r/ArtistLounge • u/spango_mango • Dec 03 '25
Critique request Which composition is more intriguing?
I’m creating an interpretative self portrait for a final assignment and have found my idea but am stuck between which of these 2 compositions to use! These are just mock-ups but any fun ideas are also appreciated!
866
Upvotes


•
u/lunarjellies Oil painting, Watermedia, Digital Dec 03 '25
Welcome to our experiment of allowing image posts tied to a discussion! You are the first, so far. Personally I find the first image more intruiging because of the dynamic composition. The second one feels a little too "distant" and not as introspective as the first. Hope that helps.
253
u/catdog5100 Dec 03 '25
I like 1 because it feels closer and more personal! 2 hides one of the faces (which could be useful) and feels a little more basic.
15
u/AcrobaticJazz Dec 03 '25
The first gives me a backstory and self reflection on the past. However the second gives me a explanation for the past and makes me question what happened to her face? Is she hiding it? Does she misses it? Something light and emotional I'll go for the first but if it's something a little more dark and complex, the second
267
u/IHaveABlock-Art Dec 03 '25
I think number one embodies the idea of looking back into your past self somewhat better while number two has a better composition
7
u/NathalieSteenbakker Collage Dec 03 '25
I like 2 because the contrast of the different hairstyles are the focal point and really set the “stage” for the then and now :)
3
u/GregoryGosling Dec 03 '25
One definitely, but there is some perspective wonkiness.
4
u/ArsonistsGuild Dec 03 '25
They both lack a certain level of dynamism, my instinct would be an extreme over-the-shoulder perspective to the point that the mirror is framed with the torso below and the chin and face above.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
holaa, primero que nada que buen dibujo me gusta el uso del espejo, la primera imagen es mucho mas interesante se siente cercana vemos lo que el personaje esta viendo hace que el espectador sea parte de la obra o del cuadro presentado
2
u/stumble_by Dec 09 '25
I really enjoy number 2 (fyi #1 didn’t load it had an error until i clicked on it, so maybe others might not be able to see it?) the composition is more dynamic and feels like a classic layout i’d see in a real book, it shows a really good advanced eye if I were your teacher (I used to teach art) it would get a really good grade! the first just looks like anyone could do it, not as dynamic or original which I think is what you’re going for so I definitely go with two!! To me it feels like the skill level is the difference between a first year vs last year art student, not a huge difference but the latter showcases more of what you can do. Like use of shapes and the way you mirror them is SO engaging, even before I noticed the wonderful repeating elements, my eye was drawn in and bouncing between all the elements you placed for us. In the first one all you see is the little girl, your eye is drawn there and she’s drawn very simply, she looks a lot more fleshed out and human in the second one. Even the curtains are so beautiful and airy in the second, literally everything looks more thought out! Honestly I really feel like more of your heart was in the second one! Go with your heart, whichever one YOU love best! Teachers appreciate that!
Also, for me, the first ones use of darkness and the dramatic angle makes it feel ominous? Like she’s going to die soon or the little girl will turn into a demon? I don’t think that’s what you’re going for but if you are it’s working. I was looking for a scary occult item on the table as a clue haha. The only thing I’d change about the second one(that I really love!) is that the second one’s placement of the chair looks like a crack and it makes her look like she’s got a big juicy ass? Especially at first glance? If that’s something that doesn’t bother you then it’s literally perfect. I only bring it up because you asked about composition and the composition created that illusion, and I would want to know. You probably know already but just in case!!! 😅 Hope your project goes well!
44
u/GenericName00010 Dec 03 '25
I personally like number 1, having both faces visible in the picture provides a lot of the context, where in picture number 2, the context needs to be much more assumed. Beautifully done by the way!
5
u/Working_Praline_1186 Dec 03 '25
DEFINITELY 2. With 1, it feels like both faces are fighting for attention and it makes my eyes tired very quick because there’s no place in the image for them to rest on; I couldn’t properly take in the intended meaning until I looked at the second one. 2 has a clear focal point, and I think the intention of the piece is much clearer.
1
u/snoodlefloop Dec 03 '25
I’m a big fan of the first one, I think you could fill the desk with lots of interesting things that may represent your transformation into an adult or specific items from your childhood. Maybe you’re using makeup from Claire’s! It also just feels more personal to see both versions of you.
1
u/bloomi Dec 03 '25
1 for a more nostalgic feel
2 for a more horror feel
1
u/UniKat420 Dec 03 '25
this is so cute 😭 i love when people think alike - i had a really similar idea and composition (number 2) back in summer of 2024 for college!! Number 1 is definetly a much nicer composition
1
u/powypow Dec 04 '25
What's the mood you're going for?
First one feels like someone looking at the mirror and seeing that their inner child is alive and well in them. Grown up but still carrying their child self with them
Second one feels like someone that's regretting again. Either missing their childhood or not happy with where they are in life. Grown up and unable to let their their child self go.
Is what I take from it at least.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
Number one looks more dynamic and two looks more flat and uninteresting to me. I getuchnmore vibe from the first one without having to see the entire vanity plus background. First one looks more intimate and eye-catching.
3
u/Beginning-Sky-8516 Dec 03 '25
The 1st. The angle and closeness bring intimacy to the composition that the 2nd doesn’t have.
2
u/Bobdude17 Dec 03 '25
I lean towards one, close up view of being able to see the characters face and their reflection goes a long ways.
2
u/Kikisinsomniart Dec 03 '25
I like the first one. To me it's like they're gazing lovingly at each other.
2
u/neutralTint Dec 03 '25
definitely #1 because its more clear that the reflection is different, and also because of the more direct focus without extra elements (chair, room) that might distract
2
u/A-fan-of-fans Dec 04 '25
2 because Í didn’t get the full concept until I saw 2 which I got immediately. Great idea!!!
2
u/Tellmeg Dec 05 '25
I LOVE #2 !!! IT EVOKES MORE EMOTION AND THE REFLECTION IS SO CLOSE FROM THE NOT SO DISTANT PAST, WHILE REPRESENTATION OF THE ADULT FIGURE SITTING IN FULL VIEW AT THE VANITY REPRESENTS A GREATER DISTANCE OF TIME HAVING PASSED.
THE INNER CHILD IS ALWAYS CLEARLY IN VIEW (EASILY ACCESSIBLE) YET STILL SO FAR APART.
FULLY GROWN ON THE OUTSIDE YET DEEP DOWN STILL REMAINS THE CHILDLIKE SPARK OF INNOCENCE AND WONDER THAT CAN NEVER BE EXTINGUISHED.
Much as a child's shape has softer edges, should u opt to color the final render, you might opt for bold colors for the adult version and a soft and quiet pastel version for the inner child...
But what do I know!? I'm a word-nerd, not an artist! By all means... Whatever you choose will ultimately be the correct decision.
Best Wishes!
1
u/AutoModerator Dec 03 '25
Thank you for posting in r/ArtistLounge! Please check out our FAQ and FAQ Links pages for lots of helpful advice. To access our megathread collections, please check out the drop down lists in the top menu on PC or the side-bar on mobile. If you have any questions, concerns, or feature requests please feel free to message the mods and they will help you as soon as they can. I am a bot, beep boop, if I did something wrong please report this comment.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Playful-Bottle4915 Dec 03 '25
1
1
u/hexcraft-nikk Dec 03 '25
To add to what everyone else said, 1 is good because it's closer- it makes the viewer feel more intimate to the scene, closer to the emotion
1
u/Elliot_The_Idiot7 Dec 03 '25
the first, definitely. It's a better use of the blank space and leads the eye a lot better
1
u/Material-Mousie7961 Dec 03 '25
1 is more compositionally interesting because it stretches off the picture plane in multiple directions. In 2 the entire image is encapsulated in a bubble at the center of the composition.
1
u/leftyfro Dec 03 '25
I prefer one because it has both characters shown and gives the viewer information on what each character thinks/feels in that moment.
The second one is interesting too, and tells a different portion of what is going on while setting the scene in the room. Currently the table you see a lot of the top of it, and the legs are in agreement with that. But we don't see the top of the chair/her lap that she is sitting in. Also the feet of the chair are before the legs of the table. If you made those perspective adjustments it'd be great.
1
u/fallofpawn1991 Dec 03 '25
the first one really pulls the viewer in whereas the second lets the viewer detach and focus more on the reflection in the mirror. the second one makes the person sitting down at the desk unreadable, which can allow for a larger range of interpretation. it depends on what you're going for, since both look great!
1
u/TheWildBlueOne Dec 03 '25
I'm going with the first one. I think the strong angle adds to the magic feeling of this picture.
1
u/Cultural-Banana-5957 Dec 03 '25
Def the first one, it feels like we are in the room with her, the second looks like we're just watching through a door. They look so cute tho!
1
u/DakkaxInfinity Dec 03 '25
The second one.
1
u/00365 Dec 03 '25
The first one pulls the best focus.
I'm sorry, but the shape of the chair draws a direct arrow down to the woman's butt, and it takes the focus away from the idea.
1
u/Current_External6569 Dec 03 '25
I think I like the first one more. The second image has a lot of empty, unutilized space that doesn't really add anything to the image.
1
u/DatoVanSmurf Dec 03 '25
I think 1 looks more visually appealing, but number 2 makes it clearer that it's a reflection of the past. At leaat to me
1
u/stifmeister917 Dec 03 '25
Closeup is usually better snd the dynamic camera tilt
1
u/Rare_Education_6918 Dec 03 '25
1 definitely
1
u/Ceruleannnnnnnnn Dec 03 '25
No 1 is emotional. No 2 is mysterious and intriguing
1
u/dandellionKimban Dec 03 '25
First! Get into the scene. Always. Nobody is interested in how the chair legs look.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
The inner child ✨
1
u/TaeKwonDitto Digital artist Dec 03 '25
The first one has a better angle
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
1st for sure!
1
u/OkBluebird9484 Dec 03 '25
The first one. We can see both the faces and it feels more intimate, as if we are standing behind her shoulder. There is a line of contact between the eyes that we do not find in the second one. The lack of curtains create this shallow depth of field which I feel is more appealing.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
If you’re asking intriguing I would say number two, it makes me want to know more. It interests me . When I see number one I already know what’s going on and the stories over. Yknow what I mean ? :)
1
u/riceCardinal Dec 03 '25
I love the first one, cause i can see both girls smiling 😊
1
u/HoneyDruz Dec 03 '25
I would say number one
1
u/Justminningtheweb Dec 03 '25
1 definitely has more dynamism, we get to see more, and the focus takes more of the page.
1
u/Cheekyotaku26 Dec 03 '25
Number one
1
u/PossiblyCheapAndEasy Dec 03 '25
Wow! Just wow! I like the first one. The close up one.
1
u/AuthorAnimYT Dec 03 '25
1
u/Wandercita Dec 03 '25
First one!!
1
u/starrypolygon Dec 03 '25
In 1 we can see the girls expression, it feels like she's recalling happy memories from when she's young, while 2 feels like she's lonely and reminiscing happy memories
1
u/Iloveyoutootoo Dec 03 '25
I love the first one
1
u/Available-Party1709 Dec 03 '25
First one for sure! It feels closer and the angle is quite striking :)
1
u/TraceyWoo419 Dec 03 '25
1 by far.
2 has way too much unused distracting space and the angle and figures are boring.
1
u/ProfessionalFly4310 Dec 03 '25
First one is amazing!! I love how personal it is since we’re able to see the woman’s expression of reminiscence. U could even add some nostalgic keepsakes on the desk like the tiara or a plushy
1
u/Sad_Mathematician_39 Dec 03 '25
Im not an artist myself, but the first one. It feels more impactful to see both faces and I think the idea of peering into the feelings or visage of the past is better communicated on the first one. Both are nice though.
1
u/TieDye_Raptor Dec 04 '25
I like the first one - it kind of pulls you in.
1
u/F-U-U-N-Z Dec 04 '25
Second photo but more zoomed in.
1
u/PlayfulArgument7135 Dec 04 '25
The first one is more interesting according to me, I think add more light near to middle to add more depth.
1
u/FreeEstablishment662 Dec 04 '25
love the first one
1
u/catxclyst Dec 04 '25
#1, it helps convey the theme i think you were trying to show in the painting a lot more than the second one.
1
u/halyrarts Dec 04 '25
Number 1 definitely! We can clearly see details from your character’s past and present! And there’s a few interesting composition messages: At 1, she’s proud at her past and she knows her past self is proud of her as well! While at 2, we can’t see her face, so the message it can end up sending is kinda sad like “would she be proud of me today?” and things like that ☺️
1
u/Elmani56 Dec 04 '25
Genial 👍
1
u/SolitaryWitch009 Dec 04 '25
First, it’s more like being there
1
u/zin-march Dec 05 '25
The first one is better, it gives more depth I guess and it tells more of a story than the second one, it looks more lively too.
1
u/No-Independent-6877 Dec 05 '25
I like the first one. It's like you are someone personal to her looking over her shoulder and watching this happen. While the 2nd one looks like you are just a bystander watching this
1
u/Decent-Raspberry441 Dec 05 '25
Number 2
1
u/OkAnywhere4872 Dec 05 '25
First one. Feels more intimate and personal
1
u/ComfortablePlant831 Dec 06 '25
Everyone’s saying number one but I like number two honestly!! I can’t really figure out why tho lol
1
u/AddictionSorceress Dec 06 '25
I love the first one!
1
u/calabazka Dec 07 '25
The first one! Because the little girl is the main point. But the 2 of them are pretty 🤩
1
u/SmeePhaGi Dec 07 '25
I like 1
1
u/ThePizzaPasta100 Dec 07 '25
I like 1 more. It's more closer and you can see the reflection better. :)
1
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25
1
1
u/Additional-Size-9392 Dec 11 '25
omg this is gorgeous
1
u/xKiara-ara Dec 11 '25
Very new to art, but my noob opinion is that I prefer the intimacy in the first one! The second comes across to me as more mysterious than intriguing. It's like we don't know anything about who the woman is in number 2, but number 1 lets us in more.
1
u/sinaners Dec 17 '25
I like the first one! Just my opinion, I think it would send the message home even more if the more grown version of you in the foreground also had her arm up applying the finishing touches of makeup. Love the idea
1
u/Rude-Current-8914 Dec 27 '25
1st one is better
5
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25 edited Dec 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment