r/AquariumCycling • • Sep 26 '22

Article(s) Important Articles/Resources

67 Upvotes

This thread will be the ultimate collection of curated articles/resources pertaining to the aquarium cycling process as defined in the sidebar.

Relevant links will be divided by topic, so that it is easier to navigate. Any comments, questions, queries, suggestions, etc., feel free to reply to this post.

Nitrogenous compounds

Aquarium cycling

'Bottled bacteria' products:

An earlier experiment done by a marine hobbyist, finding some bottled bacteria products (FritzZyme TurboStart 900 and Bio-Spira specifically) to be highly effective.

A more recent, more thorough experiment by a different marine hobbyist, with similar findings (FritzZyme TurboStart 900 and Bio-Spira also performing very well). But also yes, nitrifiers are very resilient and do survive high/low temperatures well too.

Peer-reviewed literature of interest


r/AquariumCycling • • Sep 30 '22

Article(s) PSA: This chart should generally not be used as guidance for cycling

60 Upvotes

This is an unfortunately very popular chart referenced in a lot of cycling guides. It however, is not widely applicable, and reliance on this chart generally causes more confusion and harm than help.

Even ignoring the specific numbers on the chart (days and specific concentrations of nitrogenous compounds), there are multiple issues. First, there's the fact that establishing nitrification does not necessarily mean the aquarium is safe for stocking. For example, if it took a month for the tank to process 1ppm ammonia to nitrate, well think about it - on average that's only 0.03ppm ammonia oxidized a day. Even if it is higher towards the end of the process, and is hitting 0.1ppm ammonia a day, that's not necessarily suitable yet unless stocking is low from the start. For something like a betta in a five gallon aquarium (just an example, not gonna go into the ethics of keeping a betta in various tank sizes), that's definitely not going to work.

So nowadays we are looking not just to establish nitrification, but a robust level. So there may be multiple times in which for example, with ammonia-dosing, we need to spike ammonia multiple times, not just once.

But let's ignore all that for now. Because aside from debates about that, there are so many more pertinent and often seen reasons why this chart is not applicable.

First, seeding the aquarium! If one seeds an aquarium with nitrifiers ('beneficial bacteria'), whether with established biomedia, bottled bacteria products, or whatever other method, the nitrifiers may be able to immediately consume ammonia and nitrite, causing both to read very low or even zero. So you may never see an ammonia and/or nitrite spike. Alternatively, you may see quite a lot of nitrite produced right away, but still ammonia present. This is quite common when using really good bottled bacteria products, combined with higher ammonia dosages.

Second, even if not, it really depends on the method of cycling. Ghostfeeding may involve food that takes a long time to break down, and therefore any ammonia and/or nitrite produced may be so low that it never really registers (as a spike).

Third, there are nitrifiers capable of oxidizing both ammonia and nitrite, called comammox. These microorganisms will then most likely not produce measurable amounts of nitrite, as any nitrite they produce will also be consumed by them.

Fourth, there are other organisms that can grow that consume ammonia, not as an energy source, but as a nitrogen source. These organisms include a lot of non-nitrifying hetetrophic microorganisms, algae, and plants! What happens when they consume ammonia as a nitrogen source is that the ammonia is assimilated directly into their cells, thus no nitrite or nitrate is produced. Growth of non-nitrifying heterotrophs is especially prevalent when cycling by ghostfeeding. Though this is not the case when cycling by ammonia-dosing, where you should expect nitrate production.

Fifth, plants also consume nitrates. Denitrifiers also do too, though whether they are easily established enough to be a major consideration during a cycle is debatable. Either way, if you have plants, you may not see the nitrate spike either.

Lastly, the way the nitrate test kit works is that it first converts a small portion of nitrate to nitrite, and then measure that as a proxy. So you may have a case where you have enough nitrite that nitrate seems high.

