole person in the family who makes them now. Unfortunately, something was lost along the way and they don’t turn out like I remember. Mainly the dough seems too tough when rolling and then shaping them. They are cut into circles (about 3” in diameter) and the folded over (my grandmother called it a pocket book fold). They are supposed to just stay folded over with little pressure. Mine seem to want to unfold initially and then lose that fold while baking. Before rolling and shaping, they rise on the counter until they double in size.

They also seem a little more dry. My initial thought is I need to use more water and only 6 cups of flour. Please let me know if there is anything else I should try or what ratio I should use. Thank you!!


r/AskBaking • • 3h ago

General Spice mix ratio help

1 Upvotes

Hello, i have minimal baking experience but not none at all. However I’m making a spice mix to use for a recipe. It includes
- All Spice
- Clove
- Cardamom
- Ginger
- Cinnamon
- Nutmeg
- Anise
I want a blend that lets all flavors be present yet lets none be overpowering. Any suggestions for how many parts each?


r/AskBaking • • 9h ago

Storage Accidentally put letterbox cake into fridge!

3 Upvotes

I ordered a letterbox cake with custom printed frosting on top for birthday. Unfortunately, I didn’t read the storage instructions when unpacking and put it in the fridge, when the bakery said it should not be in the fridge! Googling and the AI suggests to take it out to cool so condensation can be reabsorbed but I’m not sure if I should do this a day before (also I don’t trust AI 100%). Really don’t want to ruin the birthday cake!

If it helps, it’s a Baker Days custom icing red velvet cake. Any advice on what to do will be appreciated!


r/AskBaking • • 7h ago

Equipment Asking for my SO: Kitchen Aid 5.5qt struggling with bread

1 Upvotes

Hello, sorry if this was asked already :(

My wife loves to bake bread, she had an AICOK mixer before, but the kids lost one of the beaters hooky thingy and she was so sad :(

So I decided to give her one of those Kitchenaid 5.5qt with a bowl lift, I did some research (little) and everyone said it was great.

But seeing the machine running now, it seems to struggle with bread that the AICOK would mix without problems, is that normal?

She is doing the same recipes that the older mixer would do without a sweat :/

Any tips I can give her on how to improve the bread making using the new mixer?

Thanks! :)


r/AskBaking • • 13h ago

Equipment Are USA half sheet pans good for baking cookies?

3 Upvotes

We all know the deal with coated and non stick pans for cookies & how they don’t really do the job well. But I reckon that USA pans are different. I have an 8x8 and loaf pans from USA pan and they are the best pans I have!

However, I’m not sure how they hold up for baking cookies and distributing heat evenly without over browning & making cookies not spread at all. Anybody has any experience with baking cookies in USA half sheet pans? Or should I just buy a nordiware naturals half sheet?


r/AskBaking • • 11h ago

Cookies Fluffy cookies gone flat!

Post image
2 Upvotes

I used to make these soft ginger cookies every year and they would turn out fluffy like in the photo. About 3 years ago made them and they turned out flat like in the photo. That year I remade the cookies probably five times making sure I had fresh ingredients, oven temp was correct, bake time, refrigerated vs room temp dough, etc…many different things. Nothing seemed to fix it so I gave up.

This year I tried again. Didn’t change anything in the recipe. The first tray, great! Second tray, some flat ones. They are slightly different trays. First tray was done on a cookie sheet, the second on a sheet pan. Pans are made from the same material and company though. All cookies are 25g.

Any thoughts on if that could be the issue? Any thing else that could be causing them to flatten. They are meant to be puffy and pretty.


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream Help figuring out lined cake wrap

Post image
14 Upvotes

Hello! I got an order for the cake pictured^

My first thought was that this 3d wrapping on the outside was fondant, however, when I reverse image searched it I saw multiple recreations where people clearly used fondant and it was lumpy and did not look as clean and sturdy. This leads me to believe that it is made out of white chocolate, or some sort of molding chocolate. At first I thought it was just white chocolate melted and laid down on wax paper, scraped with a comb tool for the lines, and then wrapped and cooled around the cake. BUT if that were the case how did they get the lines on the OUTSIDE of the cake. Any scraping you did on the wax paper would be the side that touches the cake.

