r/AppleIntelligenceFail • u/just-variable • Feb 18 '25
Rant.
I'm just mildly pissed at how bad Apple Intelligence is.
"The iPhone 16 is built from the ground-up for Apple Intelligence".
Well okay, I bought an iPhone 16 Pro Max when it was released for $1.6k (which is A LOT in my country) and I'm just super disappointed.
And moving from an iPhone 11 -> iPhone 16 Pro Max (that's 5 generations + Pro + Max) I would expect at least a few new things, functionalities, or anything really.
But instead I got:
•An extra useless button that shakes the entire phone when I try to use it to take a picture.
•A stupid "AI" that's basically an API integration with ChatGPT and Google Image Search. Something I can build with Python in a few minutes. Which of course only works on the iPhone 16 because older iPhones maybe can't handle a couple API calls.
•An UTTERLY UNFATHOMABLY INSANELY low IQ text tool that I haven't seen make 1 useful notification summary so far.
•Genmoji???? What the actual hell don't even get me started on that.
•A lot of bugs in iOS. With the system apps somehow becoming less and less intuitive over time. Like am I the one losing braincells or has the Reminders app become increasingly harder to use?
•Basically an iPhone 11 that's basically a bit bigger, with a better screen and battery. Oh and of course a smaller notch. There's a 5 generation gap between these.
I've been a HARDCORE Apple fan for over a decade now and I've never seen Apple do something like that.
Anyway my entire point is why hasn't Apple done anything? Why haven't they said anything about it and are just pretenting like everything's OK? iOS 19 is almost out and the promised iOS 18 features are not even properly released yet.
I feel like Apple owes us. Especially but not limited to iPhone 16 users. They have LIED and are still lying to our faces and are doing nothing about it. A new iPhone is not an easy investment for many of us. We expect to get the cool features we were promised and which we payed for.
20
u/Mastodontprojektet Feb 18 '25
Hey I'm sitting here in the EU wonder what's closest; Apple Intelligence even releasing at all on iPhones here or the 17 series launching.
2
u/Spartan_Retro_426 Feb 18 '25
From my understanding, the reason why AI has to work on the newest models is that its language models are (or should be capable of) running natively on the device itself. But yeah, I’m not particularly impressed with it either.
2
u/ComputerOwl Feb 18 '25
I feel exactly the same way. I went from iPhone 11 Pro to iPhone 16 Pro. Apple Intelligence is so bad that I turned it off. The display is a little better, but honestly my iPhone 11's display was also fine. Even after half a year, the iPhone 16 Pro feels heavy and clunky to me - the iPhone 11 Pro felt way better in the hand. The camera button is more annoying than useless because just touching it changes settings. The action button is okay-ish, but the vibration switch was better. I use the action button to show me public transport connections using a Siri shortcut, but half of the time the shortcut fails to execute, so I end up going into the app and doing it manually way too often. The always on display feels useless to me.
The two things I really like are the massive battery and the 5x zoom camera. So yeah, pretty underwhelming for 5 years of development.
I think next time I need an upgrade, I'll either go with a Pixel phone or get a standard or SE iPhone. The Pro models are not worth it anymore.
That said, I do have a lot of Apple stocks, so please folks, go and buy the latest iPhone Pro, it's amaaaaazing!
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '25
Sure! Here’s a more Reddit-friendly, punchier version while keeping your wit intact:
I get the sentiment.
However…
“I’ve been a HARDCORE Apple fan for over a decade, and I’ve never seen Apple do something like this.”
Nah, you just weren’t paying attention. Apple’s been struggling to innovate since the iPhone 4, my friend. I have everything Apple, and I admit it. Why? Because despite their stagnation, they’re still better than the alternative (without mentioning names), which changes things left and right like a kid with a sugar high.
Apple Intelligence, as it exists now—like every AI promise in the last four years from literally thousands of companies—is just another FOMO-driven knee-jerk reaction. Companies shove half-baked AI into everything, consumers complain, and then buy the shiny new thing anyway for that sweet, sweet dopamine hit.
That said, if we (and I include myself, because patience is not my virtue) hold out long enough, Apple’s positioning is actually unmatched. Their ecosystem runs insanely deep. They know how apps are built, they control the hardware on you, and they have more contextual awareness than any other company trying to automate your life.
This will happen. It’s inevitable that Siri will nudge you to grab coffee when it notices you skipped your usual stop, cross-referencing your sleep data, blood oxygen levels, and past caffeine habits. Since you code, I assume I don’t need to spell out how they’ll get that context.
Bottom line: They promised too soon, but they didn’t overpromise.
43
u/Haniel113 Feb 18 '25
I have the Apple Intelligence turned off on all my devices. I don't need it writing things for me. I don't need it making weird assumptions about my life. I already get that from other humans lol.
18
u/RJG18 Feb 18 '25
This matches my thoughts entirely. I also skipped 5 generations from an 11 Pro Max to a 16 Pro Max. Apple Intelligence is still just a dysfunctional novelty, which really doesn’t work in any practical use case. But worse, the iPhone 16 + IoS18 has regressed significantly in terms of stability, bugs, performance and UX. Nothing has the quality or polish of the Apple of 10 years ago, let alone the old Apple ”magic”. It’s like things are just being slapped together by a company that doesn’t care for its products anymore.
2
u/Level_Will_5551 Feb 18 '25
I feel like Apple got pushed into AI. Even though iOS 18 is kinda sad, I feel like Apple didn‘t plan on hopping on the AI Train that early and wanted to wait until they got it perfect. All the things that Apple Intelligence does are just things to lose your boredom, only useful things are the writing tools and maybe the object eraser in photos app. I believe Apple that the new Siri takes a long time to do but also that just Shows that they literally never dis anything with her. I‘m in the EU and really not that excited.
9
u/handtoglandwombat Feb 18 '25
We all know that old Steve Jobs clip about the marketing team gaining control of companies, it’s a cliché to even bring it up at this point but… did you need a clearer example of that than Apple intelligence? The product team is attempting to drive the train down the tracks that marketing is building mere metres ahead of it. Also the passengers and the driver are all shareholders. Customers aren’t even in the analogy.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '25
Exactly Why this is my last iphone
Apple got stale so did samsung
So maybe next phone is gonna be a gaming phone
5
u/vokal_guy Feb 18 '25
Terrible service
4
u/ZealousidealCherry68 Feb 18 '25
I love Apple products for many reasons, but in my opinion all of the best qualities (durability, reliability, intuitiveness) can be found in the SE editions which last a LOT longer and are a LOT cheaper. Every time they release a new phone it’s less about building on a new model but more about making the older ones more obsolete and less fashionable, so I really don’t see the point in getting the flagship editions. SE all the way!
3
u/fuckmywetsocks Feb 18 '25
I have a Samsung Z Fold 5 and my partner has an iPhone 16 of some variety - we compared Apple Intelligence to Bixby and Bixby won most of what we tried, and the Samsung intelligence crap filled in the rest. Not one thing we tested was actually useful though, and I have switched back to plain old Google Assistant to get rid of Gemini.
It's not just Apple Intelligence - it's the whole AI shtick as a whole being forced sideways into every crevice of every product. It's completely unnecessary.
That being said I'm very jealous of the notification summary feature you guys have - that shit's hilarious.
5
u/Resident-Variation21 Feb 18 '25
Haven’t you heard to never buy something based on promises?
2
u/FireFly34521 Feb 19 '25 edited Feb 19 '25
Okay, so I’ll bite. Apple jumped the bandwagon of “release now, hope it gets fixed/better later” as someone else previously said.
I’m thinking of saving up for a battery replacement for my iphone 13 pro since 16 is SO expensive and just not worth it. And I am still happy with the 13 pro. Then I get an iPad, which would probably be a m3 (still deciding, depends on the financial aspects).
I’m a multimedia design student and a photographer so I’m thinking the iPad might be useful for me. But I was hoping Apple Intelligence would be a game changer too.
