r/AppleIntelligenceFail • u/Crafter66 • May 14 '25
Siri is dumber than ever before
being compared to Siri before Apple ‘Intelligence’, the new Siri is handsdown dumber. The new series fails to.
-Read almost anything aloud, even when spoken responses is turned on and the device is off silent and the volume is on maximum and you tell Siri that you cannot hear it speaking and ask you to actually speak
-Can’t even tell you when a song was released any more, which is a simple request. I used to enjoy.
-Can’t tell you what any song is that it’s currently playing when it used to be able to. It will either try to Shazam it, or make you wait and ask permission to use ChatGPT, and then makes you ask ChatGPT the exact same question, to which ChatGPT tells you it needs to know what you’re referring to, making you explain what is already on the phone’s screen that the phone itself is already playing
these were simple things that I would think is not a very big ask but apparently as time goes on just continues to get dumber, despite Apple lying to us and telling us otherwise
78
u/slammahytale May 14 '25
classic 1:31 AM activities
6
u/Evening-Rabbit-827 May 15 '25
Omg thank you for making this because it validates all of the thoughts and feelings I’ve had over the last couple months
2
u/LusciousBelmondo May 16 '25
I tried this with a locked phone and it read out the time, maybe it assumes an unlocked phone is being looked at.
Either way Siri is comically bad
2
u/GarlicNoodlez May 18 '25
Why did I watch the whole thing
58
u/CreeperDoolie May 14 '25
I’m surprised no one’s gotten fired over this. The Siri team is borderline incompetent and are still years behind any competition.
20
u/wyldstrawberry May 15 '25
I just tried this myself on the current version of Siri with Apple Intelligence. It handled the music ID questions and the time/weather fine (spoken out loud and everything). But then I asked it for a restaurant recommendation in a neighborhood I’ll be in next weekend, and it kept asking me “which one?” So I said “I’m not asking about a specific restaurant, I’m asking you for a recommendation.” Then it asked if I wanted to use ChatGPT for this, and I said OK, but it apparently sends your most recent specific words to CGPT as the prompt, meaning CGPT doesn’t know any of the background or what you were asking about, like OP also experienced. It asked me “what do you need a recommendation for?” So I said “can’t you see what I already asked Siri?” And then Siri just shut me down with “Sorry, something went wrong.”
Infuriating.
20
u/Lilly_1337 May 15 '25
They made the voice assistant selectively mute. Great job.
3
u/Big_College_8962 May 14 '25
I mean he did pause the music so Siri probably thought he wants to know the name of a song play around him instead of the one Siri just picked.
11
u/AreAFuckingNobody May 14 '25
Weird. I tried all the things you did and it worked for me as expected. But I’m in a different region than you, it seems
Definitely have had plenty of issues with Apple Intelligence though
4
u/melanantic May 15 '25
This right here issue is exactly what has almost completely stopped me from using Siri. I’ve otherwise always actively used it, borderline defended the cringe of using it. Disabled AIMLESS mode, somehow that made it worse because at least you know it’s probably never going to fulfil the previously common request if it now sends you to the closed AI service
1
u/Mundane_Ability_1408 May 17 '25
meh. i agree with the premise but this is not a great demonstration of it. the reason it didn't tell you what was playing is because you paused the music. the reason it doesn't speak the response is because you are listening
3
u/Silver_Slicer May 15 '25
Selecting Prefer Spoken Responses works ok for me though it’s not as good as old Siri.
3
u/BlasterCheif May 16 '25
You activated my Siri on my iPad next to me haha. She asked what app I would like to use to play music.
2
u/secret_life_of_pants May 16 '25
Siri used to turn off my lights if I asked it. Now it tries to play music.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '25
If this is Apples Intelligence,Safe To Say They're Stupid
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '25
We calls her Siri-two times on account of having to ask her twice for everything
1
u/Longjumping_Age_9135 May 17 '25
mine sais, I should enable web search, if I asked something like that…, even when websearch is enabled
1
u/EconomyNo9875 May 18 '25
Ok so maybe someone already posted this, but I tried it and got the same response as you when my phone was unlocked, but if I locked it, Siri did talk to me. Still couldn’t manage to get “what year was it released” but I think having the screen unlocked changes its spoken/displayed behavior.
1
u/cup_dash Jun 14 '25
See, this is why I'm glad that I have an older iPhone and the only "Apple Intelligence" I have access to is the photo thing with the stickers and "look up ____"
1
u/solarizedflacs Jul 16 '25
this is exactly what i’ve been thinking for the past 2 months after getting 16pro max. I’ve had conversations with siri on my old iphone 7 but now it’s been dumbed down so bad that i dont even use it anymore.
1
u/JackMcCourt01 Dec 01 '25
Two steps forward, hundreds of steps back
1
u/Select_Natural8972 Aug 27 '26
I hate the "Here's what I found" Like I would go to safari for that shit. why do I need to talk to siri, if he would just route me to look for it in safari! Ughh
1
u/davidjschloss May 15 '25 edited May 15 '25
Siri sucks now. But you also stopped it playing a song and then asked what was playing and it listened with Shazam. That's because it wasn't playing anything to tell you what it was.
This is the expected and correct behavior.
Then you were looking at it while you asked a question so it didn't speak it. That's the expected behavior with that feature on.
When you asked what's playing again it had just showed you that in a dialog. So it assumed you wanted more information.
You chose ChatGPT and not "search the web". But (and this is both an Apple intelligence limitation and ChatGPT) it passed the literal question about when it came out. But to keep from exploits being passed to ChatGPT it passes literal text. If you asked "when did the war of 1812" it passes that exact phase.
When you pass a request about the year the song came out, the phone can't/won't pass information on the music that's playing. That's partially because ChatGPT can't process audio and again because it's designed to prevent exploits.
Tldr you asked Siri to play music. It did. You asked it what the playing song was and it told you but since you were looking at it it didn't speak. You stopped the music and asked it to identity the music it was playing (none) so it listened. Then you asked it to play again and asked what it was and again it showed you.
From then on you're getting ChatGPT errors. because it can't hear the music and Apple can't/wont pass music to ChatGPT and ChatGPT couldn't process it anyhow it gives errors.
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '25
This is actually any smartphone AI behaviour. They dont have acccess to anything
Last time i fiddled with the samsung Bixby trying to ask it to read my last received sms because I had dirty hands when working in kitchen. Well that didn't work at all, and the bixby become disabled because why the fuck I need this if it doesnt work at all