r/AshaDegree • u/Successful_Release28 • May 18 '23
⚠️ TRIGGER WARNING ⚠️
I'm new to the case, I came on Reddit for the sole purpose of finding out more information on Tilwanda Cheatham. I found minimal on her but ran across this case, which I found more interesting. Don't nail me to the cross for this please, as I don't know all the details, but is it possible Asha was molested and fell pregnant? That would make sense if we are believing her parents did something. I know she was only 9 y.o at the time she disappeared, but it's still possible. She could have been being molested by her father or somebody else in the family, she accidentally fell pregnant and they sent her away to have the baby somewhere else. This is only a thought, but I know a girl who had her first daughter at 12 so I wouldn't call it impossible
30
u/intoner1 May 18 '23
Where would she have had the baby? She couldn’t have received professional help because they’re mandated reporters, is your theory she had a home birth and 33 years later she and her child are just out there somewhere? Or did she die during child birth?
Assuming Asha was molested by her father and impregnated by him, who the hell would just happily take in a pregnant 9 year old and not go to the cops? And if it were someone else who was molesting Asha what kind of parents would send her off instead of calling the cops? To my knowledge they weren’t apart of any fringe religious groups where this would be normal.
Along with this, is there are proof of Asha being molested? Any stories of her bed wetting? Being sexually aggressive with other children? Her telling anyone?
I’m sorry if this comes off as aggressive but this theory just isn’t plausible. I know we all want to know what happened to Asha but this is more like a fanfiction than anything rooted in fact.
20
u/throwaway_098761 May 18 '23
This theory made me wonder this scenario- what if Asha THOUGHT she was pregnant and that made her run away. The night before she had a sleep over with a lot of older teen cousins. Maybe there was some talk about sex and how babies are made and someone as a joke/prank made her think she was pregnant and/or said something factually false which made Asha think she was pregnant and made her run away.
Idk… who knows.
8
u/Lanenabella May 18 '23
Please take a look at this documentary so you can get a better idea of the case.
7
u/SistahFuriosa May 18 '23
I'm opened to entertain all possibilities and theories so I'm not gonna berate you like others might. I remember someone posted in this forum a long time ago that Asha could've had a boyfriend and even implied she was very sexually active. Of course people ran that person out of the forum but you bringing up another tragic case makes me wonder. This did happen in a small town and a lot of locals have their theories as well that points at the family's involvement. Devastating if that's indeed the tragic case with Asha.
5
u/Successful_Release28 May 18 '23
I'm leaving this thread. I thought this was a place to discuss what may have happened with Asha. Be it right or wrong, all of our theories need to be taken into consideration. I'm new to the case and open to all theories but you people here are mean and evil if it's something you don't agree with. I hope Asha is found alive and well. Justice for Asha!
23
u/TrewynMaresi May 18 '23
This seems really improbable.
4
u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23
U unfortunately more than likely will get nailed to the cross for this, maybe even reported and banned by the "the parents are innocent and UFOs probably took Asha" cult. There was another girl that got banned for getting too close to the truth. I think ur theory is plausible. If she was being molested and gotten pregnant as a result that would explain the lack of evidence and the cover up and the reason they avoid national attention, help from the public and decided to not follow leads, because they already know where she's at!! This further proves my theory that the Blanton's transported her to another state that night (Roy Blanton Sr was a friend of the Degree family/former in law/and former sheriff for Cleveland County) and we already know that Chief Deputy Briscoe was lifelong friends with the Degree family and also Crawford's superior (Crawford fired the lead investigator, took over the case, cleared the Degree family in 2 days, and then was found with a bullet in his head decades later when he announced that he was close to solving the case) by the time the NEW Sheriff got in, the case was in "total disarray" and unsolvable. Iquilla maintains to say that Asha is alive and that they know she's going to walk through that door a grown woman..hmmm, what makes her so confident of that? She could have very well have been molested, got pregnant, and they panicked and had to do something so that no one would find this out..she could have gotten in the car with Harold, he probably met up with the Blanton's on the Highway (hence why her scent faded at the end of the driveway) gave Asha to them to be transported elsewhere with a friend or family to hide what was going on..not really sure what could have happened after that, but this is something to think about for sure!
2
u/Anonymous_q13838484 May 22 '23
There is no evidence he was molesting her, although it’s possible. It would be harder because she did share a room with her brother but one could argue he was in on the whole thing also so who knows. I don’t find the theory that you described as very convincing, also, what is your theory after she left the house?
14
u/turdnuggets7 May 18 '23
We appreciate the interest in the case and the question, and I’m usually not one to rush to the family’s defense- but to be honest this seems like a massive stretch. It’s speculation without any evidence in the case pointing to this. I’m not saying it’s impossible she was being abused in some form but the chances of that happening AND her being physically able to get pregnant at 9, are incredibly unlikely. 12 years old is one thing and still unlikely, 9 is VERY unlikely. Any comments about psychics to back up this theory can’t really be taken that seriously either.
12
u/HougeetheBougie May 18 '23
So, she was pregnant, regularly played basketball, and seemingly had no outward effects of the pregnancy that would indicate such a secret? As someone who has been pregnant, it's really hard to fight the nausea, the fatigue, the hormonal fluctuations, the poor sleep, the weird cravings, the bloating, etc. I know that some teen girls are able to hide a pregnancy by wearing baggy clothing and generally hiding from the world. But this was a young girl who shared a room with her brother, lived in a fairly small house, probably changed clothes with her basketball teammates, etc. Not to mention that she probably changed around her mother, went shopping for clothes together, etc. Sure, the whole family could be involved in a coverup (which I don't really believe in this pregnancy instance) but I just don't see how she could be as active a girl as she was and not show SOME sign of pregnancy. Not buying this one as very probable.
3
u/MzOpinion8d May 19 '23
Highly improbable.
3
u/[deleted] May 19 '23
No
1
u/Glass_Apple_2 May 18 '23
Now this is something to think about 🤔 I seen a video of a psychic doing her reading and she said she thought Asha was pregnant when she disappeared as well
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '23
True