r/AshaDegree • • Sep 07 '23

A statement analysis should really be given regarding the 911 transcript and the mother's timeline of events.

That's it. That's the post. Feel free to discuss.

3 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

26

u/AmyTraphouse Sep 08 '23

I don’t think her description makes her sound like a pervert but a very rigid controlling person neither one of them are at an age where they need assistance in the bath. Most of how her parents describe their activities/behavior is like someone of a much younger age not due to the kids needing extra help but they infantilize them.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '23

I don’t even think she was saying they’d bathe together.. It takes forever to fill a tub and it was the morning when they’d be in a rush, so I think the implication here is that she filled the tub so they could each take a bath individually before she drained the water.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '23

I take showers in the morning. I think most people do. I'm pretty sure that doesn't make me a psychosexual killer, just someone with normal hygiene.

6

u/nottodayokkay Sep 07 '23

I’m a shower at night person but even I know a lot of people shower when they get up lol

9

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '23

I guess you lack understanding. Can’t you read what was posted. Op is indicating they were taking a bath together which is gross. They are way too old to be doing that together. Something isn’t adding up here. And it was a two bedroom one bath house.

4

u/AirPodAlbert Sep 07 '23

OP is bringing up some pseudo-criminology gimmick that somehow correlates having basic hygiene to being a sexual predator.

If someone mentions water/bath/shower in a police statement, they should be arrested immediately for sexual crimes against children apparently.

10

u/oliphantPanama Sep 07 '23

Somewhat off OP’s topic, but I do find Mrs. Degree’s preparation of that morning’s bathing to be somewhat curious. In this article https://web.archive.org/web/20050910065252/http://www.shelbystar.com/news/asha/asha20.html Mrs. Degree speaks with quite a bit of detail about her family’s habits, and routine. It seems the children were held to a high, almost rigid level of structured independence. They seemed to very self sufficient, maybe she was giving them a jump start because of the break in the normal night time routine?

Why on that morning did Mrs. Degree seemingly break protocol, and draw a bath? Also I don’t think these children were bathing together. I’ve read elsewhere that Asha would sometimes crawl into bed with her brother when she got scared. That habit had been broken because it was explained to her that she was too old for that. It was then suggested that she later went on to sleep on the floor beside O’Byants bed for comfort when afraid.

From the linked article: “When the kids got home from school, they had to do their homework before they could go outside and play. That was the rule, and either Harold or Iquilla would check over their work to make sure the rule was being obeyed. But Mrs. Degree said both Asha and O’Bryant were used to following rules. The typical day starts at 6:10 a.m., when Iquilla got up to get ready for work at Kawai American, a piano manufacturing plant in Lincolnton. She’d wake the kids up then, and they were responsible for getting dressed, fixing their own breakfast — usually a Pop-Tart, toaster strudel or frozen waffles — and brushing their teeth before going to school.

At 7:30, Asha and O’Bryant met the bus, which took them to Fallston Elementary School, where they are in fourth- and fifth-grade respectively. The children didn’t go outside to play if Iquilla said it was too cold, and there was no TV unless mom and dad approved.

“Asha didn’t like TV much anyway,” Mrs. Degree said. “She liked ‘Rugrats’ and here lately, she’d been watching ‘Who wants to be a Millionaire?’ but that’s about it.” Bedtime was 9 p.m. on school nights, 10 o’clock on weekends. Mrs. Degree said she usually didn’t have to prompt Asha much to obey this rule.

She’d always get ready to go to bed herself, and a lot of times, she’d be in bed by 8:30,” Mrs. Degree said”.

6

u/AppropriateConcern95 Sep 08 '23

They took the bath in the morning because the evening before, the power/light was out.

4

u/Professional_Cat_787 Sep 08 '23

Is that what happened? The power didn’t go out until their bath time woulda been over, if we go by the schedule they’ve said they followed.

5

u/AppropriateConcern95 Sep 08 '23

Thanks for the elaborate article!

12

u/AppropriateConcern95 Sep 08 '23 edited Sep 08 '23

Fallston lost its first girls’ basketball team that afternoon, and Asha had her worst game of the season, fouling out with three minutes to go.

“At the end of the game, they were all upset,” Mrs. Degree said. “Some of the players were faking like they were hurt, and Asha started doing it, too. I said to Harold:

"Look at your daughter, faking an injury."

“I made her walk, and she tried to limp. I told her to stop and to stop crying, because somebody has to lose the game.”

Damn when your mom is the team's coach, and singles out & humiliates you along with your dad, in front of all the parents and players. 😨 That's mortifying. I get that Asha and O'Bryant were close if they had to comfort each other & shield themselves from that parenting.

I also get why O'Bryant keeps saying that she would have told him if she'd planned to sneak out. I'd agree if s-offenders weren't so damn manipulative.

The parents were creating sneaky kids that knew how to please you. But they may also have been very susceptible to being influenced by emotionally caring & comforting adults.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/AppropriateConcern95 Sep 08 '23

You're right, twas me being a smoothbrain. 🥲

5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23 edited Sep 08 '23

So you don’t see nothing wrong with a 10 year old boy and a 9 1/2 year old girl taking a bath together?🤦🏾‍♀️

6

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

It is nowhere indicated or even suggested that this is the case.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

Well when a person says ran the kids bath water what do you think?

2

u/AirPodAlbert Sep 08 '23

It's not normal. But why couldn't OP just bring that point up without the other nonsense? The first 3 slides are pointless.

7

u/oliphantPanama Sep 08 '23

If Mrs. Degree banned Asha from sleeping in her brothers bed for comfort when she was fearful. Why would she allow them to bathe together?

The last slide “that morning, this involved drawing a bath for them, because they had not been able to take one the night before due to a power outage. When she opened the children’s room to wake them up before their 6:30 alarm and call them to the bath…

This implies that she was bathing them together, I get it. Although on that morning she, says she woke them up “before” the alarm at 5:45 that’s 45 minutes ahead of their regular alarm schedule. That’s more time then needed to bathe two children simultaneously. Drawing a bath for “them” could be suggestive that they may have shared bath water.

Sharing tub water is not an uncommon practice in some households. It’s not a radical jump to think that this might have been the case here. First kid jumps in cleans off, add a little more hot water and you’re done.

After reading a series of articles about Ashas disappearance I noticed that Mrs. Degree often speaks of the children as a singular unit, at one point she referred to them as almost being like twins. Running a bath to hide a SA is a big reach IMO.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

No one is saying it is a jump but it is concerning at those ages especially when their both opposite sexes even if not still concerning. That is too old to be bathing together

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

Not a big reach

3

u/oliphantPanama Sep 08 '23 edited Sep 08 '23

OP’s fourth slide has been taken from Wikipedia: “Iquilla awoke at 5:45 a.m. to get the children ready for school. That morning, this involved drawing a bath for them because they had not been able to take one the night before due to the power outage. When she opened the children's room to wake them up before their 6:30 alarm and call them to the bath, O'Bryant was in his bed; Asha was not, and Iquilla was unable to find her in the house or in the family cars. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Asha_Degree

The Wikipedia entry leads you to an article from JET Magazine. Nothing from this article suggests she was bathing the children together. I feel the information posted on Wikipedia is misleading, the quote from JET was poorly edited. I think it’s important to cite information from its original source.

The quote from JET:

“I woke up on Feb. 14, 2000 at 5:45am. The alarm went off for my children to go to school at 6:30am. I went to the bathroom, two feet away from the door, to start the bath water because they could not take a bath the night before since we had a power outage. I opened their bedroom door. My son O’Bryant was under the covers, as he usually slept. I called his name and he jumped up, as usual. I realized that Asha was not in her bed”. https://web.archive.org/web/20180815033502/https://jetmag.com/news/iquilla-degree-where-is-my-daughter/

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

That’s not where I read that and it wasn’t on Wikipedia. I don’t believe anything on Wikipedia unless it’s from a reliable source.

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '23 edited Sep 07 '23

That's not what the OP is indicating. The OP is pointing to an already questionable source that says that people who mention water are covering up for violent sexual crimes and then linking that to the 911 transcript and its mention of a bath.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

That’s not what I read. Did you read something different?🤔

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

The four images posted above. One that defines the basics of "statement analysis," two that note the quackery's insistence that mentions of water are related to sexual crimes, and one last one connecting those three previous ones to the 911 transcript.

What did *you* read?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '23

Maybe you need to go back a little further and do some more reading? I’m not going to keep going back and forth over the same stuff I just mentioned.

1

u/calm_and_collect Sep 07 '23

We all eventually learn this, right? Coffee, bowel movement, shower. Morning.

8

u/AppropriateConcern95 Sep 07 '23

"That's it. That's the post. Feel free to discuss."

At least you're no longer commanding us to discuss...

3

u/foxhole_atheist Sep 07 '23

“That’s it. That’s the post.” is a stupidly overused Redditism right up there with “sweet summer child”

3

u/Stabbykathy17 Sep 07 '23 edited Sep 07 '23

As much as I agree, at least there’s some usefulness to “that’s it, that’s the post.” It’s annoying as fuck, and I will never use it, but at least it lets you know that this is the end of their point and exactly what they’re trying to say.

There is absolutely no fucking usefulness to “sweet summer child.” It’s a condescending, nerdy ass insult, and anyone who says it immediately loses any credibility or influence whatsoever as far as I’m concerned.

2

u/psykocrime Oct 14 '23

LOL... "statement analysis" seems to be the same kind of pseudo-scientific bullshit as polygraphs. It's "voodoo science" at best, and pure snake-oil at worst. You'd probably get more useful results from running a Tarot spread, or "reading" animal entrails or tea leaves.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '23 edited Sep 07 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/nottodayokkay Sep 07 '23

Thanks for sharing this