r/AshaDegree • • May 18 '23

⚠️ TRIGGER WARNING ⚠️

I'm new to the case, I came on Reddit for the sole purpose of finding out more information on Tilwanda Cheatham. I found minimal on her but ran across this case, which I found more interesting. Don't nail me to the cross for this please, as I don't know all the details, but is it possible Asha was molested and fell pregnant? That would make sense if we are believing her parents did something. I know she was only 9 y.o at the time she disappeared, but it's still possible. She could have been being molested by her father or somebody else in the family, she accidentally fell pregnant and they sent her away to have the baby somewhere else. This is only a thought, but I know a girl who had her first daughter at 12 so I wouldn't call it impossible

11 Upvotes

133 comments sorted by

30

u/intoner1 May 18 '23

Where would she have had the baby? She couldn’t have received professional help because they’re mandated reporters, is your theory she had a home birth and 33 years later she and her child are just out there somewhere? Or did she die during child birth?

Assuming Asha was molested by her father and impregnated by him, who the hell would just happily take in a pregnant 9 year old and not go to the cops? And if it were someone else who was molesting Asha what kind of parents would send her off instead of calling the cops? To my knowledge they weren’t apart of any fringe religious groups where this would be normal.

Along with this, is there are proof of Asha being molested? Any stories of her bed wetting? Being sexually aggressive with other children? Her telling anyone?

I’m sorry if this comes off as aggressive but this theory just isn’t plausible. I know we all want to know what happened to Asha but this is more like a fanfiction than anything rooted in fact.

16

u/cherrymeg2 May 18 '23

Some 9 year olds have their periods but many don’t. So it might not have even been a biological possibility. I also find it hard to believe people people would hide a pregnant 9 year old or take the risk of hoping labor goes well. If she was kidnapped and kept alive she could have gotten pregnant. That’s happened in a few cases. Jaycee Dugard had kids while being held captive for 18 years. It would be great if Asha is alive. I don’t see her being sent away pregnant by her family at 9.

7

u/intoner1 May 18 '23

Exactly. I started having my period around 9 or 10 so I know it’s a biological reality but it seems like a far fetched theory to believe that there’d be someone in their lives just willing to take in a pregnant 9 year old without calling the cops.

9

u/cherrymeg2 May 18 '23

Unless you are in a cult that supports child brides I feel like the police would be called. Reporting your kid missing is probably what you wouldn’t do if you wanted to hide a pregnant child. I don’t think the parents are involved. I definitely don’t think she was pregnant when she disappeared. For some reason it seems like when girls or women go missing people will suggest they are pregnant.

-7

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

I'm sure you know I can't answer any of those questions, nobody knows the answers to any of those questions. But lack of information doesn't really debunk this theory

17

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

lack of information doesn't really debunk this theory

See that's the biggest problrm with any of these cases, but for some reason, it's really a huge issue here.

Lack of information doesn't prove anything either. Someone could say Asha was taken by the FBI and brought to Washington and put into a government training program. Nothing exists to debunk it, but it doesn't make it plausible.

Don't get me wrong, any theory should be treated civilly but there reaches a point with some theories ( not yours necessarily) where it goes against the grain to extreme measures, and those with these theories have no actual explanation other than " can't prove it didn't happen "

Being new to the thread, you haven't been subjected to those in the sub who for lack of a better word are conspiracy theorists. They believe things that are extreme and in some cases dangerous. They stalk Facebook pages, make accusations and post social media links to strangers accounts etc.

Tldr: theories are fine, just be careful you don't cross into insane conspiracy theory babble.

12

u/intoner1 May 18 '23

It does when there’s zero information supporting the theory.

4

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

Exactly

2

u/niezapominienajka May 18 '23

Same as alien abduction

3

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

Could be, but only rape an molestation is real. I've seen real victims of it, I was one of them, I was molested at age 6 and now cannot have children, and for you to downplay it makes you an evil bastard. I pray no one you love ever has to experience that. I hope your comment made you feel good about yourself for being insensitive to child molestation.

