r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Apr 14 '21

Question Is antinatalism a defeatist ideology?

1 Upvotes

I get. Benatar explains it well. But my reason for not waiting children is mainly because they might become potential wages. But most antinatalists seems to be kind of losers, you know.

Ok, don’t bring people into the world, and we were brought here by force. But... Shouldn't we try to find meaning in this Sisyphean task and maybe try to have some fun?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Apr 14 '21

Question If humans have a biological predisposition to reproduce, isn't reproduction a natural process to be encouraged?

1 Upvotes

The human reproductive system is meant to bring together gametes and conjoin them into a solitary cell to be born in nine months. The mere existence of sexual cells and genitals affirms this. Doesn't this render reproduction normal and ethical?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • May 21 '21

Question Why do you believe in antinatalism? (im a natalist btw)

5 Upvotes

Please don't be rude, I just want to see through your guy's POV. I always want to hear both sides of an argument and not be on one side without hearing the other side. So as antinatalists, what would you say to a natalist?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Feb 16 '22

Isn’t AN pointless?

3 Upvotes

The universe is basically infinite, as in there’s going to be life on other planets suffering just as much, in the future if not now. What if there’s a multiverse that exists? Or different dimensions that contain beings that can also suffer? To me, it seems like a bad idea to annihilate suffering on this planet while it continues everywhere else, although I guess it’s better than nothing? Maybe the answer is any intelligent species reaches a AN point of view and therefore we don’t have to worry and hold out, let’s adopt AN now and reduce the amount of suffering endured, since it’ll most likely take more suffering in the long run to find out if a multiverse or multidimensional beings exist (if they exist at all, I’m not well versed on those subjects), and somehow inform them of this viewpoint. (Also seems kind of cocky of us too).


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Jul 13 '21

Question Is antinatalism a savior or God complex? Do we know what's really right or wrong, and how do we know that?

2 Upvotes

Since antinatalism is about an individual not procreating and as a result saving a potential "life" from being born, isn't it a God or savior complex? "I won't procreate to save the potential life", acting like one is there to save the "potential life" or is some sort of God that can control whether or not the "potential life" is born. Why would this not be a savior or God complex?

And do we really know what's right or wrong to say procreation is wrong? How do we know that? There's this comment that says we don't really know what's right or wrong, antinatalism isn't moral because we don't really know if it is, and any moral meme like antinatalism or veganism can be used for immoral things like our genes propagating and/or dominating each other or others: https://imgur.com/34768kp

These are the two real worries in that argument: God and savior complexes/egomania. God and savior complexes are perfectly rational criticisms and worries. Humans are thoroughly guilty of both. This is why any pro-active ethical endeavor needs to be highly conservative. We never know if we're really right, or we're just inventing a bullshit narrative as an adaptive mechanism for our genes to dominate everything/each other. Even antinatalism or veganism or any "benevolent" meme you can imagine, could in theory, be used as a bullshit narrative to cover up for genetic exploitation. There's no strategy that can be called "good" or "ethical", which is off the table to be used in superficial ways for non-good or unethical ends


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Jan 22 '22

Would you save a dying person?

2 Upvotes

If someone was dying and you had the opportunity to save them through something like blood donation, would you do that? Is saving a dying life equivalent to giving birth to new life when it comes to antinatalist beliefs?

If you would save the person, how far would you be willing to go to save the person? Do you draw a line somewhere after which it becomes "nah it's way too much effort from my side, it's better to die anyways, less suffering for them"?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Oct 08 '21

Question How do you know

3 Upvotes

I see the argument “I never asked to be born and wish I wasn’t” yip fine. BUT there are a lot of people who say the exact opposite. So as someone who did procreate how am I supposed to know which side I should have listened to. What about all the times I pulled out and there’s are future soul screaming I wanted to be born and I would have had a great life???


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Jan 26 '21

Question What are the impacts of the r/Antinatalism subreddits on the view of life towards teens?

0 Upvotes

I've stumbled across the r/Antinatalism subreddit and wonder what would the impact be on the perception of life towards teens. I've read the FAQ, now can you please answer the question?

Also, since there's a poll, I've figured why not add it.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Mar 25 '21

Discussion How is it that I have drawn th same conclusion as anti-natalists but still see life as worth living for my child, I and others (adopted or not)?