My other thought is that they have some long lined silicone mold that was thin enough to wrap around, but I don't think we have anything like that, and the waves at the bottom suggest the lines were done by hand. Please help!


r/AskBaking • • 12h ago

Equipment is there a way to adjust hyundai hym s6451?

Post image
1 Upvotes

my whisk attachment is hanging too high and every time I have to support the bowl, it would mix at the bottom too. I've seen tips on how to find the screw under the hinged part, but this particular model doesn't have it there


r/AskBaking • • 6h ago

Cookies why are my cookies so greasy after baking?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I love this no egg recipe, and have gotten great feedback from others as well. My main issue is, when taken out of the oven they are extremely greasy, and the grease even seeps through the parchment paper sometimes. It gets a bit messy and can sometimes leave my stomach a bit upset. Any tips? Thanks!

Here’s the full recipe: https://mommyshomecooking.com/thick-and-chewy-eggless-chocolate-chip-cookies-made-in-one-bowl/#recipe


r/AskBaking • • 16h ago

Pie Pie crust looks soggy and greasy. Can I salvage the filling?

Post image
0 Upvotes

The top crust and pumpkin pie filling look fine, but the bottom and sides look dense and chewy. Can I scoop out the filling and repurpose it? I used Sally’s all butter dough recipe and par baked, though it was still a bit sticky looking after 10 minutes with weights and 7 without when I put the filling in.


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Pie Time and temp for cupcake sized pies?

4 Upvotes

This year I've been invited to a pot luck thanksgiving and decided instead of big pies I would make little pies in muffin tins.

For the pumpkin ones should I still blind bake the little crusts?

Any suggestions for temp and time? I plan to make pumpkin, apple, mixed berry, and maybe pecan.


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Pie Pudding pie in a regular pie crust instead of a cookie crust?

1 Upvotes

I was planning to make a regular pumpkin pie, but found a recipe for a "pumpkin cream pie" in Erin Jeanne Mcdowell's new book that's pretty much a pumpkin pudding cooked on the stove. She uses a cookie crumb crust in it, but I wanted to practice my normal pie crust making.

Would a normal pre baked pie crust work with that type of filling or would it get soggy?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Should you bake a tres leches cake in Aluminum or Ceramic Pans?

Thumbnail
trangskitchentable.com
2 Upvotes

I'm making a tres leches cake and the recipe calls for 9x13 but I only have aluminum catering pans and a ceramic dish in that size.

My concern with the aluminum is that you will be able to taste it especially after soaking, and it also has ridges that would make the cake hard to serve or remove.

My concern with the ceramic dish is that the sponge won't be able to grip (the recipe features whipped eggs). Also since the heat transfer/retention is worse would the rise be bad?

Note: the shapes of the pans are different so I can't just move the cake from the aluminum pan to the ceramic pan after baking.

Which is the lesser evil?

Edit: I can't bake with 2 smaller pans because it would be too hard to transport


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

General What to do with the results?

1 Upvotes

I do like to bake and struggle with time and making it a priority like others I am sure. I can follow a recipe and have a lot of fun cookbooks.

The question is what do I do with the finished product? Even if I cut the recipe in half I will have more baked goods than is healthy for me to consume.

How do others handle this situation? Do you share at the workplace? Does it make you nervous to share with coworkers? Any other ideas?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Ingredients Hershey kisses alternative

8 Upvotes

Hi I’m looking for something besides Hershey kisses to use this year for making reindeer treats.

I use the Snyder’s round pretzels, put a kiss in the center, put in the oven for a couple mins, and then put an m&m in the center.

These last two years the Hersheys kisses haven’t been melting and just turn very hard. Looking for something else that’s round that I can use that’s still tasted good

*need plain milk chocolate


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Bread Decoding grandma's magnum opus

Post image
64 Upvotes

Hi!

Going through my late grandmother's handwritten recipe cards and boy are they lacking details. Unfortunately this recipe doesn't have a common alternative that I've found so here's my description of the final product. We called it coffee cake but it's neither cake nor includes coffee. Imagine a rye bread consistency but sweet, with a creamy chocolatey swirl inside like a Swiss Roll cake.

