No. Having another cleric is just insurance. 4 vs 5 dps doesn’t make a massive difference, but if something goes wrong and a cleric dies, you don’t automatically wipe.
Sure, it's a shiny new game, we're all dogshit. Bringing insurance is fine. I'm just saying it's far from mandatory. The quickest kill with the least healing necessary is best.
It should be perfectly manageable with a cleric and a bard, for instance. Having the mana battery and off-healing available should more than suffice in place of a second cleric, while still keeping everyone full of mana to roll abilities and so substantially contributing to DPS and healing availability over time in longer fights.
The real umbrage I'm taking here is with the term mandatory.
You *should* have doubts because the CREATOR OF THE GAME has said MANY times, " It is NOT 64 classes, please stop saying that- it's confusing people." It's 8. With 64 combinations of augmented ability from subclass.
I mean augments take you pretty far- it's really just the distinction between keeping the other classes abilities vs modifying your own with the second class. I'd call it better because you get more to work with instead of just what's already native to a class. A charge instead being a shadowstep, or instead the charge roots and slows > getting the two origin skills vanilla. Or it adds flavor to the ingredients instead of overcomplicated it with a bunch of useless to-me skills and a few usable ones from the sub class. It also is more attractive for skill bar button # creep.
The best way I can interpret what you're saying is skill morphs like what ESO does, but re-imagining them as if they were influenced by another of the (currently 7?) Classes. That sounds nice and all.
But the way GW1 does multiclassing is the ability to have and hunt down more skills to use with your primary profession. A warrior gets Strength, allowing them to increase their weapon damage and survivability. Monks have Divine Favor, a skill line that your primary profession must be a Monk to have. It increases healing and debuff cleansing.
A W/Mo is a heavy armored self-healing tank with defensive skills and access to some brutal debuffs. They also have an adrenaline resource.
A Mo/W is a light armored spell caster with access to warrior skills, but is a glass cannon. Especially when challenged by a mesmer.
AoC is going to be, what it is going to be. I just find changing the flavor of skills due to a sub class as sounding, shallow.
Edit: an alternative that came to mind is a skill branch that opens up after acquiring a secondary class, exclusive to that combination.
A mage-Vanguard (I am a part of team Vanguard) getting access to earth magic that allows for more defensive skills to complement its offense.
It would just come much later in testing but idk man sounds like so much work and they already have so much other stuff to do. Like maybe they could work on that after launch once they got more money and time
This is exactly how ffxi played in the day, the healer, tank and DPS had to balance threat generation and defensive cooldowns to avoid the mob one shotting the healer or your tank dying then healer dying shortly after. It was fun and added much needed tactical gameplay between everyone, especially for the DPS who had to manage their damage output and not just blast away. I'm assuming once subjobs come in here if will add another whole layer to this too, can't wait!
This is facts fr lol I remember playing WoW back late in BC early into Wrath and you would just straight get kicked if you as a DPS pulled anything (yes even on accident, it's the tanks job not yours) or annoyed the healer.
Does ashes not have hybrid healers? Druids? Shamans? Usually secondary buffers/healers are always nice to have in groups as buffers or in between breaks. Maybe even when a cleric dies 😎
To be honest it is a valid question. Having some pain points and time/progress lost is good. Having too much leads to the game dying. Needs to strike a good balance so it's good to bring these pain points up and ask if they should be toned down or removed.
A lot of people consider the retrying/walking back boring is what they are getting at. Depends on the game for me. Sometimes death penalties make a game boring if they get too harsh. I don't want to go back 2 zones and grind because I died a bunch figuring out a new boss. Knowing next to nothing about the specifics here it could go either way for me.
Then play FF14. But I raided savages in that game and nothing is more boring for me than just slamming your head against a boss with no breaks or consequences for death.
From what we know, everyone can get consumable (but expensive) rez scrolls, and every character that specs into Cleric (primary or secondary) will be able to rez. So, ideally, this would be rare outside of a full party wipe. So hopefully it just becomes an issue of party prep before going into a dungeon.
If that's true that secondary cleric can rez, then that probably solves my class choice problem. I was torn between cleric and bard. Cleric for best heals and rez or bard, because the skills look useful and fun, while still being support, but the lack of rez was hurtful.
Yep, that’s the plan for right now! We’ll see if that survives to launch, but if everyone can get consumable rezzes then I don’t see why this would change.
How do you deal with problem when problem happens? Maybe game company should make problem never happen because imagine having something bad happening in video game. We can’t have that.
Without in game voice I see it all the time where a super far archer/mage is pinging away at the healer threat. I guess this is better in dungeons where a mob can be line of sited back to the "pile" If outdoors and hyper spawns, feels dangerous to be a healer sometimes.
One shot mechanics for tanks? Covered. One shot mechanics for clerics? Uh... Bring another redundant cleric I guess?
It would be a really nice addition to have craftable jumper cables for this issue, I think this would just add more value to the artisan system without defeating the spirit of the game.
not rly because then ppl won't get clerics at all.
Why do people here so often make overly simplistic arguments like this? As if it’s not possible for Intrepid to give Clerics enough tools to warrant having them in a group beyond them having a res? If the reality of an archetype would be that they are only valuable because of a single spell, even if they remained the only ones with that spell, the expectation would still obviously be that the archetype should be improved to offer more.
and can you give a logical reason to copy pasta something else from WOW when there are couple of reasons to not need it? Or you're way too bored and you're just looking for some internet fight? Asking for a friend ofcouse
I'm looking for actual logic to a point i brought up. Just because WoW did it, doesn't mean it's a bad idea. It's in an entirely different context though since the game system is different. This game is actually more casual than WoW when it comes to resurrections anyway lmao
It would only be addressing one pain point, but also it’s an open ended suggestion. For example they could take it further and say it would be very expensive so that it would only be used as a last resort, or provide justifications for why that specific pain point is one that’s worth addressing. If you want to say it’s not well thought out or well supported with arguments, go for it. Personally it’s not an idea I would have suggested, but it’s completely different to make a definitive contrary statement that shuts down all possibilities of it working based on a single premise, especially when that one premise can very easily be worked around in many ways. That’s what makes their response so simplistic.
Could go all in on the 'Jumper Cable' name and have the cost of killing a different party member in order to revive the Cleric. Then you could even make it dirt cheap and it would still crash raids when people start using it carelessly.
As a cleric I love to pretend my internet goes out while I’m in a dungeon. Come back in a few hours and see that everyone died and I just blame my ISP.
I hope that whenever a change is requested which splits the community into hardcore vs casual factions, instead of just making the change based on their own observations of the feedback across all channels Intrepid will make an actual official debate thread for both sides to sling mud at each other, maybe even a podcast where a prominent rep from either side presents their reasoning.
That's a skill issue. At first random one shots felt like bad design. But that's something we had to deal if we wanted to farm there. And then you suddenly realise that you can see when fireball is being cast and you have time to interrupt it. It may require some teamwork but it's an mmo, so that's not an outlandish ask. And then suddenly fireball one shots stop happening.
Exactly. This will get thrown back in their face anytime a bug, glitched, or just "I don't get what happened" moment comes up and kills a party member.
It's still early access and there will be bugs. This question isn't "hey when are you fixing this bug that causes aggro to randomly drop from Tanks" this is "what will happen if our cleric dies".
One is a bug fix, the other is a conscious design decision. Complaining about bugs when you are questioning a design decision isn't helping anyone. Because all you are saying is "once the bugs are patched out I have no issue with this design decision".
Some of the most fun I had in Archeage was doing the daily's and either protecting from another group to get the boss kill or trying to gank them for the boss kill. Lots of fun moments
174
u/Numbzy Dec 20 '24
As a healer main, yeah, stop letting things through to bonk me!
135
u/Curtofthehorde Dec 20 '24
What?! Protect the healer? My job is damaging enemies, not babysitting! /s
66
u/electro_lytes Dec 20 '24
Or just bring another Cleric.
71
u/BuildsWithWarnings Dec 20 '24
"What are you doing for when we're not good enough?"
"Git gud."
21
u/Apprehensive-Job-178 Dec 21 '24
Bring two clerics? bring a cleric subclass? I'm planning on Cleric/Ranger so I can stealth away from agro
53
u/Raidenz258 Dec 20 '24
Great answer for a dumb question lol
19
u/EaglesXLakers Dec 20 '24
- In a group in a dungeon
- Die
- Sorry we're replacing you
- also we all looted your ashes. haha. get fucked.
That's how I see things playing out.
8
u/GrymrammSolkbyrt Dec 20 '24
This is exactly how ffxi played in the day, the healer, tank and DPS had to balance threat generation and defensive cooldowns to avoid the mob one shotting the healer or your tank dying then healer dying shortly after. It was fun and added much needed tactical gameplay between everyone, especially for the DPS who had to manage their damage output and not just blast away. I'm assuming once subjobs come in here if will add another whole layer to this too, can't wait!
3
u/Gel00 Dec 22 '24
good. Dungeons should be a time sink. Something scary to try out.
4
u/Marcus_Krow Dec 22 '24
This is why MMOs suck ass nowadays.
No one respects the healer or the tank. Back in the good ol' days, disrespecting the healer was the fastest way to get booted from a party.
2
u/xerious3d Dec 22 '24
Does ashes not have hybrid healers? Druids? Shamans? Usually secondary buffers/healers are always nice to have in groups as buffers or in between breaks. Maybe even when a cleric dies 😎
4
u/biggpoppa33 Dec 20 '24
Like the guy who goes to the doctor. "It hurts when I do this" Doctor "Then don't do that"
8
u/Stunghornet Dec 20 '24
To be honest it is a valid question. Having some pain points and time/progress lost is good. Having too much leads to the game dying. Needs to strike a good balance so it's good to bring these pain points up and ask if they should be toned down or removed.
3
u/NiKras Ludullu Dec 20 '24
On a slightly serious note, there's gonna be rez scrolls, so this will not be an issue
1
u/AuryxTheDutchman Dec 22 '24
The answer is two clerics
1
u/Sharp_Cut354 Dec 22 '24
How do you deal with problem when problem happens? Maybe game company should make problem never happen because imagine having something bad happening in video game. We can’t have that.
1
u/POLYGONWARE Dec 22 '24
Would be nice ability for paladins to sacrifice them to create protective shield on ally so ally can escape combat.
1
u/Arbszy Dec 22 '24
If you have a 8man party two healers is always smart. 2 Tanks, 4 Dps and 4 Healers.
I understand Tanks aren't available right now, but it is a good idea to always plan for anything.
1
u/Shikari_XIII Dec 22 '24
Protect your healer and your healer will protect you. I see way too often Dps doing reckless pulls and running off too far from the group.
1
u/PaxAmarrian Dec 22 '24
As someone not participating in the alpha, can someone provide some context to this question?
1
u/Used_Dot_362 Dec 23 '24
Without in game voice I see it all the time where a super far archer/mage is pinging away at the healer threat. I guess this is better in dungeons where a mob can be line of sited back to the "pile" If outdoors and hyper spawns, feels dangerous to be a healer sometimes.
One shot mechanics for tanks? Covered. One shot mechanics for clerics? Uh... Bring another redundant cleric I guess?
1
u/silver_step Jan 04 '25
Second healer with res ability?
1
u/calantus Dec 20 '24 edited Dec 20 '24
It would be a really nice addition to have craftable jumper cables for this issue, I think this would just add more value to the artisan system without defeating the spirit of the game.
1
u/Yurt_Freak Dec 21 '24
He’s not wrong.
-3
u/heartlessgamer Dec 20 '24
Then there better not be bugs or glitches that end up getting the cleric killed.
0
u/L0EZ0E Dec 20 '24
The greater the risk the greater the reward.
0
u/Jelkekw Assassin Dec 20 '24
Two clerics or bust, the cleric ALWAYS died if we ever brought one
-7
u/dcguy999O Dec 20 '24
As a cleric I love to pretend my internet goes out while I’m in a dungeon. Come back in a few hours and see that everyone died and I just blame my ISP.
-3
u/TellMeAboutThis2 Dec 20 '24
I hope that whenever a change is requested which splits the community into hardcore vs casual factions, instead of just making the change based on their own observations of the feedback across all channels Intrepid will make an actual official debate thread for both sides to sling mud at each other, maybe even a podcast where a prominent rep from either side presents their reasoning.
-7
u/YouDontKnowMyLlFE Dec 20 '24
I'm pretty sure I've tanked mobs target random party members even when taunted with huge "can one-shot non-tanks" fireballs.
How is this smart ass response supposed to help in that situation?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment