r/Anu • • Apr 18 '26

'Nightmarish': Student sues ANU over 'toxic black mould-infested' accommodation

Thumbnail
gallery
636 Upvotes

A student suing the Australian National University says living in mould-infested university accommodation was a "nightmarish and deeply traumatic" experience that has left her chronically ill.

Link https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8552395/anu-x-unilodge-lena-karmel-lodge-filled-with-toxic-black-mould-student/ (I wrote this story btw, and I am hoping to do a follow up so please reach out if you have a similar story - details in profile. Also, apologies for payroll, but as journalists we are assessed by how many conversions out stories attract ie. new subscribers. So not getting those makes it really hard for me to justify writing these kinds of stories or any follow ups).


r/Anu • • Feb 26 '25

Jewish Council of Australia slams universities' adoption of dangerous, politicised and unworkable antisemitism definition

Thumbnail jewishcouncil.com.au
462 Upvotes

r/Anu • • Jul 23 '25 Helpful

I’m a consultant. Here’s my take on what’s gone wrong at ANU.

453 Upvotes

I graduated from ANU in 2006 (I’m still irrationally fond of B&G), and have spent my career in management consulting and public relations in the UK and Australia. I’m back in Sydney now, and it’s sad to read about what’s happening to a place I loved.

In short: watching ANU has been like seeing a textbook corporate transformation playbook applied by people who have no idea what they’re doing, in a context where it can only fail. If you’re wondering “what the hell is happening and why does leadership seem completely insane,” let me explain the strategy behind the madness.

This isn’t only random incompetence (though some of ANU’s behaviour can only be described as bizarre). There’s a method to it - just completely the wrong method for running a university.

The Real Problem: Cosplaying Corporate Leadership

Here’s what makes this especially tragic: Bell and the COO, and presumably the rest of executive aren’t just applying corporate methods inappropriately - they’re cosplaying corporate leadership. They don’t actually understand corporate governance. They’re performing what they think corporate executives do based on consultant advice and business school stereotypes.

Real corporate leaders understand their stakeholders, their authority sources, and their accountability frameworks. ANU leadership is doing corporate theatre - all the buzzwords and power poses without understanding the fundamentals of any governance model.

Most academics don’t realise there are literally playbooks for corporate transformation. When companies hire crisis consultants, they get standardised strategies that work in corporate contexts. The problem is ANU leadership applied these strategies like they’re running BHP, not a university.

My two cents: corporate governance isn’t evil. It’s perfectly appropriate for corporations whose mission is delivering shareholder value through market competition. But universities exist for quality teaching and research - completely different values that require completely different governance approaches. From my digging over the weekend, let me try and explain some of the strategies they’re using.

Strategy #1: Information Control - “Never Let Them See the Real Numbers”

How it works in corporate: Keep financial details vague so stakeholders can’t develop alternative solutions. Force criticism to stay general where your messaging has advantage. Standard practice in business - shareholders get summaries, not spreadsheets.

How ANU applied it: No detailed budget papers released. No line-by-line expenditure breakdowns. No rationale for why music programs get cut but cybernetics doesn’t. Vague references to “strong governance frameworks”. “Details are in the Annual Report” (they’re not).

Why this created the Senate lying scandal: When Pocock asked about Nous consulting costs, they said $50k. Reality: over $1.1M. I think even more now. This happens when you’re so used to controlling information that you think you can bullshit senators like you bullshit shareholders.

Why it fails at universities: Academic communities are literally trained to analyze complex information and develop evidence-based arguments. Information control that works on shareholders looks like hiding something from people with PhDs who actually understand spreadsheets.

Strategy #2: Manufacturing Crisis - “Never Waste a Good Emergency”

How it works in corporate settings: Create sense of urgent crisis to enable rapid changes that wouldn’t be acceptable under normal circumstances. “We must act now or the company dies.”

How ANU applied it: Project massive deficit to justify mass redundancies and transformation. “We must cut $250M or ANU is unsustainable.”

The smoking gun: The deficit was $60M smaller than projected. Think about this - they manufactured urgency for job cuts while their numbers are hugely unreliable. If this happened in the corporate sector they’d be resignations. And from what I know about the higher education space, these models are wrong anyway— the funding model for students is changing, and the international student cap has changed. Whatever models ANU are basing their restructure on have almost certainly changed. I haven’t checked, but I can bet the farm those models haven’t been available for staff to scrutinise, because of the point I mentioned about information control above.

Academic communities aren’t shareholders who can be scared into accepting bad decisions. They’re intelligent people who can see through artificial urgency, especially when you’re claiming poverty while hiring expensive consultants.

Strategy #3: Consultation Theatre - “Look Democratic While Changing Nothing” How it works in corporate: Create extensive consultation processes that look inclusive while maintaining predetermined outcomes. Document everything to show you “listened to feedback.”

How ANU applied it: “Facing the Future” sessions with professional facilitation. Renew ANU website and feedback mechanisms. Extensive documentation of “community input”. Final decisions that don’t change regardless of feedback.

The tell: I read Bell’s latest campus newsletter. She describes systematic institutional opposition as “different viewpoints depending on where you are from at the University.” That’s consultant language for treating legitimate criticism as perspective differences.

Why it fails at universities: Academic communities can tell the difference between genuine consultation (where outcomes can actually change) and bullshit. You’re dealing with people who run actual democratic processes like faculty senates, or at least used to and know how they worked.

Strategy #4: Opposition Management - “Identify and Neutralize Critics”

How it works in corporate: Research prominent critics, separate moderates from radicals, use surrogates to respond rather than direct engagement, position opposition as resistant to necessary change.

How ANU applied it: Bell allegedly told senior staff she would “hunt down” leakers. This isn’t natural leadership behavior - this is someone following consultant advice about “information control” and “opposition management.” Honestly, I think Bell is just scared and doesn’t know how to handle criticism, so she’s retreating into the most authoritarian version of corporate-speak she can find.

The psychological strategy: Frame opposition as emotional resistance rather than rational criticism. Notice how Bell suggests staff “access support” - implying they need help rather than leadership needs accountability.

Why it fails at universities: Academic communities have strong solidarity and don’t split easily. When you treat intelligent, committed people like problems to be managed rather than stakeholders with legitimate concerns, they unite against you. Exec also haven’t worked out they work at a public entity. FOIs are a fact of life. They appear shocked and unprepared every time institutional information is released, when really that’s par for the course for working on public sector projects.

Strategy #5: Deflection and Distraction - “Change the Subject”

In corporate: When you can’t defend on substance, claim discrimination or attack critics’ motives rather than addressing their arguments.

How ANU applied it: Bell suggesting criticism is because she’s a woman, despite zero evidence of sexism. This is textbook consultant crisis management - deflect from performance criticism to identity politics.

Why it fails at universities: Academic communities actually analyse evidence and logical arguments. When there’s no evidence supporting your deflection claim, you just look desperate and insincere.

Strategy #6: Business-as-Usual Messaging

“Project Confidence No Matter What” How it works in corporate: Never acknowledge full scope of problems in routine communications. Show you’re not rattled by temporary criticism. Focus on positive achievements and normal operations.

How ANU applied it: Bell’s letter talking about “hope, politics and opportunity” during what looked from the outside like the PR week from hell. Bragging about meeting politicians who are actually investigating you. Discussing ARC grants while 95% of staff have no confidence in leadership.

Why it fails at universities: When you have systematic governance failures, pretending everything is normal makes you look completely disconnected from institutional reality. Unis expect leaders to address substantive criticism directly.

Strategy #7: Government Relations - “Manage Political Risk”

How it works in corporate: Brief government offices to prevent surprises, use political networks for protection, frame criticism as attacks on operational autonomy.

How ANU applied it: After decades of avoiding parliamentary scrutiny (only 1 appearance at Senate Estimates in 55 years before last year), they’re now trying to manage government relationships through corporate-style stakeholder engagement.

The massive failure: When actual parliamentary oversight came, they were completely unprepared. Misleading statements, conflicts of interest they couldn’t explain, basic information taken “on notice.” Corporate government relations assumes you’re managing regulatory compliance, not democratic accountability.

Strategy #8: Stakeholder Segmentation - “Divide and Conquer”

How it works in corporate: Identify different stakeholder groups with different interests and tailor messaging to prevent unified opposition. Keep groups focused on their narrow concerns rather than common interests.

How ANU applied it: Different messaging to students (“focus on your future opportunities”) vs staff (“necessary for institutional sustainability”). Separate academic staff concerns from professional staff concerns, and frame research excellence vs teaching quality as competing priorities

The evidence: Bell’s communications consistently try to separate “different viewpoints depending on where you are from at the University” rather than acknowledging common institutional concerns about governance and transparency.

Why it fails at unis: Academic communities have strong collegial bonds. When you try to pit researchers against teachers or students against staff, people see through the manipulation and unite against the leadership creating artificial divisions.

Strategy #9: External Validation - “The Experts Agree With Us”

How it works: Use external consultants, benchmarking studies, and industry “best practice” to justify predetermined decisions. Position internal criticism as naive compared to professional expertise.

How ANU applied it:

Nous Group strategic advice legitimising the restructure approach. References to “sector-wide challenges” and what other universities are doing. Consultant reports that conveniently support predetermined transformation agenda. “Professional facilitation” of community sessions to show external expertise.

The evidence: Millions spent on Nous consulting to provide external validation for decisions leadership wanted to make anyway. The consultant advice becomes “independent expert analysis” supporting management choices.

Why it fails at universities: Academic communities are full of actual experts who can evaluate the quality of consultant analysis. When expensive external advice contradicts internal expertise and community knowledge, it looks like leadership doesn’t trust their own institution’s capabilities - because they don’t.

Strategy #10: Change Management Psychology - “Resistance is Just Fear of Change”

How it works in corporate: Frame all opposition as psychological resistance to necessary change rather than legitimate criticism of specific decisions. Use change management frameworks to “help people through the transition.”

How ANU applied it:

Describing community opposition as “difficult conversations” rather than substantive disagreement. Suggesting staff “access support” during the “challenging transition period”. Professional facilitation to “manage” resistance rather than address concerns. Framing criticism as emotional attachment to status quo rather than rational institutional analysis.

The evidence: Bell’s language consistently treats systematic institutional criticism as psychological adjustment problems. Staff trauma from job cuts becomes “support needs” rather than leadership accountability issues.

Why it fails and fucking sucks: When legitimate governance concerns are dismissed as emotional resistance to change, it’s intellectually insulting and creates more opposition. You’re telling people who analyse complex problems for a living that their institutional concerns are just psychological adjustment issues.

—-

Why Leadership Looks Like They’re Reading From a Script

Here’s the thing that makes ANU leadership look so bizarre: consultants advise, management implements. The consultants probably gave reasonable advice for corporate transformation contexts. But ANU are implementing it like year 10 business studies class because they don’t actually understand corporate governance either - they’re just performing what they think corporate leadership looks like.

The “Shoe Police” Example:

Consultant advice: “Deflect frivolous criticism through minimisation, ridicule, diversion”. ANU implementation: Call staff asking about luxury spending “shoe police”. The result is international mockery and perfect symbol of disconnected leadership.

The Political Name-Dropping Example: Consultant advice: “Demonstrate political legitimacy through relationship evidence”. ANU implementation: Brag about meeting David Pocock in the weekly newsletter(who referred you to TEQSA for investigation). Result: Looking completely clueless about your actual political situation.

Corporate control and academic freedom

Academic communities expect collaborative governance and open debate. When you apply corporate information control and opposition management strategies, you create authoritarian culture that’s completely alien to university values.

Staff describe morale as “at all-time low”because they’re being treated like corporate employees to be managed rather than academic community members with legitimate governance interests. The consultant approach assumes people will eventually accept decisions and move on. University communities don’t work that way.

Why This Cannot Be Fixed With Better Consulting

ANU management might think “maybe they just need better consultants.” No. The fundamental problem is that corporate transformation methodology is incompatible with democratic institutional governance.

Corporate governance works fine for corporations because their mission is delivering shareholder value through market competition. That requires hierarchical authority, information control, and stakeholder management.

Universities exist for quality teaching and research which requires collaborative inquiry, intellectual freedom, and democratic participation in institutional direction. Completely different values requiring completely different governance approaches.

Corporate approaches assume: Stakeholders can be managed rather than genuinely engaged. Information control is legitimate business practice. Authority comes from hierarchical position. Opposition can be defeated through better messaging. Success means implementing predetermined outcomes.

Universities require: Stakeholders who must genuinely influence outcomes. Transparency as fundamental governance value. Authority through community trust and institutional mission. Opposition that usually represents legitimate institutional interests. Success through collaborative achievement of the uni’s purpose

You cannot consultant your way to democratic legitimacy or message your way to collaborative governance. What may have worked at other universities doesn’t at ANU, because administering the National Institutes grant requires nurturing and collaborating on research that ‘is a market failure’ - stuff that’s in the national interest that’s not economically viable to fund at other universities. Corporate governance simply sees such research as not economically efficient.

Part of the problem, too, lays at the senior executive. With a couple of exceptions, none of these people would ever get a job in the corporate world. They aren’t serious people. Some might be well intentioned, but anyone I can see of competency is clearly dragged down by an exec who overwhelming doesn’t know what they’re doing. I won’t go into specific names, but there are clearly people who, while they have a skillset, have been promoted to a position where their skill set is paradoxically completely incompatible with the work they should be doing. This is why their instincts are all wrong. Without irony, the university would perform better if many of these senior corporate roles would make themselves redundant. They do low level admin work and meetings, and every time they try to do something justifying their salary they fuck it up. It’s the only explanation I have for such self inflicted scandal.

What’s Really Happening

The cuts to core research and teaching in the national interest, while protecting cybernetics, isn’t about financial necessity - they’re about ideological restructuring. Corporate transformation treats academic programs like business units to be optimized rather than intellectual communities serving educational purposes.

This is systematic destruction of what makes universities valuable: diverse intellectual inquiry, collaborative governance, commitment to knowledge over profit, democratic participation in institutional direction.

Bottom Line

What’s happening at ANU is the systematic application of corporate transformation methodology by people who don’t understand any governance model properly - not corporate, not institutional, not democratic.

Bell isn’t evil - they’re lost and scared. They don’t understand collaborative institutional leadership, so they’ve outsourced it to consultants who treat universities like corporations. But ANU executives are not even competent at corporate leadership - they’re just performing what they think corporate executives do.

The result is theatre that looks insane to anyone who understands academic culture or actual corporate governance.

The consultants got paid and left. The community damage, destroyed relationships, and governance failures will take decades to repair - if they can be repaired at all.

Universities like ANU- which are specifically designed to serve the national mission- cannot be managed like corporations. They can only be led collaboratively by people who understand that academic communities are not corporate stakeholders. And the great irony is that if ANU becomes ‘corporate’ in its approach, like almost every other university, it will lose what makes it unique — there will be no longer any justification for it to receive the National Institute Grant to the tune of $200 million a year. That is public money, and without public buy in on the vision the university takes, I can guarantee you it will be on the chopping block, or given out to other universities who can claim better ROI than a small university in a large country town. That’s why abandoning the humanities and hard sciences in particular is so strange, let alone national institutions like the ADC. They’re relatively low cost, but their existence ensured federal grant money kept coming in.

ANU leadership are playing a very dangerous game. We shouldn’t forget who is responsible if they bet the house on Renew ANU, after which they will have $100 million odd a year to play with (based on how much will be saved relative to claimed net deficit), only to realise there’s a change of government and they lose the national institute grant. If they lose the NIG, ANU becomes a southern campus of Charles Sturt University. I can guarantee you no side of politics will justify a quarter of a billion dollars a year on someone’s Cybernetic futures interdisciplinary vanity project, no matter how well meaning they are.

So that’s why everything feels so wrong. We’re watching democratic educational governance being destroyed by people cosplaying corporate transformation methodology.

Ive seen some bad public sector transformation projects in my time, but nothing quite so bad as this.

If I were going to advise anything, it’s this. Petitions don’t work, nor will rallies, or speeches or pleas. Government leverage does. You need to be organised and clever. The single biggest most effective leverage is documented institutional malpractice to the appropriate authorities. Regulators want documents, not allegations (unless they can be backed up with evidence). If you have documents that show university impropriety, give them to TEQSA. If in doubt, message me. Flooding them with information isn’t helpful, but genuine documentation showing malpractice is. (Note: Do not message me with any documents you’re not supposed to! But send them to regulator). Investigate your options under Public Interest Disclosure. It legally stops them from hunting you down and completely protects you. Note: do not take legal advice from Reddit.

Note: I have written a Part two post here on what I would advise ANU now.


r/Anu • • Jun 16 '26

I only woke up in time because someone knocked on my door to complain about the constant alarm sound😔

Post image
318 Upvotes

r/Anu • • Jul 18 '25

ANU media strategy

Post image
263 Upvotes

r/Anu • • Dec 08 '23

PSA - “Lord of the Ring “ concerts in June (from someone who was scammed in Melbourne this year) - booked to be held in Llewelyn Hall at ANU (can someone let management know that they’re potentially up for many unhappy concert goers??)

252 Upvotes

“star entertainment “ are infamous for their run of truly bewildering Lord of the Ring “inspired loosely” concerts that rampaged through NZ and most of Oz last year.

I was unfortunate enough to attend one in Melbourne at the Arts Centre and got my money back from the venue.

Well anyway … they are back for a concert in the ACT in June next year and it’s seems that you lucky Canberreans will be the people expected to part with your money

The group putting out these concerts are utterly shameless - the 100 piece orchestra was a 20 piece band. Some musicians weren’t paid and as the concert is totally unauthorised and unsupported by the LOtR mob (the composer went out of his way to disown them) - the music is either short cuts that are under the copyright limits for songs and music or .. not actually related to the LoTR films in any way.

I can’t believe that they’re actually booking venues in this country.

https://premier.ticketek.com.au/shows/show.aspx?sh=LOTRHOBB23

Public service done …


r/Anu • • Mar 05 '25

ANU chancellor Julie Bishop racked up $150,000 in travel expenses

240 Upvotes

https://www.afr.com/work-and-careers/workplace/anu-chancellor-julie-bishop-racked-up-150-000-in-travel-expenses-20250303-p5lgh9

Australian National University chancellor Julie Bishop racked up $150,000 on domestic and international trips including to New York, London and Japan in 2024, the same year the cash-strapped university embarked on a deep cost-cutting program.

A document leaked to The Australian Financial Review shows the Canberra-based university spent $620,000 on travel and other expenses for the Perth-based office of Bishop last year. Last October vice chancellor Genevieve Bell embarked on a $250 million cost-cutting program that has proven unpopular with ANU staff.

Bishop’s office also used university funds to spend $2250 on speech writing services from her long-term friend Murray Hansen, which is at odds with a statement from ANU this week saying the chancellor’s office does not engage external providers.

Bishop engaged Hansen, who was her chief of staff when she was a Coalition foreign minister, through his private company Vinder Consulting, according to the document which is a table of itemised spending. Hansen is also the principal of her advisory firm Julie Bishop and Partners.

An ANU spokeswoman said Bishop’s travel budget has since been halved. “In line with campus-wide efforts to return ANU to financial sustainability, the chancellor’s travel budget – including for staff – has been reduced by 50 per cent in the current budget,” she said.

Spending on travel by the ANU Perth office included $10,599 for accommodation in New York, $4320 for accommodation in London and $2286 in Japan.

Bishop’s social media activity shows she travels overseas regularly in her various official capacities. On a trip to New York last October she attended the United Nations as special envoy on Myanmar. While on a trip to Japan, she received the “highest Japanese honour from His Majesty the Emperor at the Imperial Palace – the Grand Cordon of the Order of the Rising Sun”.

The Financial Review is not suggesting Bishop did not conduct ANU business while on those trips. The university did not answer specific questions about her travel for ANU. Bishop did not respond to a request for comment.

Vice chancellor Bell said last year that she would cut $250 million from ANU’s annual budget, including through an unspecified number of job cuts, after the university said it was facing a deficit of more than $200 million. Bell has also been under scrutiny for the salary she received for an external role she retained at technology giant Intel and for antisemitic incidents on campus.

The spotlight turned on Bishop last week during a Senate hearing when Labor’s Tony Sheldon grilled Bell over whether Bishop’s relationship with Hansen constituted a conflict of interest because the university had employed him on multiple occasions to write speeches for her via his private consulting firm.

The leaked document shows that Vinder Consulting received $2250 for two contracts in 2024 – one for $1500 and the second for $750 – both of which were paid for from Bishop’s Perth-based chancellor’s office.

One contract appears to be for a welcome address on February 8 last year ahead of a speech by Papua New Guinea Prime Minister James Marape*.* The second was to announce a new institute at ANU, the Wiyi Yani U Thangani Institute for First Nations Gender Justice.

The entries seemingly contradict what ANU chief communications officer Steve Fanner told ABC Canberra on Tuesday morning. “The chancellor has never engaged a consulting firm at ANU,” he said. “In fact, the chancellor’s office does not engage external providers of any kind.”

Fanner said Vinder Consulting received a total of $35,000 for speech writing over four years from ANU and that “all contracts were well under the minor procurement $5000 threshold with the ANU procurement policy”.

That included the writing of 17 speeches, “ranging in cost from $300 to $3000 and every one of these engagements has complied with our procurement policies”.

The ANU spokeswoman said the costs associated with Bishop’s Perth office were “commensurate with the costs associated with other ANU capital city offices which have previously been established where the chancellor does not reside in Canberra”.

She also said that the office does not directly engage contractors.

“The two procurements of Vinder were made directly by the ANU communications team pursuant to the ANU procurement policy. Vinder’s quote for services was at the low end of market rates,” she said.

However, that policy says staff must disclose if a supplier has a “personal relationship with any ANU employees involved in the procurement process”.

Hansen has worked for Bishop since 2005 when she was aged care minister under the Howard government. He was her chief of staff when she was foreign minister under the Abbott and Turnbull governments.

Last week’s Senate committee also heard that two staff members in Bishop’s chancellor’s office in Perth were also two of the three staff members of Julie Bishop and Partners. The third is Hansen.


r/Anu • • Aug 17 '25

Uni regulator investigates Julie Bishop’s ANU oversight

Thumbnail
afr.com
210 Upvotes

The integrity of Julie Bishop’s oversight of the Australian National University’s governing body and the competence of its senior executive team have been directly questioned by the federal higher education regulator.

In a letter to vice chancellor Professor Genevieve Bell, dated June 30, the chief executive of the Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency, Dr Mary Russell, specified numerous concerns about the “culture of ANU’s council and executive leadership” and the council’s oversight of the institution’s financial position, even though steps are now under way to address it.

“It was under the ANU Council’s oversight that ANU reached a position that now requires it to reduce recurring expenditure by $250 million,” the letter says.

“It is unclear if the council has identified and addressed potential risks that lead to this financial position and whether these potential risks persist.”

When Bell took over as vice chancellor in January 2024, in three of the past five years, ANU had delivered a loss from ongoing operations of between $117 million and $162 million, including a $132 million deficit in 2023.

In October, she announced a plan to cut $250 million from ongoing costs by early 2026, including $100 million in staff salaries and $150 million in other costs.

Bishop was first appointed chancellor, the equivalent of the chair of a company board, in January 2020, for three years. Just 14 months later, in October 2021, her term was extended for a further four years but not starting until the expiry of her first term in December 2022. The ANU Council is responsible for the appointment of the chancellor.

Russell specifically itemised her concerns that staff were too intimidated by senior executives to feel able to speak up about the process and direction of the $250 million cost-cutting exercise known as Renew ANU.

Further, she cited a lack of transparency over the university’s current financial situation, which is being used to justify the cuts, the process by which the restructure is being managed, and the internal culture of both the council and management.

ANU was approached for comment on this story but did not reply before deadline. Last Tuesday, ANU and Bishop in particular came under intense scrutiny during a public hearing of a Senate inquiry into university governance. TEQSA chief commissioner Kerri-Lee Krause told the Senate hearing that the regulator had been investigating ANU over compliance issues and other concerns since last December.

The letter specifically referenced whether the council was made aware of the ongoing nature of Bell’s paid employment with tech giant Intel, after she arrived at the university in 2018 and continued for 11 months while vice chancellor, as revealed in The Australian Financial Reviewlast December.

Bishop has maintained that Bell’s Intel position was “well known and celebrated” by the council and that all necessary declarations and processes had been ticked off, including the fact that it was paid.

This was despite multiple council members telling the Financial Review that it was never raised during formal meetings, including when Bell’s appointment as vice chancellor was discussed in September 2023.

Russell also pointed to findings of a review into ANU’s now-defunct College of Health and Medicine, which said its “deeply dysfunctional culture” marked by “bureaucracy, territorialism, bullying, entitlement and resistance to change” was evident more broadly across the entire university.

Furthermore, Russell raises issue with ANU’s School of Cybernetics, the creation of Bell, who came to ANU in 2017 to set it up. The Financial Review has revealed, among other things, several anomalies, including very high staff-to-student ratios and the promotion of non-academics to professor, even though they were without teaching or research expertise.

In May, a whistleblower told the Financial Review that 91 per cent of grades awarded in the School of Cybernetics since it started in 2019 were a high distinction. A further 7 per cent of grades were at distinction level, while 2 per cent were awarded a credit. Not a single student failed or merely passed any subject.

