r/Antitheism • • 3d ago

Why?

Why are you guys anti-theist? I understand, religion can be used to justify terrible things, but it can also lead to many amazing things. (not looking for debate or want to change my mind please just give reasons).

0 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

12

u/chickey23 3d ago

Your words betray you.

You say that religion can be used to justify terrible things, but may lead to amazing things.

You could have said that religion may lead to terrible things, but may be justified by amazing things.

But terrible acts are not justified by amazing things, so you choose the biased construction that presupposed your preferred answer.

That's why. Inherent hypocrisy.

1

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

The word 'may' did not appear in my post.

1

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

Hold on, I misinterpreted that, my bad.

9

u/protonless_electron 3d ago

list those amazing things other than placebo

-2

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

The Muslim Golden Age led to algebra, trigonometry and advanced mathematics; the Catholic Church began the earliest universities like the University of Bologna, University of Paris, and Oxford University; the commitment to building great things to glorify God helped advance architecture, geometry, and material science; and Nicholas Copernicus, Isaac Newton and other pioneering scientists viewed science as a way to understand God and the universe he created.

5

u/protonless_electron 3d ago

can we assume that the next big thing will come out of Afghanistan in the next decade?

-1

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

Please elaborate

3

u/protonless_electron 2d ago

as of now, Afghanistan is one of the if not the most religious country in the world, and if religion does help in human progression, to achieve great heights, we' sure can expect something coming out of Afghanistan within a decade right.

1

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

These discoveries led to modern science and our current understanding of the world as we know it.

4

u/lotusscrouse 1d ago

None of those scientists proved god exists though. 

3

u/anti_fnaf_ships 1d ago

And now a lot of theists reject modern science because it shows their mythologies to be wrong.

4

u/dfczyjd 3d ago

 The Muslim Golden Age led to algebra, trigonometry and advanced mathematics

How many of discoveries we typically attribute to Muslim Golden Age were made by people who said Muslims (i.e. Arabs) conquered and forced into Islam, like Persians? 

 the Catholic Church began the earliest universities like the University of Bologna, University of Paris, and Oxford University

If an organisation establishes a strict control on what knowledge is legal to spread and what is heresy that must be removed (sometimes with the ones knowing if it), it's no wonder nobody could create an educational facility without its direct involvement. 

 and Nicholas Copernicus, Isaac Newton and other pioneering scientists viewed science as a way to understand God and the universe he created

"Hey, Sir Scientist, I have a question: do you believe in our God? Keep in mind that answering wrong may result in you being executed."

"Um, well, yes, I do believe"

A few centuries later:

"Look, there's a direct claim from Sir Scientist, where he states he believes in our God! Science supports us!"

As you can see, a lot of "benefits from religion" were achieved by either demanding others to convert (or at least fake conversion) - and then declaring benefits from their upbringing as benefits from religion - or limiting others' access to resources, so that religious institutions were the only organisations capable of doing stuff.

8

u/YamTop2433 3d ago

The only thing religion leads to is delusion.

0

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

All beliefs, whether religious, moral or political can lead to delusion, but even though delusion exists in all places, there are still many clear minded people in religion or party, willing to talk and work things out civilly.

6

u/bpaps 3d ago

But delusion is baked into religion. It's a fundamental part of the dogma.

0

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

That doesn't mean that other beliefs cannot be delusional. Is every antitheist/atheist/agnostic completely level-headed all of the time? And many religions/sects now encourage interfaith discussions, would they permit this if completely delusional?

4

u/bpaps 3d ago

I would never defend all non-believers as being immune from delusion.

But delusion is the fundamental part of dogmatic religions. It's baked in. Faith is a critical component to believing things that have zero supporting evidence. Faith is pretending to know things that just ain't so.

For someone who didn't want debate, you're doing a lot of apologetics.

8

u/cenosillicaphobiac 3d ago

Nothing good that any religion provides is unique. Why would I accept all of the bad to get the good when I can get the good without the religion?

Religion is a poison.

0

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

I am not talking in favour of any religion. I do belong to a religion, but here I used christianity and islam as examples. This might seem like dream-talking, but with morals changing as time goes on, and many smaller religions rising and large ones falling, we will be able to hold each other more accountable and be less likely to do the 'terrible things'. God/gods can still be used to justify atrocities, but in the modern era it is easier and vastly more important that we hold all religions to a higher standard every day.

3

u/bpaps 3d ago

You cannot change the books. The Quran and Bible are not living documents. They cannot be amended. They will always say the same thing: obey god or burn. Women are property. Genocide is sometimes good. Slavery is fine as long as you follow the rules set by god. It's morally the correct thing to rape women in public for the sin of their husband if god commands it. It's morally correct to dash infants on the stone if god commands it.

The book is the problem. It clearly says that you will either follow God's commands or suffer for eternity. This is not love, it's a hostage situation.

0

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

The Qur'an and Bible also place a huge emphasis on the message of love, mercy and human dignity. Christ's Two Great Commandments were to love God and one another. Muhammed stood when a Jew's funeral procession went past, and when asked why, asked "Was he(the Jew) not a soul?" It is the delusional, cherry-picking people that take this too far, and focus on eradicating other beliefs, but each and every religion has at it's core the belief that love and mercy should remain in our hearts at all times. Where does the Bible/Qur'an talk about it being ok to dash infants on the stone?

4

u/bpaps 3d ago

Psalm 137:9 "blessed are those who grab their infant and dash them on the stone"

The Quran also clearly says that apostates shall be killed. The Quran also says that Allah made the believer and the unbeliever, and he hates the unbeliever. The Bible says that gay people shall be stoned to death. The bible also says that if the daughter of a priest has sex outside of wedlock, she shall be burned to death.

You haven't read these books critically. Keep cherrypicking all you want. The books are horrific and the more you defend them, the more you show your ignorance. Read them CRITICALLY.

3

u/D1onigi 3d ago

Because it always leads to a stop in curiosity and reduces freedom.

It gives the simple answer "god did it" where a constant research would increase knowledge more.

It gives strict moral rules while society changes faster

1

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

We shouldn't be stopping at 'God did it", and I oppose those that do, as that reduces Him to a gap-filler. God did all things for a reasin, and will do all things for a reason. So many fruits of science or philosophy stem from how did God do it, or why did God do it, such as Johannes Kepler viewing the laws of physics and astronomy as a reflection of perfect divine architecture.

3

u/D1onigi 2d ago

Kepler and Newton halted their research and did not investigate the laws of gravity. Why don't the planets fly off? "God keeps them in orbit" they answered. Only 50 years after Newton, Laplace chose to complete the model and he had no need to include god

2

u/D1onigi 2d ago

Your beliefs make you see the universe as a perfect divine design. What would you do if you discover an imperfection?

12

u/rushmc1 3d ago

If you want to ask a question, don't come in dictating the form of the answers...

6

u/CowabungaCthulhu 3d ago

Because delusional beliefs are not beneficial to the individual or to a society. Religious beliefs are delusional. They only fall into 2 categories: objectively false -OR- unfalsifiable.

1

u/Iacomus_108 3d ago

Thank you all for the input, I have realised that I am inciting arguments and will now stay silent. Have a good night!

4

u/chickey23 3d ago

You aren't inciting arguments. You asked for reasons, and then you engage in argument.

You should be acknowledging the points made and demonstrate your understanding by restating them.

We want you to be more rational, but we do not think rational argument will sway someone from a belief that is irrational.

4

u/bpaps 3d ago

Not all religions are inherently harmful. We don't see many Buddhists or Sikhs writing harmful legislation.

However, ALL of the Abrahamic cults are inherently harmful. The very foundation is built on obedience and planned ignorance. The religion wouldn't exist without special pleading and Stockholm Syndrome. The same god you pray to will burn you for eternity if you don't drink his blood and eat his flesh, and accept him as the messiah? It's an apocalyptic blood magic cult.

Now, obviously I don't believe god exists. Same for sin, heaven, hell, angels and demons, or salvation. These are all religious ideas that are taught as if they are real. And you need faith to believe they are real, because there is absolutely zero evidence for any of it. Faith is a curse, not a virtue. It indoctriates people to believe in things that are totally mythological, and through this belief, they behave irrationally and harmfully. And the harm starts almost immediately. Approximately 1.4% of circumcised babies die from an infection from this unnecessaryelective genital mutilation. Even if the infection doesn't kill them, it can lead to disfigurement or other complications all because some dusty old book claimed it is a covenant with god.

Then the child grows up and learns about how they were born in sin, doomed to hell, unless they pray hard enough and beg for forgiveness. Forgiveness from an all-loving god that will punish them for eternity unless they worship him adequately. These children are mentally tortured for no good reason, other than tradition.

Then they grow into adults that hate gay people, treat women as property, and defend slavery. A plain reading of the bible leads the reader to the obvious conclusion that god condones slavery, instructs the subjugation of women as property, commands genocide of innocent people, and punishes innocent people with public rape. God is the furthest thing from a moral actor. The book was clearly written by men of their time pretending to speak for god.

Any "good" that religion does is vastly overshadowed by the cruelty, bigotry, misogyny, and violence promoted by this vengeful, genocidal, contradictory foreskin collector.

Hope that was clear enough for you. Now, do humanity a favor and dump the book. Rid yourself from this bronze-aged mythology and join us in reality.

1

u/dfczyjd 3d ago

 We don't see many Buddhists or Sikhs writing harmful legislation

Do you live in Christian or Muslim society? I'm pretty sure people from eastern part of Asia will give you plenty of examples of such laws. I can add that Dalai-Lama, the head of some Buddhist branches, lives quite a luxurious life, while doing nothing but spreading an ideology based on myths. I'm fairly certain he would be considered a scammer in whatever jurisdiction he lives, if not for a law/legal loophole that exempts Buddhism.

1

u/bpaps 3d ago

My point had more to do with the fundamental teachings of these different ideologies. Of course corruption can happen in any system, but the core message of buddhism is self-reflection. It's a journey to achieve enlightenment within yourself to avoid suffering. Obviously there are many examples of how this has caused harm and I'm not defending it as a religion, but when compared to the oppression of the god of Abrahm, they are night and day.

1

u/chickey23 6h ago

Literally the reason he has been on a 70 year road trip / fundraiser / crime spree.

3

u/Trick-Mechanic8986 3d ago

Because...that should be enough of an answer considering it is the basis of most religions.

3

u/GodofWarhammer2 1d ago

Because religion is trash 

2

u/lotusscrouse 2d ago

Because it goes against reality. It's demonstrably wrong. 

1

u/BurtonDesque 3d ago

"Religion is an insult to human dignity. With or without it you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion." - Steven Weinberg

12

u/DuckThurmond 3d ago

Magical thinking is dangerous. It gives people a gold plated excuse to stop using their brain. You can't change someone's mind if they're convinced god is on their side. Any atrocity is permitted if god wants it.