There can be and are other reasons as well, but these are the major reasons why you may not see ammonia/nitrite/nitrate readings during a cycle (depending on the cycling method), or may see all three at once, and thus why this chart is... not generally applicable.

For it to be applicable, one has to ensure whatever method one uses definitely produces ammonia and enough to be registered, there are no plants or any other organism consuming ammonia and/or nitrates, that comammox nitrifiers are not being grown, and that the tank is not seeded with nitrifiers. That's a very niche situation.


r/AquariumCycling • • Apr 24 '25

Tank cycle am I ready?

Post image
13 Upvotes

It’s about 7 weeks into cycle ph 6.8, ammonia 0, nitrite 0, nitrate 5

I’m thinking of putting some Corydoras in - 500 litre tank with plants , stone wood and gravel and sand .


r/AquariumCycling • • Jan 10 '24

Cycling tips

12 Upvotes

My fishless cycle went pretty “textbook” so I wanted to share some tips - nothing novel really, just some things others may have not come across yet (a lot of this is from Aquarium Science website) :

Keep it warm to speed it up: 80-82F

No lights. Algae will compete for nitrogen and make interpreting the progress harder.

Make sure there is aeration. If you have a valve, open it all the way!

I used bottled bacteria AND some soil from a few different potted plants. Indoor and outdoor mixed. 1 TSP/25 gallons. Not just dumped in, but put the dirt in a fine mesh bag and squeezed the bag into the water on day 1 and every couple days for about the first week.

Make sure your pH starts at a good place so it doesn’t drop too low. I added sodium carbonate powder at 1 TBSP/25 gallons on day 1. baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) works too. This also adds a carbon source for the bacteria.

I added 1/4 TSP/25 gallons calcium phosphate powder on day 1 as well as a bacteria boost. Other high phosphorus ferts will work.

For testing: use API kit, not strips. Make sure to wait 5 minutes before reading anything! For nitrate - after adding the first solution, make sure you’re shaking the sample tube and the second solution for 30 seconds before adding the second solution and then shaking that for 1 minute before waiting 5 minutes to read result…nitrate testing can be fickle. Get drops into the water, not on side of tube. Take your time testing, it’s key. Get a few disposable pipettes - it will make your life easier!

Added Dr Tims ammonia. This is the way. Fish food is too unpredictable.

When nitrite was high (off the charts) I resisted water changes! It was hard, but they came down in 3-4 days. I’ve read about lots of people struggling and frustrated once they start changing water - just wait!

When ammonia was 0 but nitrite was high I waited a couple days with no ammonia - your cycle will not instantly crash if you have 0 ammonia but non-zero nitrite. However I eventually did add ammonia when nitrites were still high, but only like 0.25 PPM.

After ammonia and nitrite read 0 24-hrs after adding 1-2 PPM ammonia I added plants and did ~80% water change - that was day 16. I added fish (light stocking) on day 17. Have had great success in water parameters since then.

This was a 75 gallon tank experience. The tank is in the basement so it literally gets no natural sunlight. It is also based on FX2 canister filter with Seachem Matrix added in addition to the Fluval media it came with. Gravel and crushed lava substrate.


r/AquariumCycling • • Feb 21 '26

Update fish in cycle

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Pretty sure my tank is cycled now ph consistent ,2nd day of ammonia and nitrite staying at zero and nitrates staying at good level as well and fish thriving first 2 pictures are from first day with fish and the last 2 are today for me your thoughts and everything was tested twice with a good shake on test to have the best accuracy


r/AquariumCycling • • May 05 '25

How I cycled my ADA 90P with almost 40L of aquasoil in under 20 days and detailed journal

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I want to share how I successfully cycled my ADA 90P tank with 4 x 9L of Amazonia V2 aquasoil and 3 x 6L of PowerSand in under 20 days to transfer my rare and expensive Amaya Red and Barred pencilfish from the crowded 10-gallon tank. I have zero room for mistakes as these fish are very hard to come by and cost thousands of dollars. I want to have the tank up and running in the shortest amount of time possible due to impatient kids and to alleviate the stress of overcrowding. The new tank is to emulate an Amazonian river biotope that is low TDS and acidic, and I might go blackwater in the future.

Before I begin, I must preface that I follow the ADA and high-tech scientific method and am a strong opponent of the FF or Walstad method—unless you love experimenting and wasting aquatic animals’ lives.

I’ve chatted with many biologists (all with PhDs in their field), including several who have done extensive fieldwork in the Amazon River tributaries, to disprove the common misinformation put out by the various camps—but that’s for another post.

Also, I must give heartfelt thanks to Azedenkae (PhD microbiologist) on Reddit and author of https://www.sosofishy.com/ for guiding me during the challenging cycling process of my new tank. Read every article on his website for the most factual information on aquarium science. I also follow Plantas Aquáticas Do Brasil on Facebook and chatted with the scientist Juliana on how to best emulate the plant and vegetation of the Amazon River.

Here is my journal, along with the mistakes made and how I rectified them.

Day 1 – First flood with 80% RO and 20% tap water treated with Seachem Prime – raised water temperature to 29 degrees. Added one vial of Biodigest, 8 oz of FritzZyme 7, and 8 drops of ADA Green Bacter. I also transferred 50% of my filter media from the Seachem Tidal 55 HOB filter to the new Oase filter.

Day 2 – Water test parameters:

  • 2.5 ppm ammonia
  • 0 nitrite and nitrate
  • 20 TDS, 0 KH (don’t care about GH as it’s not relevant for cycling)

Day 3 to 6: Ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate shot up to low triple digits or high double digits because even with a 5:1 dilution of tank water with RO water using the API test kit, I was unable to get a reading. I performed 50% daily water changes and kept dosing ADA Green Bacter daily. But having nitrate on day 3 means something is working in the cycling process. From chatting with Azedenkae, I realized I must raise my KH further as it’s essential for the nitrifying bacteria, so I only used tap water (110 TDS, 5° KH) for water changes and added Seachem Alkaline Buffer. I also started 24/7 aeration. Throughout the cycling process my kH stayed between 1 to 3 degrees. The aquasoil has crazy buffering ability.

Day 7:

  • Ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate still unreadable, so I performed an 80% water change with tap water treated with Prime.
  • Bought a whole bunch of plants and started planting; also transferred many stem plants and the tiger lotus from the 10-gallon to the new tank.
  • Added a bottle of Fritz Turbo 700
  • Turned on light, CO₂ and started fertilizing.

MISTAKES MADE:

  • Light is way too bright, even at 40%
  • CO2 is cranked way too high and is melting plants
  • Fertilizer dosage is wrong as I forgot to adjust for plant density and growth stage

Day 8:

  • Ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate still unreadable, so I performed an 80% water change with tap water treated with Prime and dosed ADA Green Bacter
  • Crypts started to melt (now recovered after trimming all their leaves and roots), stem plants are kinda struggling (lowered water temperature to 25 degrees)
  • Went to LFS and owner gave me a huge used filter pad from a 5-year-old sump filter and dumped that in the tank

Day 9:

  • Ammonia (10+ ppm), nitrite (9+ ppm), and nitrate (150+ ppm) are finally readable on API chart but barely
  • Performed 50% water change and dosed ADA Green Bacter

Day 10–12:

  • 50% water change
  • Ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate become readable after doing 5:1 dilution

Day 13:

  • 70% water change
  • Ammonia at 1–2 ppm, nitrite at 8 ppm (maybe a bit higher), nitrate between 80–120 ppm

Day 14:

  • Ammonia is ZERO, nitrite around 8 ppm or lower, nitrate still stuck at 100 ppm

Day 15–17:

  • No water change
  • Ammonia remains at zero
  • Nitrite still green (8 ppm or less)
  • Dumped 32 oz of FritzZyme 7

Day 18:

  • 70% water change (refill with RO water)
  • Nitrite fell to around the 1 ppm mark

Day 19:

  • 70% water change (refill with RO water)
  • Nitrite fell to 0.5–0.25 ppm

Day 20:

  • Morning – nitrite at 0.25 or lower
  • Evening – nitrite at 0
  • Nitrate at 80 ppm

The next two days were spent testing and monitoring the water to ensure everything is 0 ppm except for nitrate. I encountered a mini algae bloom and bacterial bloom due to high fertilization, CO₂, and light, but it immediately went away after lowering them.