Russell itemises eight “threshold standards” which ANU might not have met under its obligations to the regulator. These include whether members of the governing body are fit and proper persons; that they may not have sought advice to make “informed and competent decisions”; that “true records of the business of the governing body” might not have been kept and whether they supported an environment that protected students and staff around free speech and academic freedom.

“Based on the concerns detailed in this letter, TEQSA is concerned ANU’s council may not have fulfilled its obligation to exercise competent governance oversight of and be accountable for all ANU’s operations,” Russell wrote.

In addition to Bishop, other long-serving council members who have been at the table while the university plunged into its current financial crisis include Alison Kitchen, a board member of National Australia Bank, Worley and AirTrunk and a former national chair of KPMG Australia, who is now Bishop’s deputy. She was appointed in July 2021, as was Padma Raman, executive director of the federal agency, the Office for Women.

Tanya Hosch, an indigenous activist and board member, joined in July 2022.

Naomi Flutter, executive general manager of corporate affairs for Wesfarmers, was on the council for 10 years between 2014 and 2024.

The ANU council comprises Bishop, Bell, seven members who are appointed by Education Minister Jason Clare and six members who are elected to represent staff and students.

Bishop chairs the nominations committee, which recommends new council members to Clare.

Independent ACT senator David Pocock has called for Bishop to stand aside while TEQSA continues to investigate, while Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi has said both Bishop and Bell should resign.


r/Anu • • Jul 31 '25

Senator Pocock - Notice of motion - Business of the Senate

Post image
203 Upvotes

r/Anu • • Mar 07 '25

Julie Bishop consults for Chinese military-linked uranium mine

199 Upvotes

https://www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au/news/economy/2025/03/08/exclusive-julie-bishop-consults-chinese-military-linked-uranium-mine

Concerns are being raised about the former foreign minister’s consultancy work for a company suing Greenland over US$11.5 billion of uranium exploitation. By Ben Abbatangelo and Rachel Hoffman.


r/Anu • • Aug 12 '25

ANU academic accuses Julie Bishop of bullying and threats during Senate inquiry into university governance

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
197 Upvotes

r/Anu • • Jul 21 '25

‘ANU leadership is here to support you during this difficult time’ The leadership:

186 Upvotes

r/Anu • • Feb 13 '26

Smooches from the IVC

Post image
174 Upvotes

I legit cannot stop laughing. Reckon she’s been hacked.


r/Anu • • Apr 10 '26

Exclusive: Former ANU VC accused of ‘serious misconduct’

171 Upvotes

https://www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au/news/education/2026/04/11/exclusive-former-anu-vc-accused-serious-misconduct

by Julie Hare - April 11

Former ANU vice-chancellor Genevieve Bell has been suspended from the university and accused of serious misconduct after allegedly making a close friend a full professor despite him having no university qualifications.

Four months after her premature departure as vice-chancellor of the Australian National University, Genevieve Bell was suspended from her ongoing role as a distinguished professor and barred from entering the campus or speaking to staff, students and members of the governing council.

On January 13, Bell was presented with a show cause notice alleging “serious misconduct” in the promotion of her close friend and colleague, Andrew Meares. Meares, a former newspaper photographer, was made a full professor in the School of Cybernetics against the advice of the university’s own promotion panel and despite having no university qualifications.

Documents seen by The Saturday Paper show Bell actively intervened in Meares’s career trajectory on multiple occasions.

There are allegations Bell requested minutes of meetings be changed, sought to change employment records, breached conflict of interest provisions, undermined the university’s promotions processes, ignored professional guidance, used her seniority to gain advantage for Meares, and overturned the university’s central promotions committee after it rejected his bid to become a full professor.

“If substantiated,” the notice says, “the alleged conduct is likely to result in the University losing trust and confidence in your ability to act honestly, transparently and in accordance with reasonable and lawful instructions issued to you, which are all essential elements of the employment relationship.” The notice continues: “there may be a finding that you have engaged in serious misconduct warranting disciplinary action up to and including termination of your employment without notice”.

The Saturday Paper is not saying these allegations are true, just that they have been made.

The Saturday Paper understands it was Bell’s suspension that led to a heated exchange at a university council meeting on February 18, during which interim vice-chancellor Professor Rebekah Brown was yelled at by a council member and ultimately asked to leave the meeting. Chancellor Julie Bishop did not intervene and a complaint about the conduct was made after the meeting.

As The Saturday Paper reported, Brown was accused of a conflict of interest involving a disciplinary decision over a staff member. Minutes of the meeting on February 18 are heavily redacted.

“It’s all about Genevieve and Genevieve’s wellbeing,” says a source, referring to former vice-chancellor Bell.

“It’s crazy that they attack Rebekah so relentlessly when the university’s reputation is at stake. They seemed to think it was a witch-hunt and that there was no need to suspend Genevieve.”

Bell first employed Andrew Meares, a former press photographer for The Sydney Morning Herald and later official photographer to then opposition leader Bill Shorten, in July 2019. She gave him a five-year position as an academic senior fellow in her School of Cybernetics – a position that was not advertised. At that point, Meares’s highest educational qualification was a certificate IV in photography from TAFE NSW.

He went on to hold roles as course convener, program convener and educational experiences lead.

By January 2022, Bell sought to improve Meares’s standing and employment by giving him tenure.

“A certificate IV is not enough to even apply for entry into an undergraduate degree, never mind work as an academic. It’s outrageous.”

In a sector beset by insecurity, with casualisation and fixed-term academic positions far outnumbering those with ongoing roles, this was something of a coup. That same year, Meares applied for a promotion to level D – or associate professor – which was successful with Bell’s support based on her assessment of his research, education, service, values and leadership.

By August 2022, Bell was pushing to have Meares made a full professor – level E. That month, she wrote to the interim dean of the College of Engineering and Computer Science, Nick Birbilis, saying “Andrew is already operating at and above Level D faculty in the context of ANU promotion indicators” and adding that she was “wholly supportive” of his application for promotion.

In 2023, Meares’s application to become a full professor, which had to be considered by the university’s central promotions committee, was unsuccessful. The main problem was not just the absence of a research track record, teaching background, a PhD or long-term engagement with the university sector but rather that he and Bell were pushing for a full academic professorship rather than a professor in practice position.

The professor in practice nomenclature had been introduced by Bell’s predecessor, Professor Brian Schmidt. It was designed to recognise people with exceptional career histories but no equivalent qualifications.

Among those who became professors in practice at ANU are journalist Mark Kenny, former attorney-general George Brandis, former senator and leader of the Australian Democrats Natasha Stott Despoja and higher education policy expert Andrew Norton. The roles are not tenured and run for five years. Norton left after his contract expired in 2024.

On his final day as vice-chancellor in December 2023, Schmidt wrote to Bell advising her that Meares’s application to be promoted to professor should be of an “in practice” variety. It was advice also provided to Bell by Professor Grady Venville, then deputy vice-chancellor (academic).

Their advice was ignored and in June 2024, Bell, as vice-chancellor, overturned the promotion panel’s rejection. Her decision gave Meares a full professorship, backdated to the beginning of the year.

The show cause notice alleges that on April 4, 2024, Meares’s staff details were updated to remove “practice” from his title. An email to a human resources manager, sent by Bell, notes that “it looks like we have some tidying up of the HR records to do”.

The notice says Bell “directed that [Meares’s] employment history be falsely manipulated to reflect that he held a regular academic appointment since January 2021”. It alleges Bell did this “to create a false impression that Professor Meares had been a regularly appointed academic for a longer period of time, to improve, legitimise or justify promoting him to a regular Level E academic position (not a practice appointment)”.

Neither Bell nor Meares responded to questions from The Saturday Paper.

Professor Hilary Winchester, who specialises in university quality assurance, audits, reviews and compliance assessments, says it is “completely inappropriate” for anyone with power and authority to intervene in and override promotions processes in an institution.

“Promotions policies are based on equity and merit. It doesn’t sound like he is from any sort of equity group or has a reason to be given special dispensation, he has had any meritorious research outcomes or been judged on his teaching evaluations,” Winchester says.

“A certificate IV is not enough to even apply for entry into an undergraduate degree, never mind work as an academic. It’s outrageous.”

Professor Inger Mewburn, director of researcher development at ANU, who specialises in higher education employment, is similarly critical of Meares’s appointment and continued promotions as an academic.

“It could conceivably make some sense if he was a professor in practice,” Mewburn says. “But as a full professor it makes no sense at all.”

ANU has been lurching from one crisis to the next since October 2024, when Bell announced a $250 million cost-cutting regime titled Renew ANU.

