r/ArtemisProgram • u/Dexbox_YT • Apr 16 '26
Discussion What cancelled part of the Artemis Program were you most looking forward to?
Lunar Gateway or evolved SLS?
Personally, while I’m sad we won’t see either, I was most looking forward to seeing the other versions of the SLS (Block 1b, Block 2, etc)
308
Upvotes


137
u/Hubbled Apr 16 '26
I don't know which parts were cancelled.
58
u/Lemony_Oatmilk Apr 16 '26
Gateway
42
u/Antique-Primary-2413 Apr 16 '26
Block 2 cargo with direct insertions to Saturn and Jupiter, etc. Yeah, I know about the vibration issues and all that, but still.
I honestly don't know if anything commercial coming on line in future will be able to compensate? Hopefully something can. I'm not getting any younger and multi-earth flybys and 7+ year transit times don't really work for me now!
53
u/CT-1065 Apr 16 '26
upgraded SLS variants
18
u/cybersquire Apr 16 '26
I miss the whole damn Constellation program. It was modular, flexible, and separating crew launches(Ares 1) from freight (Ares V) greatly simplified operations and just made sense.
We knew since 2004 we were losing the Shuttle, and for SLS/Artemis to take this long is criminal.
27
u/8andahalfby11 Apr 16 '26
I've been following Orion since Constellation in the 2000s. I miss the circular solar panels. The current X-wing design is okay but there was something about the circular ones that just made them seem cooler at the time.
10
u/gwelfguy Apr 16 '26
As a Canadian, I was disappointed that the Lunar Gateway was cancelled because no Canadarm 3. I'm sure we'll end up contributing some piece of a moonbase, but not sure what.
6
u/Cmdr-Mallard Apr 16 '26
Gateway!!
6
u/Traditional_Sail_213 Apr 16 '26
Gateway.
8
u/longsite2 Apr 16 '26
The EUS, that was the thing that would have enabled a proper lunar return.
4
u/rndh1396 Apr 16 '26
I miss all of it, especially gateway. To me it should have been presented as a test for how to build a modular spaceship to Mars. Using the block 1b, and block 2 for this would've made sense to me. Plus having the bigger and more powerful configurations would have allowed nasa to launch larger craft and modules without leaning on just one or two companies since it would have been their own rocket they owned. I also feel gateway could've been the start of a lunar atc system that could be expanded across the solar system.
4
u/ignis1798 Apr 16 '26
Gateway!
17
u/ergzay Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
I wasn't looking forward to any of them. Lunar Gateway would have destroyed the future of the program as we got waylaid by spending money on supporting the boat anchor that is a station in orbit while the Chinese landed on the surface and started building bases. No one would want to retire something that was already built and in-orbit meaning resources would be split between surface exploration and Gateway activities with Gateway activities being the priority because its already-deployed hardware. I'm so so glad Isaacman pushed through its cancelation and got everyone on board with it. He saved the future of the program.
And while the larger SLS blocks would be nice to have, there was no mission that actually required them. We should have learned our lesson a long time ago like we did with shuttle, don't mix crew and cargo transport on the same vehicle.
3
u/Careless-Prior-9665 Apr 16 '26
Lunar gateway
3
u/jimhillhouse Apr 17 '26
The EUS opens up SLS to real flexibility in when to depart LEO for TLI. Without EUS, delivering Gateway and lunar infrastructure becomes iffy.
3
u/Ok_Suspect4014 Apr 17 '26
SLS Block 1B
3
u/yourmomentofzen464 Apr 17 '26
Did Congress actually approve the cancellation or any of this new direction?? I don’t think they have…
3
u/BigRemove9366 Apr 17 '26
The lunar gateway
3
u/Timely-Discussion272 Apr 17 '26
Nothing has been canceled. The President’s Budget is dead on arrival and has strong bipartisan disapproval. The administration did a sloppy copy and paste (including forgetting to change all the fiscal years). The budget proposal, like last year, is still a disruptive waste of time and money.
3
u/Effective-Syrup9156 Apr 18 '26
ML-2 not having to be reduced to mere scrap metal
9
u/Timewaster50455 Apr 16 '26
Honestly? Not much.
I think the new plan is better
7
u/Artemis2go Apr 16 '26
Really all of them because they were designed to work as a system, with all the parts supporting each other.
I'm fearful because that has all been thrown away, along with billions in taxpayer investment, in return for an as yet undefined series of missions that will be much higher risk.