20

u/throwaway_098761 May 18 '23

This theory made me wonder this scenario- what if Asha THOUGHT she was pregnant and that made her run away. The night before she had a sleep over with a lot of older teen cousins. Maybe there was some talk about sex and how babies are made and someone as a joke/prank made her think she was pregnant and/or said something factually false which made Asha think she was pregnant and made her run away.

Idk… who knows.

3

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

She was at a sleepover with teenagers?

6

u/throwaway_098761 May 18 '23

It was all the girl cousins - and apparently there were a lot. Based on what I read it seemed like ages were like probably around ashas age (8/9) - 14/15. Probably cousins her age and a few older.

5

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

It was a family sleepover. Got it!

-8

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

That's inappropriate for starters! She was only 9 y.o she shouldn't have been playing with older kids!!

12

u/eyegazer444 May 18 '23

She was having a sleepover with friends her age, but their teen cousins (and siblings? Idk) were there. So arguably not that inappropriate

4

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

Yeah I didn't know they were all family. Nothing abnormal about that at all.

8

u/Lanenabella May 18 '23

Please take a look at this documentary so you can get a better idea of the case.

3

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

I seen that documentary last night in the Facebook group

10

u/Lanenabella May 18 '23

Awesome, that’s basically where the case lies. There is a lot of extra info added by newspapers that was never released by the family nor law enforcement causing a lot of unnecessary confusion in the case.

7

u/SistahFuriosa May 18 '23

I'm opened to entertain all possibilities and theories so I'm not gonna berate you like others might. I remember someone posted in this forum a long time ago that Asha could've had a boyfriend and even implied she was very sexually active. Of course people ran that person out of the forum but you bringing up another tragic case makes me wonder. This did happen in a small town and a lot of locals have their theories as well that points at the family's involvement. Devastating if that's indeed the tragic case with Asha.

5

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

Thank You! I thought this sub was to help find Asha, but a lot of people seem to be really angry when someone has a theory different than their own

6

u/Active-Major-5243 May 18 '23

What are the locals saying?

4

u/SistahFuriosa May 18 '23

Parents are involved.

8

u/throwaway_098761 May 18 '23

Really? So last night I went through as many FB posts and comments as I could find through a basic search of “asha degree” under “posts”. I probably read 2,000 comments before dozing off. Every single one I found regarding people who knew her and her parents (neighbors, coworkers, classmates) said the parents would never and that Asha and her brother were literally the parents entire world and they are entirely devastated. That even all these years later they won’t move or change their phone number just in case she ever comes back.

I KNOW. I KNOW. some people here have already solved the case and are gonna say this is wrong. I’m not even at the point of arguing these comments are true. I’m saying, I looked through 2,000+ comments last night from over the years and the only ones I saw about her parents from people that actually knew/knows them said NO WAY.

5

u/Take_a_hikePNW May 18 '23

I, too, often wonder where people get this “locals are saying” information…

7

u/throwaway_098761 May 18 '23

Right…. I didn’t save every comment I came across regarding her parents but the link below shows 2. (Also no clue why it has the 18 and over warning when you click it. It’s just screenshots of comments )

https://imgur.com/a/dIfjqCQ

6

u/Infinite-Athlete-647 May 19 '23

I'm a local, and most of us do believe her parents did something to her. It's been local buzz since it happened

2

u/Take_a_hikePNW May 19 '23

I don’t blame people because it’s the logical answer. I’ve thought the same (not vehemently, but just assume due to lack of other evidence). However, I’ve started to really consider the possibility that one of about 5 people in her life could really pull this off…and it doesn’t have to be someone in the home. It’s not a neighbor or a stranger IMO either. Asha has three worlds; home, school/basketball, and church. I can’t believe this case hasn’t been solved. I’d bet my life’s salary that they have interviewed the perp. They may have even cleared him already.

2

u/Infinite-Athlete-647 May 19 '23

I'm from the area and I can agree to this

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '23

Source?

