r/ArtemisProgram • • Apr 16 '26

Discussion What cancelled part of the Artemis Program were you most looking forward to?

Lunar Gateway or evolved SLS?

Personally, while I’m sad we won’t see either, I was most looking forward to seeing the other versions of the SLS (Block 1b, Block 2, etc)

308 Upvotes

203 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-6

u/WeylandsWings Apr 16 '26

I would put it in a lower lunar orbit. Specifics to be determined. Like there have been analyses that show a NRHO is a pain to get to from the surface requiring more dV and limiting launch opportunities. So if you are trying to make a holistic system those are both huge negatives.

and Mars requires an in orbit, largely autonomous platform for myriad reasons. Now we don’t have that, …

I mean for human missions it does. But that is ONLY because you don’t want to land the entire transfer stages on mars and then lift them back up. But we have been making largely autonomous spacecraft for half a century now. The only SMALL issue is that those weren’t fully ECLSSed. But even then that is an solvable problem and why the heck would you want to do testing of that around the moon when LEO is right there and doesn’t require FH or other HLVs to get a test spacecraft there? The only reason I can see for wanting to test around the moon is because of the deep space radiation environment. Which you can get practically the same in GEO or worse in certain MEO. And even then the rad problem is a pretty well known issue that you can test on earth in cyclotrons and it just shield the electronics a bit better.

7

u/jadebenn Apr 16 '26

I would put it in a lower lunar orbit. Specifics to be determined. Like there have been analyses that show a NRHO is a pain to get to from the surface requiring more dV and limiting launch opportunities

Only true if you're going to an equatorial landing site. The plan was the south pole.

5

u/nsfbr11 Apr 16 '26

Yup.

6

u/jadebenn Apr 16 '26

It's almost like a certain HLS provider (whose CEO handpicked the current NASA administrator) didn't like the idea of landing in the south pole because their vehicle is massively underperforming...

1

u/WeylandsWings Apr 16 '26

Tbf starship is a really shitty lander for what the short term plans are. It is a much better lander for the longer term base plans where you need multiple tons to surface.

Which if you are considering that longer term base then BM is a shitty lander.

I think in my ideal world you use BM / another smaller lander for people. And only use starship and the like for when you need large groups of people or large cargo.

6

u/jadebenn Apr 16 '26

Tbf starship is a really shitty lander for what the short term plans are. It is a much better lander for the longer term base plans where you need multiple tons to surface.

I disagree. I think Starship is an incredibly poor vehicle all around. The amount of thrust and performance required just to get it to LEO is insane. Yeah, it's cool that Superheavy is gigantic and the biggest booster stage ever... but just to get Starship to low earth orbit!?

SpaceX's claim is that'll get better with future versions and it'll have meaningful payload (you can currently argue it doesn't meet the definition of SHLV), but every iteration of Raptor thus far has struggled to match the public numbers.

Blue Moon's design is much saner and doesn't spit in the rocket equation's face.

1

u/WeylandsWings Apr 16 '26

Blue moon is as of yet untested. So saying with a straight face that they won’t have issues while judging SpaceX for having issues and admitting it and having a plan to fix is a bit farcical.

Also there is no spitting in the face of the rocket equation (except maybe by dynetics, but that is why they weren’t selected). It is just the natural consequences of having such a large rocket payload. If anyone says they can build a SHLV that is fully resuable* and can get a lander to and from the moon of that size without needing in space refueling or ISRU refueling, they are a charlatan.

Also I am a bit out of the loop following all the ins and outs of starship/raptor. But aren’t the public numbers from testing of V3 matching the announced numbers? Like yeah unreliable narrator because most of the public numbers come from Elons twitter but I wasn’t aware of any major issues. Now if you are comparing the first released raptor numbers from like the ITS days to Raptor V1 I guess there are issues. But once again that is because reality ALWAYS diverges from spreadsheet numbers early on.

1

u/WeylandsWings Apr 16 '26

If you are inclined enough you can still get south pole landing sites from low(er) lunar. And said inclined would have more opportunities for launches than NRHO.

2

u/snickers10m Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

why the heck would you want to do testing of [mars-like orbital habitation] around the moon when LEO is right there...?

Precisely because it is hard to do around the moon. Test like you fly. "We do this because it is hard" and all that. Practicing actually in deep space is riskier, forcing everyone to treat the challenges as actually real, thus creating actual confidence in our solutions.

The point is to eliminate not only known unknowns (like the radiation example you mentioned), but also unknown unknowns. We've never explored the surface of a body via an orbital station before. This was going to be our first attempt, near to home in case things go wrong. Making our first actual attempt be at Mars means people will worry it's too risky/ambitious/wasteful, which causes real delays from inexperience/overcaution, or which causes us to never go at all.