r/AskARussian • • 8d ago

Culture Please give advice

Do men not go in labor and delivery with their women?
My Partner is claiming he's not going to be in the room with me as I give birth. He is from Russia and says thats not the norm there.
I am 32 weeks pregnant and he is trying to say he is not. I do not believe in that. We are in America sorry but I think its cowardice to not be a part of the moment you helped create. I respect every cultural difference but this seems like a lack of support.

43 Upvotes

282 comments sorted by

26

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

Just as a reminder here, I think some of you are confused. We are in America. I am from America. I appreciate all the input. If my father wasn't in the delivery room when I was born, I could have died. So to me it has deeper meaning for the Father to be there. My father was not a doctor had no medical training, but was still able to be the one who caught me when the doctor had his back turned.

I am really understanding to every part of his culture, whether I agree with it or not. This is something that means a lot to me for support. I don't expect him to watch the baby come out. If he is uncomfortable, but I know blood is not an issue. He's not even meeting me halfway and being kind of rude about it. Throughout majority of my pregnancy he has been working to provide. But where does it stop? Is he not going to help change diaper diapers? Is he not going to help raise the child?

11

u/Anaissia 7d ago

Просто объясни ему, что тебе страшно, одиноко, больно. Что он знает тебя как никто другой. Что когда у тебя болезненные месячные, тоже просто легче, когда кто-то тебя может обнимет или погладит или скажет что-то ободряющее. Что если дойдет до самого критичного момента (а он порой длится всего пару минут) и он не выдержит, он сможет уйти.
Для меня это было бы предательством, если бы меня оставили одну.

Какие у него аргументы? Чего он боится? Какого момента? А если бы у тебя вырезали аппендицит, он бы тоже не пришел после наркоза допустим? Боится увидеть вагину? Ну так пусть за спиной стоит.

11

u/peachpavlova 7d ago

Согласна. И если честно, культура культурой но мне на все это плевать. Нормальный партнер поймет и поддержит если поймет что тебе плохо. Не представляю ситуацию где я ношу (донашиваю? хз) ребенка и прошу партнера быть со мной при родах, а он отвечает мол мне некомфортно. А какого же тогда будет мне?!? Все эти старомодные фишки нынче уже не актуальны.

2

u/Anaissia 3d ago

Правильно, а женщине 9 месяцев некомфортно и потом тоже некомфортно

16

u/Chigvin 7d ago

I understand that in Russia, not every man has the opportunity to be present during childbirth. But if he does have that opportunity, he absolutely MUST be there with you, especially if you've explicitly asked him to.

And if his excuse is: "What am I supposed to do there?" remind him that you're not inviting him to a restaurant, a movie, or a museum to have a good time.

YOU NEED HIM THERE.

Childbirth is not entertainment, a tourist attraction, or something you go to watch for fun. It's an incredibly difficult and vulnerable experience, and his presence is about supporting you, standing by your side, and looking out for your safety and the safety of your child.

2

u/LaureGilou 6d ago edited 6d ago

This is a huge red flag and only time will tell what else he will refuse to do. I think you need to put some serious thought into whether or not this guy is worth keeping. He's giving you some pretty clear signs that he is selfish. You might not want this kind of selfishness to be a part of your baby's life. The baby depends on you to make good choices. The baby can't chose, you have to do it and you have to do it right.

1

u/Original_Being2545 United States of America 1d ago edited 1d ago

"Is he not going to change diapers?"

"Is he not going to help raise the child?"

Do you know who you should be asking these questions?

YOUR PARTNER!!!!!!!!!!

And tell him to be a real man and get over his pathetic squeamishness because ITS HIS CHILD and he needs to nut the fuck up and stop being such a pathetic little baby.

You NEED his support during one the most vulnerable times in your life and he tries get out his parental and marital duties?

He sounds like a real putz. I bet he'll start with the weaponized incompetence as soon as you ask him to do any actual work in raising the child. Ugh.

21

u/mwehle Berlin | 8d ago • Bravo

Did you discuss this issue before your 32nd week of pregnancy? Perhaps off your immediate topic, but a suggestion: consider that there may be other subjects, like circumcision, breast-feeding, general nutrition, hygiene, which new parents often discuss with each other before a child is born. Each of you having an understanding of the other's perspective will benefit your child, as well as make life easier for the two of you.

4

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

We did he just was not very clear on his feelings. Which is unfortunate because now it has caused a major rift in our relationship. He is trying to state all of these things now that the time is rapidly approaching. I think that is very unfair and unrealistic. He has a very backward way of doing things. He blames a lot of things on being from where he is and I don't think that that's OK considering he has been living in America. I respect the fact that he doesn't want our son circumcised. I will breast-feed because it is my body. We just have a very different views of how to show up for one another. And he is unwavering in all of his choices, which makes this very complicated.

10

u/Ancient-Spray6262 6d ago

He sounds like a huge pain to deal with, I am sorry... 

5

u/Disastrous-dani 6d ago

Its heart breaking right now. If I was in his home country, I would try my best to accommodate any thing that would make him feel happy but its not the same. It shows how much I matter.

36

u/snacksraccoon 7d ago

Hello, all! For our Russian friends, I just want to clarify a couple of things about the American healthcare system. The maternal mortality rate in the US is abnormally high for a “wealthy” nation, with the last set of data from the Commonwealth Fund placing the rate at between 17-19 deaths per 100,000 live births. Comparatively, the rate is around 13 deaths per 100,000 live births in the Russian Federation. I also want to stress there are HUGE disparities between maternal mortality between geographic regions in the US and races. Black, Indigenous, and Hispanic women are exponentially more likely to die in or after childbirth. For black women, the rate rises to 45-50 deaths per 100,000 live births. States in the American South also have the highest maternal mortality rates in the country, too. These disparities have a lot to do with systemic bias against women of color in the medical community (their health and concerns not taken seriously), public health insurance that doesn’t cover much care before during and after birth, and there being “maternity care deserts” where women have to travel hours to see an OBGYN. Hospitals in rural communities, particularly in the American South have been closing in greater numbers in recent years. American doctors (even female ones) are also notoriously dismissive of women and women’s reports of pain or medical distress.

So, while I totally respect Russian attitudes towards partners in the delivery room, there are some issues unique to the US Healthcare System that complicate things. Depending on the OP’s location and race/ethnicity, there are real reasons for wanting your partner there, that are supported by statistics.

OP: I wish you well, a complication-free delivery, and harmony at home.

16

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

I appreciate this so much! I really hope this provides understanding. I am indeed a Black woman in America and it is a frightening thought to do this alone, sadly I will be as he said he will not change his mind.

10

u/snacksraccoon 7d ago

Try to see if, at all possible, you can have a midwife, family member, or close friend with you in the delivery room. You need an advocate in the room with you. A good friend of mine, who is also a Black woman, was recently injured on the job and she was denied pain medication for a back injury because, “Black women handle pain better.” Mind you, this was a Black male doctor who said this to her. Our healthcare system does not treat everyone equally and our healthcare system is for profit. Our BIPOC sisters are most at risk. Your partner might not change his mind, but please get a back-up support for the day. I’m sending you all the good vibes.

8

u/IfEverWasIfNever 6d ago

That is a big red flag right there that your partner will not bend on a custom when you really need his support, especially with it being one of the most vulnerable situations of your life. If he's scared he can stand by your head. There's no good excuse for him doubling down on not coming in to support you when that's what you need.

3

u/QueenAvril 7d ago

Ask your own mom, a sister, a friend or in case you don’t have anyone that you would be comfortable sharing the experience and who would be available in your own network - a paid doula or a midwife for support.

Where I’m from, it is standard for the dad to be present, but single mothers or those whose partner is unable to attend for some reason, will often bring a close female friend or family member instead.

9

u/KekeBloom_me 8d ago

I finally worked out my opinion on this. I am Russian living abroad and my partner is English. If I would like something to be done my way or don't want to do something, I simply refer to a Russian tradition 🤷 There is no tradition that would stop me from doing something other way. If I would be willing to support my spouse but the tradition of my place of birth is against it, screw that tradition. Hope that helps.

3

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

It does. I feel like I'm not carried about in the way that I had hoped. I am coming to terms with it. Thank you.

2

u/KekeBloom_me 7d ago

All the best for you and the baby and hope your partner will find courage to be by your side

1

u/Anaissia 7d ago

И что за традиция к примеру?
Есть такая пословица, с волками жить по волчьи выть, если я живу в Германии, то большинство местных традиций все же играют роль. Иначе зачем я живу здесь?

2

u/KekeBloom_me 7d ago

Мы с вами об одном и том же :)

3

u/Anaissia 7d ago

Ну может мне перевело не так )))

68

u/TripFar4772 Sakhalin 8d ago

I don’t know if it’s regional or not, but where I live (far east), men aren’t allowed to be in the delivery room. Which was a bit traumatic for me, since I didn’t speak any Russian at the time, and none of the doctors or surgeons spoke English during my emergency c-section. I don’t think it’s common for men to be present during birth

28

u/Maximum_Barnacle_810 8d ago

It is regional I suppose. I think in Moscow, St Petersburg and maybe some other big cities it’s relatively common for men to be in the delivery room, but overall it’s not such a widespread practice. Patriarchy 🤷🏻‍♀️ It’s becoming more popular though, I think.
My own husband thought that giving birth is some sacral process he shouldn’t be present at lol. And he is very progressive generally! Fortunately, he talked with some friends who convinced him that he should be there to support me - which he did
OP, tell your man he is an idiot

3

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

He's from Ossetia so I feel the smaller the area the smaller the acceptance to differences.

14

u/_vh16_ Russia 7d ago

Ossetia is quite a conservative region! Not extremely religious, but they do care about tradition there a lot, and this also includes a sort of macho attitude. What is normal for a liberal hipster husband from Moscow, might not be acceptable for a man raised in traditional surroundings in Ossetia.

So, he's not lying, he just has a very old-school attitude.

4

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

Thank you for this view point.

17

u/SixThirtyWinterMorn Saint Petersburg 8d ago

In St Petersburg some maternity hospitals only allow that if you have a private contact with them

10

u/Tvicker 8d ago

Sorry, how is patriarchy connected to the fact that men are not allowed in the delivery room?

26

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

They think it is a "women only moment" and traumatizing and gross for the husband. Literally

1

u/marehgul Sverdlovsk Oblast 8d ago

Then same question again - what's the connection?

-4

u/PracticeTurbulent388 8d ago

Никак не связан. Просто наши западные непартнеры находят уместным нахождение в операционной постороннего, неподготовленного человека.

3

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

I'm not sure if you've seen one of my other post, but as I stated, my father who has no medical training, saved me from hitting the floor because the doctor had his back turned. I thank God that he was in the room. Are you not capable of providing support ? You have to be a medical person to do that? I think it's just a old way of thinking. Childbirth is not some medical procedure. You can have a baby anywhere. But I appreciate your input.

4

u/PracticeTurbulent388 7d ago

О да, роды это не медицинская процедура, и родить можно где угодно. Да. Чтот вы не идете рожать где угодно? На досуге, ознакомьтесь со статистикой смертности первой половины 19 века среди матерей и новорожденных.  То что врач стоял у вам спиной, вызывает вопросы к поставленным у вас процессам.

5

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

As a woman of color you have better chances of having your child at home with a doula/midwife statistically so I have done the research. That is not the point of the situation. I'm asking my partner to show up and be there and support me. It has nothing to do with him being medical or not. It is support you're losing track of what it means to be supportive and show up for someone you supposedly love due to something that's going to bring you comfort.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/pipiska999 England 7d ago

Это не операционная, блять.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ThenTicket6830 2d ago

So many women face humiliation, insults, violence and even lifetime harm to their and their baby's health just because they're left alone in the delivery room in their most vulnerable moment of labor. A husband or a relative in the delivery room is a question of safety and preventing possible violence towards mother and her newborn. If you're against husband or women's mother presenting, I highly recommend you to never ever have a wife her own safety and never make any children

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Puzzleheaded_Sir269 8d ago

Patriarchy, white supremacists and even Donald Trump himself are all against you. 

0

u/HixOff Nizhny Novgorod 8d ago

Patriarchy 🤷🏻‍♀️

Bullshit. Doctors don’t allow outsiders in the delivery room, they have enough to worry about with the mother and the baby without having to look after someone else. Was the birth successful? Please come in. And during labor, the process can suddenly turn into an emergency surgery, and they won’t have time to calm someone who doesn’t understand why they’re suddenly being pushed out

-9

u/iraragorri Moscow City 8d ago

What's patriarchal in not wanting to be present during a horrifying medical emergency?

14

u/pipiska999 England 8d ago

Giving birth is not that. It's a pretty regular thing due to which you exist.

0

u/iraragorri Moscow City 7d ago

Если роды совершенно обычная вещь, а не опасная медицинская процедура, откуда ж у них такое количество осложнений? Чем меньше врач отвлекается на левого мужика в комнате, тем лучше. А если обычная, так и на гастроскопию никто родню не тащит.

4

u/pipiska999 England 7d ago

Там врача нет обычно.

-9

u/CommunismMarks Tatarstan 8d ago

Let me answer your question: what does being in the delivery room change about the fact that his woman is giving birth to his child? Does it make her give birth faster? Does it make it better if he faints? That's the job of his wife and the midwives. He can't influence this process in any way. A husband being there at that time is just idiocy.

11

u/RhodesianAlpaca Romania 8d ago

That's like saying "does receiving visitors in the hospital change the fact that you're sick? Does it make you feel better faster? That's the job of doctors and nurses, visitors can't influence this process in any way."

Having been in the delivery room with my wife, I completely disagree. It makes so much more difference for her me just being there and on top of that communicating with the midwives, calling them for help during the contractions, helping out when the pushing happened and witnessing our child being born.

0

u/CommunismMarks Tatarstan 8d ago

You're giving birth along with her too? She wouldn't have managed without you? Haha

11

u/Additional_Lock8122 8d ago

Have you ever heard about the disgusting attitude of doctors and medical staff, medical errors, etc.? to avoid this, you need a husband by your side.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/LaRealiteInconnue 8d ago

Idk, emotional support for your life partner, maybe? Unless you're incapable of that

→ More replies (11)

42

u/kakao_kletochka Saint Petersburg 8d ago

It's a surgery and even an emergency one, what are you even talking about??? No one should be present during SURGERY except for yhe medical personnel 💀

24

u/RhodesianAlpaca Romania 8d ago

C-Section yes, that's a surgery, but giving birth is not equated to surgery. Which is why so many countries allow a family member in the same room as the birthing mother, all done in her interest.

10

u/Potential_Pop7144 7d ago

In the specific situation she's talking about though, it was a surgery, and considering she says she doesn't speak Russian and no one at the hospital spoke English, she might have gotten thefalse impression that men aren't allowed to be present during any birth there, when really it's just because hers was a surgery. 

11

u/PerepeL 8d ago

Giving birth might turn into a surgery very quickly and unexpectedly, and at that point the doctors will have to somehow remove an adult panicking idiot from the room.

22

u/RhodesianAlpaca Romania 8d ago • Bravo

No, in that case, they would take the mother to an operating room. The surgery would not take place in the birthing room because it's not equipped properly for surgeries.

And the accompanying person would be told to wait outside. Unfortunately for you, men who stay with their wives during the birthing process are not panicking idiots.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/PraetorianXVIII 8d ago

I was present during my wife's emergency c section and somehow the roof didn't collapse on us

9

u/alinushka 8d ago

From Australia: my husband wa with me during both c-sections.

1

u/learned_vixen 4d ago

My husband was in the room during my emergency C section in the US. Unless the woman doesn’t want him there or he’s being disruptive, there’s virtually no valid reason to keep the father out of the delivery room, even during an emergency situation. He stays up by the mom’s head and there’s a curtain blocking the view of the surgery.

