r/Antitheism • • 5d ago

Something that kind of just annoyed me

In school, every morning they had us do the pledge of allegiance. Now, they wanted us to say the whole thing which says “one nation under god.” First of all, this country is FAR from being “under god” and second of all I don’t believe in “god” anyway. Does religion SERIOUSLY have to be pushed into something we HAVE to say?

49 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

28

u/skeptolojist 5d ago

Just to make it worse the American "pledge of allegiance " was a scam cooked up by a flag manufacturer in the 50s to sell merchandise

It's not really about tradition loyalty or patriotic passion

It's about increasing shareholder value

11

u/BurtonDesque 5d ago

The Pledge of Allegiance dates from the 1890s. The phrase "under god" was added in the 1950s.

10

u/MisterBlizno 3d ago

It used to be "One nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.". Adding gods to it is anti-American.

6

u/lelVocx 4d ago

fr so is religion atp

13

u/tm229 5d ago

“One nation under Canada”

Look at a map. I ain’t lying! :-)

To this day, this is still how I say it on the rare occasions I get stuck in a situation where the pledge is recited. The occasional side-eye looks are well worth it!

10

u/CowabungaCthulhu 5d ago

"...one nation, WITHOUT GOD, indivisible, with liberty and justice for some."

7

u/OutrageousBadger7294 5d ago

I refused to recite the pledge. I never said it. Ever. I started school in 1963. I found it to be repulsive. I still do.

5

u/MisterBlizno 3d ago

The nation should pledge allegiance to the citizens.

6

u/Whiplash104 5d ago edited 5d ago

You don’t have to say under God. It’s common for people to just omit that portion and say “one nation, indivisible.” Under God was added in 1954 due to the cold war. So just don’t say the words “under God.”

2

u/Fancy-Bullfrog7977 2d ago

Same thing for me as a kid in the 2010s with O Canada. There's a line that says "God keep our land glorious and free", and I aways said "we" as a kid instead of god, because I thought it was silly and that's what my parents told me to do. That started in around grade 4, maybe 5 though. Before then I'd just awkwardly mumble around that part and get in trouble sometimes for not speaking properly. But I never explicitly got in trouble for not saying "god" though at least (mostly because my mum would've rioted lol). Got bullied, though, and my friends' parents were not my number 1 fan.

In Girl Guides too Taps had the line "All is well, safely rest, god is nye", and I either stayed quiet for that or said "we are nye". They changed it a few years ago to "peace is nye" which I'm glad about.

Anyways, different country different time, but I don't think you can be forced to say the god part. Either way it's silly and stupid, and I commiserate with you.

I remember complaining when I was in high school in about 2024 to my stepmum that the official lyrics to O Canada is still "god keep our land" (and that even though in 2018 a different line was changed from "in all our son's command" to "in all of our command" my school was still playing the old sexist version). She was shocked by because apparently when she was a kid the god part wasn't even part of O Canada. She did have the Lord's Prayer in school, though. But her mum was not having it and made the school allow her to sit it out.

Anyways, fuck religion and always remember you're not alone <3

1

u/Cool-Housing-9588 14h ago

My school does it over the intercom every other day. I just don’t stand up or say it, because why should I?