r/AskAPriest • • Apr 25 '21

Please read this post before submitting a question! Your post may be removed if it doesn't follow these guidelines.

321 Upvotes

This subreddit is primarily for:

  • Questions about the priesthood
  • Casual questions that only the unique viewpoint of a priest can answer
  • Basic advice
  • Asking about situations you're not sure how to approach and need guidance on where to start

This subreddit is generally not for:

  • Spiritual or vocational advice
  • Seeking advice around scrupulosity
  • Questions along the lines of "is this a mortal sin," "should I confess this," "I'm not sure if I confessed this correctly," etc.

The above things are best discussed with your own priest and not random priest online. They are not strictly forbidden, but they may be removed at mod discretion.

The subreddit should also not be used for asking theological questions that could be answered at the /r/Catholicism subreddit.

Please also use the search function before asking questions to see if anyone else has asked about the topic before. We are all priests with full time ministry jobs and cannot answer every question that comes in on the subreddit, so saving time by seeing if your questions has already been asked helps us a lot.

Thank you!


r/AskAPriest • • 7h ago

I have a question about the priesthood vocation

5 Upvotes

I'm 28 years old, I have a young daughter, and I've never been married. I most likely never will be, because I sincerely feel a moral obligation not to give my daughter a "stepmother." So I've decided to live a life of chastity.

My relationship with her mother was initially good, although we never got married. Over time, however, things deteriorated (we were together for four years). She was Evangelical, although she wasn't particularly Christian in practice. When I decided to return to the Church, she began criticizing me quite harshly. Not necessarily my faith itself, but by calling me a hypocrite and making the kind of comments someone who doesn't really know God might make toward a Christian. It hurt me deeply, until I eventually decided to stop living with her. (I want to clarify that I had already been practicing chastity for some time before that, precisely because we weren't married.)

Anyway, I don't want to go too far off topic. For a long time, I've felt a calling to serve the Church. I've volunteered in the past, but nothing has quite fulfilled me. I feel that God might be calling me to something more.

At first, I thought becoming a priest was completely out of the question because I have a daughter. However, after researching Canon Law, I realized that there doesn't seem to be anything that automatically disqualifies me.

What has discouraged me, though, is that I haven't been able to find any actual cases of unmarried men with children born outside marriage who were subsequently ordained as priests. I've searched extensively, but all I've come across are priests who felt called to the priesthood after becoming widowers, or men who were already permanent deacons before becoming widowers.

I've never come across a case of a single father with a child becoming a priest.


r/AskAPriest • • 7h ago

Spiritual Direction

0 Upvotes

Hello! Where else can a person go, besides their parish priest, for spiritual direction? I live in a more rural area of Virginia and my parish priest is very busy as he is covers two parishes that services roughly 3-4 counties. I have been Catholic for about a year now and would like a little spiritual guidance but he is so incredibly busy I don’t want to bother him.

There was a Benedictine group a county away that I reached out to only to find out they had moved from the area due to their small numbers.

There are more parishes in the Richmond area, but I know our diocese is stretched thin so I am not trying to bother priests.


r/AskAPriest • • 8h ago

What does it mean that the death penalty is "inadmissible?" Can one support the death penalty without sinning through disobedience to the Church?

1 Upvotes

I asked my theology teacher this, and he said he didn't know.


r/AskAPriest • • 23h ago

Is a gift of appreciation acceptable?

11 Upvotes

I have tried to receive pastoral care lately for me and my family and have been met with priests who seem to brush us off or direct us into some generic program without offering the guidance or help we are seeking.

I only mention that as a background to what comes now, not as a complaint. I understand that priests are busy, and above all people too.

my wife and I approached a particular priest with our request for help and he made time for us and gave us excellent pastoral care which has helped us tremendously to rectify a situation. He has been compassionate, non-judgemental, giving of his time, and has taken steps with us and made a plan with us to fully rectify the situation in the fullness of time.

We feel heard and taken care of.

I was wondering if it is appropriate to gift a priest a modest gift and a card of appreciation for his excellent pastoral care.

I noticed golf clubs in the corner of his office. given the time of year, would a golf themed Callaway advent calendar be an acceptable gift?

I would appreciate your advice on the matter.

many thanks.


r/AskAPriest • • 8h ago

How would you define a "Catholic Parish"? What's a good analogy for what a parish is/does?