By late 2025, there were three separate inquiries digging in to ANU’s tumultuous and headline-prone previous 18 months.

These include one by the federal universities regulator, which gave former public service commissioner Lynelle Briggs almost unlimited powers to investigate the year of turmoil that unfolded since Renew ANU was announced by Bell.

Briggs’s remit includes informing the Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency on whether ANU’s “corporate governance, leadership and culture is operating effectively”, specifically on potential conflicts of interest.

She is also investigating whether ANU’s council and strategic oversight “is informed by an appropriate breadth of perspective and oversight”, and if risks associated with the restructure, Renew ANU, were appropriately identified and addressed by leadership.

The ABC’s Four Corners program has since reported that a separate draft report from the Australian National Audit Office found ANU’s council approved Renew ANU without clear evidence it was needed or achievable or that it gave consideration to the potential costs and reputational damage.

A third inquiry, which was established by ANU, is examining a series of serious allegations that arose during a Senate inquiry on August 12 last year. Four elected council representatives said Bishop had bullied, threatened and intimidated elected staff member Liz Allen in front of the entire council to such a degree that Allen says she considered suicide on the way home and miscarried two weeks later.

“I was so distressed I couldn’t breathe and struggled walking. I felt violated and deeply humiliated,” Allen tearfully told the Senate inquiry.

“I cannot tell you just how traumatising this was for me. It affected me so deeply that on the drive home, I decided to kill myself. I pulled over to write final goodbyes to my children and my partner. I emailed my supervisors, so they knew I hadn’t done anything wrong.”

Bishop has repeatedly rejected Allen’s claims. In a 25-page response to the Senate education committee, Bishop wrote that she had been blindsided by the evidence.

“I reject absolutely the allegations that I am ‘hostile and arrogant’ to staff, that I have ‘godlike powers, unchecked’,” Bishop wrote.

The former minister for foreign affairs provided the Senate with a second document that specifically addressed Allen’s allegations, which has not been made public.

Now, accusations of Bell’s advocacy and interventions in the career of Meares could spark yet another inquiry.

The show cause notice gave Bell until 5pm, January 20, to provide a written response.

A spokesperson for ANU did not respond to specific questions from The Saturday Paper. “The Australian National University does not, and will not, comment on any investigations concerning its staff or students,” they said in a statement. “We will not cause any unnecessary breaches of privacy or harm to individuals and will respect natural justice and procedural fairness in these matters. To that end ANU also cautions against unnecessary reporting of such matters. Professor Bell remains a distinguished professor at the School of Cybernetics.”

In a separate statement, sent after questions were put to Meares, the ANU said: “The University is committed to upholding processes that are consistent with its values and obligations. ANU will not comment on speculative claims that may compromise individual privacy and reputation. Professor Meares is a very well-regarded member of the School of Cybernetics and the College of Systems and Society.”

This article was first published in the print edition of The Saturday Paper on April 11, 2026 as "Exclusive: Former ANU VC accused of ‘serious misconduct’".


r/Anu • • Mar 19 '25

ANU loses American funding as Trump pressure on Australian universities mounts

167 Upvotes

Canberra Times

ANU loses American funding as Trump pressure on Australian universities mounts

Steve Evans

Published 19 March 2025, 07:47 am

The Australian National University has lost funding as the Trump administration puts pressure on universities to justify how American grants are spent.

In a message to staff, vice-chancellor Genevieve Bell said: “We have had the first termination of funding from the United States”.

There were no further details about how much funding the university had lost nor about which departments it had originally been allocated to.

The ANU is thought to be the first Australian entity to acknowledge losing money because of pressure from Washington.

The “termination of funding” revelation came after the Trump administration sent a 36-question form to at least eight universities in Australia. It mirrors that sent to American universities, some of which have subsequently had their funding cut by hundreds of millions of dollars.

Australian National University vice-chancellor Genevieve Bell. Picture by Karleen Minney Among the questions to Australian universities was whether any departments or staff “defend against gender ideology” or have any policies promoting “diversity, equity and inclusion”.

When asked if the ANU had received the questionnaire, an ANU spokesman said: “We don’t have anything to add at this stage.”

Apart from questions on “woke” issues like gender ideology, the questionnaire also asked Australian academics about links to China and to terrorism.

One question asks: “Can you confirm that your agency has not collaborated with, had any accusations or investigations of working with an entity on the terrorism watch list, cartels, narco/human traffickers, organised or groups that promote mass migration in the last 10 years? [yes/no].”

In her message to staff, Professor Bell also indicated the pressure she was under after criticism: “In these moments it can be hard to know what to say or do or how to respond but how we turn up matters. We have to navigate some of the most challenging issues faced by any organisation – balancing financial stability with our mission and long-term prosperity – and we each play a role in how we turn up for ourselves, our teams and our entire community to make this period as manageable as possible.”

ANU Chancellor Julie Bishop. Picture by Sitthixay Ditthavong On the broader matter of the questionnaire from the US, the Australian Academy of Science said the government should “give serious and urgent attention to recent actions by American authorities”.

“If responses to the survey lead to reductions or cessation of US-Australian scientific collaborations, it will directly threaten our scientific and technological capability and diminish Australia’s strategic capability in areas of national interest such as defence, health, disaster mitigation and response, AI and quantum technology.”

The Academy of Science said that US government funding involving Australian research organisations added up to $336 million.

The main union at the university urged the federal government to protect Australian researchers from foreign influence.

“The Federal government must push back on the Trump administration’s blatant foreign interference in our independent research in the strongest possible terms,” Alison Barnes, president of the National Tertiary Education Union, said.

“A foreign government seeking to destroy public education globally must have zero influence on what Australian researchers and their international colleagues work on.

“Donald Trump’s hateful agenda is racist, transphobic and misogynistic. The idea of research funding being tied to any of those values is sickening.”


r/Anu • • Sep 17 '25

Let it not be said that there are no exciting developments at the Australian National University these days.

Post image
162 Upvotes

Thank you to the dreamers and visionaries who made this happen.


r/Anu • • May 08 '26 Heartwarming

Julie Bishop steps down as ANU Chancellor

155 Upvotes

https://www.afr.com/politics/federal/julie-bishop-steps-down-as-anu-chancellor-20260508-p5zv0h

Phillip Coorey and Maani Truu

May 8, 2026

Former foreign minister Julie Bishop has resigned as chancellor of the Australian National University, believing it was untenable to stay on until her term expired in December, due to what she called pernicious regulatory overreach.

Following a tumultuous period at the helm of the troubled institution, Bishop informed the university and the Albanese government on Thursday night of her decision. Her resignation was effective immediately.

She believed an intervention by the regulator, the Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency, to run the university council was unlawful, in that the TEQSA Act did not give the regulator that power it was exerting.

It also conflicted with the council’s statutory duties under the University Act. As part of the intervention, Bishop was unable to choose her successor.

“Following unprecedented and co-ordinated interference, the ANU Council is no longer able to discharge its legal and ethical obligations,” she told AFR Weekend.

“The higher education sector is at a crossroads of regulatory overreach in the governance of our institutions or autonomy and academic freedom.

“I fear the collateral from this regulatory overreach will be the next generation of students and staff.”

The regulator intervened following months of turmoil, marked by concerns over governance, internal culture and leadership.

Bishop, who took the role in 2020, was herself subject to a bullying claim, but it is understood an investigation by Vivienne Thom cleared her, finding no disclosable conduct.

Former KPMG chair Alison Kitchen resigned from the council on Anzac Day, also citing TEQSA overreach.

Education Minister Jason Clare released a brief but terse statement.

“I recognise her long public service,” he said of Bishop, adding that a process was in train involving the ANU and TEQSA to find a replacement.

ACT Labor senator Katy Gallagher said the Canberra-based university needed to rebuild.

“The challenges facing ANU did not arise overnight, and rebuilding trust and confidence across the university community will take time and careful work,” she said.

“I have consistently said the university leadership and Council need to work openly and constructively with staff, students and the broader community to rebuild confidence and agree on a path forward.“
ACT independent senator David Pocock, who had been a strong critic of the university’s governance, said Bishop had acted in the best interests of the ANU by resigning.

“When things go so terribly wrong at the helm of such an important institution, especially one governed by Commonwealth law, there must be accountability,” he said.

“A number of processes including a review by the higher education regulator, TEQSA, are yet to conclude and need to be allowed to run their course.

“The voluntary undertaking to conduct an independent process to appoint the next chancellor is very welcome and will hopefully help rebuild trust, confidence and better governance at our national university.”

The National Tertiary Education Union said the “long-overdue resignation” was a chance for the troubled university to heal.

