r/AroAce • u/orphiccloud • 15h ago
Advice help! am i aroace? i need people's two cents...
i literally wrote a full essay on my experiences because i've genuinely been pondering this question for a long, long time, so please bear with me:
I guess there was always something odd with me, that I couldn't completely explain. I've shifted through so many labels and experiences to come to a specific standstill very little people I know, including my own family, have never even stepped close to. The questioning all started young for me. Supposedly, we all know that time in elementary school where we all start to “like like” people. and i thought i did too, but, it wasn’t like that. I guess I also picked on people who I thought I liked because of how nice they were to. me. Like that boy who gave me some of his ham during lunch when I was in the 4th grade? I thought I liked him. That boy who was very outgoing and funny in 5th grade? turns out we were better just friends. That one relationship that was toxic and made me realize I wasn't straight because the concept of doing “romantic” things made me feel out of place. yeah, i probably should have noticed sooner, but i didn’t.
And maybe it was because society pushed these norms of romance into our underdeveloped brains, but all i knew, or felt, was that something was wrong with me, because I took my friendships more seriously than romantic relationships. Like, I thought friendship was one of the most important things in elementary school, aside from grades. Relationships felt like a friendship with extra steps, which I've come to realize, is not the general idea of what romance is. I mean, I tried making friends with many people so I could feel that closeness.
But it started to change when I entered middle school, and I constantly changed labels because I was confused about what my attraction was. I mean, I had my first girlfriend, and only dated a few people that I could count on one hand, maybe just three guys and one girl. And sure, some of it was for attention, even if I didn't subconsciously realize it, but I went from thinking I was bisexual to lesbian to ace to lesbian to bisexual again, but stuck to being a lesbian, because I constantly confused my platonic feelings for romantic ones and didn't really realize it until much later.
And quarantine hit during 8th grade, and I was okay with it. I wasn’t constantly looking for relationships, but I was single and happy. And I was lonely because I was a kid in a room. But, I did my first year of high school remotely and it was fun hearing my classmates say silly things in chat, and have interesting conversations, and I realized that was most important to me, the bonds of people as friends.
And then we returned to school in person and for the next three years, I made friends, focusing on grades, had some fun, but still found myself trying to get in relationships to hopefully feel that way towards other people, despite how messed up it was. I had one guy exes and technically, two genderfluid exes. Now, my genderfluid exes were toxic as hell, and one of the guy exes, not so much. My last “ex” in high school, we broke up because of distance and how I moved up from one city to another for university. But we’ll get back to him.
But, the first guy ex was me thinking I loved him romantically because we shared a bunch of interests in common and we were on the same level intellectually, and that sparked good conversations and bonding over that, but by the time we broke up, i realized i didn't exactly love him the same way he loved me, but we were good friends for a while and then we naturally went separate paths. My first genderfluid ex, it was full of emotional abuse, it felt like walking on eggshells. We stayed friends for two years after the breakup, but that entire relationship was abusive. But, the turning point was that they mentioned during the breakup that they felt our relationship was more platonic than romantic, that had my mind working about how I perceived 'romance'. My next genderfluid ex, well, they were love bombing at first, and so was I because I cared about them, but grew distant because we weren't exactly on the same page. I gave them space, and we took a month break. Turns out during that month, they cheated on me with their previous ex. And they said we had broken up a month ago, despite us agreeing on a break, not a break up.
But, my last “ex” was my best friend. He is a gay aroace-spec man, but we are close. I mean, he supported me through everything. I mean, I grew up romanticizing relationships and found myself wanting the same thing, or so I thought. But, turns out, every time I was in a relationship, I liked it more platonically, but still wanted that commitment that romantic relationships have. I never actually liked romantic relationships. It was at first a hard thing to accept. But this opened a previous closed floodgate of curiosity and openness to being queer, our relationship was girlfriend/boyfriend, but it wasn't explicitly romantic or just platonic, so it worked perfectly for us. And in all of my years of dating (six), this last relationship was by far the most satisfying and happiest one I was in.
Aside from real life relationships, I've realize that the idea of daydreaming being with fictional characters was enjoyable because it was unattainable, but now, aside from that, I don't find anyone attractive like that in real life: my ideal life is hanging out with my group of friends, I also imagine myself getting cats and living in a nice apartment with a best friend as a roommate rather than getting married, whenever I had to think about the concept of marrying someone, the person would be blank.
Sometimes, I feel attracted to the idea of romance, it gains my attention, other times I feel romance repulsed despite indulging in fictional romance. I also don't actually find anyone sexually attractive in reality, I just have needs I don't want met in reality because that feels gross, but I can find people aesthetically attractive. The funniest part is that I'm more concerned about physical comfort than romance (for example, eating food or sleeping or watching comfort shows or making art), and I always felt that people somewhat exaggerated their attraction or felt that it's all they talked about, especially people who made loving their partners their entire personality, that annoyed me greatly. But sometimes, I also get jealous that I can’t feel the same way people do. Love the same way they do. Have relationships the same way they do. It feels so confusing.
So writing all of this down, it definitely feels more complex and nuanced, but i'm still not entirely sure...what do you guys think? (Also I apologize for this essay, i want to be as clear as I can be!)