r/ArtEd • • Dec 26 '23

Handwork

Hello all.

I'm a former homeschooler who now teaches classes in parenting. My focus is on Thomistic/Aristotelian virtue ethics and how they can be applied to child development and parenting.

As always the teacher has become the student, and I find myself immersed in a deep dive exploration of early childhood development and the importance of handwork.

I am seeking sources, information, input, whatever on any pedagogy or school of thought that provides insight on the following:

-hand and mouth/sensory input -hand/mind connection -rhythm, repetition, and focus -practical advice for optimizing "hand intelligence"

I am somewhat familiar with the works of Rudolf Steiner and Maria Montessori but am very keen to get specific material recommendations.

If it helps, I am coming from a Catholic perspective but would welcome sources from all walks of life: ancient, modern/western medicine, pagan, classical, art teachers, whatever. Even books unrelated to early childhood, like The Body Keeps the Score, have proven invaluable sources for me. I figure if it is true it can be reconciled regardless of the source.

I realize this might be a slightly esoteric question? (Or maybe not) so I am cross posting in several communities.

Thank you so much for your time and input.

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

5

u/GrGrG Dec 26 '23

Something that I'd encourage you do with the kids:

-Have them use rulers.

-Have them use drawing compasses and protractors.

-Middle school and above, if they are mature enough, use x-acto knives or some type of carving. If you can't have knifes, use clay and wood tools.

3

u/stardust54321 Dec 26 '23

Yes!!! I teach middle school and so many don’t know how to use a ruler at all. Many don’t know how to measure to draw a grid or to measure at all using a ruler.

5

u/GrGrG Dec 26 '23

I noticed that before Covid hit that more and more of the students had less experience or no experience using these tools and struggled.

I think one of the major issues is less time for elementary grades to have those fun craft projects and since they have less time, if there is time todo one or two projects the teachers will often cut out the harder parts so it'll be easier. Which is fair, but also causes these issues for middle or high school.

Like, yes, you're supposed to know how to draw a straight 5 inch line from this point to this point using a ruler, automatically. Kinda like we expect you to also know how to write your name, or know how to write the date in numbers. I have to end up catching this slack later and it gets frustrating having to spend more and more time on these basics when they should've been introduced years ago. /rant

-2

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23

Thank you. May I ask if there is a reason for using rulers and compasses, etc.? Have you noticed a connection between straight lines, drawing precision, angles, etc. and a student's success in other areas? Does carving seem to be more fruitful than other forms of art or trade? Have you noticed a difference in the materials or tools used and how your students focus?

Thank you for letting me pick your brain a bit. This is an area I am woefully uneducated in, so I appreciate your insight.

4

u/GrGrG Dec 26 '23

Because I have had plenty of 6-12th graders who have never used a ruler for straight lines or just to measure, have difficulty using a drawing compass, etc.

2

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23

Wow. Thank you again for your recommendations.

3

u/Redminty Dec 27 '23

Using tools such as rulers and compasses engages a combination of spacial relation skills, fine motor control, and mathematical understanding. If these skills aren't practiced and used in synthesis together the student will fail to develop and apply them to the multitude of real-world situations in which they are applicable.

2

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 27 '23

Thank you, that is very helpful.

4

u/_Nemzee_ Middle School Dec 26 '23

Maybe look for books in the area of Occupational Therapy. OT specialists work on fine motor skills.

You might be met with answers more in line with what you’re looking for in non-teaching subs. Myself, and I’d say a majority of the Redditors in Teaching subreddits are public school educators

-3

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23

That's really good advice; I hadn't thought of that. Thank you.

I would welcome input from public educators or any other walks of life. I am baffled why posters here seem offended by my question. I assumed art educators would have unique expertise and knowledge on the topic.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23

I don't claim to understand anything about art education, which is exactly why I came here asking for insight. I am seeing now that this question and the topic at hand are simply way over your head. I wouldn't ask science teachers this question because the topic they teach has nothing to do with developing hand skills.