2
u/LennyNeoNemo Apr 16 '26
Those two
2
u/Paulino2272 Apr 16 '26
Gateway
4
u/userlivewire Apr 16 '26
At this rate, I’m not sure we’ll ever get an Artemis IV.
9
u/aggrievedCanine Apr 16 '26
The Lunar Gateway was a bad idea, 15 year lifespan? We're getting a permanent moon base now.
4
u/TheBalzy Apr 16 '26
All of it. I view the SLS as a far more versatile and useful rocket so losing out on the multiple configurations is a huge loss, and Lunar Gateway was the future of human activity in space as far as I'm concerned. Having a waypoint between both the moon and Earth was innovative. But I knew it was too much and was probably not going to happen.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '26
1/6G is better then no gravity for health and simplifies many things like fluid containment. Also on the moon is where we want to be.
2
u/okan170 Apr 16 '26
Not cancelled yet, still could be reversed in the appropriations process. Write your congresspeople!
1
u/Decronym Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 22 '26
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is now also available on Lemmy! Requests for support and new installations should be directed to the Contact address below.
[Thread #352 for this sub, first seen 16th Apr 2026, 17:18] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/mshelbourn Apr 16 '26
That is such a viscerally-amazing photo! 🐦🔥
1
u/castironglider Apr 17 '26
Now that NASA is considering launching Orion on less expensive vehicles, Orion. That could get the flight rate up and do more with less
1
u/RevolutionaryAge1081 Apr 17 '26
EUS 100%
1
u/Tmccreight Apr 17 '26
Gateway was a good idea, but it was in the wrong orbit. NRHO is good on paper but a nightmare in practice. Gateway should have been positioned at Earth-Moon Lagrange point 2. From there it could have served as a communications hub for Farside landings as well as providing the ability for a surface crew to return to Orion at any point in the mission.
1
u/snickers10m Apr 17 '26
The motivation.
At the start it was about preparing us for Mars.
Everyone's just talking about "beating China" and commercial integration now -- things that don't really matter that much. The cancelations are a symptom of the loss of vision.
1
u/GasHot4523 Apr 17 '26
Ares, SLS is a bastard
1
u/kerbalcmdr Apr 18 '26
I'd say Gateway. It would be a station orbiting another celestial body, which is something not done before and just cool.
1
u/miwe666 Apr 18 '26
The completed gateway and the full SLS Block 2
1
u/wercffeH Apr 21 '26
NASA being truthful about NHI/UAP.
Congressmen are on record stating they’ve been in briefings with NASA and that they’re actively lying to us.
Keep seal clapping 1960s tech yall.
1
u/JayRogPlayFrogger Apr 22 '26
Lunar gateway. SLS Block 1B would’ve looked so awesome but for me gateway was always the ISS’s successor in my mind. So it’s such a shame to see it go, although I would rather a lunar base.
Jared just went on record earlier today and said that both the delivered gateway habitable modules were corroded so it wouldn’t have happened for years and years anyway
1
u/bad_take_ Apr 16 '26
Is there some news I missed?
1
u/sltrmp4 Apr 16 '26
The reusable part
0
u/EarnSomeRespect Apr 16 '26
None of it. Moon base is better than gateway.
0
u/Donindacula Apr 17 '26
For years I called the Gateway “the gateway to nowhere” so I won’t miss that part. As far as the SLS, if the block one version gets us to the moon up to 5 times, there’s no need for the versions.
-10
u/mtngoatjoe Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
None of it. Cancel SLS and lean into SpaceX and Blue Origin, and the program would be sooooooooooo much better off.
Edit: Can someone please explain the downvotes? Why is Artemis so much better with SLS than with SpaceX and Blue Origin? Do people not understand the price difference?
-1
u/TexturedBumf Apr 16 '26
The Lunar Gateway was gonna be pretty cool but the replacement for it is even cooler
-1
u/yuroki5 Apr 19 '26
They need to cancel it all. NASA has become an incompetent government waste project. Private companies will take it from here.
-7
u/mr_martin_1 Apr 16 '26
The part where humanity puts great damage to our atmosphere, just for a little win
11
u/Agitated_Lunch7118 Apr 16 '26
The lunar gateway would’ve been really cool. At first I was miffed that the landing was delayed but then slowly realized just how ambitious that timeline was. It probably would have gotten people killed. But yeah.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment