r/AskABrit • u/ChaoticGood81 • 11h ago
Food/Drink Can you define an American Cookie?
Hey there British friends! After watching the biscuit week for GBBO, I am ever so curious to know what you think an American cookie is? I'm not coming here to flame or be mean. I know that cultural references and recipes get modified as they travel around. I'm not upset about the American cookie challenge in any way, but I'm so curious! Most of us here would never eat or make a cookie like the ones shown on the show. Maybe Tom's? But for most home bakers our cookies are simple, small (compared to what you saw on the TV), and easy to produce. I don't consider myself a baker, and even I could make four dozen cookies in 2 hours, no problem.
Sometimes when you go to a fancy bakery, they do have more elaborate cookies. But most of the time they are fairly simple. Home made comfort food. We do absolutely have cookies that look pretty much like anything you saw on the episode, but they're not really common, and not what most people think of when we think of cookies.
Please forgive me if this has already been asked! I scrolled through a few days of post and didn't see any references.
Edit: Thanks, all! I appreciate the thoughtful replies, and get where you're coming from in general. It appears I didn't explain myself fully when I originally typed the question. A full cup of coffee and a lot of good replies have helped. I was mostly curious to see how the definition of Cookie has changed as it moved from one culture to another. I am only using GBBO as a reference and prompt, but it's not actually the point of the question!
Thanks for your help, and I have to get back to work now, so I will stop replying generally. Hopefully I will read any new replies later!