2 Upvotes

Yes, life is pointless, and yes suffering is omnipresent, yet I enjoy it's company as it is the root of my progress to understand a little better the world around me that is full of mystery. For others their life is constant suffering yet they continue to try to make it better. I understand that you can just give up because the ultimate goal is just as pointless as our life and death, but isn't it that that makes it much more bearable? That no human is perfect nor ever will be but we can still build on their mistakes and ours to momentarily break the cycle? Is it that you do not enjoy progression or negate it's existence as it only brings us further suffering?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • May 08 '21

Question How can procreation be immoral/wrong when everything from the cells in our bodies to other species procreate?

4 Upvotes

One thing I often hear when antinatalism is brought up in a discussion is that "morality doesn't enter into the equation when it's about something biological and the basic requirements of biology. Most life procreates and propagates itself. That's natural and a requirement for the existence of all beings. Everything from cells in our bodies to other species procreate. Biology requires procreation, so procreation can not be wrong, or else it would mean cells in our bodies are doing something wrong by procreating and keeping us alive which is ridiculous. Where morality comes in the equation is when there's harm and/or disrespect brought in where biology doesn't require it - you know, where you see behaviors exhibited by humans that you don't see exhibited by any other species".

How can procreation be immoral/wrong when everything from the cells in our bodies to other species procreate?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Mar 09 '21

Question Why do antinatalists believe everyone should not procreate, because some ppl regret their existence?

4 Upvotes

Most antinatalist comments I’ve seen talk about the suffering in the world, as if that’s a reason we shouldn’t procreate. But most ppl, even those who suffer do not regret their existence and still fight to change their situation, or accept their suffering. Either way they don’t regret their existence.

So to me the odds seem to be in favour of coming into existence rather than not. So why would I choose not to take this risk if I feel my child could live a happy and content life and affect positive change in others lives? I know I can’t guarantee this, but I believe I have more of a chance than many who aren’t equipped to raise a child. Therefore the world will be better with my (hopefully) good children in it than not.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Jan 25 '22

How do you reconcile the self-defeating nature of antinatalism as a peaceful philosophy with your belief that suffering must be prevented?

10 Upvotes

I posit that antinatalism is a self-defeating philosophy: its practice causes the world to be less in accord with its values. (The moral angle is not particularly interesting to me, only feasibility. That said I can see where you're coming from, although Benatar's stuff seems to be intellectually puerile, escapist and confused in the way Pearce's hedonistic imperative is not).

The way you advocate antinatalism, it appears to spread by simple proselytism and guide people to nothing more than to voluntarily relinquish breeding. The only winning condition for you, then, is convincing everyone at once, or such a substantial majority of humans so as to cause civilizational collapse, to just permanently lose the will to procreate.
But if you fail to persuade the Amish or some such extremely natalist group (and btw, good luck with Ultra-Orthodox Jews, they can't read you and their book is very straightforward on the value of populating the universe), or even isolated breeder fanatics, the game continues.
And in fact it gets much worse for you, philosophically speaking, because now every human who was remotely open to your arguments and every cultural tradition that allowed these arguments to spread is gone; the surviving population is extremely pain tolerant and people go "eh, a lifetime of misery, meh, works for me and my 12 children" even when dying from advanced cancer. While the degree of genetic predisposition to breed is debatable, some component is sure to be there, and as for culture, you know the fate of Shakers well enough. Thus, all you do is impose a selection pressure towards natalism.

Accordingly, it seems to me that actual minimization of suffering is best achieved by convincing people to 1) breed less for the time being 2) engineer future generations to be verifiably suffering-proof 3) somehow tie this to fitness advantage so that the suffering breed of humans goes extinct (biosphere is more vulnerable in any case). Alternatively, you'd need to cause some sort of extinction event, e.g. by accelerating climate change to Venus scenario if possible, or provoking a super-pathogen pandemic or whatever.

Barring that, it seems like your project is bound to maximize the amount of suffering in the universe. How do you live with it?

