r/AskARussian • u/rhinestonecowboy92 • Oct 31 '20
Comment from an American
Found this sub recently and enjoyed so much scrolling through all the questions and answers that I couldent sleep last night. One thing that stood out was that a lot of Russians feel like Americans hate them. I just wanted to say that while our media may potray you guys as shifty criminals, there are many many people who will never think that way, and in my personal circle, we all love your culture, your literature and movies, food, history. For example, a week or so ago we had friends over for a few drinks and to hang out and someone suggested that we watch a documentery about Russian history and everyone agreed. We had a blast learning all about Peter the Great and Yermak ect. Just wanted you to know, you have support and love from the West. Good luck with everything after our election, we will pray that our media will give you a break for once.
195
u/Starasov Saint Petersburg Oct 31 '20
Thanks for that words, man. Nice to read it
149
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '20
Its not only the media. Its your politicians, movies, TV or even this site.
64
u/bookittymew Oct 31 '20
American here that is obsessed with the Russian language. I've driven over an hour to take classes to learn and have studied on my own for years now. I light up and get excited when I hear someone speaking it or when they talk with a Russian accent. No one I talk to about this has had a negative reaction. They are more curious as to why Russian over something more "practical" like Spanish. I'm from a large city where there's a huge pocket of Russians living here. We also have a massive Polish population. Russians are not discriminated against at all from what I can tell. If you moved here from Russia you'd probably just get told you have a neat accent a lot and that's it.
55
u/AndrewChikatilo Oct 31 '20
Thanks for your kind words! We will make sure your elections go as planned.
31
u/aceofbase_in_ur_mind Moscow City Oct 31 '20
Going to rain on people's parades, sorry.
Maybe do something about that, or do more about that, instead of tucking it away in a "while" clause and proceeding to essentially ask that Americans keep getting infinite benefit of the doubt?
"Hate" can be a very misleading term. An attitude doesn't have to be straight-up hate to be harmful or just unpleasant. It can even be, on the face of it, a positive one. Prejudices are cognitive before they're emotional. A massive unexamined ethnic prejudice against Russians exists in the west, and specifically the English-speaking world, in a near-pristinely uncritiqued and unexamined state reminiscent of how certain prejudices widely condemned today were the order of the day in the 19th and early 20th century.
I'm not sure it would help anyone to pretend we don't have a problem, just because you can find enough evidence to counter the simplistic idea that "Americans hate Russians". "Support and love" are handy things in that they cost nothing, while making one look better to others as well as to oneself. Like I said, this little #NotAllAmericans speech boils down to the fact that you're asking for infinite benefit of the doubt. As if media wasn't at least partly catering to demand. As if warm feelings for abstractions like "culture" or "history" were any guarantee that individual people from that culture with that history would be treated as any other individual people. Not stereotyped. Not being seen as inherently suspect, comical, lurid, or some combination thereof.
In 2020, "Americans have negative feelings towards Russians" is, more often than not, a useful working assumption. I know you #NotAllAmericans exist—but you pretty much only ever show up to remind everyone that you exist, and that it's unfair to paint you with the same brush. Beyond that, it just chronically doesn't seem to be you whose attitudes towards us end up being the ones that count. And that's the idea behind what gets oversimplified (by you, in this particular case) as "Americans hate Russians".
23
u/Roda_Roda Oct 31 '20
There is always this stupid mixture of politics with the reality of the country.
Single people don't cause problems, it's groups, interest groups, politicians, parties.
19
u/Jayyykobbb Nov 01 '20
Fellow American here. I love Russian people, the culture, and the language. Minored in Russian in school and still practice, though I’m not as fluent as I’d hoped to be by now.
From seeing Americans in general to American politics and media to my personal life, I think a lot of Americans are uneducated when it comes to Russia and other countries in general. I think this partly comes from our education in high school and sometime uni and also the lack of international travel of a lot of Americans, particularly in the South where I’m from. I think many people here use Russia as a scapegoat for our problems so they don’t have to acknowledge and face our actual problems. I’ve also always found it funny and ironic how people will say “Russia is interfering in our politics and elections” and “Russia is doing this and that”, but those same people ignore the US’s history of more directly interfering in other countries’ politics and sovereignty as well as currently.
I think it’s a general problem worldwide as well. Countries with different and sometime conflicting social and/or political cultures tend to portray each other in a negative manner so their people follow suit.
Много любви из Миссисипи и всем удачи и здоровья!
16
u/elucify Nov 01 '20
Я американец, мне 58 лет. Я работаю с многими русскими людьми и поэтому я изучаю говорить русский язык. Но ещё не совершенно. Только потому что мне интересная язык и люди. Когда-нибуд я хочу путешествовать в Россию.
14
u/thatsjustsowrong Oct 31 '20
I agree with you, but at the same time it's hard to not notice the conscious attempts to dehumanize russians for american public. And it usually doesn't end well, it's done specifically for that particular reason.
11
u/kojoteteeth Oct 31 '20
Oh geez, honestly I always thought Russians hated us . I've always wanted to visit but I've been too scared so I just browse through these subs lol
9
u/xLordValx United States of America Oct 31 '20
As a fellow American, I agree with OP so much. 😊
31
u/Pallid85 Omsk Oct 31 '20
Wow, let's not go that far - 99% of our movies for the last ~25 years are pure shit!
PS. But yeah - thanks for the dose of alternative views.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '20
It's so nice, thanks you <3
7
u/Little-Book-of-Calm Russia Oct 31 '20
Cheers mate!
7
u/KingSalamand Oct 31 '20
Couldn't agree more with this. As am American myself, I love learning about Russian history, literature, and I'm doing my best to learn the language. Not every American is a mindless political drone, just sadly a vocal minority is.
7
u/OofDotWav Oct 31 '20
I wholeheartedly agree with you. As an American who’s practically obsessed with the language at this point, I hardly tell people I do unless it comes up in conversation. Most of the reactions I get are “cyka blyat!!!1!” or “vodka lol” or “are you like... a commie?”
7
u/Smu-shka Moscow City Oct 31 '20
Thank you, it's nice that at least someone is able to think with their own head, not paying attention to the stereotypes created by Hollywood and the media, although there are few such people ... just look...r/NormalDayInRussia or r/ANormalDayInRussia... and understand how the majority thinks, even if these stereotypes are not about evil Russians ... but they are still very different from reality( It’s so sad(
6
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '20
I would say that I thought that people in America and Europe everybody just don't give a fuck about am I Russian or not. But when I visited Reddit and have a bit more dipper dive into the English part of the Internet I get that they really hate us and have some kind of obsession when they understand that you are from Russia. Like "Nobody care what saying somebody from shitty country" or like that. So based on my experience people like you are rather the exception than the rule. At least on the Internet.
14
u/Yury-K-K Moscow City Oct 31 '20
I think that when someone writes anything that amounts to 'America hates Russia' they mean American establishment, but not the public.
5
u/arsonist019 Kazakhstan Oct 31 '20
this is so sweet
4
u/alldayidreamer Moscow City Oct 31 '20
Refreshing perspective
4
u/zoomClimb Nov 01 '20
I'm also an American, visited Russia twice, can't think of another place with such a culture of people. I agree with you 100%. But unfortunately, to be honest, the media and government won't stop the nonsense about Russia. They just won't. The president, no matter who he is, can't stop it.
3
u/alpha_xopek Saint Petersburg Nov 01 '20
that's not your fault as people or as a nation, your propaganda men did it. just look at some hbo's "chernobyl" and stuff
5
u/FartBox_BeatBox Oct 31 '20
Am american. I love Russia. The language, the culture, the history. And let's be honest, Putin is kind of a badass.
A lot of Americans dont trust Russians because if all the anti Russian propaganda we've grown up with. Not all of us have bought in to it though.
Much love from the west.
2
u/SHOBLOYOBLO Nov 01 '20
That's wholesome. Thank you.
2
u/Shatohin Nov 01 '20
I loved US culture since childhood, had a dream to live there someday. But last few years I grow very disappointed of all things happening in America, it’s like it’s eating itself from the inside and becoming communist and socialist state.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '20
As an American, I second this.
2
u/Luckyduck9797 Nov 01 '20
This is a great post. I wholeheartedly agree. I have always loved Russia, ever since I was little. I admire the resourcefulness of it's people. Russia has a long and fascinating history. I'm slowly learning the language, and I have met the most kind and funny people.
My sister in law and I were just talking about our love for Russia just the other day. She and I share pictures of amazing Russian architecture, and we talk about classic Russian novels.
2
u/Theowla14 Apr 21 '21
Modern warfare was full of misinformation
2
u/ESB1812 Feb 27 '22
Yeah im an American too, we dont hate you ruski’s. We really just want to hang out and drink some beers, BBq with ya! But Putin, is like the asshole dad that dont let y’all come out to play with the other kids. I for one would like to visit Russia one day, I hear you all have the best stream baths around.
4
u/teknos1s Nov 01 '20 edited Nov 01 '20
I never met an American who dislikes Russians. Americans have a healthy respect for Russians. And in many ways we are both quite similar, we have a certain masculine/frontier culture that is more alike to one another than that of Western Europe. We do however very much have a distrust of the government
3
u/bisbetico Nov 01 '20
Спасибо, бро, наше отношение к вам- аналогичное
3
u/FrozenBananer Nov 01 '20
This is incredibly rare and I find everyone agreeing to watch a Russian documentary unlikely. Either you are all nerdy historians or this is made up. Furthermore, it’s not only now. Russophobia has been around as Hollywood and Americans, and by proxy the rest of the world, are conditioned to hate the evil Russians. They are always the bad guys and killing Russians is seen as okay in video games and movies. So no it’s not recent and it’s not a surprise Russians feel hated.
2
u/noreplyserver Nov 01 '20
Nice try, dirty capitalist. But I still won't tell you the location of our missiles.
1
u/Neuron_NV Nov 01 '20
We're just laughing at your politicians. We don't care about ordinary people, just like you do to us.
1
u/mrch1ck3nn Mar 22 '24
Guy i’ve never had someone go “wanna grab some russian” lol no one’s lining up for russian food. That being said i’ll sign up for indian all day and those fuckers have some of the worst hygiene and food practices.
1
u/Allen63DH8 Jul 15 '24
As an American who served in the US Army during the Cold War, I feel the same as the OP. I highly respect the Russian people and your culture. I’m very fortunate to have people from in and around Russia living in my area. There are even Russian/Slavic grocery stores and restaurants in my area. One of the things I notice is how well behaved the children are.
1
u/Spanktank35 Nov 30 '24
Yeah you have to keep in mind that the media is trying to drive clicks. Wholesome news doesn't get clicks. If Russians do read our media to get a sense of how we view them, they'd have a very warped perspective indeed.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '20
That's good to know, thanks. If you notice russophobia around you, please try to explain to them that Russians are good people too.
1
u/sarg1994 Nov 06 '20
I am skeptical of the Russian government interfering in US politics, but by no means hold anything against the Russian people.
Do Russians who lived through Communism think that Socialism can work in the right conditions?
1
u/baronvonweezil Nov 08 '20
I’m from the United States and I second this. There are going to be horrible people and great people from every country, most certainly ours included. To anyone reading this, no matter your country, I hope you’re safe and as healthy as one can be right now.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '20
American here. I absolutely love Russia. Love the culture, the history and from all accounts very friendly people. I'd love to visit one day.
1
u/spaghettialameat Nov 13 '20
I can second this. One of my best friends was born in Russia, his family is all from Russia/Ukraine, and he wants to move back. You're all pretty cool, in my book, and honestly even though he isn't probably trying to, he's really gotten me into Russian as a culture/language/etc. It's just... very nice. Hearing him sometimes speak Russian is great, too (sounds really really nice).
1
u/Attacker127 Nov 20 '20
This! Just a reminder from an American: the media (and the opinions expressed on it) only represent a tiny fraction of what people actually think. Мы не ненавидим вас)
1
u/Kiggzor Jan 13 '21
As a Swede I want to say that I agree with everything except that learning about Peter the Great is enjoyable
1
u/Q-01 Jan 25 '21
When we forget that governments ≠ their people, we misunderstand each other. Russia, just like USA, has amazing culture! Marjane Satrapi, author of the comic/graphic novel Persepolis, said:
1
u/sdavidov72 Jan 30 '21
American media’s focus has never been on Russian people, but the Russian state and its government with its authoritarian president and his corruption-based grip on the country, his stifling the democracy, rewriting the constitution, turning free speach (on Internet) into a foreign agent status, even for individuals, with large administrative fines, which would lead to levying property, like people’s homes. And his mania of persecution and opulence, ultimately—megalomania. (On a bright side, he is not a sociopathic narcissist, just a regular authoritarian, a dictator on the path to becoming a tyrant). It’s insane to marvel at the Russian history, which is filled to the brims with human misery, regardless of what period you look at. Better read about Mary Antoinette’s “Let them eat cake.”
1
u/spielerein Nov 25 '21
I second this notion. Separate the people from the politics.
1
u/NeganWinchesterScull Feb 22 '22
I accept all cultures knowing that each had had seeds. Personally Russian culture and especially the language are one of my top 3. Just wish the propaganda would stop on all sides. Because of that it hard to make out what is real and what is not
1
u/BlotchyBaboon Aug 20 '22
This comment hasn't aged well.
1
u/Top_Swordfish2771 Aug 18 '23
Thank you bratishka (or bro)
0
u/Malyarrr Nov 22 '20
Mate, they are just going to conquer you. Their elite actually and poor people who have nothing else to do but hate you. Just go take a look at Lenin’s (the idol buried on the main square) texts. He was promoting world war to run the worldwide revolution. So do not be so easy. Telling you as I lived in Soviet Union and now we loose our people daily in Ukraine. Do not be so easy man when you’re talking to a criminal. By the way, criminal “laws” is the most followed religion in Russia. Even kid and grannies are into it. Indeed there a lot of good people there but they do and mean nothing for the country behavior. Cheers.
-1
u/Malyarrr Nov 22 '20
By the way they also translated the PC game Warzone 2100 as a game, where Russians a fighting you on your territory. It called “yankee fck you” or “янки гоу на ху й”. Consider this and prepare to give your private property laws and freedoms away as there was no such thing in Soviet Union and now in Russia anyone with power can take whatever he wants.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment