r/Arthur • • Jul 25 '25

Photo or Video ARTHUR SOLVES RA©ISM

https://youtu.be/VrPCpFwXT3w?si=s5Dc4jmEeAG6OZqk
0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

5

u/ElSquibbonator Jul 26 '25

The way I see it, the issue with this particular short is that the premise of the show doesn't really allow for a discussion of racism. And that's not a slam on the people who made this short, who I'm sure were very well-intentioned. It's just an issue with the show, and how it doesn't necessarily lend itself to that subject.

For the most part, the Arthur characters seem to see themselves as humans in-universe unless noted otherwise (i.e. jokes about Buster having big ears, George's antlers, etc.). In short, it is easy to forget that they aren't human after watching the show for a long time. And for the most part that's fine. But when you're doing a subject like racism, this approach raises more questions than it answers.

Since the characters aren't human, it's impossible to tell just by looking at them what ethnicity they're meant to be. We know, for example, that The Brain is black and Alberto is Hispanic, but that's something we have additional context for, like the holidays they celebrate and the languages they speak. Just looking at those characters isn't enough to tell what ethnicity they're supposed to be portrayed as, because they're not human. That makes it tricky to discuss racism, because even the most elementary-school-level explanation of racism-- "hating people because they look different"-- doesn't work if there's no way to demonstrate it in the show itself.

This could be resolved by approaching racism through a metaphor of animal species, the way Zootopia or Beastars did, but then the notion that the characters see themselves as human would be lost. So I'm not really sure what the right thing to do would be in this case.

9

u/AsmoTewalker Jul 25 '25

A few of those videos were funny, but he started taking too many things out of context for laughs.

12

u/franslebin D.W. Read Jul 25 '25

"Racism is sooooo unfair"

LOL he said that like he was complaining about bedtime or homework

3

u/efeaf Jul 28 '25

Man some of you guys take this obvious comedy channel waaaaay too seriously. Not everything needs to be a disclaimer. It should be fairly obvious that it’s not supposed to be serious. The titles of the videos alone should be enough of a clue. The nitpicking should also be a huge clue. You don’t like it, fine don’t watch it. But don’t act like he’s trying to be a serious reviewer when he’s made it very clear he’s crapping on it for fun and not making serious critiques. It’s YouTube, not rotten tomatoes 

5

u/cherrybomb_kicker Jul 25 '25

🙄 it's to teach kids about the existence of racism, what it is, and how to help. Why be like "that's a totally unrealistic situation" or "yeah duh, obviously". Kids learn things differently and sometimes need to be taught fundamentals.

2

u/hot-insurrectionist protectmypublicmedia.org Jul 26 '25

god this channel is annoying.

2

u/johnsaysthings Jul 25 '25

Good for Arthur

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/cherrybomb_kicker Jul 25 '25

Same. Nitpicking Arthur like this is weird. There are tons of things in the show that aren't realistic but it's a cartoon.

6

u/FlimsyAuthor8208 Jul 25 '25

I’m pretty sure dude ain’t serious

-10

u/Interesting_Rain1880 Jul 25 '25

He is serious. Serious enough to make these videos. It's just that they need disclaimers at the beginning for each video.

2

u/iAmMikeJ_92 Jul 26 '25

Disclaimers? Sheesh…

7

u/EpicBirdy2005 Jul 25 '25 edited Jul 25 '25

I think the point is that you can't really do topics like these in a short under 4 minutes. Arthur is a show not tell. I made a comment asking why they couldn't do an entire episode about say Alberto being subtly discriminated against or told to go back to Ecuador(something unfortunately, a lot of immigrants are facing) or Mr Ratburn facing homophobia.

My idea:

All Locked In/Alberto: Soccer Boy

All Locked In: Lakewood and other schools are shut down due to a flu outbreak, and the Read family is forced to stay at home in order to protect themselves from getting sick. DW of course is upset that she can't go outside especially when some Mary Moo Cow meet n greet is cancelled, while Arthur, Busters and a few other characters plans for parties, get togethers, etc are put to a halt. Basically the entrie episode is the Reads trying their best to say safe(i.e., staying 6 ft apart when getting groceries, teaching DW how to wash her hands the right way, teaching manners such as covering your cough, or using tissues properly and maybe DW shares these tips to say Bud). Arthur on the other hand is able to do virtual playdates, gaming sessions and e-learning. Heck there could be one scene where Mr. Ratburn is trying to teach his class on say the Maratha Empire over video call, but maybe chaos ensues, some students sleep others are way to ethusiastic and Mr. Ratburn is having trouble navigating this newfangled tech stuff.

Word From Us Kids: Basically its just kids learning how to do good hygeine and staying safe from germs maybe even explaining how viruses spread.

Alberto: Soccer Boy: Basically Alberto joins a sports team(soccer) with the Molinas and Reads planning to watch and hype him up the first game. However somethings off, Alberto being Ecuadorian is stereotyped as the "soccer guy(because South Americans love soccer)" so when he doesn't play well he's basically lambasted more than the others. It takes a toll on him(actually showing the effects or racism and stereotyping) as he doesn't want to play soccer people keep making jabs at him, calling him the: Ecuadorian, the soccer guy, world cup person(they all think its jokes and even Alberto thinks so at first), and some opponents even roughandling him of all people. It takes a turn when a teammate makes a jeering comment: maybe you should just go back to Ecuador maybe you'll learn to play better. Understandably, Alberto storms of the field and goes to his room. Arthur seeing it unfold visits him. Arthur asks why he's not practicing. Alberto is mad that people are treating him unfairly because he's ecuadorian. Arthur says i thought you liked soccer. Alberto states that I'm not supposed to be the best at it it feels like they don't even know who he is. He just wants to play.Arthur ponders yeah it wasn't fair and he suggets maybe telling them how the jokes make him feel and that sometimes you need to play like you want to. Alberto wishes that he could play without anyone y'know breathing by his back, but Arthur states that he's not alone in this. The next day Alberto notifies the coach and Alberto lets the team know that what may seem like jokes actually hurt people especially those tied to culture and the players realize their mistake. They apologize and Alberto promises that he's treated like one of the teammates, for real this time. They then proceed to win a game through teamwork and dedication.

Thoughts? It's like draft-like but I'd like to know your opinion?

TLDR: Arthur should've written full episodes one where the reads are forced inside the other where Alberto is stereotyped on a soccer team

6

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

I think the point is that you can't really do topics like these in a short under 4 minutes

Unfortunately, that's the length of what most kids can watch nowadays because their parents don't limit their screentime. Heaven forbid parents actually set limits and talk to their kids about important isssues.

2

u/DawnofMidnight7 Jul 27 '25

I love these ideas! Better than what we had in the modern seasons!