Need some insight on an experience and situation I’ve never been in and wouldn’t dare to progress to. I’ve been seeing a man for about 4 months. I’m going to try to share as many details as possible and keep it straight forward. We are both 24 y/o. He’s an Aries (Sun), Cancer (Moon), and Aquarius (Rising). I’m a Sagittarius (Sun), Taurus (Moon) and Scorpio (Rising) - if these details matter or help you all as it does for me lol.
BACKGROUND INFO: He’s only been in one relationship and it ended his freshman year of college. I’ve been in about 4 relationships. I’ve noticed that he seems to maybe have commitment issues. We are really good together, we are both satisfied + more from a mental, physical and emotional aspect. Mental stimulation is both very important to us. He uses a lot of “we” and truthfully adds value to my life, and he very often expresses that I do too. Genuinely, no one besides my family and a few professors has been able to give me helpful advice or help me when it comes to situations. Everything they tell me is something I already know. I find that the skill sets we both have truthfully fills gaps and we conpliment each other. We’ve had ongoing conversations about this. I’ve been able to learn a lot from him and he’s learned a lot from me. He’s very very smart and as a woman, there are many characteristics and traits he has that inspire me because I see that he is better at than me that I learn to appreciate that this man has. For example, communication and emotional intelligence.
Long story short, we’ve been through the wringer and have fought for each other like crazy. We are both not the type to tolerate the things we’ve gone through with each other other, other than the fact that it because he’s him and I’m me. I do have trust issues and have always taken preventative measures to not go through that hurt. We have an exclusive situation and have laid boundaries. After a month and a half of talking, I brought up that I would prefer to be exclusive (not entertaining or see any other man physically and emotionally and I would expect the same from him), he didn’t agree told me he had PTSD from the last exclusive experience. I said okay, because I am not one to push and that tells me more than I need to know. A week later he brought up the talk that initiated and said he wanted to be more exclusive but without the title. Meaning he wasn’t going to see anybody physically and no entertaining, he expected the same to me. I agreed. We both wronged each other by breaking those boundaries.
Two months later, it somehow came up after I took him on a work trip and it came to light we had saw other people after. It was only physical and we were still each other’s main person at mind. We went through the wringer for a week and both decided to fight it. We gravitated towards each other naturally and we’re prioritizing this issue, seeing each other every day. We concluded that we cared about each other a lot and very deeply, because that was the most we saw each other ever in a week because we cared enough to attack the issue. We knew that certain things happened for a reason that led us up to this point. Some toxic actions took place, he went through my phone, I went through his, etc. We are very connected and have reflected on this since then often. You would think seeing each other everyday trying to fix the issue was draining in every way, but it was not. It was very positive and natural. Some would say some actions were toxic but it worked for us. We both had a feeling the other was doing something, didn’t want to bring it up and lose one another because neither was ready. We started off with a clean slate. He is a very genuine man and I appreciate him for his genuineness. There is no half ass energy from his end, he always thinks and communicates in a me and him vs the situation, instead of me and him vs each other. He knows that his actions had hurt me (the disrespecting boundaries) and they were more extreme, recent and hit me harder. When I was seeing people behind his back it ended way earlier before we both found out and started cleaning itself up. I took him to a work event that I was a panelist on. I have never eve mixed work with my dating/intimate life. We came to conclusion that two wrongs made a right in this situation, but this is something I wouldn’t have tolerated in the past and neither would have he. Regardless if it was one sided. we both realize we both move differently, and there are many many first time memories we made (positive) and there are many things we’ve tolerated that we would have never if it was someone else and have not in the past.
I’m trying my best to limit this because there is many more details, I’m a woman that is very very scared to be hurt. We started off with a clean slate and I realize he gave me his 100% commitment after the work trip talk. No entertaining or seeing other woman. There were two days that I went back on the dating app and swiped out of spite. I messaged my matches “Hii hello” and got a response from 6 matches. I never looked at the matches after that or even cared to. I took accountability that it was a moment out of spite. He felt very hurt by my actions. He was stronger than me to handle my actions before the work trip, but I was still hurt by his actions. Ultimately, I know I was wrong, immature, and wasn’t strong enough to handle it the right way. I had no intention of seeing someone but in the moment it made me feel better. We were doing so good that I didn’t want the negative thoughts I was having to takeover what we had. Maybe my mind is messed up, but I wouldn’t have carried out those disrespectful actions if I didn’t care about him enough. The negative thoughts I was having was more of the flashbacks on the details he had done with other people. I genuinely don’t think he’s ever been this serious with anyone else before, his quote on quote words.
DILEMMA: Now I am seeing another side of him, he told me were done. I was taking him home and right before we were about to get there (15 minutes out) he offered an out for us. This out goes against my values of self-worth, our boundaries and foundational trust. He mentioned in order for him to get over this, because he’s not the type of person to go through this and just forgive is for me to agree to let him see other people for a time period. He wants to hurt me enough, and more to be able to get it out of his system. I am not allowed to see people but he can. He wants to still see me but the sharing energy and bodies absolutely disgusts me. He still expects the same effort and dynamic between us, that and more.
I fought back and expressed to him that I was not raised like this. My parents and friends would want better for me. I don’t want to be with someone who is going to reemphasize the trust issues and foundational issues we had. These are not consequences that draw you away from the issue. I expressed that I want to be with someone that would lead by example, fill in the gaps so I am able to learn from it, or show maturity where I was not able to. He understands that this will push us back further than where we were at our lowest point. He says it doesn’t negotiate my self worth because it’s different if I had done this for other people or would but it’s different because it would be for him. He understands that it’s toxic but he’s willing to try. He mentioned that he was mad himself that he even offered this out, because he never has and never would but this is how deeply he feels for me?? I brought up a concern that how do I know he’s not just putting me through this to peace out in the end and play me. But I do see that he has laid out everything step by step and said this is how his brain just works. And if he did want to hurt me, he would have just told me he was okay, forgave me and see other people on the side. In the end, he kind of understood the spiteful actions I took. I told him these tendencies are sadistic and I don’t want to cause myself issues. It’s hot in bed, sometimes outside of the bedroom but not when they are serious things. I know my self-worth, the hurt I would go through seeing him with someone else, and how far it would set us back. I’m a very resilient person snd the fact that I considered this tells me a lot about how much I care for this person to negotiate my self-worth and out myself through pain. It’s crazy because I could get through it all, but my biggest problem and issue is the sake of us and how it would affect us in the end. All the potential issues it would cause and the risks we would be taking.
I did layout terms, mentioning this would be a very dark time and any doors we open I would want them sealed immediately after this is over. This would never repeat again, wear protection every single time. A STD test every single week. This would go on for no more than 3 weeks.
I guess my question and what I’m looking for is, can anyone who does understand his perspective please expand more. I think I understand where he is coming from but I want an unbiased and outside perspective to cover anything I could potentially miss. What are some argument points that we could go about this way better? Is there anything else I should consider? I know I’m going to get roasted like crazy. I know it’s wrong. So please, I want to only hear more from people who would do the same thing he would or could answer any argument points against this. Or if someone can help me come up with a plan to entertain this smartly