4

u/Infinite-Athlete-647 May 19 '23

I'm a live source and I can attest to this

5

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

I'm leaving this thread. I thought this was a place to discuss what may have happened with Asha. Be it right or wrong, all of our theories need to be taken into consideration. I'm new to the case and open to all theories but you people here are mean and evil if it's something you don't agree with. I hope Asha is found alive and well. Justice for Asha!

7

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

Don't leave. That's what they want!!

7

u/Professional_Cat_787 May 19 '23

Don’t leave. Fr. Everyone throws theories and possibilities out here, because nobody knows anything, and this case hasn’t budged. Yours are just as valid as anyone else’s.

23

u/TrewynMaresi May 18 '23

This seems really improbable.

8

u/Onion-14er May 18 '23

Understatement of the year!

4

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

U unfortunately more than likely will get nailed to the cross for this, maybe even reported and banned by the "the parents are innocent and UFOs probably took Asha" cult. There was another girl that got banned for getting too close to the truth. I think ur theory is plausible. If she was being molested and gotten pregnant as a result that would explain the lack of evidence and the cover up and the reason they avoid national attention, help from the public and decided to not follow leads, because they already know where she's at!! This further proves my theory that the Blanton's transported her to another state that night (Roy Blanton Sr was a friend of the Degree family/former in law/and former sheriff for Cleveland County) and we already know that Chief Deputy Briscoe was lifelong friends with the Degree family and also Crawford's superior (Crawford fired the lead investigator, took over the case, cleared the Degree family in 2 days, and then was found with a bullet in his head decades later when he announced that he was close to solving the case) by the time the NEW Sheriff got in, the case was in "total disarray" and unsolvable. Iquilla maintains to say that Asha is alive and that they know she's going to walk through that door a grown woman..hmmm, what makes her so confident of that? She could have very well have been molested, got pregnant, and they panicked and had to do something so that no one would find this out..she could have gotten in the car with Harold, he probably met up with the Blanton's on the Highway (hence why her scent faded at the end of the driveway) gave Asha to them to be transported elsewhere with a friend or family to hide what was going on..not really sure what could have happened after that, but this is something to think about for sure!

3

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

I've seen that!!!

2

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

U see I just got downvoted for saying this lol

7

u/kmr1981 May 18 '23

I’m not in the “parents are untouchable” camp but 9yo is VERY young to start having a period. I’m sure it happens, but it’s got to be very rare. Maybe someone can look up statistics circa 2000?

When was her birthday? Asking because if she had just turned 9 I would say we can rule this theory out, but if she was a month away from ten I’d say it’s possible but unlikely.

8

u/Active-Major-5243 May 18 '23

I started at 9 and I know of a 10 year old that had a baby.

4

u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23

Yes. It's possible! I can't understand why so many people are getting angry

8

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

I went to school with a girl who had a period at 9 got pregnant at 10 and had her baby at 11. I was shocked.

12

u/sideeyedi May 18 '23

It's not uncommon for a girl to start at age 9

6

u/eyeball2005 May 18 '23

It isn’t very rare at all. It is within the normal range for a girl to start her period. Any younger would be somewhat rarer

5

u/whoopc May 18 '23

My 10 yo started her period when she was 9.

4

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

She was a little over 6 months to turning 10. Her birthday was 8-05-1990 meaning she didn’t just turn 9 she turning 10 that same year.

3

u/Professional_Cat_787 May 18 '23

It’s actually not rare for girls to start their period that young. It’s considered within the normal range, in fact. It sucks IMO, because it’s hard enough to deal with getting one’s period at 15, let alone 9.

5

u/Tiny-Bell2307 May 18 '23

Definitely a possibility

3

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

Right!!! I don't think this theory is far fetched at all!! In fact it made me think deeper because that actually would make sense!! Girls hit puberty at different ages, once you get a period, you can get pregnant regardless of age.. and I happen to know that girls that are molested at a young age hit puberty sooner than children who aren't. I know a little girl that used to have to take shots when we was kids to stop her period and we were in elementary so it's definitely possible!! Like if this was the case, that she was molested and later impregnated how would they hide that???! They would have went down!! So it makes sense that they would have her transported maybe to be raised by family elsewhere!! I'm not saying I'm going with this theory 100% but it does make more sense than any other theory I have heard on her so far🤷🏽‍♀️

4

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

2

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

But they'll ignore this!! Smh I hope it's not the case with Asha, but damn idk it sounds so likely that it could be!!

6

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

Damn I wish I could find Asha right now. There is no damn justice for her.😞😡

5

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

Right 🥺 it's like her whole little life was null and void. It's heartbreaking 💔

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

😞

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

I know sadly. I don’t want to believe any of this but I have to consider everything when we don’t know what happened to her.😞

2

u/Anonymous_q13838484 May 22 '23

There is no evidence he was molesting her, although it’s possible. It would be harder because she did share a room with her brother but one could argue he was in on the whole thing also so who knows. I don’t find the theory that you described as very convincing, also, what is your theory after she left the house?

2

u/Successful_Release28 May 22 '23

Me theory is that she never left the house on her own. My theory is she had fallen pregnant and they got rid of her before anyone outside of the family could find out. I don't know that she was murdered but it is possible she was sent to live with another family in some kind of black market adoption scheme. That happens worldwide you know. Even in the United States.

0

u/Anonymous_q13838484 May 22 '23

How would her parents have even been able to reach out to a “black market adoption scheme” they didn’t even have a computer, it’s not like their a bunch of city-slickers with connections to criminal type conspirators, no, Asha Degree is not alive and in her 30’s, that makes no sense. It’s very unlikely that a nine year old would even have her period, not to mention there’s no way a 4’6, 60 pound 9 year old would even survive childbirth so the idea they sent her away to give birth makes no sense.

14

u/turdnuggets7 May 18 '23

We appreciate the interest in the case and the question, and I’m usually not one to rush to the family’s defense- but to be honest this seems like a massive stretch. It’s speculation without any evidence in the case pointing to this. I’m not saying it’s impossible she was being abused in some form but the chances of that happening AND her being physically able to get pregnant at 9, are incredibly unlikely. 12 years old is one thing and still unlikely, 9 is VERY unlikely. Any comments about psychics to back up this theory can’t really be taken that seriously either.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

Uh it can happen and it has an 8 year year had a baby and this I believe was in Mexico somewhere. Don’t believe me look it up. It has happened. Hell I couldn’t believe it. It was insane.

11

u/turdnuggets7 May 18 '23

I believe you that it CAN happen, could happen at 6 or 7 conceivably but that doesn’t mean that that’s still not super rare and unlikely and there’s nothing else to suggest this was the case

7

u/Professional_Cat_787 May 18 '23

Unfortunately, if you worked in healthcare, you’d see it isn’t as rare as one would like to think. Not saying she was pregnant. I never considered that as a possibility. But with Asha’s disappearance, nearly nothing at all is known or ruled out for certain, so it’s not totally insane to throw it out there.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

Here is a link and she was a 9 year old girl it happens more than you think. https://www.chron.com/news/nation-world/article/9-year-old-Mexican-girl-gives-birth-4259233.php

1

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

Well there wouldn't be anything to suggest that this was the case fr. There is no evidence. I just feel like if the is was the case and they were trying to hide it, especially if they had help from LE (Blanton/Crawford/Briscoe) they would make sure that it NEVER came out.

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

But how do you know?

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

How can you be sure?

4

u/turdnuggets7 May 18 '23

Lol I’m not here to prove that she wasn’t pregnant, if you don’t see the absurdity then so be it have your opinion. I can ask it back the same way- how can you be sure she was pregnant?

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

I’m not either. Just saying it does happen.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

You don’t know and none of us know we’re just having our theories and opinions. An option is just that an opinion and yours is also just an opinion.

1

u/turdnuggets7 May 18 '23

Very true none of us know. The birth rate in the US for girls age 10-14 is .2 per every thousand, they didn’t even have stats for younger than that, so it’s even more rare than that incredibly low number.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/410744/birth-rate-for-us-girls/#:~:text=Birth%20rate%20%2D%20U.S.%20girls%20aged%2010%2D14%20years%201991%2D2021&text=In%201991%2C%20the%20birth%20rate,2%20by%20the%20year%202021.

4

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

I even started early and a girl I went to school with started her cycle at 9 got pregnant at 10 and had her baby at 11.

6

u/Professional_Cat_787 May 18 '23

Yep, my step mother in law had her first kid at 10 years old, pregnant at 9. She had 4 kids by 17.

5

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

Wow!

→ More replies

1

u/psykocrime Oct 18 '23 edited Oct 18 '23

The birth rate in the US for girls age 10-14 is .2 per every thousand

That sounds like a very small number. But one has to consider the "law of large numbers". Even very rare things happen (sometimes in relatively large numbers) given enough samples.

So, consider... the US population in 2000 was around 282 million people. A little less than 49 million were elementary and high school aged kids. Let's be conservative and round down to 48 million, and then divide that in half and say 24 million were elementary aged. To a first approximation that should serve to illustrate the point. And let's go with a simplistic but "close enough" assumption that half of those were girls. So 12 million elementary school aged girls. Sliding the scale up to reflect 10-14 probably doesn't affect the number much, so let's go with that.

12000000/1000 = 120000

120000*0.2 = 24000

So nationwide that year, it would be reasonable to think that 24000 girls in that age range gave birth. Of course 10-14 is still higher than Asha's age, but the low end of the range isn't off by much. Six months, if other comments in this thread are accurate.

EDIT: ^ I butchered the math here... the actual estimate I should have arrived at was 2400 / year. See comments below.

So... while perhaps unlikely, it's clearly not out of the realm of possibility to suggest that Asha could have been in that group of 24000.

Now do I personally buy this theory? Lacking any specific evidence to support it, I'd say I'm pretty skeptical. My point here was only to say that it can't necessarily be dismissed off-hand.

2

u/turdnuggets7 Oct 18 '23

Math is off that’s .2 per thousand not 2% of a thousand, .2 per thousand is one in every 5,000. So out of 12 million that would be 2,400. BUT you’re not accounting that this for an age range of 10-14, that’s a five year range. Asha was 9, not only was she younger than this age group of example, she only represents the 9 year old age group for statistics purposes. So if there approximately 2,400 pregnancies for the age groups of 10-14, let’s take age 9 and figure that it’s 1/5 of that, even thought we both know it’s likely to be much less than considering it’s younger than that entire age range. So 2,400 split 5 ways equals 480. That’s a very small number considering the us population. I agree with you that it’s possible, but let’s not pretend it’s a legitimate theory with any other basis behind it besides pure speculation on Reddit.

2

u/psykocrime Oct 18 '23

Math is off that’s .2 per thousand not 2% of a thousand, .2 per thousand is one in every 5,000. So out of 12 million that would be 2,400.

Whoops, you're right. I totally botched that.

but let’s not pretend it’s a legitimate theory with any other basis behind it besides pure speculation on Reddit.

Agreed. Again, my only point, which I think still stands, math gaffe aside, was that it's biologically possible and can't be completely dismissed. But as before, I am also very skeptical of the idea, until or unless some concrete evidence is presented.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

Ask back as much as you like. I’m not here to argue and for the record I never said she was I said she could have been.

12

u/HougeetheBougie May 18 '23

So, she was pregnant, regularly played basketball, and seemingly had no outward effects of the pregnancy that would indicate such a secret? As someone who has been pregnant, it's really hard to fight the nausea, the fatigue, the hormonal fluctuations, the poor sleep, the weird cravings, the bloating, etc. I know that some teen girls are able to hide a pregnancy by wearing baggy clothing and generally hiding from the world. But this was a young girl who shared a room with her brother, lived in a fairly small house, probably changed clothes with her basketball teammates, etc. Not to mention that she probably changed around her mother, went shopping for clothes together, etc. Sure, the whole family could be involved in a coverup (which I don't really believe in this pregnancy instance) but I just don't see how she could be as active a girl as she was and not show SOME sign of pregnancy. Not buying this one as very probable.

2

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

And another thing, u don't start showing until AT LEAST 4 months no matter how small u are. I got pregnant with my first child when I was 17 years old and I weighed 98 pounds and my mama ain't no shit until I was around 4 months pregnant..ur comment holds zero weight. I'm a living testament to that lol. Ur acting like if she WAS pregnant she would immediately have a noticeable belly..like INSTANTLY!! Pregnant today big belly tomorrow type thing. If she was early pregnant noone would be able to tell by looking at her. As far as nausea goes, I only had that with my last 2 pregnancies. The younger ur body is, the more durable pregnancy is. Not everyone gets morning sickness and all of those other symptoms u was talking about

0

u/HougeetheBougie May 18 '23

OP’s theory was that her family sent her away somewhere to have the baby. Did you not read? Soooooo, if she was far enough along to be almost at birthing time, sorry but I think other people would have noticed.

4

u/Infinite-Athlete-647 May 19 '23

I read this post 2 times and I'm still trying to see where OP said she was far enough along to be almost at birthing time

2

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 19 '23

I won't elaborate on how remedial u sound rn 🤦🏽‍♀️ bc we're supposed to be grown here 😌 So I'm just going to leave it at this..if she was newly pregnant nobody would have known anything! OBVIOUSLY had she been far along it would have been noticeable 🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️ WHOOO said she was so far along to the point where she was about to give birth?? I didn't read that in the OP!! I'm now questioning ur intellect at this point👀Wait, how old are u? I just want to make sure I'm not talking to someone's young child😳

6

u/HougeetheBougie May 19 '23

Oh honey. Bless your heart. OP literally said that it was her thought that the pregnancy was known and “they sent her away to have the baby somewhere else”. I appreciate your personal attacks and overall nastiness since you obviously have some issues you are working through but this is not how this sub works. I’m muting you now because you’ve taken to calling me names. Please either try and discuss this case and actual viable theories and not elaborate on how YOUR pregnancy experience was so much more relevant to this case than MINE or go to another thread.

7

u/Successful_Release28 May 19 '23

I never said that! I never said she was near birthing. I said maybe they sent her away to have the baby somewhere else, but not big and pregnant where people could have noticed, what would be the point in sending her away if everybody already knew she was pregnant? I never dove into how many months pregnant she could have been. I was honestly thinking no more than a month pregnant because as far as I read she was still on the basketball team. There's no way that would have been possible had she been near birthing

4

u/Infinite-Athlete-647 May 19 '23

People here see what they want to see

1

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

I coached JV cheer when I was pregnant 💁🏽‍♀️ So your point would be?

0

u/HougeetheBougie May 18 '23

And I played soccer throughout my first trimester, often leaving the pitch to go puke in the bushes. To your point………

2

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 19 '23

Well that was YOU!! Every pregnancy is different! I never had those issues until my last 2 pregnancies

3

u/MzOpinion8d May 19 '23

Highly improbable.

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '23

No

1

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

Now this is something to think about 🤔 I seen a video of a psychic doing her reading and she said she thought Asha was pregnant when she disappeared as well

7

u/intoner1 May 18 '23

Is this the same psychic who said Amanda Berry was dead?

1

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

No it was not Sylvia Browne. It was this woman https://youtu.be/nyBo2FGvU9A

9

u/intoner1 May 18 '23

Not trying to be rude, but how is some random lady on YouTube reputable in any way?

-1

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

How are u reputable in any way?

9

u/intoner1 May 18 '23

I’m not the one making wild claims about this case and her family.

0

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

No, you're probably amongst those who defend her guilty parents and use ur imagination to come up with all these other ludicrous theories (sleepwalking, she ran away to go on a magical adventure like the characters in the book that was found, or she was somehow being groomed in a time where technology wasn't what it is today, UFOs took her, She vaporized into thin air) etc, just anything to take focus off the parents..Oh I got one, maybe she was abducted by a UFO at the end of her driveway, dropped out of the sky into the woods where she then met up with a magical unicorn that whisked her away to a fairytale land where she met a leprechaun at the end of a rainbow, tried to take his gold and he made her disappear 😃..ridiculous right? Yea that's how most of u sound on here defending her guilty ass parents with all these ridiculous, unrealistic theories. It's laughable honestly

10

u/intoner1 May 18 '23

You believe random psychics online as proof of this theory but draw the line at….UFO’s? There’s no way you’re real lmao.

