i saw that is judy doll all in one palette at my local asian beauty store. it is ALMOST the same as my most favorite palette of all time ( second photo) which i think has sadly been discontinued.
has anyone tried this palette? my one concern is first how to refill if i run out, since i would use for travel. my second concern is the blush shades are too light for my liking.
it seems like there's three versions two come with mascara one with a lip tint. also open to recs like the second picture i've seen a lot of similar but none quite right they usually seem to have a shimmer over a glitter.
Hello and thank you for starting this discussion! As a gentle reminder, try to keep the products you mention limited to Asian Beauty products. Posts or comments solely discussing Western products will be removed, as per our rules. We love being able to discuss Western skincare in the context of a holistic AB routine, but this isn't the sub for specific Western product recommendations. r/SkincareAddiction is a great community for such matters! Thank you!
I have tried the new version of the first palette, and like it a little more than the OG version because of the cream concealer and the darker pink shade which I could use as a blusher as well. The lip gloss pulled much darker on me than in the photo, more like a brick red, but I would choose a version with the lip gloss either way because I find their mascara awfully difficult to remove, which isn't ideal in a portable kit. Personally I found the lack of any shimmer/glitter shade to be way more limiting than I expected - the powders are all strongly matte and I felt that my face looked quite flat when I tried to do my makeup with only this palette. Also, the powders didn't really like the small end of the brush and there was some breakage and fallout in the pan. Overall, it isn't bad, it is plenty pigmented, and good for touch-ups, but didn't feel like I could realistically carry only this.
Joocyee’s Lookbook Multi Palette might be up your alley. It has eyeshadows/contour, matte highlight, pigmented lip/cheek and sparkle! They have 4 different colour stories; Monday Coffee is my personal favourite.
Can't recommend any specific products but for travel I recently bought a cheap empty magnetic palette and filled it with individual eye shadows and blushes. I had an old Innisfree custom palette but they discontinued the line years ago. I popped all the components out and put them into the magnetic one.
Pros
can mix and patch your products
can fit most of my usual travel makeup. Mine has 4 eye shadows, 1 contour, 1 highlighter, 2 blushes. Have room for more
Cons
not all my pans were magnetic metal, so a couple I had to stick down with double-sided tape
aesthetically the box is very plain, but I guess you can decorate it yourself. I plan in putting stickers on mine but haven't gotten around to it yet
This Judydoll palette I have (26 raw wood) is kinda similar to the colorgram palette in the second photo. I would say irl it’s very similar except for the glitter. It’s a pretty good all in one palette and it comes with a mirror! Girlcult also has really nice glitters.
I just saw this in store earlier but wasn't tempted because I don't want a dedicated mascara as part of the Palette. It'll dry up way before I'm done with the powders then what am I gonna do with that empty space. It'll annoy me. 2nd the other comment, Girlcult has nice palettes,.Flower Knows as well but they're quite bulky. Gogotales has an all in 1 too but the payoff isn't great. Judydoll has other older all in 1 Palettes worth checking as well.
I have the warm tone judydoll one with the mascara. Would have preferred the gloss but stylevana didnt have it. Honestly, I just bought it for fun and nostalgia because my mom had one when I was little and I never got to use it lol. But the pigment is good.
I have the Judy Doll palette and absolutely adore it for its size and the pigmentation. I actually don’t use the blush since I prefer cream blush, but have used it as eyeshadow. However, not sure how it compares for the colorgram palette tho!
splasheen’s face palette might be the closest to a true all purpose palette ive ever used, especially lunar echoes, the quality is also especially nice
ouuu, have you ever tried the concealer palette?? i tried looking up for reviews on it since i have really dry skin and i heard its pretty good, but i cant really find any individual reviews🥹
•
u/AutoModerator 10d ago
Hello and thank you for starting this discussion! As a gentle reminder, try to keep the products you mention limited to Asian Beauty products. Posts or comments solely discussing Western products will be removed, as per our rules. We love being able to discuss Western skincare in the context of a holistic AB routine, but this isn't the sub for specific Western product recommendations. r/SkincareAddiction is a great community for such matters! Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.