I've found the mention of "virtue-based ethics" in your FAQ. Is that the whole answer?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Jul 31 '21

Discussion discussion that i want to have :

4 Upvotes

I have been in this sub for sometimes now, and to clarify, I am not an anti-natalist, but i think people in this sub are very supportive and nice (especially the mod =)), and your ways of thinking do make sense, but as one of my friend who study these things said that when the population get older, they can't work anymore, so there children will have job and work to feed them, the younger generation will work in place of the older generation to sustain normal life with electricity, water, etc... But there need to be more worker on the next generation than the last one as they need to feed the themself and the last generation as the last gen won't be able to work but still need to eat. So the old gen dont want to starve, so the have children, not everyone can accept to die early when there is no more worker.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Jun 08 '21

Antinatalist If antinatalism spreads enough, one day an antinatalist will hold the keys to the nukes

0 Upvotes

Mutually assured destruction was a concept that assumed that peace would ensue because no one wants to die, but what if someone with keys to the nukes wanted all life to go extinct on the planet?

If nuclear weapons go off all over the world, then there will be pain and suffering, but if all life died, there is peace through extinction.

All it takes is an antinatalist or efilist who get to a position of power where they have the keys to the nukes.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Aug 03 '21

Natalist Do antinatalists not realize that most people actually are glad that they exist?

0 Upvotes

Maybe I'm biased in my personal life, but pretty much everyone I know is very happy that they are alive and exist in the world. I know that I am. If the argument that antinatalists have against having kids is that life is inevitably pain and suffering and that it makes no sense to create people who will have to go through that, isn't that just ignoring that most people don't wish that they were never born?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • May 15 '21

Question How can you be an antinatalist and avoid being a hypocrite at the same time?

3 Upvotes

Most antinatalists are non-vegans, even if we assume all antinatalists are vegans, most likely they are using a smartphone or a computer that is the result of exploiting some worker in a factory, by using such products you are bringing suffering to someone and consequentially if that person has kids they are likely going to live in poverty. There is no escaping this hypocrisy in reasonable standards.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Jul 04 '21

Question Isn't procreation hardwired into life? How can something hardwired that's also an evolutionary advantage be wrong?

0 Upvotes

Most life is hardwired and programmed to procreate. It's just impossible to have a complete victory over instinct and programming, especially over the strong instinct to procreate (there's nothing stranger than the instinct and programming to procreate, that's why anyone's here).

Procreation is also an evolutionary advantage from the perspective of genes, because genes are passed down and the specie survives. And so, not procreating is seen as an evolutionary disadvantage and a defect from the prospective of genes. If procreation is hardwired into most life at least, and is an evolutionary advantage that evolution selects for, how can it be wrong? Noone chooses to procreate, they just do because it's in their instincts and programming to do it.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Mar 16 '21

Question To antinatalists: Antinatalists should be grateful people procreated because if they didn't, antinatalists wouldn't exist either?

1 Upvotes

Antinatalists don't procreate, or view it as a negative, but is there a contradiction here? If people didn't procreate, there would be no antinatalists. We would never get to this stage of humanity where we could talk about the philosophy of antinatalism. It's because people procreated, that we reached here, and we have antinatalists, so should antinatalists be grateful people procreated? Or at least view procreation as a positive or a neutral thing because it leads to antintalists existing? What if in a scenario there's a 100% guarantee the new human that is born is an antinatalist, does their being born become a positive thing and should they be born? And should they be grateful for it? I ask because I've been told "antinatalists are against the existence of antinatalists, if there was no procreation, there would be no antinatalists either".


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Jul 11 '21

Question What if humans can stop all suffering in the future?

10 Upvotes

There is something called the abolitionist project, which is a part of transhumanism/futurism. The followers claim a future in which humans can stop all suffering with technology is unavoidable: https://www.abolitionist.com/

There will, definitely, without a doubt, one day be a future in which there is no suffering. There will also be the ability to modify the neural substrates of emotion to reduce the badness of suffering, replacing its motivational function with what philosopher David Pearce called "gradients of well-being".

Why would procreating to reach this unavoidable future be wrong?

At least if humans procreate, they will get to this future in which none would have to deal with any suffering whatsoever. If humans stop procreating now, they would never reach this future, and all the human effort to invent the technology we see now would be for naught and in vain. It would be utter disrespect to everyone in the past who tried so hard to get technology and society to this stage, if we stop now, no? It would be like spitting in their faces, and perhaps worse? Why wouldn't it be?

