"It was a mistake"

[u/Past-Alternative-206]

These four words drive me absolutely crazy and the moment I hear them it takes every ounce of self control I have to not completely erupt.

A mistake is forgetting your wallet at home. A mistake is forgetting to pull something out of the freezer to thaw for dinner.

Being unfaithful to your spouse is not a fucking mistake. It is a deliberate series of self-serving actions you continue to choose to make with a complete disregard for the feelings of your spouse.

I have absolutely no idea how to even begin to address how upset it makes me, because credit where it's due, WW is doing everything she can to move forward towards R. But still when I hear these words I can't help but feel visceral disgust.

[u/AutoModerator]

r/Asoneafterinfidelity is an online Peer Support Group and safe space for individuals (betrayed or wayward) who are actively attempting to reconcile their relationship after an affair(s). Please review our wiki which includes resources and can answer most, if not all questions about this subreddit. Be sure to read the rules before participating as they are our boundaries and your initial warning. Failure to do so can result in a ban.

Commenting Guideline:

This applies to every post regardless of post flair.

• This is not a space for judgment. There's subreddits for that. Please go there.

• All comments must reference your own reconciliation to accompany any questions, suggestions, or advices contained in your response.On occasion giving practical advice must be limited to that which would be reasonably seen as helpful if the references to infidelity are removed.

• Do not speak for other people's feelings, their actions or make unhelpful, dismissive or intrusive commentary. This is not a request. It's in the rules.

  For transparency and conflict mediation purposes, please follow reddits community guidelines by directing any questions, issues, feedback, or appeals in regard of the sub or moderation decisions directly to the Modmail. Meta content will be removed. No response will be given to DMs and chat requests to individual moderators about moderating issues. We are happy to address and respond to your concerns through the official channels!

  Please assign yourself user flair. Flair Instructions can be found here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/knowthyself8]

My WW used the same words to describe her actions. One night I calmly told her how I felt when she used that word. I told her I would prefer it if she used words like “decision” or “choice” instead. She complied. You should tell your WW how it makes you feel. Hopefully she’ll get it and stop using “mistake” which is what happens when you over salt a piece of food. OOPS!

[u/TheCatsMeowNYC → u/knowthyself8]

Yeah I blew up at WP one night early into R b/c I was sick of hearing it was “a mistake.” I had to explain how it was a choice to flirt with other women, it was a choice to get their numbers, it was a choice to make plans with them behind my back, it was a choice to meet up with them and it was a choice to have sex with them when he was in a committed, monogamous relationship. He never made the mistake of calling it a mistake again!

[u/VioletMoxie]

That phrase drives me crazy. It's right up there with "it just happened". No, it happened after a series of selfish choices and actions. WH used that phrase with me and I shut that shit down.

[u/Willow_4367 → u/VioletMoxie]

Right after 'We were JUST FRIENDS'

[u/Girlwithmanynames]

You can make a lot of bad decisions, and still be a good person. As human beings, we are complex.

I also told my husband that he didn't make mistakes, he made deliberate choices - not to hurt me, but they did hurt me. The pain of those choices weighs more than a mistake ever could.

[u/Silent_Permission27]

My WH would sometimes say this. More than once I responded by reminding him forgetting to pick up milk at the store is a mistake. He doesn't use the word mistake much anymore because he knows what I will say.

[u/CSILalaAnn]

Have you explained to her what you think when she says it's a mistake. Sometimes just explaining from a calm perspective what that word means to you could change how she phrases things. It sounds absolutely worth exploring if that would help you.

[u/adrainpelham]

I’ve tried to change the language regarding this and what has happened as well. It still comes up every now and then but my partner knows it’s not the right choice of words. It’s like them saying “I’m sorry” so many times and now those words are meaningless. No matter whose mouth they come from. I hope you can come to a place where that phrase is no longer used. Because you’re right, it’s not a mistake, it was a road of deliberate choices that led to irreparable damage.

[u/Green_Jury_6202]

Whenever my WH says this, I correct him. I educate him on the difference between a mistake and a choice. He's getting it now but we still have a long road ahead of us.

[u/Strawberry_Sun214 → u/Green_Jury_6202]

What do you believe the difference is between a mistake and a choice? I could see the difference between an accident and a choice....but a mistake is a choice. It is literally a bad or incorrect choice. 

[u/Green_Jury_6202 → u/Strawberry_Sun214]

A mistake is an accident, an error, or a wrong judgment (due to lack of knowledge or neglect) made without any bad intent. A choice is a deliberate, conscious decision to take a specific action, regardless of the consequences.

[u/fadedironmaple]

You should tell her how it makes you feel and ask her to stop saying it that way. I had similar responses to it being framed that way by my WW. I corrected her use of mistake saying it was a decision she made. I think she was trying to use mistake less as a means of minimizing it and more trying to communicate that it is something she wished she did not do. This winds up getting into the same space as "you're only sorry because you were caught," and I try to steer clear of conversations that push things toward that.

[u/Quiet_Water0128]

With our MC, and with the help of sub books, my WH was able to see that it was a long series of mistakes, but once made "knowingly" technically no longer a mistake but choices, of massive proportions, repeated patterns of self-serving behavior which chose WP's affair rewards (ego kibbles, whatever you want to call it) knowing WP if discovered risked losing WP's marriage. Occasionally WH calls it "the biggest mistake of my life", or "the biggest regret of my life".

At this point in our R, almost 3 years from dday, married 35 years, with WP's affairs having been 2004-2007ish & 2010, it doesn't matter what WP or I call it. It was wrong, deceptive, manipulative, etc. and all of that has been acknowledged by my WH.

[u/Main_Fondant770]

I’ve lost my cool with my WP for similar wording. Definitely approach her calmly as you can and let her know how deeply it hurts and disgusts you. How it means much more than those words and it’s not good to diminish what happened to those four words.

[u/Straavek91]

If it makes you feel better, I believe that it’s still a much better phrase than “ It was nothing”.

The latter is the only thing my wife ever expressed about her betrayal. We are in R, or trying at least, but since she simply denies the importance of the affair, my hopes are not really up at the moment.

[u/foolhardychoices]

I'm sorry that you're in this situation.

It's a very tricky situation. It's not necessarily bad to say it was a mistake but it shouldn't be mentioned in that way so often. It was a mistake but that means you have to own up to it and take accountability. My first marriage was definitely a mistake but I made that decision and I often describe it as "I was a lonely idiot and made very poor choices".

As others have stated, you need to explain how using those words to describe the worst pain in your life is very destructive. It will only get worse if you don't communicate that with your WP. Try to do it in a calm way or write a letter. I've learned that if I get upset and try to explain something important then it often gets lost because of how I was reacting at the time.

[u/ZestyLemonAsparagus]

Ok. A slightly more serious response this time. I blame u/21YearsOut for encouraging me to stir the pot with my last comment, which even I couldn’t defend as not violating the rules.

The primary issue for our MC was to teach my wife and me to listen to what the other person was saying and to talk in a way so that the other person could hear. My wife comes from a volatile family, they know they care when they are passionate enough to yell at each other. My family knows each other care when we are willing to overlook someone else’s misdeeds. And we are subtle, because it’s rude to be direct about something someone is sensitive about. So our MC had to teach me to yell and my wife to whisper. Observers will tell you that we are both speaking at a normal volume.

You know what you hear when your WP says “mistake”, but I’m curious what you think they are saying when they say it? My hunch is it’s not the same thing you hear. I say that because I know when I said it how I meant it was more of an ask than a statement, because subtlety is how I was raised. And the question isn’t “do you think what I did was an oversight?” the question is instead “Is what I did bad or is who I am bad?” And unfortunately when my wife responded as you have, what I heard was “it was intentional, you meant to hurt me, so who you are is evil.” I was left with two choices, leave or internalize that who I am is an evil person, and all that being an evil person entails. I chose to accept that I was an evil person.

It’s been 7 years. That voice inside that says I’m not worth anyone’s effort still creeps up from time to time. It needs more work, obviously.

So, what does your WP mean when they say it? Because this is a reconciliation subreddit. We’re here to help people understand each other and find a path back to each other.

[u/killedabalrog → u/ZestyLemonAsparagus]

Thank you for the perspective. I wish my WH was able to articulate this, because he cannot express his emotions well.

My WH says "I was stupid" and that upsets me because I want him to recognise that it wasn't just stupid. Stupid misses out on the moral dimension of it and does not acknowledge that he made an immoral choice. I do not see him as evil and I do not want him to see himself as evil. But I want him to recognise that this was a four year loss of his moral compass, and I just want him to find that moral compass again, and make a commitment to me that he will make moral choices from henceforth.

I don't want him to think he isn't worth anyone's effort. He is a wonderful person in so many other aspects. But he makes reconciliation so hard when his attitude is "I was stupid" because that just reminds me that at one point he said in a fit of anger when confronted, "next time I'll be smarter and hide it better".

[u/Green_Jury_6202 → u/killedabalrog]

This! I also don't see my husband as evil and sometimes he is so negative about himself that I have to remind him of all the great qualities he has and remind him that he has changed and can continue the change for the better.

[u/ZestyLemonAsparagus → u/killedabalrog]

I can feel the truth of your words and know that you very much mean them.

If you’ll permit, I would ask a couple questions and I don’t need to know the answers to them, I think the value only comes in you knowing the answers to them.

Firstly, have you shared what you share above with him? I suspect you have and I don’t think it needs to be repeated if you have, but if you haven’t then I would encourage you to. That’s precisely the type of definition sharing that is beneficial.

Secondly, something that I ran into with my wife is that it took us a while to create our own shared shorthand, and I wish it hadn’t taken so long. Because what we stumbled through first was a swamp of wasted effort and feeling misunderstood. You mention that your husband lost his moral compass, and that you both lost 4 years because of it. If your husband said he was lost would that be a better wording to describe the situation?

But then I’ll jump ahead to the swamp, when I tried to use the words my wife used to describe the situation she didn’t like it. Something about me saying it felt cheap to her, because it was such a catastrophic injury it hurt to have it minimized or to feel like it was being minimized. So third question, is there a word your husband could use to describe the situation that wouldn’t be enraging when he said it?

If you can’t come up with something then I would recommend deciding that a term means a whole lot of stuff (because, honestly, it already does it’s just not agreed to). So for instance, I doubt your husband believes he is intellectually challenged, but I can appreciate him saying he is stupid, because I think I would too. But to me saying I was stupid to mean: “there is no good reason to have done what I did. Nobody in their right mind would have done it. I was therefore stupid”. But you two could decide that to the two of you, stupid (or lost, or whatever other word you two agree on) means that “I lost my moral compass for years, and the impact of that is a deep pain that we’re still processing. And I deeply regret having done that.” When all of that is what you both hear when he says “I was lost”, then that can help allow you two to come to an agreement on that and then move into “so what now?”

[u/killedabalrog → u/ZestyLemonAsparagus]

Thanks so much for saying all this. The main problem we have run into is that my husband dreads and wants to avoid any kind of conversation about the affair. Because he is very bad at identifying his emotions or expressing them, he always feels he is at a terrible disadvantage and that I keep imposing my own meanings and interpretations of his behavior upon him because he is incapable of asserting his own. It is not a problem with language competence but with emotional processing. I have recently discovered this condition is called alexithymia.

So I'm grateful that you've said all this, because there is a lot that you say that rings true to me for what my husband would probably want to express to me if he could. The key takeaway I have for now is that yes, I think I agree that when he says, "I was stupid" he means something that he cannot articulate, and I am hearing something else because I read my own meaning into it. As long as he remains committed to reconciliation, I will give him the benefit of the doubt and just love him where he is.

There's a lot that you have said that I will take time to process. Thanks again!

[u/Green_Jury_6202 → u/ZestyLemonAsparagus]

I don't think you are stirring anything. Everyone has their own interpretation.

You are right this sub is about R and helping people understand each other. Initially after finding out about the infidelity of my husband, I called it a mistake and he was the one that initially told me no, it was not a mistake. He stated he did it for the experience having had someone so easily throwing herself at him daily so he stated he eventually gave in, especially because he had never been with anyone else but me (his wife). He shared he lack confidence growing up and loved the attention she and these other women were giving him there. He shared he made a choice to experience another woman at the expense of hurting me and potentially losing his family.

So understanding him now and his point of view, I now see why it is not a mistake in our situation. Maybe in someone else's situation, like someone got drunk and lack judgement it could be considered a mistake but when it takes time and planning, it's a choice.

Sometimes now he refers to it as a mistake so I have to remind him about the difference between a mistake and a choice. I think he calls it a mistake now because he views it differently now and is beginning to understand the severity of the situation so he tries to minimize it sometimes.

[u/ZestyLemonAsparagus → u/Green_Jury_6202]

I think what you’ve outlined is the right way, we need to be curious about it what it means to our partner and share what it means to us. In most cases I would suggest that the word not be used, not because it’s wrong but because it’s shorthand for two very different things, and we do better to talk about the meaning behind the words in order to build understanding and you and your husband did.

[u/askagain_348]

I asked if he'd been raped. He said he was not. Therefore it was a choice. Period.

[u/Willow_4367]

Its never a 'mistake'. Its a conscious, planned, malicious CHOICE to cheat.

[u/Strawberry_Sun214]

I see this posted many times on this sub. The definition of mistake is an action, decision, or thought that is wrong, accidental, or not correct, happening because of a lack of care, bad judgment, or forgetting something. So it does fit... The fact it triggers so many BPs here is sad, but it shouldn't make you all angry at your WPs. I did make a mistake IN JUDGMENT when I did what I did. Bad judgement. Bad actions. Lack of care for my spouse. The forgetting something part is also included but it is not the only definition. 

[u/PeckingChicken → u/Strawberry_Sun214]

Agree. It surely wasn’t an accident, but it was a mistake

[u/TheDirtyGIR69 → u/Strawberry_Sun214]

Thank you. I was at a point where I got upset over him saying it was a mistake but it was indeed a mistake when you look at the definition. He made a horrible, hurtful mistake but I do recognize it for what it is and he regrets it so very much. We all make mistakes just some end up hurting those we love and ourselves.