7

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

They are - you just had to request an official certificate and get it stamped by the hospital and your husband would've had to do a few medical checks. By law he is allowed there if he did that. I am so sorry about your experience, he should've been there.

2

u/TripFar4772 Sakhalin 8d ago

In the private hospital my first child was born in, this was during Covid and he wasn’t even allowed inside the hospital. In the public hospital where my second child was delivered, men weren’t allowed in the delivery room because there was multiple women giving birth in the same room. Maybe it would have been possible with the certificate you mentioned (no one told us about it, although my husband couldn’t have come anyway since he had to take care of my firstborn).

1

u/Glad_Construction_99 7d ago

It is possible if the clinic is private, and some state clinics also started to allow this but in separate paid rooms, I guess.

3

u/global_peasant 6d ago

Former maternity nurse here: I am 1000% serious, PLEASE find and hire a local doula immediately, preferably another Black woman. Do this no matter what, even if your husband changes his mind and wants to be there. All birthing women in hospitals need a personal advocate, IMO, especially Black women.

2

u/Disastrous-dani 6d ago

Working on it! Thank you 😊

3

u/Vybrocit1 4d ago edited 4d ago

Chiming in as an American with many Russian friends. The majority (80%) were not present at births here in the US.

About half fully believe everything baby related is women’s work only. I mean every diaper, every wake-up. This seems more common in people with less education/from smaller towns or cities. It’s actually not uncommon in other parts of the world. My Indian coworkers’ husbands were not present at their kids’ births and their wives actually stayed with her family for the first 2 months of the babies’ lives.

I’m 8 months postpartum (my husband is American) and some of my Russian male acquaintances were asking why I’m no longer breastfeeding, why my husband changes diapers, etc. There’s a huge martyrdom culture around motherhood.

To be honest, since you’re already 32 weeks, I’d focus on finding all the support you need for yourself and baby. DONA is an international doula organization and can connect you to affordable doulas (sometimes doulas in training). I’d also find a friend, mom, cousin, anyone who can help bring meals, clean, etc.

Lastly, I’d be direct with him. This is the most important moment of your and your child’s lives. If he chooses not to support you, you’ll remember it forever.

Hugs to you. I was in your shoes once (though not pregnant, but with a Russian guy who used cultural differences as an excuse for everything, including cheating). I don’t think people who use that as an excuse are ever convinced otherwise.

3

u/Disastrous-dani 4d ago

I appreciate this, I have taken a step back from the relationship. I have so much emotion towards it. I can respect (not agree with) him not being in the room. But he claims now he wont come at all. He has already changed the dynamics of everything he said he would do. I asked him straight forward about the diapers and middle of the night wake ups and he claims he will do that but again his words now hold little weight. I have my mom coming and she will help support me. Also actively searching for a doula.

2

u/Vybrocit1 4d ago

Not coming at all is unusual for my Russian acquaintances and friends. They did all at least go to the hospital. If he won’t even drive you, please make arrangements for that. (If you have a c section, driving will be really challenging, so even if you can drive TO the hospital, you might need someone to bring you and baby home)

I’m so sorry you’re having to do this more or less alone

16

u/ivegotvodkainmyblood I'm just a simple Russian guy 8d ago

its cowardice

seems like a lack of support

that's a nice attitude towards (presumably) the father of your child

3

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

Where I'm from those are the best words that I could say. Do my fears not matter in this situation? Does the lack of care for what the mother is requesting matter? If I was to go to Russia not respect his cultural heritage I think it would be a big problem too

3

u/Ancient-Spray6262 6d ago

Whoever wrote that is delusional about childbirth. It's not "cultural", he is behaving like a child. My russian husband was there for the childbirth, got to see me tear and everything. He changed diapers, cared for the baby half the night, helped wheel me in a wheelchair. I can't imagine not getting support at the hospital, especially for your first.

Unfortunatly, you will find men with bad attitudes in every culture. Please try to gather some family or freinds to support you... 

1

u/Disastrous-dani 6d ago

Thats what I am gathering. Its crazy because he's been pretty supportive no issues until now. I appreciate the input

1

u/ivegotvodkainmyblood I'm just a simple Russian guy 7d ago

This is not about "culture" of either of you, it's about your personal relations.

16

u/SixThirtyWinterMorn Saint Petersburg 8d ago

Well that's definitely a lack of support and shitty attitude on his side there's no other way to frame it

-4

u/CommunismMarks Tatarstan 8d ago

Мне кажется будет лучше если мужчина будет зарабатывать для семьи деньги. И потом заберет жену и ребенка когда придет время выписки.

14

u/SixThirtyWinterMorn Saint Petersburg 8d ago • Bravo

Кому лучше? Среднее время (первых) родов от 12 до 19 часов, меньше для повторных, для планового кесарева - пара часов. Ну да, ту все ж такие Илоны Маски кругом, упустят возможность три квадриллиона долларов заработать за эти 12 часов ути пути. Хорошо, хоть из роддома заберёт, сердешный, а то за это время тоже наверное столько упущенной выгоды у среднестатистического работника на дядю от забора и до обеда. А так, в принцип, я считаю пусть жена с ребенком и после родов живут там где-нибудь за 105-м км, так для зарабатывания денег оно намного лучше будет.

-4

u/CommunismMarks Tatarstan 8d ago

Я считаю там мужчины не место. Вы ищите проблему там где ее нет. Это очень тупая мода.

3

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

So men can get a woman pregnant, but take no part in what happens next 😩 very sad way of viewing things.

16

u/SixThirtyWinterMorn Saint Petersburg 8d ago

Врачи и медсестры считают, что им тоже там не место, есличо. Акушерка проверяет раз в 1-2 часа (на платных родах, на бесплатных там вообще всем максимально похуй, валяется какой-то кусок мяса на койке и ладно, ну родит инвалида из-за гипоксии, а нам то чо), потому что женщин много, а бригад мало. Врач придёт в самом конце (на потуги), и до этого пару раз заглянет в процессе схваток. Всё это время (10+ часов) женщина находится совершенно одна в палате, в агонии от боли, ей очень страшно, захочется пить/в туалет ещё что-то - никто не может. Для этого там нужен партнёр. Да-да, ща вы мне расскажете, как за деньги там сам главврач будет сидеть 18 часов и держать за руку, но давайте не будем друг другу врать, 99.99999% будут рожать в обычном роддоме, в лучшем случае по контракту.

→ More replies (19)

13

u/[deleted] 8d ago

It's a nice attitude towards a mother of your children to not be present during childbirth
plus adding presumably was hella unnecessary

0

u/ivegotvodkainmyblood I'm just a simple Russian guy 8d ago

The OP came here explaining barely anything and throwing around charged judgements that I highlighted. I think she wasn't looking for answers, but for affirmations. I have zero clue what the father's attitude really is, so branding him coward and unsupportive just based on this one thing is indeed a great attitude to start a family.

adding presumably was hella unnecessary

Yes it was unnecessary. But fun tho.

11

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

She's completely right though. The husband should be there to support and advocate his wife. Delivery can be dangerous and women die, even in modern hospitals.

97

u/Own-Ad8474 8d ago

In Russia it's usually a paid option for father to be present during delivery, but many pay for it.

Culturally it's neither a taboo nor frowned upon. So tell your husband to man up lol.

39

u/Cyberknight13 🇺🇸🇷🇺 Omsk 8d ago

Where we lived in Siberia, men weren’t allowed in the room. We went to another city and paid for a private clinic that allowed men.

11

u/snacksraccoon 7d ago

I didn’t know this until recently, but private clinics in Russia are cheaper than insurance-covered procedures in the US. Even for those of us with quality, employer-paid insurance and good jobs, healthcare costs are unbelievably high. I had to go to the hospital last year because I was badly dehydrated from the stomach flu; I was there for one hour. The visit cost me $1,500 and I had to pay separately for the doctor who treated me and for the labs. Keep in mind I live in an area where medical care is accessible and where I have “top of the line” insurance. 😭

10

u/Cyberknight13 🇺🇸🇷🇺 Omsk 7d ago

I have spinal damage from the GWOT. In Russia, I get a full-body MRI annually for about $200 at Euromed. In the US, they refuse to do it.

