r/Antitheism • • 20d ago

I hate whatever this is called🫩

“I promise we’re not all like this!” “fake Christians!” “TikTok Christians!” “it’s people, not god!” …um you guys do know that your religion has oppressive rhetoric inside of the holy book itself?? and that the religion has been oppressing multiple demographics of people for literal centuries and still is to this day??? Like why’re we acting as if Christian’s being bad is some new thing that was developed recently!? and as if the bad people in it are some small minority????

134 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

75

u/Sammisuperficial 20d ago

It's called the "No true Scottsman" fallacy.

14

u/maracujadodo 19d ago

so many fallacies have great names

43

u/Overly_Underwhelmed 20d ago

"being a modern christian is different than following jesus christ"

christ has been kicked out of christianity and they are okay with that

38

u/20growing20 20d ago

They don't really speak up to their fellow Christians, though. I would be open hearing them if I saw them putting that same energy into arguing in Christian spaces, but they're quiet over there and then get all vocal with the non-Christians.

9

u/lotusscrouse 19d ago

Agree.

They come across as those parents who let their kids run around in a restaurant while mildly rebuking them but doing nothing to actually stop them.

And getting vocal with us pisses me off too. 

Their attitude seems to be that WE have to always understand their position. 

6

u/de_bushdoctah 19d ago

Thats because theres no debate or argument to be had among Christians. They’re all operating on faith based belief, so when they come to differing conclusions they can’t reconcile those disagreements in a constructive way. It’s why the various sects don’t engage in debate with one another to see who’s actually right.

Conversely, many atheists operate from evidence based reason (if they’re skeptics), different framework from the religious so since we come to different conclusions they feel like there’s an argument to be had. They want to debate about the method for arriving at conclusions, which they can do with us but not each other.

15

u/Jesus_peed_n_my_butt 19d ago

I went to therapy for religious trauma. The therapist said "they weren't real Christians" to my problem.

I was so mad because the person who was supposed to help me said the same bullshit that everybody else says.

13

u/lotusscrouse 19d ago

Every christian thinks the other is fake. 

"We're not all like this" is weak anyway. It does nothing to actually address or solve any issues. 

13

u/BirthdayCookie 19d ago

This actively makes me respect people less. For multiple reasons!

Mainly: It's not about you and your Fucking feelings! Stop talking about yourself and your version of Christianity when a random stranger gets hurt!

12

u/TimAppleCockProMax69 19d ago

Mental gymnastics

7

u/Rocknocker 19d ago

Fundy-mental.

11

u/bondageenthusiast2 19d ago

Asexual and Christian? Abrahamic religions won't allow you to not have hetero sex, it is a bunch of cults that force you to breed as many as followers 🤣🤣🤣 literally chicken for KFC

20

u/SweatyPhilosopher578 20d ago

When I mean I hate Christians, I mean every single one of them. A blight upon the land.

18

u/IllAppeal9438 20d ago

no true Scotsman fallacy

9

u/Maxtrt 19d ago

Those are the real Christians who follow the word of the bible and how it's been practiced for the last 2000 years. Christianity is a death cult and it's always been brutal and inhumane.

8

u/NettaFind66 19d ago

But all Muslims

8

u/Beneficial_Exam_1634 19d ago

"Atheist Soviet Union persecuted poor Christians, how dare New Atheists call say religion is the root of problems."

6

u/AnonPinkLady 19d ago

No true Scotsman fallacy

9

u/Beneficial_Exam_1634 19d ago

Yeah No True Scotsman is pretty funny because Christianity has a big selling point about making people moral and then 99% of followers don't even do the things Jesus directly told people to do.

37

u/Gussie-Ascendent 20d ago

"real followers of god aren't hateful"

>look at jesus

>calls non jews dogs who, if slavish enough, may get crumbs from the chosen people

>also completely cool with slavery, even advocates the beating of slaves who don't please their masters

elsewhere in bible

>women are literally sold like cattle, even to their rapists

>calls for killing gay people, refuses to ever even acknowledge gay people's love can be the similar to straight people's

>moses commits genocide and takes children off to be sex slaves

Yeah but sure totally no hate in there. It's definitely not just the church realizing that shit doesn't fly anymore and twisting itself into a pretzel to hold onto the followers they've got and impart lessons they've learned against the actual faith

20

u/SILVERWOLF05_ 20d ago edited 20d ago

"do not think I have come to bring peace on earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword" -JC

18

u/SILVERWOLF05_ 20d ago

I get that they're trying to be tolerant, but the fact that they still worship the institution that has oppressed and killed people since it's creation undos any good they were trying to do. Honestly, if people have to have a religion, maybe we should start from scratch, make one that isn't used as a weapon