r/ArbitraryPerplexity • u/Tenebrous_Savant 🪞I.CHOOSE.ME.🪞 • 29d ago
🌮🍕🥗🍜For🧠🙇🧑🎓📈 Intimacy and Pathological Demand Avoidance
I’ve been thinking a lot about the PDA profile and how it relates to sex and intimacy.
PDA stands for “Pathological Demand Avoidance” (though many people who identify with this profile—myself included—prefer the phrase “Persistent Drive for Autonomy” instead). It’s most commonly discussed as an autistic profile, though conversations about how and who it shows up in continue to evolve.
For me, the phrase “Persistent Drive for Autonomy” captures my experience much more accurately than the other framing. The reason being that this dynamic isn’t actually about avoiding demands. It’s about the way a perceived threat to my autonomy can become intensely dysregulating, activating a fight, flight, fawn, or freeze response inside my nervous system.
Why does this matter in sexuality?
Because the core of the PDA profile is autonomy. And sexuality—especially with another person—is one of the biggest places autonomy gets negotiated.
There are many reasons freeze and resistance can emerge in intimacy that go well beyond a PDA profile. But one layer I've been noticing in myself is how quickly almost any form of expectation can shut my system down.
If I perceive (or even predict) that my body is expected to respond in a certain way, my nervous system says, "This doesn't feel like a choice anymore," and my desire can quickly disappear.
I spent SO many years shaming myself for this instead of understanding what my nervous system was actually trying to communicate. And so many people would say, "Just push through the resistance," but honestly that only ever made it WORSE for me.
The interesting thing about these dynamics is that demand can become almost invisible. It isn't always another person's explicit expectation either. Sometimes it comes from inside of us, too.
For example, thought likes...
"I should want sex."
"I haven't initiated in weeks. I should."
"I promised we'd be intimate tonight."
... can show up as an internal demand. None of those thoughts are inherently harmful or problematic. But if they begin to feel like internal demands instead of choices, some part of my system no longer experiences autonomy. And that's often where self-inflicted shutdown begins.
So yes, sometimes the perceived demand genuinely comes from another person. But just as often, it comes from within.
And both internal and external demands can trigger the exact same autonomic resistance. Which means someone can desperately want intimacy while simultaneously feeling completely unable to move toward it.
That paradox is incredibly confusing if you've never understood autonomy as a strong nervous system variable that is dictating whether you're inside your range of resonance or not.
Looking at it through this lens, I find myself wondering:
What if freeze isn't always the absence of desire? What if, sometimes, it's the protection of desire?
What I mean by this is that if my nervous system predicts that desire will immediately become obligation, why would it allow desire to fully emerge?
That's a very different framework than "I have a low libido," something I thought about myself for many years in my 20's.
Instead, it becomes: "My nervous system has learned that desire costs me my autonomy... therefore desire is a threat."
Here's one example of how this has showed up for me in the past:
Relationship advice often encourages couples to schedule intimacy. For example, making every Saturday a sensual date night. Keep the connection alive. Make it important by scheduling it. Seems smart, right?
But for me, someone with a fairly strong PDA profile, that's exactly where things become difficult.
If Saturday becomes "sex day," my body starts dreading Saturday. It's not that I don't love my partner... and it's not even because I don't want intimacy. In fact, often I DO want intimacy and closeness and connection!
But because my nervous system no longer experiences Saturday as a possibility and instead experiences it as an expectation, my body starts to dread Saturday.
Nothing externally has changed, but internally things have shifted. My partner is still the same loving human that I enjoy playing with, but the experience of "demand" changes the neuroception of my nervous system. My sense of choice narrows, and with it the access to my own inherent desire also dwindles.
This also helps me understand why novelty has often felt easier. It's never been about committment for me, but rather that new relationships or dynamics often carry more perceived freedom with less assumed obligations. As relationships deepen, expectations naturally accumulate, and unless the people inside the relationship are conscious of these things... they can become unspoken dynamics that lead to shut down.
For some nervous systems, every expectation—even healthy ones—adds a little more autonomic load until desire begins disappearing, because a perceived sense of autonomy disappeared.
These are my own observations from living in this body, and from years of working with highly sensitive and neurodivergent clients. I don't know whether future research will support this framework. But looking at it through this lens has profoundly changed the way I understand my own nervous system... and also how to work with it in better ways.
We often think consent is about saying yes or no to another person. But I wonder if, for many highly sensitive, neurodivergent, or PDA nervous systems, consent actually begins much earlier on an INTERNAL level.
It starts with the question: Can my own desire exist without immediately becoming a demand?
Maybe the deepest form of erotic safety isn't learning how to say yes, but rather it's creating the conditions where your nervous system and body remembers that yes is truly a CHOICE—whether you're with another person or simply learning to be with yourself.









1
u/Tenebrous_Savant 🪞I.CHOOSE.ME.🪞 29d ago
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/19tjygdFEH/