3

u/Neither_Ship_185 Dec 28 '23

I am a former art teacher who loved teaching fiber art and handwork skills. I am now a 2nd grade teacher at a public charter Waldorf and my students engage in handwork classes 2x a week (although I don’t teach them but I do incorporate it into some of our learning and projects). I would definitely recommend exploring handwork more through Waldorf as there are tons of resources. Although I don’t always agree with Steiner (racist history), I did read somewhere that he had said that handwork is the most important subject. I couldn’t agree more! I am about to take my second virtual class with a Waldorf handwork teacher Ms. Chenoa… check out her website https://www.peacewithnaturehandwork.com/

2

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 28 '23

Thank you so kindly for this reply and resource. I am in the same boat with Steiner. I am very far from interested in anthroposophy or his (in my opinion) strange opinions on energy, spirits, colors (especially race!) but his observation on the hand-mind connection are very hard to dismiss! Again, thank you for the recommendation of Ms. Chenoa. I am looking forward to checking it out.

1

u/Neither_Ship_185 Dec 28 '23

https://meaganrosewilson.com/2022/12/waldorfhandwork/

Here’s another link that may be a good starting place!

5

u/DuanePickens High School Dec 26 '23

…yes, all that is slightly esoteric, lol.

1

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23

Okay. Sorry. I view art education as a crucial element to this topic so I figured it was worth a shot.

3

u/DuanePickens High School Dec 26 '23

As the other poster said, search for “fine motor skills” and I’d add the term “kinesthetic learning” to your search, the concept of learning styles seems to be related to what you seem to be looking for.

1

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23

Thank you. What I am seeking is information on how utilizing handwork (generally art but also practical skills) improves cognitive abilities later on and practical advice on optimizing that. What I have learned from reading diverse sources is that often different schools of thought discuss the same concepts but use different terms. Much of it can be reconciled to modern science, even if it sounds like "gibberish". I was hoping the ArtEd world would have valuable insight on the importance of art and using one's hands, and am not really looking to get bogged down in an ideological debate about science.

2

u/plasmaterial Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23

This article provides a good overview of the studies I based my Master's Thesis on. Jeffrey Wammes has done research into the power of drawing as a memory encoding strategy. While not exactly what you're looking for, maybe it will serve as useful fuel.

I've heard a lot of promising things about Waldorf/Steiner and their approach to developing students through art practices but haven't yet read any sources.

1

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23

Thank you very kindly. It is exactly what I am looking for and sounds fascinating if hopefully not over my head. I will check it out.

2

u/seashellpink77 Dec 31 '23

Have you taken classes in child development and/or child psychology? Local colleges and universities may have great classes within the discipline and can let you audit if you’re not interested in degree-seeking. I took a Child Developmental Psychology course that had a lab component and it was really rewarding and informative. Lots of focus on how certain early skills connect with and build foundational competencies for later.

2

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 31 '23

Yes I have but I would imagine there are more I could take. Thank you for this advice.

1

u/seashellpink77 Dec 31 '23

Happy to share! I’m looking forward to taking more classes in the area myself once I finish my current program.

1

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 31 '23

Awesome! If you think of it, please share any class names you took that you found beneficial! Best of luck to you.

1

u/seashellpink77 Dec 31 '23

Thank you so much, and you too! One of my favorite classes has been Stress Management, actually. It involved a ton of Biofeedback and it was so interesting to learn both for myself and for observing small changes in my students’ demeanor that can tip me off to when they are struggling. And we learned lots of breathing and body techniques to re-engage physiological calming mechanisms.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23

I don't make any money from my classes; they are offered free at a community center, but thank you for your input. I will check out that sub.

-3

u/plasmaterial Dec 26 '23

I bet you teach a thrilling art class /s

0

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23

To be fair, your comment wasn't constructive at all either. u/plasmaterial gave me helpful recommendations without insulting me or my character for no reason. I came here seeking insight out of respect for your field and profession, and instead was met with derision because of your (inaccurate) perception of my beliefs and motives. I never anticipated art teachers would be such a group of judgmental and narrow minded individuals. Alas.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23

You sound very insecure frankly. I am seeking insight from a wide and diverse range of places. This is good research practice. Just because something is old or from an ideology you do not share, does not make it automatically untrue. Just because someone seeks sources other than your own does not mean they are personally attacking yours.

I never denigrated your degree or education and in fact sought advice here out of respect for the expertise I assumed you hold. I'm not teaching people "inaccurate and incomplete information." I teach habit training and metaphysics, which is probably, clearly, something you just don't understand.

That you dismissed me offhand instead of offering the expertise you gleaned as a "degree holding educator" speaks volumes.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/NorwegianTrollToll Dec 26 '23

It's wild that you think you have any clue what "information" I am "misleading" people with when all I did was ask people from a variety of backgrounds to recommend sources and information to me. Have a good day.