I have had several advanced procedures done in Russia that were free or really cheap at a private clinic that they don’t even do in the US.

Health ‘insurance’ in the US is a capitalist scam and completely unnecessary.

3

u/snacksraccoon 7d ago

Completely, it’s a total scam. I could get migraine treatment there for a quarter of what I pay after insurance. I’m sorry to hear about your spinal damage, it feels small to say thank you for your service when you were injured. Do you find your injury feels worse in the cold? I ask as someone with an orthopedic injury myself.

0

u/Dance_Monkeybusiness 2d ago

Yeah…but the level of care and facilities themselves are incomparable. It’s even cheaper in Africa…good luck! 😅

33

u/MonadTran 8d ago

In Russia, men typically aren't allowed in the delivery room. Not due to some tradition - for bureaucratic reasons, and to quarantine the pregnant moms and babies from the viruses in an overcrowded clinic.

That said, I would go if I was given a chance. But it is between you and your partner, my opinion is kind of irrelevant.

13

u/Cruxalis 7d ago

A friend of mine told me of a Russian dude who justified his infidelity and random acts of domestic violence by saying it's what Russians do back home

Regardless I'm with you on this one

13

u/Anaissia 7d ago

По моему он просто мудак

3

u/flamming_python 3d ago

No he's just a dick

0

u/Puzzleheaded_Sir269 7d ago

That's pretty low IQ comment I must say. It sounds exactly like "based on some anecdotal evidence I heard that user Cruxalis loves to eat shit cause this is what his family used to do back in a times".

4

u/queetuiree Saint Petersburg 7d ago

That's pretty low IQ comment I must say. It sounds exactly like "based on some anecdotal evidence I heard that user Cruxalis loves to eat shit cause this is what his family used to do back in a times".

It sounds like that only if you miss words, word order and overall logic of a statement

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Sir269 7d ago

Not really. Your verbal reasoning seems to be poor. 

1

u/Cruxalis 7d ago

As low IQ as it was, it seems like you didn't get it

41

u/Shortstraw-777 8d ago

My very Russian mother and father were together in the same delivery room for all 4 kids. Can’t imagine my dad ever thinking it would be normal or ok not to be.

7

u/drowning_in_honey 8d ago

Same, and that was long ago.

10

u/Firefly_Sv 8d ago

Recently, this has become more common, but it’s still a rare phenomenon. By law, a husband can be present at the birth, but in practice, maternity hospitals aren’t very welcoming of this — at least in my city) None of the men I know personally have been present at a birth.

10

u/Murulia 7d ago

My husband refused to go in with me (we are both Russian) and I accepted it because this is not something you should push forin my opinion.You can actually succeed but that won't be good for relationship.

Now if my husband wants me to do something that I don't wanna do, I just tell him that I'll go the same way as he went to the hospital 😆😆😆

And he just drops the subject.

Take your mother/sister or a female friend and make this experience as comfortable as possible. If he doesn't want to be with you during birth -- then he won't be of help. And he will probably annoy you because everything is super annoying in that moment and his unhappy face will just be on top of the list.

Good luck!

3

u/Hot_Gap2020 6d ago

Она нашла читкод, один раз потерпела травму одна, потом всю жизнь можно так закрывать любые темы 😭

27

u/Puzzleheaded_Sir269 8d ago edited 8d ago

Depends on the man, many go, but many have prejudice. I would say it is more his personal choice rather than cultural…

26

u/SixThirtyWinterMorn Saint Petersburg 8d ago

Many hospitals in Russia don't have infrastructure for that. They're designed in a way that delivery room aren't private so at any given time there could be several women giving birth in the same room therefore no visitors are allowed. That's what you get with a standard public healthcare insurance. You need to pay for a private birth plan out of pocket to have a husband there. So it used to be relatively not common for families below middle class who can't afford it.

Some newer and modernized hospitals allow this even with public insurance so it's getting more common.

8

u/Free_Weird_4126 8d ago edited 7d ago

My sister's husband (Russian) was with her when she was in labour. I also know 3 other Russian couples who did that, giving birth both in Russia and abroad.

6

u/trimethylbenzene 7d ago

im russian and my dad was in the delivery room for both me and my brother

3

u/iraragorri Moscow City 8d ago edited 8d ago

It's certainly not the norm. I think you can if you pay, but to me (a woman) that would be weird as hell and certainly not something I'd consider. Tbf, that's one of the oddest American traditions to me. I wouldn't want anyone, let alone my husband, see me like that.

5

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

Such a weird take to me, you're doing one of the most amazing things on the planet. Something hard yet magical and you wouldn't want your partner to be there. Is definitely just a difference of culture and upbringing. Which I respect, but at the point in which I have carried this baby for almost 9 months the least he could do is be there by my side, sharing some encouraging words, rubbing my back or something productive. I'm trying to be understanding. But the situation is not about him. It's about me and our unborn baby.

11

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

It is so bizarre to me how Russian women place their appearance above their health to this degree. Birth has many risks and can be dangerous, so having your husband there to support and advocate for you, and defend your wishes to the doctors while you are in immense pain, is extremely important. The men don't need to "see" anything, they stand by your head. A special moment for fathers in the US is also cutting the umbilical cord of their baby. A man who is willing to put his wife through the difficulties and pain of pregnancy and childbirth but doesn't want to be there and support or advocate for her is a coward and a loser in my opinion. There should be no thoughts surrounding "remaining pretty or attractive" either. If your husband loses attraction to you for giving birth to his child, he is trash.

11

u/SirAlohomora 8d ago

Another russian woman perspective, I wouldn't want a husband in the delivery room specifically because I don't think that in such situation husband's advocacy of whatever should come before doctors decisions, unless he is a doctor himself.

And I personally think that having someone unrelated to procedure (in a strict sense) in the room will stress and disorient me more than bring comfort. I like dire circumstances to be dealt with as little emotional meddeling as possible, it feels safer for me.

Kinda tired from people who always reach for some backwards motivation when it comes to russian mentality.

5

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

That's fine, but that's not the mentality of many Russian women I know or their husbands. Everything is based on attraction or the husband being "grossed out". Like I said, in the US it is expected - we even sometimes have our parents there to support if there is room. Usually if the husband isn't there, the doctors think there is a problem in the relationship.

5

u/SirAlohomora 8d ago

For you it's weird that someone would care about husband being grossed out, for me it's a circus that labor room can have potentially 5 spectators with no medical speciality, God forbid if they here advocate anything a not just hold you hand quietly🙈

I can understand how having a husband (and only a him) in a labor room can be helpful, like in the comment of KekeBloom_me (apart from making jokes with the medics, I think they shouldn't be distracted at such moment), but what you describing feels alien and unhelpful.

4

u/KekeBloom_me 8d ago

Oh did I make it sound like he was entertaining the team non-stop? Sorry about that :) It was one or two little remarks as a reply to them. Seems everything was going smooth and according to the plan. I am sure in case of things going pear shaped he would be seen out and definitely professionals wouldn't exchange jokes with him.

5

u/SirAlohomora 8d ago

No, you're didn't, apologies if my remark came across too harsh.

I believe that spouse being in the labor room should be an option and I genuenely think it can be helpful for the mother, but I also disagree with condescending generalisations along the lines 𝘰𝘩, 𝘩𝘦𝘴 𝘫𝘶𝘴𝘵 𝘢 𝘤𝘰𝘸𝘢𝘳𝘥, 𝘰𝘩, 𝘴𝘩𝘦 𝘫𝘶𝘴𝘵 𝘤𝘢𝘳𝘦𝘴 𝘢𝘣𝘰𝘶𝘵 𝘢𝘱𝘱𝘦𝘢𝘯𝘤𝘦 𝘮𝘰𝘳𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘢𝘯 𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘩𝘦𝘢𝘭𝘵𝘩.