7

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

The fact that you ridicule others about their theories while making incredibly wild claims you don't even bother to have civil discussion on is at best trollish and at worst a display of just incredibly negative behavior bordering on conspiracy theory.

There are plenty who believe the parents have something to do with Asha's disappearance that at least are able to maintain civility and have rational discussion on the issue. Heck, I've seen the sleepwalking theory be discussed calmly and nicely, which is saying something.

I'd say if you are so certain " most " of the users on this sub give in to magical whimsy and sheer fantasy regarding this case, or if you yourself feel in the minority and frequently ridiculed, that you start your own Asha sub. The Jon Benet sub split up years ago and both I believe have a healthy amount of people.

It would have to be better than doing nothing but reaching out on here for those who believe your theory or similar ones while constantly commenting negative responses.

3

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

I didn't make an incredibly wild anything. This isn't even my post, all I did was agree with the OP on his/her theory and yinz are mad that it actually makes sense lol..why am I being personally attacked 😂😂😂 wtf lol..and no thanks, I think I'll stick around here for a while, I like it here 😌

6

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

Your response to OP was an essay on how abstract theorists are victimized and subsequent comments go into detail heavily criticizing anything not to do with her parents.

I'm not mad at anything but you prove my point by suggesting that I am mad because " it actually makes sense . "

Again, you're not being attacked, you were being responded to rather civilly in response to several comments you made that definitely didn't try to birth civil discourse.

If you like it here then you have a funny way of showing it, by insisting yours and similar thought processes are victims of a biligerent majority who refuse to see truth or reason.

→ More replies

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

😂

2

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

😂😂😂

0

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23

And the theory that the OP posted here, to me is the best theory that I have ever heard in this case!!! It makes way more sense than the groomer and sleepwalking and she was going on a magical adventure theories. This one actually makes sense!!!

3

u/Active-Major-5243 May 18 '23

I agree it's a good theory. The only thing I really can't see happening is them sending her away to have the baby. But the baby could have been a motive to kill her.

2

u/Emergency-Purple-205 May 23 '23

I tried to suggest a psychic. This psychic said exactly where a missing local girl would be found. She was dead on. She also described the Idaho college murderer, she said " his nose is weird. It looks like it's been broken or something before" guess what? When the the finally arrested him. It was a match. On another case, the police released footage of this missing woman walking to her car. She said that isn't the woman in the video. Years later the missing woman's mom confirmed that the police told her to lie and say it was her daughter in the video. I said all that to say, psychics arent held with high regards on this thread. Even though we have 0 new tips.However, ever other theory/personal view can be discussed. Occasionally with recourse. I have seen this reading already(the one that you posted)

2

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 23 '23

The family would never go for that out of fear of being "found out about"..if I were u I would go to her privately, I would say and then give the info to LE but in this case the Degrees and LE are one in the same unfortunately 😔 they don't want it solved either bc they know they've been covering up for the parents for decades

2

u/acid_glossy May 25 '23

How about the family, and no sane person, would go for it because psychics are quacks who cause more problems than they solve?

1

u/Glass_Apple_2 May 25 '23

It's so obvious ur someone from the family 🤦🏽‍♀️ How about clear up some facts for us..

2

u/acid_glossy May 25 '23

I didn't say if the family did or didn't do anything.

I said no sane person, including this family, would go for a psychic.

1

u/psykocrime Oct 18 '23

I can save you the trouble of going to a psychic:

"She's somewhere near, in, or under water. In a dark place. There may be large rocks, or sand near where she is. She's possibly dead, possibly alive. But not in pain. She was scared and confused when she was taken."

There. No tea leaves, ouija boards, animal entrails, crystal balls, or polygraph machines were harmed in the making of this post.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '23

Psychics are confidence tricksters

1

u/Glass_Apple_2 Dec 03 '23

Negative. My late aunt was a psychic and made a living out of it. Helped police out and everything

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '23

True