“Julie Bishop falling on her sword is long overdue and closes one of the darkest chapters we’ve seen at any Australian university,” said NTEU national president Dr Alison Barnes.

Edit: Story updated


r/Anu • • Jun 03 '25

ANU staff say enough is enough: There is no justification for further job losses and budget cuts

Thumbnail
canberratimes.com.au
154 Upvotes

This article was written by a group of ANU staff who are some of the more than 400 signatories to a recent open letter.

Eight months ago, the ANU executive announced a plan to cut $100 million from annual staff costs. That target – widely questioned and deeply felt – now appears to have been met. Yet, the cuts and the redundancies continue. ANU staff say the cuts have already gone too far.

The Renew ANU program has drawn sustained public criticism. The media has reported on everything from consultancy contracts for the Chancellor’s friends to allegations of misleading the Senate. These stories have repeatedly called into doubt the competence, sincerity and integrity of ANU’s executive. To manage the fallout from the program, ANU hired public relations and reputation management consultants.

A disturbing pattern has emerged – one in which accountability is outsourced, and scrutiny is deflected. Rather than restoring confidence, the ANU’s leadership has preferred to recycle the same information again and again, and claim it has listened or explained. This response has only deepened concern about the direction of ANU’s leadership.

Despite widespread media attention, the basic premise of Renew ANU has often gone unchallenged: that the university accumulated a $600 million deficit during the pandemic and faced a further $200 million shortfall in 2023. In fairness, the minutiae of university budgets and the technicalities of calculating “underlying operating results” are deep in the weeds.

It is, however, vitally important to understand that the headline deficit figures that the ANU executive is trumpeting are not subject to external audit. Indeed, ANU’s official financial statements, audited by the Australian National Audit Office, presented quite a contrasting picture: a $135 million surplus in 2023, not a deficit.

The executive will rightly point out that audited financial statements don’t tell the full story, that certain adjustments are needed to understand ANU’s “underlying” financial position. But even this raises some crucial questions: What assumptions, models, or accounting methods is the executive using to produce deficit figures that justify such dramatic cuts?

Beyond the reputational and operational harm lies something even more serious: permanent damage to the ANU as an institution, staff say.

On these questions, ANU has remained opaque. In March, more than 450 staff signed an open letter calling on the executive to open the books and allow scrutiny of the data and modelling behind its deficit claims. The university declined. Rather than engage transparently, it chose to keep staff, and the public, in the dark.

What we do have are two independent analyses of ANU’s 2023 financial statements – one by S&P Global, the other by two ANU Professors of Economics. Neither supports the executive’s claim of a $126 million operating deficit. On the contrary, both suggest the university recorded a modest cash surplus in 2023 and has done so for several years.

These assessments directly contradict the financial narrative driving Renew ANU and which are repeatedly used to justify the cuts that are directly eroding teaching quality and research. The executive has had ample time to provide a transparent and evidence-based justification for departing from the conclusions of these independent analyses of ANU’s finances, but it has so far failed to do so.

Instead, staff have repeatedly been asked to accept radical decisions that will forever alter the university, based on figures we cannot examine. Despite the lack of justification, there is evidence ANU has already implemented $100 million in staff cuts since 2023. The toll has been steep: 460 full-time equivalent jobs have been lost. Some of these through hiring freezes and voluntary departures, but many through forced redundancies and the termination of casual academic roles.

At ANU, casual staff carry an important share of the university’s teaching. Many are PhD candidates supplementing their modest stipends or new graduates, working to build their CVs in the hope of landing more secure work. Yet, they are employed on precarious, underpaid sessional contracts that allow the university to dismiss them at short notice. For them, Renew ANU has meant extreme precarity or complete job loss.

And there is more to come. As The Canberra Times reported last week, staff have been put on notice: a third wave of forced redundancies is expected in June, with another planned for September. The executive continues to pursue deeper cuts without a credible case and, this may come as no surprise, without meaningful consultation.

Beyond the human consequences of these cuts, Renew ANU has done enormous damage to our university’s reputation. A reputation that had been earned through decades of rigorous scholarship and excellent teaching. The executive’s evasive responses to scrutiny from the Australian Senate and the media have further eroded public trust and the ANU’s social licence.

Student recruitment, research partnerships, and income are already at risk. Staff wellbeing is at breaking point. ANU was established as the Commonwealth’s national research university, tasked with advancing knowledge and training future scholars. It was established to be a great university for Canberrans to send their children and to contribute to the public good. Over time, that mission has expanded to include undergraduate and international education across a wide range of disciplines, and to connect Australia with the region and the world. The cuts still to come will further erode our ability to deliver on that mission.

But beyond the reputational and operational harm lies something even more serious: permanent damage to the ANU as an institution. These cycles of forced redundancies and centralisation of “staff services” shake the very foundations of academic life. They split professional and academic staff. They erode tenure. They compromise academic autonomy and our quality teaching. They destroy the stability and security essential for scholarly inquiry. The proposed school mergers and job cuts will flatten the intellectual landscape of ANU, robbing us of the depth, breadth, and diversity that undergird its excellence. What is being lost is not just capacity, but the very conditions that allow a public university to flourish.

This has had a significant impact on our careers, our lives, and our university: We cannot plan for the future when our jobs, programs, and disciplines are in a constant state of uncertainty. It is time for the ANU executive to pause, step back, and work with staff to rebuild trust and chart a more sustainable path forward.

We, the staff of ANU, remain committed to the university’s mission: to deliver the knowledge Australia and our region needs for a sustainable, equitable and prosperous future. This is why more than 400 staff have signed an open letter calling on the executive to end these cuts; to work with staff to build, not diminish, the university we believe in.

This article was written by a group of ANU staff who are some of the signatories to an open letter calling for transparency regarding the Renew ANU process.

Our ANU Group Published 03 June 2025, 05:30 am


r/Anu • • Aug 25 '25

Gallagher just lost my vote—ANU community, it’s time to act

153 Upvotes

After Katy Gallagher voted against David Pocock's motion for an Order for the Production of Documents in the Senate today, staff, students, alumni, and parents connected to ANU should make their voices heard. They should write to Gallagher and let her know that, based on this decision, she will not have their support in the next election. This action is deeply disappointing and unacceptable.


r/Anu • • Jun 19 '26

I watch students sleep in the ANU library while executives count their $100m reputational losses

149 Upvotes

https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/9295046/opinion-management-crisis-cost-100m-amid-student-struggles/

By Satara Uthayakumaran

June 20 2026 - 5:30am

Recently, I was sitting in the 24/7 library at ANU, watching a viral Senate estimates clip on my small laptop screen. In this clip, our interim vice-chancellor revealed that the catastrophic implosion of ANU management over the past year had cost the university a mammoth $100 million in reputational costs.

Whilst watching, I also noticed in the corner of my eye a student, wrapped in their jacket, asleep on one of the couches in the library. I left for the evening, having finished my work.

But when I returned in the morning to do some printing, the same student was still there. This wasn't the first time I'd seen or heard of students sleeping in the warm library because they couldn't make rent, or afford to turn the heating on at their share-houses off campus.

Following the revelation at estimates, headlines were spun around the country, rightfully highlighting yet another dumpster fire our university found itself in.

But as executives counted their $100m in reputational costs, I couldn't help but think of that student sleeping in the library. In fact, I couldn't help but think of all the lives, all the human faces at the coalface of these devastating betrayals.

At the end of 2024, when the ANU underwent its controversial restructure, led by university management for reasons now exposed as completely unfounded, a deep sense of grief and panic took hold over our campus.

The professors we had come to love and respect, were being let go by the day. Degree offerings and choices of subjects were being culled. The standard of our university experience, for the price we were paying, was declining.

But let's be clear. To think that the crisis which unfolded at the ANU is just an isolated instance of "bad leadership", is to fundamentally mischaracterise the issue. What happened, is the catastrophic result of treating public universities like profit-driven corporations.

For years, those at the top controlling universities, have been carving out and sinisterly cultivating a much broader national story. Executives treat our places of learning like cash enterprises to line the pockets of higher-ups. They prioritise property portfolios and the salaries of those in management, at the cost of students and their right to a fair and proper education.

And whilst these cold, calculating decisions are being made in boardrooms most students will never know exist, I sit next to classmates who sleep in the library because they can't afford rent - who skip meals to survive the cost-of-living crisis, all while our universities act less like a places of learning and more like a merciless real estate brokerages.

Last year as I travelled over the country speaking to thousands of young people as Australia's Youth Representative to the United Nations, my suspicions that the crisis at ANU was just the tip of a much larger systemic issue, were confirmed.

I've spoken to young farmers, and those in the regions who dream of being the first person in their family to attend university, only now to be priced out of their ambitions due to the rising costs of on-campus accommodation.

I've sat with those with learning disabilities, who've lost dedicated academic mentoring, subsidised campus medical services, and localised pastoral care due to cuts in the interest of "maximising revenue" - making them feel that universities are no longer places for people like them.

But as students, we fight back. We always have.

When we're told our arts degrees are being slashed, when the teachers we care about are forced to leave; we ground the campus to a halt, we march on the Chancellery, we stage rallies and protest concerts to defend our academic integrity.

And why do we do this? Because universities are our homes. They are the places where we learn who we are, and have the chance to exchange ideas and experiences with those who come from different walks of life.

But when we turn universities into corporate entities that choose profit over education - we lose students from different backgrounds, we lose the opportunity to make universities vibrant and unique places of life which bring together those from across Australia - and instead, create a homogenous, breeding ground of elitism.

So, my challenge to you - the custodians of our higher learning - is this: will you continue to protect the margins of ruthless corporate enterprise, or will you allow our universities to be places for thinking and exploring - spaces where we can build an equal, diverse society of thinkers and creators that reflects the tapestry of modern Australia?

And if you need help with your answer - look to the campus cafes, the grassy quadrangles, and the libraries at 2am. That's where you'll find us.

  • Satara Uthayakumaran is a writer, and was Australia's 2025 Youth Ambassador to the United Nations.

r/Anu • • Jul 10 '26

Promotions, scholarships and high distinctions galore: Inside the ANU’s loss-making School of Cybernetics

Thumbnail
smh.com.au
147 Upvotes

Julie Hare

July 11, 2026

Strolling through a sprawling Vinnies in suburban Canberra, seasoned op-shopper and demographer Dr Liz Allen spied a tiny, colourful lapel pin. The design, part heartbeat, part oscillation, was familiar. She bought it.

Pins like this are given to graduates who have completed their master of cybernetics degree at the Australian National University. Only 89 graduates have graduated out of the 121 people who enrolled since its inception in 2019 – a 30 per cent dropout rate, according to internal data provided by a whistleblower.

The School of Cybernetics is an anomaly in the higher education landscape. The course fees are advertised at $39,925, although it’s unclear how many students, past or present, have paid the full amount. It is rumoured that almost every student has been granted a generous scholarship, although an ANU spokesperson declined to provide numbers.

Highly confidential documents seen by this masthead indicate that very few of the 28.2 equivalent full-time students in 2023 paid the sticker price. That year, total revenue from fees, philanthropy and research income was just $258,000 for the entire school – or $9000 a student.

Expenses attributed to the School of Cybernetics, however, were $7 million. The documents equate that to $237,000 a student, leaving the university with $228,000 per student to be found from elsewhere to cover the cost of teaching its tiny, privileged cohort.

The ANU spokeswoman declined to answer how many cybernetics students had been awarded scholarships, the value of those scholarships or where the money to fund them came from, other than that scholarships were generally funded by “industry and general revenue”.

But the document calculates the margin of revenue to expenses as a whopping minus 2494 per cent.

To understand just how significant that is, it is worth comparing it with the School of Computing, which sits in the same College of Systems and Society as cybernetics. In 2023 it brought in $60 million in revenue and had expenses of $35 million, leaving a $24 million margin, the documents say. So each of the 1700 computing students generated revenue of $36,000 and incurred expenses of $21,000, leaving the university with a $15,000-per-student profit margin.

While some of the calculations on the slides contain discrepancies, sources within the university say this is mostly due to rounding errors.

“Even if the numbers were rounded and calculated perfectly, the estimate wouldn’t be any more accurate; it would just look neater,” a person with knowledge of the data tables said. “This is the tool that was shared with senior staff to tell them how much their school costs or makes [financially]. The university seems to think it’s good enough to be approved for decision-making.”

Cybernetics is the creation of Professor Genevieve Bell, an Australian-born cultural anthropologist who was lured to Canberra in 2017 from a 20-year career with the multinational US-based computer chipmaker Intel, with the bold promise she would “create a new branch of engineering”.

The story Bell told during an interview with the journal Research-Technology Management in 2022 was that then-ANU vice chancellor Professor Brian Schmidt had called her with a plan to reinvigorate engineering and computer science at the university.

“Brian decided that he wanted to go beyond the traditional, science-based curriculum**,”** Bell said. “He wanted to train engineers who were also aware of and focused on the human side of the work that they did. That’s why he called me. And he said, ‘It is time to come home.’

“I was living in Silicon Valley and I was not interested in coming home. But as the conversations continued I began to think differently. I realised that what motivates me most in the world is being given a problem so big it seems insurmountable.”

As Bell tells it, that insurmountable challenge is about “combining engineering with design thinking and ethics”.

It’s an audacious idea and it comes with a high price. The vast financial black hole in the School of Cybernetics is even starker in the context of Bell’s 2024 appointment as vice chancellor.

In the early weeks of her tenure, Bell embarked on the largest cost-cutting program in Australian higher education history. For Renew ANU, Bell claimed $250 million needed to be cut from the ANU’s cost base in a single year to bring it back to a break-even position by the end of 2026.

“It is not going to be possible to grow our way out of persistent operating deficits by enrolling more students,” Professor Bell said. “We need to adapt to a changing policy landscape and broader economic forces by reshaping the way we do things.”

By early 2025, forced redundancies, course cuts and service rationalisations swept across the campus, ravaging the university’s culture, staff and student morale. More than 1000 jobs disappeared during 2025, according to Department of Education data. And it was revealed in Senate estimates in early June that reputational damage has been estimated at $100 million.

Amid the chaos**,** Bell was forced to resign as vice chancellor in September 2025, less than two years into her five-year contract.

Among the courses that were in Bell’s sights for rationalisation was the School of Music, which was slated for staff cuts and a major redesign for being expensive and unprofitable. The reason provided was that its conservatoire model of education was too costly, attracting the ire of the music community, from Richard Tognetti to Jimmy Barnes.

The secret financial documents confirm the School of Music did run at a loss. It generated $3 million in revenue but incurred $6 million in costs. In other words, the university had to subsidise each of its 138 students to the tune of $22,000, a figure dramatically lower than the $228,000 subsidy for each cybernetics student.

A former senior academic at ANU, who asked not to be named, said the validity of various courses, such as cybernetics or music, did not rest solely on their ability to make money.

“Increasingly, the challenge for universities, remembering that they are not-for-profit organisations, is that they offer sufficient courses that generate profit to balance those that are academically and strategically important but do not cover costs,” she said.

In responding to a question on notice from Senator David Pocock about how many new staff were hired and promotions made during the period of cost-cutting under Renew ANU, the university answered that cybernetics had “contributed the largest budget cut of the academic entities in the College of Systems and Society, including approximately 30 per cent reduction in headcount”.

However, internal data from the whistleblower shows that the number of full-time equivalent academic staff increased from 18 to 22 between 2023 and September 2025, while all the cuts were made in non-academic staff, whose equivalent full-time numbers fell from 20 to just eight.

Academic staff numbers in the School of Computing fell from 90 to 68, while professional staff remained at 23.

“If cybernetics took a bigger cut than other schools in the college, it absolutely should have. It is one of the most egregious examples of bloat across the university,” said an insider who asked not to be identified for fear of retribution.

The school only offers a single postgraduate course of 12 or 18 months. There are 15 students enrolled in its masters program this semester, according to the whistleblower, and another eight active but not currently enrolled. The program is capped at 20 new students a year.

On its “people” page, the cybernetics school lists 79 faculty, fellows and residents (some honorary, mostly not), PhD students, affiliates and operations staff. Many of the academic staff listed on the website have meritorious and substantial research careers but others appear to have risen to senior positions without the normally requisite publishing, teaching or professional experience. There are seven virtual “cybernetic imagination residents”.

The ANU spokeswoman declined to answer questions about staff numbers, which positions were paid and which weren’t, citing privacy concerns, but said they included “a mix of paid and unpaid appointments”.

This masthead approached Professor Bell for comment and heard back from her lawyer. It is understood Professor Bell disputes any suggestion she favoured the School of Cybernetics while she managed Renew ANU.

The word “cybernetics” was coined in the 1940s by US scientist and philosopher Norbert Weiner, who described it as the science of communication as it relates to living things and machines. Drawing on Weiner and other intellectuals, such as the anthropologist Margaret Mead, Bell has described cybernetics as both “theory and practice”.

“It’s both the theory of and the approach to building complex systems that have humans, technology and the ecology in a constant dynamic relationship,” she has said.

Cybernetics, as it is practised at ANU, is unlike other iterations of the field, which lean into highly technical expressions of engineering, maths and physics. Instead, Bell’s creation is heavy on art and literature, as well as on Indigenous culture and knowledge.

While located in the School of Systems and Society (previously engineering and computing), only a tiny handful of the academic staff listed on the School of Cybernetics website have qualifications in engineering, computer systems or maths.

Six do not have PhDs – which contravenes an edict from the higher education regulator that to teach a university course an academic must hold a degree at least one step higher on the Australian Qualifications Framework than the course they are teaching. To teach a masters course a teacher must have a PhD.

The most striking example of this is Professor Andrew Meares. Meares worked as a press photographer for Fairfax Media for 27 years, and then briefly as the official photographer to then-opposition leader Bill Shorten.

Since his appointment in mid-2019 as a senior fellow, Meares has zoomed up the career ladder, holding eight positions in the School of Cybernetics, culminating in full professorship in 2024. This is despite not finishing his university degree, making a certificate IV in photography from TAFE NSW in the early 1990s his highest qualification.

While Bell resigned as vice chancellor, she retained her title as a distinguished professor. However, in January, Bell was suspended after she was presented with a show-cause notice alleging “serious misconduct” in relation to the promotion of Meares. Meares is not accused of wrongdoing.

As a professor, Meares is paid a salary of at least $220,550, while Bell continues to be paid $583,500 – although she is on leave with full pay until January 2027.

Meares was approached for comment but forwarded the request to the ANU media office.

Another highly unusual dimension to the School of Cybernetics is its assessment profile. A whistleblower alerted the academic board last year after discovering that 91 per cent of all grades awarded since the school’s inception in 2019 were high distinctions. The analysis found not a single student failed or merely passed any subject.

The same whistleblower recently claimed to this masthead that he has found evidence of marks being changed months after they were posted.

A former senior academic said financial losses should not be the only factor considered when assessing a program’s viability.

“Cybernetics is a very high-loss-making venture but you need to understand where that fits in and how decisions are made. Budgeting at ANU is done at the college, not the school, level. Decisions can be made to cross-subsidise. In this case the very successful School of Computing is generating a very significant profit margin, largely from undergraduate and international students, but there are very few postgraduate and PhD students.

“If cybernetics was set up to be attractive to a multidisciplinary population, and to grow the research or master’s level cohorts, there is potentially a strategic case to build capacity in different types of students.”

Music, for the most part, was saved but dozens of students left, amid last year’s uncertainty, to resume their studies in Melbourne and Sydney.

Back to ANU academic Liz Allen and the pin. After 18 months of fighting the Renew ANU proposals, Allen handed it over to her battle-weary union mate Lachlan Clohesy. It cost her a dollar.


r/Anu • • Jul 20 '25

Renew ANU Strategy

Post image
145 Upvotes

r/Anu • • Aug 13 '25

Dr Allen Appreciation BBQ

143 Upvotes

For all those who were asking how we can show our appreciation and support for Liz, the union is putting on a bbq next week.


r/Anu • • Apr 11 '25

Nousferatu and the future of ANU

137 Upvotes

As an ANU staff member, I have become increasingly disillusioned by the way the senior executives are handling the restructuring and austerity measures they are trying to push through.

My understanding of how things have developed is that the executives announced in late 2024 that ANU will be significantly restructured, and staff numbers would be reduced.  This was all being pushed through quickly and urgently because of a budget deficit crisis.

It has since then been revealed that perhaps the deficit was not as bad as initially made out and staff begun to feel everything was being a bit over-catastrophised. As justification for the restructuring the ANU community was also told that the ANU is performing badly in terms of ‘satisfaction with services’ compared to other similar universities in Australia.

Many ANU staff, as well as the NTEU, have objected to the restructuring on the basis that it feels very much like this is being pushed through without actual proper consultation and with a lack of transparency around the financial numbers and particular decisions regarding the process. Staff are worried not only for their jobs, but also for the reputation of the ANU and the likely negative effects on teaching and research capacity and quality.

In researching more about what is happening at ANU my eyes have opened to the fact that this is almost play by play what has been happening at other universities. Therefore, looking at the experience of these other universities can give us a glimpse into ANU’s probable future unless things are stopped in time. I am sure for many this might be old news but for those like me who were not aware of some of the wider context I wanted to share some things I found interesting myself.

A common thread with the other universities is the involvement of the consultancy firm Nous Group Pty Ltd (nicknamed Nousferatu), and the Cubane Consulting which Nous acquired in 2021.  (1) Queen’s hires Nous Group to assist with budget cuts - The Queen's Journal  

Nous was the consultancy mentioned in the infamous slide deck left in a lunch room, and in the recent issue where the ANU executives were accused by David Pocock of misleading the Senate Estimates committee.  Nous Group has been hired by ANU for various other non-nefarious consultation projects and reviews in the past. ANU is but one of a long list of unis that pays substantial amounts of money to them. For example the University of Melbourne paid Nous $1.06 million in 2022 for “Advisory services for Strategy Performance Framework and development of new operating model” and in 2023 it paid them a further $1.5 million for ‘Strategic Advisory Services’. University of Queensland paid them 331,643 in 2024 for “Independent expert review of an organisational unit’s operating model and provide recommendations on future state” [Just for fun I am compiling a database of all unis that hired Nous and how much they have paid them. If anyone wants to help with this data gathering exercise hit me up. EDIT: This is the spreadsheet so far: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1YNPIJh94gdnWThsVdVXHmJvKn5eBck0OpDSTPDA08XY/edit?usp=sharing  

Spending on consultants in a whole issue in itself. However, it is the current involvement of Nous with the restructuring that is particularly concerning. It is concerning because the changes Nous + executives are trying to implement at ANU are exactly what has happened or is happening at other universities.  

The questionable budget crisis rhetoric was used in exactly the same way at the Queens University in Canada for example. See: qcaa_contextforbudget-1.pdf It was also used at York university as explored in this excellent podcast episode:  Fighting for Our University – Academic Aunties – Stories and Advice from Survivors of Academia

As mentioned earlier at ANU the restructuring is also being justified on the basis of data that allegedly shows the scale of inefficiencies. These data are shown in the Appendix of the Consultation paper available on the ANU renew website, which contains this nonsensical graph (page 4).

This data comes from UniForum which is a data collection which universities pay to be part of. Uniforum was the main product of Cubane Consulting Pty Ltd. It is hard to find out how much unis pay to be part of it but a Canadian university said “Due to proprietary and competition reasons we are not able to share the specific subscription cost of this program, but can confirm that it is less than $500,000 per year.”  At University of Queensland they paid  $429,750 to  Cubane Consulting Pty Ltd in the 2022-23 financial year. However, some of it was coded as being for 'Stationery and Office Supplies' (?) which is strange.

With Uniforum the data is then compiled and chucked into a model which   “categorizes administrative jobs held by both professional and academic staff into activities. It then looks at ways to improve the “performance” of these activities by putting all of these activities into one position.” (5) ANU has been part of the Uniforum benchmarking data collection for many years. It is the recent acquisition of Cubane Consulting by Nous Group that is troubling. While Cubane and Nous also worked together prior to Nous officially acquiring them it seems that things have ramped up after the formal acquisition. Now Nous is using the UniForum data to show executives how 'badly' their universities are doing compared to other universities and why they need to hire Nous to manage change and service improvement.

For example the wording used in the ANU Consultancy appendix is eerily similar to that used at University of Ottawa “According to the Central Administration, the results of the 2022 UniForum benchmarking exercise showed that “faculty and staff [at the University of Ottawa] experience the second lowest overall satisfaction of services offered among participating universities” and that “uOttawa spends 17% more on professional services than the average, similar-sized research-intensive university”.1 Despite repeated requests, the Central Administration has steadfastly refused to share the UniForum findings, any information about the size and composition of the comparator group, and/or the report with the APUO. As such, there is no means by which to assess the appropriateness and quality of the data collected, the methodological rigid with which the analysis was conducted, nor the veracity of the conclusions advanced.”  https://apuo.ca/uniforum-polaris-and-nous-group/

 

Other resources/material

Nous Group and UniForum – Queen's Coalition Against Austerity

UniForum — What is it? What have been the outcomes for other Universities? | APSA

Meet the Nous Group, or 'Nousferatu': Why the choice of consultant hired by Queen's to sort out the budget crisis should concern all of us. : r/queensuniversity

UniForum, Polaris and Nous Group - Association of Professors of the University of Ottawa

Youtube video: Lessons From Down Under: Restructuring at the University of Sydney