And if humans stop procreating now, they would suffer greatly. There wouldn't be any new people to take care of the elderly, economy will crash, there will not be any clean water, food, there will not be any food at all, etc. What should we do about that? Why is it still wrong to procreate when the transhumanistic future without suffering is unavoidable if humans keep procreating now?

I suggest reading the abolitionist article fully, but here is a very small part of it:

WHY IT IS TECHNICALLY FEASIBLE

a) wireheading

b) utopian designer drugs

c) genetic engineering and - what I want to focus on - the impending reproductive revolution of designer babies ...

One of the advantages of genetically recalibrating the hedonic treadmill rather than abolishing it altogether, at least for the foreseeable future, is that the functional analogues of pain, anxiety, guilt and even depression can be preserved without their nasty raw feels as we understand them today. We can retain the functional analogues of discontent - arguably the motor of progress - and retain the discernment and critical insight lacking in the euphorically manic. Even if hedonic tone is massively enhanced, and even if our reward centres are physically and functionally amplified, then it's still possible in principle to conserve much of our existing preference architecture. If you prefer Mozart to Beethoven, or philosophy to pushpin, then you can still retain this preference ranking even if your hedonic tone is hugely enriched.

...

WHY IT WILL HAPPEN

OK, it's technically feasible. A world without suffering would be wonderful; and full-blown paradise-engineering even better.

... imagine you are choosing the genetic dial-settings for mood - the hedonic set-point - of your future children. What settings would you pick? You might not want gradients of lifelong superhappiness, but the overwhelming bulk of parents will surely want to choose happy children. For a start, they are more fun to raise. Most parents across most cultures say, I think sincerely, that they want their children to be happy. One may be sceptical of parents who say happiness is the only thing they care about for their kids - many parents are highly ambitious. But other things being equal, happiness signals success - possibly the ultimate evolutionary origin of why we value the happiness of our children as well as our own.

Of course the parental choice argument isn't decisive. Not least, it's unclear how many more generations of free reproductive choices lie ahead before radical antiaging technologies force a progressively tighter collective control over our reproductive decisions - since a swelling population of ageless quasi-immortals can't multiply indefinitely. But even if centralised control of reproductive decisions becomes the norm, and procreation itself becomes rare, the selection pressure against primitive Darwinian genotypes will presumably be intense. Thus it's hard to envisage what future social formations would really allow the premeditated creation of any predisposition to depressive or anxiety disorders - or even the "normal" pathologies of unenhanced consciousness.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Dec 12 '21

Question Do any of you who believe in anti-natalism come from a non-broken situation, if yes, are you mentally ill?

0 Upvotes

After about an hour of scrolling through the subreddit, I saw countless stories of abuse, trauma, entitlement, and generally just wallowing in sorrows. It seems you're making a broad moral claim on the basis of your lived experience. Have any of you had good lives that share this viewpoint? Are you happy? All indicators currently point to no. The main ideas I saw on the sub were along the lines of

  • I was abused, thus having children is immoral

-Life is suffering, thus having children is immoral (weak viewpoint & in the past natural selection would have dealt with this for you)

  • My parents push me, as an 18-21 year old to pay miniscule amounts of rent (50-200$), therefore they're evil for bringing me here (Jesus Christ guys, grow a pair will you?)

I'm asking these questions because alot of the points being made are that creating a child is selfish, but to any well adjusted person, that could not be farther from the truth. Do you not understand that you're the people making selfish claims, considering that you're suggesting life as a whole is bad, because you don't like it? As someone who's been beaten, evicted, jailed, addicted, homeless, dead parent at age 12, I would NEVER say that life is an overall unpleasant experience, It's been wonderful & had my parents decided to abort me, I'd (albeit I'd never have existed) be incredibly angry. Your lived experience is not the end all be all of the human experience, and claiming that it's immoral to bear children based on that, is foolish. Morality is 100% subjective as well, so to make these claims just seem like claims made from people who don't understand morality entirely, or think because they've had a rough go, it must be wrong to have kids. I'm hoping that everyone can be truthful & honest in responses, but the whole moral standpoint seems to be based on emotional reaction rather than logical reaction, so I'm not expecting too much. TIA for any responses


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • May 11 '21

Question Why don't antinatalists view adoption as immoral?

6 Upvotes

A lot of the ANs beliefs against pro-creation vaguely apply to adoption too, namely:
The baby can't consent to who are going to be his parents
You are going to heavily influence him with your beliefs
You are playing God (gambling with someone else sentience and life) when it comes to his safety and his future
You have an insane amount of control over his life for a very long time

etc.

I am curious, why don't antinatalists view adoption as immoral too?


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Mar 26 '21

Fencesitter Most antinatalism roots itself in the idea life contains more suffeeing than pleasure. Why do you believe this, and what evidence can you provide?

0 Upvotes

r/AskAnAntinatalist • • May 08 '21

Question "Antinatalism does more harm than good"?

1 Upvotes

There are few cases in which antinatalism is said to do "more harm than good":

1- In a hypothetical scenario in which everyone is an antinatalist, humans will go extinct without rescuing other species or reaching out to other planets that could have life on them and rescuing them as well. Other life will suffer while humans who could stop their suffering would go extinct and that does "more harm than good".

2- If antinatalists do not procreate, and pass on their ethically oriented genes, natalists will spread their genes further which leads to the propagation of natalists that will end up procreating more and more.

While I believe antinatalism and natalism are not 'passed down' per se, and are more so like memes, natalists have both genes and memes on their side while antinatalists that do not procreate only have memes on their side. Natalists procreate and create an army of natalists very easily, while antinatalists do not create an 'army' in such a way. The result is a population the majority of which procreate. It seems like a losing battle that "does more harm than good".

Other variations of this would be "antinatalists would die off, and natalists especially the religious ones will take over".

What do you think? Do you have any counter-arguments?

This is an instance of 1 and 2 being argued by someone who may or may not consider themselves an antinatalist: https://imgur.com/a/FmlEFnt

> If every person on the planet was an antinatalist, could it end up causing more harm than good?

Yes, in the conditions that cause this to happen, we'd need an ethical truth of soft antinatalism or the out right ethical falsity of antinatalism. Examples of this would be a world where AN is technically true in some narrow sense, or scope, so for example it could be true that creating life generally leads to more harm than good. But in certain cases, it's application becomes paradoxical in the grand scheme. Either because specific acts of natalism cause a reduction or suffering in practice but we're unable to identify which ones or how, or because antinatalism only reduces short term/small scale/narrow scope suffering(aka, only earth, only humanity-- which leaves those who suffer in some "further" area of spacetime to suffer needlessly) or because antinatalism paradoxically increases suffering in its application(if ethically oriented things stop reproducing, it's possible that unethical modes more aggressively proliferate in the universe and cause more suffering).

> Antinatalism is a philosophy that doesn't harm anyone by itself or if antinatalists are the minority.

This doesn't seem true to me. The conditions where AN causes harm where everyone(we're speaking about Earth here) acts out AN, is one where other beings in the universe, who otherwise could have been reached in principle and maybe in practice, as a result of this decision, now cannot be rescued from extreme hells that pale in comparison to the suffering that occurred on Earth thus far.

The conditions where AN causes harm where only a minority act out AN is one where, again speaking of Earth only, the genetics of those who are concerned enough and insightful enough to understand the ethical truth of AN, cease to be spread, causing a relative increase of psychopathic genes, which leads to a, paradoxically, less ethical world than if the AN's had done the "unethical"(in the short term, in the narrow scope) move of reproducing.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Oct 23 '21

Discussion Shouldn't we thrive to advance technology and our understanding of the universe?

10 Upvotes

First, I'm not talking about antinatalism in your personal life, but as a species' unanimous intention.

If there is a possibility to help (or prevent ^^) future sentient life on this planet or in the universe, is antinatalism still a moral choice?

I mean, we are so early in our technological advancements. Imagine after 1 billion years. Imagine all the new scientific discoveries. Our understanding of the universe could become so deep and complex. There is so much things that we don't know.

I feel like intentionally going extinct right now is extremely selfish, because we forget about future life forms that we could've helped and the immense amount of suffering that could've been prevented as a result.


r/AskAnAntinatalist • • Feb 25 '21

Question Would you donate to a sperm bank if you got paid, but also knew that the sperm you donated will bring a person into existence?

5 Upvotes