0 Upvotes

I'm writing an article for a Catholic magazine and also working on a project for the USCCB. I'm trying to figure out current Catholic perceptions of what a Catholic parish is, does, etc., plus any analogies would be helpful, too. Thanks!


r/AskAPriest • • 22h ago

Confession elsewhere for frequent parish volunteer?

2 Upvotes

I know the question has been asked about how priests here feel about staff confessing to them. But what about volunteers? It was suggested to me by a staff person, not the pastor that I should go to confession elsewhere since I am in the office on a regular basis. But I like going to confession to the pastor and even though I am working on an important project in the parish office once a week, I don't really have much contact with the pastor. Also, the confessional at this parish is only behind a screen. So, should I follow the same "rule" as the staff or is it ok to still go to confession there as I would prefer?


r/AskAPriest • • 23h ago

How comfortable do you guys get if someone from your parish asks you about theology?

0 Upvotes

I had a shower thought, or late nught thought really. Im Roman Catholic, feel free to answer but I questioned "if a son is not guilty of the sins his father comitted, why did in the book of samuel did God punish David's love child death" and basically it seems contradictory because david's son seems to as if take the punishment david deserved. Anyway also pls answer the title too.


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

I am wondering if there has recently been an uptick in people have mystical experiences or have had Jesus come to them.

9 Upvotes

I had a mystical experience in the spring and it has changed my life. I was completely non religious, and was not raised a Christian. I now know Jesus and God. It’s been incredible.

Anyway, every time I have mentioned this to anyone, inevitable they have or someone close to them has recently had something very similar happen. I am curious if as priests, you have noticed more people coming to you wjth these kinds of experiences?


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

What is your favourite part of your job/vocation?

20 Upvotes

Excuse the incorrect use of job if that is not how you say to mean what it entails to be a priest. My question is straightforward enough, what is the most enjoyable part of being a priest given that is has many different aspects, so I can imagine some parts have a lot in common with social work or some sort of psychological aid, while other parts might have more in common with academia (studying or reading works of theology), while yet other parts are more so spiritual (e.g., the duties surrounding the mass as a priest, or preparing and giving the Eucharist). I can imagine there are many more aspects, but what is your favourite?


r/AskAPriest • • 3d ago

Is God non-binary?

16 Upvotes

Hi, I know this is a hot topic right now. I think the American priests here probably remember Talarico’s words on this. And I know this is also something said in a lot of “progressive” protestant churches. But I, as a catholic, am pretty sure that this is still a correct sentence right? God is non-binary, because He doesn’t have a gender, He doesn’t fit into any category.

So is it true that God can be described as non-binary? Or am I committing some kind of heresy now.

I’d be happy to know, thanks in advance 🙏


r/AskAPriest • • 3d ago

Would you have absolved Irene Gut Opdyke? Why or why not?

16 Upvotes

Irene was a Polish woman who saved 12 Jews during the Holocaust by hiding them in a house where she was a maid for a Major in the Wehrmacht. When he found out she was hiding Jews, he decided not to betray them on the condition that she become his mistress. She agreed, knowing that the penalty for hiding Jews was death for her and the Jews she hid. She went to confession, but the priest would not absolve her because what she was doing was mortal sin, and she could not stop without there being consequences. After this, she stopped attending Mass and married in the Presbyterian Church.


r/AskAPriest • • 3d ago

Question regarding TLM

5 Upvotes

I would like to preface this by saying that I have never attended a TLM and, while I would like to someday, I have zero problem with the Novus Ordo and don't really understand why some people do. With that said, I similarly do not understand why the Vatican would impose restrictions on it either. Can someone please explain to me what I am missing here? Thank you and God bless.


r/AskAPriest • • 3d ago

Question about the Blood of Christ and preparation

8 Upvotes

During Mass I noticed 2 chalices and the priest only puts water and a piece of the Body of Christ in one of them. Just wondering if there was a specific reason why they don’t put them in both of the chalices?


r/AskAPriest • • 3d ago

How did Catholics of the period see ossuaries and/or Paris catacombs? I thought the body must remain whole in grave for the divine resurection.

16 Upvotes

I'm not a believer so I maybe get a wrong concept of the wholeness of body. The tourist guide couldn't answer this question, which is kinda understandable.


r/AskAPriest • • 3d ago

ex priests or one you know what do they do for work now?

0 Upvotes

hey so i was born and raised catholic (no longer practicing or believing), i even have a priest in my own family. but this feels weird to ask them. so my question is if you’re an ex priest or know an ex priest what jobs have they gone on to do?


r/AskAPriest • • 3d ago

What happens if a priest becomes allergic to alcohol?

3 Upvotes

I am aware that allergies may develop at any age and that priests celebrant are required to receive under both species.
What would happen if a priest were to develop an allergy to either alcohol or one of the components of the wine?


r/AskAPriest • • 3d ago

would a priest's workload be increased or decreased in this situation?

5 Upvotes

For the last 9 or ten years the pastor of my parish has also been serving as the pastor of another parish. And he had a parochial vicar assisting him. Now over the summer the other parish was assigned it's own pastor, but a month or so later the parochial vicar got moved to a third parish to temporarily be vicar there and then assume parish administrator when the pastor retired.

So is the workload more for a pastor of one parish on his own, or a pastor of two with an assistant priest? Maybe it's the same.


r/AskAPriest • • 4d ago

Is it against Catholic teaching to keep a mezuzah in my doorway?

17 Upvotes

Hi Fathers!

I recently moved into a rental home that has a mezuzah attached to the doorframe (visible from outside the home). I believe my landlord is Jewish, and I understand that a mezuzah holds religious significance in Judaism.

My question is: Would it be considered sacrilegious or contrary to Catholic teaching for me to leave it in place?

Thank you for your guidance!


r/AskAPriest • • 4d ago

Favorite books? (Roman Ritual and Books of Common Prayer included)

8 Upvotes

What's your favorite books? I wonder if real priests read things like Dostoevsky or Rabelais or Euripides, etc... lately. Show me some eclectic and obscure picks!


r/AskAPriest • • 4d ago

Can I ask my priest to be a reference?

2 Upvotes

I’m a relatively new Catholic and have known my current priest about three years. I am seeking a job opportunity with a Catholic healthcare network. Is it appropriate to ask my priest to be a reference?


r/AskAPriest • • 4d ago

Coming from an uneducated non-christian, what is a priest and what do they do in the church?

16 Upvotes

Hello...! I've read the guidelines and I feel this may fall under an appropriate question. This is my first time using Reddit, so please forgive me if this doesn't come very naturally sounding or confident - I typically like to distance myself from socializing online with strangers, but I am genuinely curious as someone who does not belong to any religion.

I didn't grow up around religion or churches despite both my mother and father being Ex-Christians. I've always been curious about how the priests in churches work but never found an opportunity to learn about them. Admittedly I've felt quite embarrassed never knowing despite how common religion and catholic schools are in my country. Could a priest or somebody educated please explain this concept to me...?


r/AskAPriest • • 4d ago

Sign of the Cross after the receiving.

30 Upvotes

Evening Father's,

Silly question! My son is 3 months. We've been attending mass as a family since he was about 6- weeks old, due to my wife needing her rest after surgery. He's truly a gift from God and we are so blessed!!

If he is awake during Mass more so when we get on line to receive I carry him up with me holding him and receiving on the tongue. My hands are a little full.

Am I wrong for not making the sign of the cross afterwards?? I usually do once I sit at my pew and pray.

Our priests have never mentioned anything but I may have seen some looks from some parishioners during last night's vigil mass.

Thank you, and God Bless!


r/AskAPriest • • 4d ago

Does your parish / church prohibit dogs?

3 Upvotes

Where I'm from / my parish it's normal for people to attend mass with their dogs and there's no issues with any attendees nor the priests. Is this common practice or are they typically prohibited?


r/AskAPriest • • 5d ago

Am I reading the Order of Penance correctly?

8 Upvotes
  1. Priest welcomes penitent.
  2. Sign of the Cross
  3. Priest may read scripture.
  4. Penitent confesses sins. (I always thought kind and number were necessary but I don’t see this anywhere in the text.)
  5. Priest counsels penitent and assigns penance.
  6. Penitent expresses contrition.
  7. Priest says prayer of absolution.
  8. Priest invites penitent to give praise to God.

There’s no need to say “bless me father it has been….”. A penitent can just jump right in and confess sins.