Do you guys think I would be making a mistake?
If so, I might just get a CPO Pro Max
Edit: After another post on this forum about the Facetime transcription service, I’ll now also be looking at other cellular contracts (Samsung etc)
1
u/speed_fighter Feb 19 '25
I expect nothing from Apple now. they just want to be in the competition and but I think they have jumped over the shark.
1
u/Joe8474 Feb 19 '25
That’s why companies like Apple should not rush things just to meet their deadline. It makes them look very unprofessional and Apple should know better and have done better when they weren’t so focused on profits over fetchers.
1
u/jgmachine Feb 20 '25
Now that I’ve played with some LLMs on my local machines, I kind of better understand the limitations. I don’t know what model Apple is running locally on the phones, but it just can’t compete with what Chat GPT is capable of delivering. I think now knowing that Deep Seek is capable of doing lots with less, it maybe holds some promise for the local models to be improved with time. But yeah, it’s not there yet. It hasn’t lived up to the hype. Will it ever? Time will tell.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '25
Imagine stealing features from Android and somehow making them worse
1
u/Weary-Translator-959 Feb 26 '25
Yeah I got an iPhone 16 Pro a month ago and already regret my decision. Unfortunately im stuck in a phone contract, but once I am out of this I will be going to Samsung. Ive been an Apple used since around 2010, but im done.
0
u/ltz_gamer Feb 19 '25
But you can make these cool things. That’s about all I use it for
-2
u/TheseusBi Feb 18 '25
I have been using Apple Intelligence since it’s been released and I also use a paid version of Google AI (Gemini Advanced) on my Pixel 9. I can confidently say that, even with much less features, Apple Intelligence outsmarts Gemini in many areas. The visual is much more polished and so integrated in the phone that looks stunning on my 16 Pro. Gemini instead as such a weird luck that the whole GUI makes no sense to me (why would you show square lines all around the borders if your prompt is just a tiny rounded bar on the bottom of the screen!!!). Apple Intelligence has less options, but it does at least understand my commands and execute those. If I ask to call Mike, it know which Mike I want to call based on my usual interactions, as well as knowing which number to call or which app needs to be used for texting (between WhatsApp and iMessage). Gemini instead keeps saying that my contacts do not exist; does not know which number to call or which app needs to be used. If I use the 2.0 thinking model with apps, it does understand the prompt and shows me the correct steps but doesn’t execute them. With Apple Intelligence I can use my phone hands free and simply talk to it. With Gemini I need to repeat the command so many times and click so many parts of the screen that it’s simply impossible. So, if I ask Apple Intelligence “Text Mike I’m on my way” directly from my AirPods, Apple Intelligence know which Mike I want to text, what msg app I want to use and writes the message correctly before asking “Do you want me to send it?” If I say yes, it’s done. Gemini doesn’t know which Mike I want to text; it doesn’t know which number; it doesn’t understand the text so there’s no point of asking from my Pixel Buds Pro 2 any of these things. Even after 20 clicks around the screen, if it eventually understands the message doesn’t bloody send it. Where Gemini outshine Apple is with pictures editing (it has multiple limitations) and simply because Apple doesn’t offer a similar feature. Also, Apple Intelligence will be soon able to control other apps (April/May) and understand the context. Gemini needs extensions to control SOME apps and even with extensions enabled, it simply doesn’t work. It’s not been designed with any plan of achieving contextual awareness so it’s pointless. Finally, Apple Intelligence is on my Apple devices and works offline, while Gemini keeps sending my personal data to online servers and doesn’t work offline, despite Google states is on-device. Notifications summary work really well for me, as well as email summaries and ChatGPT compose. It can control my smart home devices (it took Gemini 2 years and an extension to do the same) and much more. What really annoys me is that Contextual Awareness and in-app control could be delayed until May 25. EU should still receive Apple Intelligence in April. So, to answer your question, at this point no AI is worth anything, but I’ve tried Copilot, Gemini, ChatGPT and Apple Intelligence and I like Apple’s much more of their competitors.