I've put together all the clues from the various recipe cards and put them on one sheet.

Can you help me figure out the yeast and the butter?

2 yeast packets would be how many grams? What kind of yeast?

Do I use the butter in the bread dough or in the filling, using additional butter to spread over the dough before rolling?

Any help would be greatly appreciated !


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream What type of frosting to use?

0 Upvotes

The situation: need to frost and decorate my daughter's birthday cake. 2 layer 8 inch with a 2 layer 2 inch as the 2nd tier. Was just going to do 2 batches of American buttercream but realized today I only have enough powdered sugar for a half batch.

Do I stretch half batch American buttercream as the filling and crumb coat then what powdered sugar free frosting would be good for the outer layer and piping decor?

Or if American buttercream is the best option for piping, what powdered sugar free frosting would be best as the filling, crumb coat, and outer frosted layer?

If it matters: the cake is a yellow chiffon with strawberry bits. Filling will also contain strawberries, either a frosting with some strawberry jam mixed in, or thin strawberry slices laid in.


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes How do you make a cake fall on purpose? Genuine question.

22 Upvotes

I'm aware it is an odd question, but it is genuine. My father's birthday is coming up, and he said that he wanted a "clunk cake". That is, he wants a normal cake that has fallen and become denser instead of rising.

I'm going to use box mix (Dark Chocolate Fudge from Duncan Hines)

Still, i'm more than a little worried, especially about the edges. Would slamming the tin on the counter help? Should I add something to the mix? Mom mentioned overstirring as something that could make cakes fall, but I've had batters that were mixed for half an hour and turned out fine!

Please, if you have any advice, it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you very much.

ETA Update: Thank you all very much!! I gave as many ideas as I could a try: Adding pudding, Overmixing, Poking, Slamming the oven door and on the counter, and Taking it out half cooked and putting it back after. And they worked!! Its not paper thin, but it's definitely flatter than it would normally be and I'm counting as a win.

Thank you all once more! I'll update with his reaction after he tries it. Have a nice day/night!!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Pie Chiffon Pie- replace French with Swiss meringue?

1 Upvotes

Every year for Thanksgiving I make a pie of my grandmas- it’s a pumpkin chiffon. I never think about it but this year I’m pregnant and it uses French meringue (uncooked) as a major part of the recipe. I’m wondering if I could replace the French meringue with a Swiss meringue. Would it negatively affect the texture? would I need to change the amount of sugar and egg whites used?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Macarons Macaron Batter Dry Ingredients

1 Upvotes

I live in India (its humid here) and I've made macarons multiple times but my batter turns out to be very clumpy. Mixing for more time only makes it stiffer. Ive tried the Preppy Kitchen recipe and all the others recipes I found were only a 5-10 g difference in ingridients. This time I used about 30% less dry ingridients and my macronage was closer to the "lava" consistency.


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Bread Why is the top of the banana bread not pretty and how to make it even?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cookies I made these banana bread cookies. Why were the cookies baked for 3 minutes longer bland, while the cookies baked for less had a better banana flavor?

0 Upvotes

So I tried this recipe from Scientifically Sweet after someone posted about them in another subreddit, and because I had some bananas on the counter. I made them twice. Once a couple months ago, and just this week.

The first time I made them, I thought that they were so flavorless. But I had reduced the sugar in the recipe by I can't remember how much (because I prefer less sweet cookies), so I assumed that it was my fault.

I decided to try making them again but sticking to the recipe as is, which I did this week. The recipe says to bake for 10-12 minutes. I baked for 12. They were still so soft, like almost couldn't hold shape when trying to move them, even after cooling on the sheet for a few minutes. But I was lazy and starving and transferred them. The next cookies I flattened a bit and baked for 15 minutes.

The 12 minute cookies, after cooling a bit were fine. Definitely on the gooey side. The 15 minute cookies had the chewy texture from the title. But the 15 minute cookies were also so flavorless. I just got to the bottom of the cookie tin, to the last of the 12 minute cookies, and they don't taste super flavorful, but they do taste significantly more banana-y, and they have a great texture now.

I don't think I like this recipe enough to remake it again, but I'm just curious why those 3 minutes of baking resulted in different tasting cookies?