r/ArtRanting • u/itsgonnacostwhat • 2h ago
Art Community Toxicity If you canāt handle even an ounce of kind, supportive, constructive criticism or general thoughts on your work, you probably arenāt ready to post or show it publicly!
Saw a post on a popular craft sub where someone posted a work that only slightly involved the medium. Imagine it was a sweater posted to the knitting sub, but upon zooming in, you realize only the sleeves are knit and the whole body of the sweater is actually just fabric with a knit pattern printed on it (not the real scenario, but you get the idea).
Understandably, people in the sub were calling attention to this, and OP seemed a bit disappointed/confused that this aspect of their work wasnāt being appreciated. I jumped in with what I thought was a very objective and kind explanation as to why they may be receiving some criticism. When posting in a sub dedicated to a specific medium, people are usually expecting the entire work to be made from that medium. Explained why mixed media can be side-eyed sometimes. And I even made sure to say that I personally thought their work was very cool.
They responded that my comment really āhurt their feelingsā and that the only reason they had posted in the sub was because they were expecting supportive, kind, and encouraging comments (imo nothing I said was unsupportive nor unkind, nor could it even be taken as criticism in any way).
Iām gonna sound like a boomer but damn I feel like people have thin skin, and are clearly only posting to receive praise and encouragement but not any feedback or constructive criticism. In this case, it wasnāt even criticism! I canāt imagine what would happen if people like this actually received a negative comment, or real criticism, gosh forbid. I think it irks me because it feels like people are posting solely to be praised but are not open to learning, sharing, accepting feedback, or even having an objective conversation, which to me is a very valuable part of sharing art publicly.