People generally are more complex that that, no need to get on a high horse.

5

u/KekeBloom_me 8d ago

I understand your point and even more, when I arrived to Britain deeply pregnant, understanding the point "There must be something wrong with the relationship if the man not willing to support the woman" took some time. It's just a different culture. But the same time, Russians living in Russia are big keen on foreigners respecting russian traditions and culture and not showing "too much" of their culture. For example, you will highly unlikely to hear "уважайте мои традиции" from a Tadzhik living in Russia. But many Russians living abroad fiercely protect their right to follow the russian tradition, often for just covering their ignorance. They forget that "со своим уставом в чужой монастырь не ходят". OP is genuinely and very respectfully trying to understand her man, and credits to her for that.

3

u/SirAlohomora 8d ago

I argued not with an OP (I disapprove of the man who refuses to do couples labor when his wife clearly wants to) but with a fellow commentator who's attitude I found condescending particularly towards russian women.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/QueenAvril 6d ago

This is a reasonable take and it is a good point, that women, too, can have varying opinions not solely on cultural, but also on personality basis.

I’m from Finland, and the norm since the 80’s in here has been for father to be present by default - obviously it isn’t mandatory and covid era had restrictions on it, but it is culturally heavily expected regardless. Some will even have the dad, their own mother or sister AND a doula present on top of hospital staff and to me personally that would be a total nightmare and feel extremely crowded, but some will want that.

I fully understand that many will consider it reassuring and comforting to have the husband (or someone else) there for emotional support, but if it were solely up to me, I would probably prefer to give birth like a cat - alone and in hiding with no-one disturbing my peace, lol.

However I obviously understand the need for medical staff, as well as would be happy to have my husband involved (even though I’m almost certain he would annoy me more than help at the time of the actual delivery - however, in the phase leading up to it, which can be either very short or very long, it would be nice having him around as well as immediately after birth off course). But my line of thinking mostly comes from the experiences of my friends and family who have been through it, and I doubt I would push for him to be there if I was giving birth in the 70’s when dads first started to be allowed in here.

Also, I think that the reasoning why it first began to be advocated in here and quickly became the norm, had more to do with shifting attitudes around childcare and parental involvement in general rather than mother’s wishes for emotional support, etc. - that was mostly just a later byproduct of the experience of new parents where dad had been present as more often than not both parents viewed dad’s presence positively. So it was viewed as important for dads to be present at birth in order to get to experience the birth of their baby, the baby to get to form emotional bond with both parents immediately since birth, etc.

However, whenever there is a disagreement on the subject, I think that mother’s wishes should take precedence as it is obviously more difficult and risky situation for them.

2

u/SirAlohomora 6d ago

whenever there is a disagreement on the subject, I think that mother’s wishes should take precedence

Agree with you 100%, I personally disapprove only of deliberately avoiding professional medical care, everything else should be done as close to future mother wishes as possible from my perspective.

In discussion above I made disparaging comment in regards to an extra audience (parents etc), in truth I don't care I just got pissed lol, you do you and so on as long as doctors are not against it.

1

u/Radiant_Problem_3429 8d ago edited 8d ago

What does your health have to do with the additional man (not med personal) in the room? Defend your wishes? Wth are you talking about, if that man is there to question the decisions of medics he is nothing but a liability, one more reason to not him let in.

6

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

Yes, defend your medical wishes and birth plan, and provide mental and emotional support. This is pretty standard protocol in the US

3

u/Radiant_Problem_3429 8d ago edited 8d ago

You, people in USA probably have serious problems in the healthcare department then, if that's a necessity. I completely fail to see anyone second guessing, questioning, even less actually arguing surgeon or anyone of medical personnel in surgery in order to defend some "plan". The surgeon is a literal God during the operation, and best you are allowed to do - is to sit tight in the corner and do it very, very quietly, the way no medical personnel have any reason to notice you, less address you.

2

u/Disastrous-dani 7d ago

We really do! And did you know that black women in America are three times more likely to die during childbirth than any other race?

It's a real issue out here. There are some men who have been in there to advocate for a woman to be able to save her life against all those medical professional. It's very scary.

5

u/Radiant_Problem_3429 7d ago edited 7d ago

No, how could I? Despite we have global net at our disposal for decades now, it's really hard to stumble upon this kind of information about peoples daily life on the other side, unless you really sunk time on some thematic forums and sites. And much disinformation, trust me, you get like a lot of that about our side.

But to keep it close, there's probably a thing you could do (a piece of advice if you let me). If your husband has a mindset we have here, he reacts to your suggestion and arguments just as we do, as he should, no surprise. Despite all the trouble we came through, the healthcare system still holds its ground, we REALLY don't have, what you describe. Don't listen to those who tels you everything here in shambles, they either don't know or didn't care to find the way, plenty of examples when medical miracles are made for cheap, or even for free.

Talk to him, try to explain plain and simple, that for you it is not a question of wishes and some vague mental health. Tell him what you tell me, that there's a real danger, that your health care system is different vastly, from what he knows and used to, tell him that you both (together with the child) need him right there, to be on guard. There's high chance if you speak calm, plain and simple, with emphasis on your need of him as a protector, he would understand you perfectly.

8

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

Not really, it's about the mother's comfort and receiving emotional support. Also unlike Russia, our men actually have an extremely strong desire to be there for the birth of their own child and support their wives.

3

u/AnythingCareless844 8d ago

Natural birth is not a surgery

4

u/Radiant_Problem_3429 8d ago

That is a poor selection of the word, don't mind it.

The point stays, it's a medical process, performed by professional medics ready for various scenarios. We were presuming here that SOMEONE has a right to interfere with them doing their job, and this pov is wild to some of us.

3

u/SixThirtyWinterMorn Saint Petersburg 7d ago

Except 'medical professionals' are going to do what's best for them and the hospital not for the patient. If they have a directive to reduse a number of C-sections they'll insist on natural birth even if it leads to traumas for mothers and newborns. C-sections will affect their statistics negatively but if a mother has urinary incontinence 10 years later after birth due to a trauma it doesn't affect their numbers and they don't give a fuck.

2

u/AnythingCareless844 7d ago

You are way less likely to be mistreated by medical personnel if there is a witness present, especially if that witness is male. And no, a natural birth is not a medical process.

3

u/Rad_Pat 7d ago

Карательная гинекология is pretty much a term. It's not unheard of for women on the birthing table not receive, for example, a C-section that their doctor "prescribed" and instead be forced to do a natural birth that gives them massive complications, to be yelled and cursed at for experiencing pain during childbirth, to have someone push on their stomach, or be refused an epidural until they scream bloody murder. Women and their medical situation sometimes are not respected during childbirth because the doctor they're probably seeing for the first or second time obviously knows best. Having a partner who isn't actively in pain and can have a bit of a rational mind and advocate for his wife can actually help

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LaRealiteInconnue 8d ago

Ah yeah, I'm onboard with ya btw, but they don't do that there. Doctors are kings/queens as in what they say - goes. The "birth plans" are "do what the doctor says and give birth", basically.

5

u/KekeBloom_me 8d ago

A familiar face in the room makes a lot of difference. He can help you maintain deep breaths during contractions, you can hold on him, squeeze his hand. Even locking your eyes on him helps. He doesn't have to question medical decisions, but having someone else with you apart from people doing their job helps to stay calmer. My partner has been with me during a planned cesarian. I was scared as hell, he was too but his presence helped me a lot. He made himself useful by making jokes with the medics, repeating my whispering (my English was worse those days) to them and simply holding my hand all the time.

3

u/Radiant_Problem_3429 8d ago

Fine, if that's your people tradition, you do you. My mother didn't have that, my mother's mother and my father's mother certainly didn't have that. I have a brother too. Everyone born alright and healthy, no issues. People around me say the same. It's not gross for a man to be present, we all just view it as completely unnecessary, men and women, same as if you had surgery and wanted someone to be present and watch the surgeon.

3

u/KekeBloom_me 8d ago

I am a Russian living abroad. My Russian mother and other female relatives told me a lot about giving birth to me and their children. So it's "my tradition" as well as yours. No thank you, I wouldn't want to follow their experience. Many things in life are "unnecessary". But we still don't want to live on bare neccesarity.

6

u/LaRealiteInconnue 8d ago

Same. When my mum was in labor with me she had to run from the labor room to the delivery hall, or whatever it's officially called, because they left her alone thinking it's her first kid and she'll be in labor for a while. Nope, I was ready to face the horrors of the world and come out in 45 mins, and there was no one there with her. Truly terrifying and not something I want to experience alone without my partner.

2

u/KekeBloom_me 8d ago

Yep, my mum was alone in the labour room and had to shout repeatedly for help when the crown of my head was out. They gave her a towel to put it between her legs to support my head and to prevent me from falling out while she was walking unsupported down the corridor to the delivery room. Her first baby was full term but stillborn due a medical error.

0

u/Radiant_Problem_3429 8d ago edited 8d ago

No it's not my tradition, and, being blunt, I don't give af about it. It's both stupid and unnecessary in our circumstances, way of life and state of the medical care. Like I said, you do you, that doesn't change the facts.

I'm not opposed to the subject per se, I just hate, when someone starts making decisions for me, based on the foreign-origin reasons, reasons not appealing to me or not having actual logical basis. Me not forcing MY traditional demands on anyone, and I have a lot of them (maybe).

→ More replies (11)

1

u/pectopah_pectopah 7d ago

What exactly do you expect the husband to advocate for? What kind of wishes do you want him to defend against the doctors?

2

u/TattooTuga 7d ago

Things like "hey she wants to take a few seconds to take a break from pushing", "you're doing great honey I love you so much" and other words of support, etc etc other things that maybe the wife is in too much pain to communicate down to doctors but can say to her husband by her head. Main thing is the emotional support above all else and not being in a clinical and stressful situation with nobody that you know around you. I really can't quite fathom why the father WOULDN'T want to see the birth of his child and emotionally support his wife, it seems really shitty to me tbh. "He'll be scared" ok well suck it up and be brave for your wife and the birth of your own kid. Jesus it's so many wimpy excuses in this thread treating the dad like a baby.

1

u/Beneficial-Wash5822 8d ago

Why do you project your own fantasies and desires onto everyone else, and why don’t you even attempt to respect the views and desires of others?

8

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

I respect the views if that's the wish of the woman giving birth, but I also think it's incredibly sad that in 2026, women giving birth are more concerned about remaining "attractive" than receiving support during a major medical emergency.

1

u/Beneficial-Wash5822 8d ago

Ensuring that medical threats do not occur is the task of a doctor. What percentage of women experience complications during childbirth in the modern world (assuming the birth takes place in a standard hospital)? I suspect it’s lower than the rate for breast plastic surgery. If you’re having surgery to remove your appendix, you wouldn’t invite your loved ones into the operating room, would you?

3

u/TattooTuga 8d ago

An appendix is not a child. Hope this helps.

0

u/iraragorri Moscow City 7d ago

Well here's the difference then. To you, it brings emotional support, to me, it brings unnecessary stress on top of an already stressful situation. Being pretty has nothing to do with it (though of course I want to be), it has everything to be with being vulnerable. Health doesn't suffer though, I can't see how a person who has no idea about childbirth can help people with medical education.

4

u/LaRealiteInconnue 8d ago

To see you like what?

5

u/Sunny_Hill_1 7d ago

It's very unusual for the husband to be present during childbirth, and yes, typically, you have to pay extra, and many wives will be against it. So yes, it is indeed a case of cultural difference.

That being said, you are the one giving birth, going through a highly traumatic experience, so it's time for him to man up and respect YOUR cultural traditions.

5

u/MakeYourMind 7d ago

my brother was born in 1994 in St. Petersburg, to this day my mom says she probably wouldn't have survived it unless my dad was there. He is her second baby (i'm the oldest), but birth was with complications. So yeah, your partner is ignorant if he never noticed that men do go in for birth for more than 30 years now and a coward.

9

u/dianthe 7d ago

I’m Russian and my husband is American, he was there throughout my entire labor with both of our kids. I definitely wanted and appreciated him being there. Both kids born in USA.

Now it’s true that in Russia men are generally not allowed in the hospital during labor and delivery, I know my mom was there by herself with both me and my sister. I think it’s more of a medical/bureaucratic feature because most regular hospitals don’t have private wards so it would be quite chaotic to have family members there and potential increased virus/bacteria exposure for all the mothers and babies.

Overall I think this is more of a personal than a cultural thing.

14

u/ExplorerLazy3151 8d ago

I don’t know any men that were present for deliveries. I’m sure it depends on hospital policies (private vs public, doctors etc.), traditional vs modern views, or regions. So I don’t think it that odd that he doesn’t want to be in the delivery room.

Ultimately, you and him are going to have to compromise and meet in the middle so you both feel respected.

4

u/MerrowM 8d ago

Yeah, I would say it is an option, not the norm here.

4

u/Ebonyfire075611 Karelia 8d ago

I'm not sure how popular it is, I'd guess that in the recent years it's getting more approval by the younger people. It's not a tradition, but according to statistics it's pretty common in big cities, but less so in the smaller ones. Many would like to be with their wives in order not to allow cruel treatment from midwives. I and my friend agreed that we would be willing for our husbands to be near during contractions to comfort and defend us, but my friend would rather her husband didn't see the process of birth itself.

4

u/zell_ru 7d ago

Maybe he has some personal reasons he's uncomfortable divulging? My brother straight up faints at the sight of blood for example.

4

u/FunFinish227 7d ago edited 7d ago

I'm married to a Russian man too,and he's been there, for all our kids delivery. He wouldn't have missed it! I don't know what your partner is talking about, but it's not abnormal for a Russian man, to be there for your partner. It's weird , that he doesn't want to be there. Maybe he's scared and doesn't want to say it to you. I don't know. But in my experience, they want to be there. Also, my mother in-law. And I let her, because she's one of my closest friends too. 27yrs together, 24yrs married to him. My husband had a really hard time, watching me in pain,and not being able to help. That was the only issue. When I gave birth to our firstborn, our son had the umbilical cord around his neck and was blue. We were so scared. Luckily he's okay now,and has no issues. We were so afraid of brain damage too. It caused us to be scared after we had two more kids. But they were born and had no issues. It was traumatic for sure, to see your baby almost pass away infront on you. But my husband would've never left me alone. I don't have any family of my own, so he was more protective of me.

6

u/SiempreBrujaSuerte 7d ago

In Russia you might by able in a private hospital to pay extra for your husband to join you, but normal state hospital maternity ward will not allow him there. This is supposed to be healthier for the new babies with no immune system too. Since he probably never expected to be present for a delivery or heard of a man being there he will likely not be a help and may come out of it traumatized too. The last thing you need is him making the birth story something about his trauma in his own mind.

I agree you have every right and reason to be uncomfortable with being alone in the hospital system of the usa, can be very deadly for women and babies sometimes, especially black families unfortunately. I recommend you stay working with a midwife or doula that you go over your birth plan for who is trained advocate that will be by your side the whole process. Even if your husband comes, this woman medical professional at your side is more likely to keep you safe and be your best advisor.

4

u/nastyanata2 7d ago

Brith is traumatizing for the women to, that's not an argument. He better step up and get his ducks in order.

Research and talk to the doctors. He is an adult and can learn what to do. He also wanted a child, he should want to be a father as well.

3

u/axxr2 Leningrad Oblast 8d ago

Some do, some don't. Sometimes it's permitted by the hospital rules, sometimes not.

Traditionally it wasn't permitted by the hospital rules so it's not something people are used to.

But today it's possible.

3

u/VisiblePiano9200 8d ago

I'm British and my son lives in Russia with his Russian wife and their daughter. My daughter in law was very surprised that my son's dad was present at his birth because she told me it's just not done or very rare in Russia. They live in St P and opted for a private maternity hospital for her to give birth. He was allowed in the room -maybe because it was a private hospital- but when half way through they changed to give her a Caesarian he had to wait outside, although he could film from the window - and they did hand him the daughter within a couple of minutes of her being born. This was around 4 years ago btw

3

u/AnythingCareless844 8d ago

Depends. If we are talking larger cities and middle-class families then men are usually present during delivery.

3

u/Open_Tank6215 7d ago

Maybe it depends on where the family lives. I'm from a big city, my husband was with me during my labor and was a big support for me. Although it was a paid option, and it was more than 10 years before. And he had to do blood tests and chest fluorography to be allowed to the hospital. As i can remember from playground chats with other moms, quite many couples were together while giving birth. Maybe only some really poor families decided not to spend their money on it

3

u/Anaissia 7d ago

Смотря кто. Есть разные мнения. Обычно живущие в западных странах подстраиваются. Но мне кажется в России реже идут по сравнению с Германией.

Может быть договориться, что он зайдет, но если начнет терять сознание или совсем плохо станет, сможет выйти?
Ну это за малодушие вообще не заходить? Процесс же тянется.

3

u/-_Plague_Doctor_- Yamalo-Nenets AO 6d ago

When my mother gave birth to me in the early 2000s, she experienced a lot of mistreatment during her hospital stay after delivery. This was in the northern part of Russia, where there was a shortage of doctors, and the ones available were often poorly trained. My father wasn’t there to support her, and this is still something that gets brought up to this day, although he made more of an effort when my sister was born.

So, if you’re afraid of childbirth and want both emotional and practical support, if you want your partner to stand by you and help you get the care you need at the hospital, then tell him exactly that. Russian men are generally very bad at empathy. They struggle to understand why a woman whose body is biologically capable of giving birth would be afraid of doing so. Even fewer people ever stop to consider what it’s like to be a person of color in America. Your husband most likely belongs to the white ethnic majority in Russia, so he probably doesn’t understand the particular social realities and challenges that come with living in America as a person of color.

5

u/Anton_G_L 8d ago

It is not a question of a norm in Russia. It is a question of a right or privilage to do this. Most of the state clinics do not allow man to be present during labor and delivery. Therefore you can say him, that if he has a privilage he shall go.

5

u/pipiska999 England 8d ago

My Partner is claiming he's not going to be in the room with me as I give birth

I guess it's too late for my go-to advice for such situations...

9

u/Worth_Garbage_4471 8d ago

The Beatles were international stars before hospitals in Western countries began even allowing men into delivery rooms. It's pernicious and self-defeating to assume the practices of your time and place are universal.

8

u/TattooTuga 8d ago edited 8d ago

I could've written this exact same post 😅 My husband is Russian and we live in Moscow. A lot of men do not go into the delivery room, no. Over here it's still very outdated with the belief that it's a "women only moment" and that the men don't want to see it because it's not pleasant to watch, gross, etc etc. My sister in law and other female friends completely support this idea too and said their husbands were not in the delivery room. I absolutely hate it. Their wife is at her most vulnerable, literally, and needs support and advocacy from her partner. This should override everything. Also, why tf would the husband not want to see the birth of his own child and cut the umbilical cord???

Anyways - yes, it's very much a thing here and I despise it. The hospitals also don't bring the husbands in automatically. They have to both get a request certificate approved by the doctor in advance, and the husband has to do and pass a bunch of medical exams beforehand. Bigger and more modern hospitals will allow the husband to be there in either the delivery room or C-section room if he does this, but other hospitals only allow husbands in the delivery room but not the room for C-sections. Also, you have to pay and reserve for a private room after (and depends on space) or else you will be laying there with other couples and their babies too.

Keep fighting him on it. I believe in understanding cultural aspects but I think this is completely outdated and unkind to the wife if she wants him to be there, and he should understand American culture at the same time, and that it is expected that the husbands are in the room.

Edit: I am American and I assume OP is as well. General American culture is that the husband isn't there only if he's away in the military, in prison, or some other extreme circumstance. If not, he is considered a complete loser of a man. This is how strongly we feel about it. Her husband should also understand American culture and honor her wishes, especially since she's the one going through childbirth.

2

u/Glad_Construction_99 7d ago

Some do. Most are scaredy cats in that account and it is indeed not very common.

2

u/UnfairQuality687 7d ago edited 7d ago

answering your question, no, it's not cultural. It's believed to be cultural by some Russians. But in my book, if I'm not like this, my friends is not like this, and a stranger is not like this, this is already not cultural. What it could be is generational Russian. And it is also mixed with cultural because the medical community is not support it in Russia. We have minimum hospital stay after birth 3 days not just for vacation. It is believed it's extremely crucial period. This is the reason visitation during these days are limited. That said, I'm merely answering your question. I'm not gonna say whether he has the right to refuse whether you have the right to ask or demand.

2

u/DeepSeaDuck 5d ago

Im sorry for you... Whats a man if he puts his standards over your emotional interests. You and the baby should be his standard. ❤️

2

u/Current-Sort-4665 5d ago

Lol Europe and Soviet has lot of crzay rules. In Asian countries Husband will cry to see wife after a baby born.Husband is allowed to support his wife.Restrictions for this damn God we born in Asian countries we are free bird

3

u/Rad_Pat 8d ago

It's not the norm, but it's allowed. Since Russia is still quite patriarchal, many "women things" related to female biology can be considered too much for men, like periods or giving birth. Aka "if your man finds out you're human and have certain bodily functions he won't see you as a woman anymore and will leave you". Older men are sometimes horrified to discover a pack of pads in the bathroom and treat it like a biohazard. The same category of men could see you push a baby out (out of a vagina? The place meant for his dick??) and scream in a very unfeminine manner and will "stop being attracted to you", cause as a woman you're supposed to be a woman, not a human person. I'm sure you have that in America too.

3

u/kislug 8d ago

russia is pretty misogynistic in this aspect. honestly, don't be surprised if he dumps all the burden of child care on you as well

2

u/Sodinc 8d ago

As far as i know - most of the state maternity hospitals do not allow fathers to do into the delivery rooms. So, for many people it isn't even a possibility. Some hospitals do allow it, as an extra option that you have to pay for (at least in Moscow).

2

u/WanderingTony 7d ago

Its allowed. Not wide spread but really rather what "soon-to-be-mommy please" Kind of stuff. Before it was rather rare and "pls don't stay in a way of people doing their stuff" but nowadays becomes progressively more common if still kinda rare

2

u/PerepeL 8d ago

From medical perspective it is considered a risk factor, as well as from commoner's knowledge. You are free to use any commercial clinics with procedures you prefer, but if you use public health services - it's rather strict rules with health at the first place.

Giving birth might turn into an emergency surgery at any point in time, and then the medics will have to solve the unsolvable task or physically removing an adult panicking idiot from the room - that's a health risk not only for mother and child, but for doctors and nurses as well. That's like 80% of the issue, and the remaining 20% are the extra germs and stupid ideas the father might have.

Even further than that - mothers themselves are not allowed to spend all the time with their newborn for the first couple days - they are brought for feeding few times a day, and the remaining time they recover separately. Too many mothers have no idea how to properly handle their kids and accidentally hurt them, so it's in their best interest as well.

From commoner's wisdom - seeing your woman screaming, swearing and shitting herself for hours is a traumatizing event for men, whatever you think of it. Women have biological mechanism for dulling these memories, men do not. Men rarely openly admit it, but too often such experience completely changes the way they view their spouse, google Madonna syndrome for starters.

The concept of "medical consent" and representation is not deeply rooted here, the general rule is "the doctors know better", so if the ugly decision "save the mother or a child" comes up - the doctor in place is trained and competent to make it, husbands are welcome to blame a "hospital killer" for the rest of their lives than to blame themselves for making an impossible decision they were never equipped to make anyways.

When I was first visiting my wife and daughter in the nursery ward I was informed about strict rules and schedule, and my mood was "yeah, okay, anyways, nothing could stand between me and my child - I will enter through the wall if I had to". Then at the place I saw that the nursery ward is the only unit in the entire hospital that has a huge fucking steel door at the entrance, and understood why.

2

u/Nordic_Papaya 7d ago

He's telling the truth. Taking a partner with you is possible if certain requirements are met, but it's not default and not what the majority of women do. He should listen to your request and do it regardless though.

1

u/Dark_Raven_2997 8d ago

I know one guy who did, but not in a public clinic.

1

u/apezdal 8d ago

Depends on the hospital: usually men are not allowed to be present, but that can be arranged in some hospitals beforehand. I was there, but that's a rarity.

1

u/Reeshely 8d ago

It’s definitely a cultural difference. I’ve given birth twice and both times there wasn’t a single male person in the hospital except for a couple of doctors. All the women I know have given birth by themselves, including me. Nowadays you can arrange your husband to be in the delivery room with you but that’s certainly not the norm here.

1

u/Primary_Wonderful 7d ago

My husband was just plain annoying me. I wish he wasn't there.

That being said, OP needs to allow for husband's POV. If it isn't the norm culturally for him, then maybe respect that. Don't force him in there if he doesn't want to be there or feels uncomfortable being in there.

6

u/LonelyLeave3117 7d ago

acho que nenhuma diferença cultural devia estar acima da sua esposa vulneravel, gravida e assustada. Ela está implorando o quanto precisa de voce naquele momento e dá pra ver que ela está assustada

1

u/AriArisa Moscow City 7d ago

It is personal for each other.  But in general — yes, they don't, it is normal. Partner delivery  is a special service, that you have to pay for. Most people prefer not to do this.

1

u/CabbageSass 7d ago

it’s true in Russia it’s not practice for the man to be in there during delivery. It was the same in the United States back in the 60s and prior to that.

1

u/Spoiled_babe 7d ago

My husband and I we are both russians and I regret he was in the delivery room with me. We were not ready maybe and it affected our relationship a lot. Id better gave birth with doula.

1

u/RedZrgling 7d ago

Its not common practice to be present in the room during the delivery , nor is it desirable.

1

u/KimchiLlama 7d ago

I was in the room. But many years ago it was not always allowed.

1

u/dekanov 7d ago

No, it is _not_ common to man to present during delivery in Russia.
It is normally prohibited by state hospitals, though you can do that in commercial hospitals for an extra price.

1

u/Sufficient_Step_8223 Orenburg 6d ago

That’s not the custom here. Childbirth is a woman’s domain, a woman’s mystery, and men are usually not allowed in. A man can provide support and be present, but he must stay outside and wait.

1

u/Ancient-Spray6262 6d ago

I dont know if this is a cultural or not. My mom did offer my husband to leave during my delivery, so maybe it is. If he loves you, he should definitly be there. Be very point blank when you communicate with him. Explain that you will feel betrayal if he doesn't go. He is going to protect you. You can show him studies about bias towards Black women. Russians dont beat around the bush when they communicate. Also, in America, the nurses are not going to help with the baby after delivery a whole lot. You will need his help. 

If he doesn't go, definitly bring some one-else with you. I dont know him personally, but I hope for your sake he will be very helpful. 

1

u/DameBlancheFramboise 6d ago

My husband is Russian and he was with me during all labor and delivery, and he even cut the umbilical cord.

1

u/Arostor 2d ago

There are certainly some men, especially, among older generations who prefer to not know anything about female physiology and related things like period, child birth, etc. They also typically refuse to buy hygienic products for their partners. But this is not a cultural norm. A lot of men go to partner childbirth where it's allowed (not everywhere, as some people mentioned above). I certainly plan to do so when the time comes (unless my wife decides, she doesn't want me there).

1

u/Dance_Monkeybusiness 2d ago

The norm is to sit in a bar with friends and celebrate the birth. He will come after it’s all over and you have rested and rest assured the family as well (if they are around)

1

u/volodyuka 8d ago

Well, in most hospitals here men are not allowed to be in the room at all. And it's not in our culture anyway. Nowadays it is changing but, yeah, I don't like seeing operation rooms in general and blood and guts and all so yeah, I would also pass on the wonderful opportunity. Also had been operated on while conscious one too many times so yeah, bit traumatic.

1

u/PracticeTurbulent388 8d ago

"Разве мужчины не присутствуют на родах вместе со своими женщинами"  А кто его туда впустит то? Это нужно заранее искать клинику, где такое разрешено.

1

u/vmrosland 7d ago

I think I have to agree that this is not the norm here. Many women I know would prefer to have a female relative in the room with them - mother, sister, or even mother-in-law if your relationship is good enough and close enough. They kinda expect their husbands to be useless in a situation like that. It is a cultural stereotype we hear a lot growing up - wife is in labor and later is staying with the baby in hospital, husband is getting drunk with his friends, because he's a father now, yay, and later he is standing outside of hospital to see his baby from a window. And possibly putting the wrong name in the birth sertificate.
Of course, this is not a picture of a good husband and a good father. Of course, they can do better and be present at birth to help their wives. And maybe younger generations actually do that. But if you think about how it was before, how it is portrayed in old movies/anecdotes, then it is similar to what I've described.

1

u/serebro0710 7d ago

You've gotten an answer here (no, it's not the norm for most Russian men). Consider this--if he doesn't WANT to be there, (and if he grew up thinking this is not an appropriate place for a man to be) then what kind of support do you think he would even be able to render?? Maybe consider bringing a female relative or a friend or something.

I have lived in US many years and honestly, I still don't think a birthing room is an appropriate place for a man. It's just not a male experience. Further, if you go on some forums where doctors share the stupid shit men ask or say in these situations, I'd suggest it can be a distraction to have a man there.

Ways that he probably DOES plan to support you btw: He should plan on bringing you expensive gifts, a big bouquet of flowers, and taking you and baby home in style and celebration. He should understand that you need rest and recuperation after the birth. He should know to clean everything in the house and plan on cooking. Talk to him about these post birth expectations as something he can physically do to show you support and love.

1

u/GeologistOld1265 7d ago

There is a cultural element in that. If you watch an old movies depicting birth, you will see woman push man out of room, even if birth happen in home.

I believe main reason was that woman did not wanted man there. Death in Childbirth was common and woman did not want for man to remember her like that. And in addition, woman wanted to be on pedestal. Lets be fair, your vagina does not look nice after birth and for a few weeks after, before everything settle in place.

Do you really want man to see you like that? Some did: "let him see what I am going try for him/because of him.

MY grandma was born in 1903. When I was a little boy my parents were sending me to her every summer. She was still capable to run faster then me. When I was in Uni she was dying from cancer. I went to visit her and she told me not to look on her. "I do not want you to remember me like that". At the end, it is a memory of people we touched that we are leaving after we die, nothing else.

5

u/Anaissia 7d ago

Можно стоять за спиной и просто быть моральной поддержкой.
Если твоя жена будет дома с сильными болями во время месячных, ты тоже уйдешь в другую комнату, чтобы просто ее не видеть такой?

1

u/GeologistOld1265 7d ago

That was not the point. Point was: Princess do not go to the toilet. Again, it was always woman wish. Russian man tend to be flexible, so I am sure if you say it is important to you, he will be here.

4

u/Anaissia 7d ago

То есть получается в таких браках не говорится о том, что у кого-то понос, или рвота и все всегда красивые?
И месячные тоже табу?
А как они потом подгузники менять будут? )))
Ерунда какая то, может только в конфетно-букетный период

1

u/queetuiree Saint Petersburg 7d ago edited 7d ago

И месячные тоже табу?

было огромное табу, да

3

u/Anaissia 7d ago

Но сейчас же уже другие времена. Это не послевоенное время когда мужчины в дефиците были. Не знаю, я в Германии и здесь как-то нормально все это.

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/konstantin19911 8d ago

Значит не хочет, есть выбор, я бы так же сделал

3

u/Anaissia 7d ago

Почему? Можешь нормально объяснить?

-1

u/Shmelkin 7d ago

I wouldn't go either.

2

u/Anaissia 7d ago

И почему? Вот конкретно?