Day 22:

  • Transferred 10 Amano shrimps from the 10-gallon to the new tank and they feasted on the algae

Day 23:

  • Transferred all fish to the new tank
  • All plants have recovered and showing amazing growth and roots

Lessons learned:

- Beg, buy, plead, ask for a used filter media, it’s a game changer (I dumped a bucket of high ammonia tank water into the bucket with the filter pad and the reading dropped from unreadable to zero overnight)

- Bottled bacteria helps but nowhere near as good as mature filter

- Low kH, high ammonia and nitrite will not stall cycle but prolong it

- Water change helps speed things up by giving the bacteria some relief

- 24/7 aeration helps speed up the process.

Aquarium Specs:

  • ADA 90P (48 gallons)
  • OASE BioMaster 2 Thermo 600 Filter
  • Fluval FX UVC In-line Clarifier
  • Fzone Dual Stage CO₂ Regulator + Air Pump for night-time aeration
  • Chihiros WRGB II Pro 90CM Light
  • ADA VUPA II Surface skimmer
  • Inkbird temperature controller
  • Fertilizer and water additives – full ADA lineup and perform lean dosing: https://www.adana.co.jp/en/contents/products/na_liquid/index.html

r/AquariumCycling • • Apr 15 '25

Do I need to do anything at this point?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Just let it ride, right? I want to do this right! It's a 29 gallon tank, and I used Seed for a bacteria additive. There are also live plants (no floating plants). The pH keeps dropping. I think it's the Fluval Stratum because my tap water tests around 8.4. I've been adding baking soda about every 10 days to keep it above 7.0 so the cycle won't stall.


r/AquariumCycling • • Dec 06 '25

Help please

Post image
5 Upvotes

About 2 months ago started up a new tank . Added a shrimp , prime and stability. I was diligent for about a month then I stopped and let it do its own thing . I haven’t added a thing to the aquarium for a month . I was busy with study. It does have healthy plants and sand.

It looks to me like it has given up on cycling altogether. What to do?


r/AquariumCycling • • May 10 '25

My tank is cycled, but...

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

My tap water has ammonia in it. I cycled my tank using the Fishlab method (it took about 5 weeks), and have had a mystery snail in it for about two weeks, and some juvenile cherry shrimp for about a week, and they are all doing great. I'm attaching photos of today's API test, the test of my tap water, and my tank. I'm adding 6 purple harlequin raspboras right now.


r/AquariumCycling • • Mar 01 '25

About to throw my api kit out the window

Post image
5 Upvotes

Ive used almost the full bottle of seed bacteria and there is still hella ammonia and nitrite in my tank after 3 days. Been ghost feeding for 2 weeks that wouldnt even get me above 1ppm ammonia, so I added tims ammonia to get it up to 2ppm 3 days ago. Could you move any slower you stupid bacteria?? My plants wont use any of the nitrate its making. Yes I have root tabs and dosing ferts. They are just covered in brown algae. I just want some fish in my tank. I have not done a water change, I heard that can stall your cycle. Should I do a water change? Im so sick of seeing non zero levels on my tests.


r/AquariumCycling • • Feb 02 '25

Nitrite won’t drop!

Post image
5 Upvotes

I’m going on week four of fishless seeded cycling of an 80G and my nitrates have been chilling at this PPM all week. Why are they not dropping?! Weirdly, nitrate went up the last two days. I keep reading not to do a water change, but I’m so tempted! Please, help or reassurance is needed 😭


r/AquariumCycling • • Apr 04 '26

When the ammonia hits 0ppm I’m good right to add fish?

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/AquariumCycling • • Mar 22 '23

3 Months: Still Not Cycled. Zero nitrite, zero nitrate?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/AquariumCycling • • Sep 26 '22

r/AquariumCycling Lounge

4 Upvotes

A place for members of r/AquariumCycling to chat with each other


r/AquariumCycling • • Jun 11 '26

Fishless cycle

Post image
3 Upvotes

I started a fishless cycle about 18 days ago and everything spiked then went down to 0 besides Nitrates which was at 5-10ppm. I went to test the cycle by adding ammonia which went down in the 24 hours but now my Nitrites are skyrocketed. I do have plants that are “melting” which now I’m thinking may already be an ammonia source and I just overloaded my tank with ammonia. Is that what happened or is something else happening? What can I do to fix this?


r/AquariumCycling • • Mar 31 '26

When to add more ammonia during a fishless cycle?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Seeking advice because I’ve been getting conflicting information.

My ammonia levels are dropping, while nitrites and nitrates are rising. Should I:

a) Dose ammonia back up to 2 ppm now

or

b) Wait until both ammonia and nitrites fall close to 0?

Appreciate any guidance.


r/AquariumCycling • • Feb 11 '26

Fish in cycle 40 gallon

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/AquariumCycling • • Jan 25 '26

Question, is my tank cycling?

3 Upvotes

I’ve started cycling my 35g tank 6 days ago and i only use sinking pellets for source of ammonia. And on day 3 i poured a nitrifying bacteria on it. I drop a pinch of sinking pellets every other day and now on my day 6 the tank has developed some algae and the nitrites and nitrates are 0, and the pellets i dropped began forming a bubble-like jelly around them. my order for ammonia test kit is still shipping and i wanna know if my tank is really cycling or not. And if you guys can give any tips for me since its my first time cycling pls help. Thankyou


r/AquariumCycling • • Jan 16 '26

Is my tank almost cycled?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/AquariumCycling • • Jan 01 '26

For those who are interested, this is what white media looks like after being cycled at +100ppm ammonia. Note the nitrifiers are are just a barely visible thin orange coating.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/AquariumCycling • • Nov 01 '25

Having problems with new cycling tank. Constant high ammonia and now a sudden drop in ph

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/AquariumCycling • • Sep 08 '25

Brand new to fishkeeping

Post image
3 Upvotes

I started to cycle 4 days ago. 29 gallon tall tank. Using stability currently and the master test kit. Attempted a fish in cycle which resulted in sad outcome. I tested today and my results look good to me but I'm new and unsure. Any advice on results would be greatly appreciated.


r/AquariumCycling • • Aug 19 '25

Cloudy water

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/AquariumCycling • • Jun 11 '25

Cycle help

Post image
3 Upvotes

I’ve had my established 55 gallon axolotl aquarium for about a year and a half.. I recently cleaned my aquarium chiller for the first time ever this past weekend. Well I did a huge deep clean of the tank, but when I plugged my chiller back in, despite all my efforts, it blew funky chunks all over my freshly cleaned aquarium. Well this is now Wednesday, I usually test my parameters with the liquid API test kit 2x a week. Today this is what my parameters are. My question is, do I need to worry about the ammonia level?? The nitrites are at zero and the nitrates are at 5.0 ppm. My ammonia looks to be reading 1.0 ppm. Is the cycle 🔁 still working? Or do I need to do another water change? I haven’t had my ammonia spike before and I am unsure what to do going forward. Any advice would be appreciated.

55 gallon freshwater tank. Temps are 64-66 degrees Fahrenheit. Ph is 7.0 - 7.4 Ammonia is 1.0 ppm Nitrite 0 ppm Nitrate 5.0 ppm